10 Forgotten One Night Only WWE Returns
They are here for a good time but not a long time.
Vince McMahon knows that wrestling fans have long term memories. He also knows that nothing sparks a crowd reaction quite like the return of an old school legend.
Whether it's a one-off appearance like The Rock at WrestleMania 32 or a fully-fledged run like Bill Goldberg earlier this year, seeing a veteran performer that can still go in the ring and do it one more time is as nostalgically satisfying as it gets.
However, not all returns are burned into our memory banks like the sight of Ric Flair walking that aisle, the night after Survivor Series 2001. In fact, some of yesterday's biggest superstars have returned for a one-shot appearance, only for their homecoming to be almost completely forgotten after the fact.
Such is the fickle world of sports entertainment...
10. RVD - Royal Rumble 2009
While there have been countless one-night only returns in the Royal Rumble match over the years, one of the more legendary yet, criminally forgotten surprise entrants was that of 'Mr PPV' himself, Rob Van Dam.
Bizarrely, RVD's shocking one night deal at the 2009 Rumble is very rarely even acknowledged, let alone shown in historic Royal Rumble discussions.
Nevertheless, on this night, the crowd erupted when the extreme superstar made his way down the aisle and chants of "RVD" shook the building from the moment he hit the ring. Unleashing his martial arts offence on everything that moved, the fans in attendance were definitely pleased to see 'The Whole F'n Show' make his return to the big time.
Van Dam would last just under 14 minutes in the match before getting eliminated by Chris Jericho. RVD wouldn't return to WWE again for four and a half years, instead opting to ply his trade in TNA.
9. Tatanka - WrestleMania 32
When you think of the great WWE in-ring WrestleMania returns in recent years, names like Bill Goldberg, The Hardy Boyz and The Rock are often quick to spring to mind. One name that is not is Tatanka.
As a participant in the Andre the Giant Battle Royal at WrestleMania 32, Tatanka's first appearance in a WWE since 2007 was about as random as it gets. While legends spots are great for a nostalgia pop - as DDP proved in that exact same match - Tatanka's insertion was made even more bizarre by the fact he wasn't even given his own entrance. WWE's decision to have him there with no bespoke entry robbed him of the very nostalgia pop that the legends are famed for.
Instead, the Native American simply showed up in the ring with the rest of the acts that weren't given the privilege of a solo introduction and just began battling like he had never left. Even the commentary team seemed surprised by his inclusion and only clocked him several minutes in.
Nevertheless, it wasn't his night and WWE's tomahawk toting tribesman wound up being the eighth man eliminated, downed at the hands of the eventual winner, Baron Corbin.
8. Sycho Sid - Raw 2012
In one of the more surprising returns to WWE in recent history, the reappearance of Sycho Sid in June 2012 was as shocking as it was awesome.
Having not appeared in WWE since 1997, the former two-time WWE Champion and two-time WrestleMania main eventer made a one-off appearance in the ring to answer the challenge of Heath Slater.
At the time, Slater had been berating legends of the industry in a similar vein to how Randy Orton and Rob Conway had done in the past. Naturally, this would lead to his legendary comeuppance at the 1000th episode of Raw; however, before that, it gave a number of veterans a chance to work off some ring rust and hand Mr Slater a solo beating.
The deep voiced pop that greeted his entrance proved that the hardcore fans of old hadn't forgotten him and his decimation of Slater thereafter was a welcome sight. Sid appeared to be just as psycho as ever, laying his opponent to waste with a classic powerbomb, to chants of "Sycho Sid" as he celebrated.
7. Honky Tonk Man - Cyber Sunday 2008
While the Honky Tonk Man did make a memorable, one-stop cameo at Royal Rumble 2001, he also made a surprising return to in-ring WWE singles competition at the always interesting Cyber Sunday PPV in 2008.
Fans were given the option to choose the opponent of IC Champ, Santino Marella, with Roddy Piper, Goldust and Honky Tonk as the options. While Roddy Piper may seem like the overwhelming fan favourite on paper, this came at a time when Santino had been running his mouth for weeks about his Intercontinental Title run, even going as far as to have his own "Honk-A-Meter" that tallied up the length of his reign.
The Elvis lookalike beat out both Piper and Goldie for the right to face Santino with 35% of the vote. While the match itself was brief and the crowd seemed a little unsure how to react once the bell rang, Honky Tonk received a decent enough pop when he walked out the curtain. In fact, it was a rare babyface reaction for the man that made a career being primarily heel.
Despite HTM winning the vote, WWE made good use of the other two options and both 'Hot Rod' and 'The Bizarre One' made an appearance after the match. To date, it was the last WWE match in Honky Tonk Man's career.
6. Mankind - Taboo Tuesday 2005
After weeks of feuding over Mick Foley's lack of perceived coolness by Carlito, a match was set up between 'The Hardcore Legend' and the Puerto Rican for Taboo Tuesday 2005. In a unique twist of the cyber show concept, fans were given the opportunity to vote for which one of Foley's personalities they would get to see: Mankind, Dude Love or Cactus Jack.
With 52% of the vote, Mankind won the poll in a landslide and Saint Mick donned the leather mask for the first time in five years.
While Foley had been in the ring three times since his memorable feud with Randy Orton - notably challenging Toshiaki Kawada for the AJPW Triple Crown Title at Hustle-3 - the time out of regular competition had seen him regain a bit of ring rust over the previous year. Regardless of the rust, the crowd were still pretty happy to see the three-time WWE Champion and the appearance under the guise of Mankind was a nostalgic moment that definitely was cool.
5. 'Superstar' Billy Graham - Superstars 1986
Billy Graham was one of the most charismatic personalities in WWE history and his tie-dye clad return to the WWF was an eagerly anticipated event in 1986. Unfortunately, the initial return of the 'Superstar' would wind up doing far more harm than good for the former WWWF Champ.
His first appearance in the WWF for three years at that point, Graham was welcomed back with a huge ovation from the crowd. Strutting his way down the aisle, 'The Reflection of Perfection' did so to the sound of Bad To The Bone, a wild crowd in attendance and a noticeably excited Vince McMahon on commentary.
On that night, Graham squared off with journeyman jobber, Bob Bradley. After less than 90 seconds later, Graham looked to take it home with his patented bear hug submission. Whipping his opponent into the ropes, he grabbed Bradley around the lower back and lifted him off the ground only to awkwardly lower back to his feet soon after. In reality, the weight of Bradley had destroyed Graham's already weakened hip.
As a result of the injury, not only did Graham need surgery, but an entire hip replacement. The colourful legend wouldn't wrestle again for another 10 months and the severity of the injury ultimately led to his permanent retirement in 1987.
4. Marty Jannetty - Raw 2007/2009
As one half of The Rockers, Marty Jannetty shot to fame in the late '80s as a quality tag team practitioner and genuine in-ring talent. Sadly, he had a wealth of issues behind the scenes which saw his many runs with the company cut short, leading to an extended WWE absence from late '96.
However, 2005 saw the former WWF Tag Team and Intercontinental Champion make a stellar - albeit criminally brief - two-match return to the company. The first match saw a memorable Rockers reunion on Raw, while an impressive bout with Kurt Angle followed later that week, all in the aid of building up the HBK/Angle match at WrestleMania 21.
Despite his great performances and good crowd reaction, Jannetty was gone shortly after following a domestic incident. He made a short return in 2006, coming to the aid of Michales, but wouldn't return to WWE action until December 2007, when he squared off with Mr Kennedy.
Once again brought in to further an existing HBK feud, Jannetty was defeated in just 5 minutes. The former Rocker would return once more in 2009 against The Miz, who was intent on proving he wasn't the "Jannetty" of his team with John Morrison. Miz would defeat Jannetty in less than three minutes, bringing the veteran's WWE career to a close.
3. Various Legends - Raw XV 2007
When it comes to anniversary shows and milestone episodes, WWE always does a great job tipping the cap to the past, with a nod to the stars that got WWE where it is today. The Raw XV Anniversary was no different... except instead of a nod, they gave a gigantic wave for all to see.
That wave came in the form of a "15th Anniversary 15-Man Battle Royal", featuring a whole host of stars from yesteryear - many of whom hadn't featured on WWE TV in quite some time. With The Fink on announcing duties, it was simply classic.
While the bout itself featured entirely of returning superstars, many of these veterans had appeared sporadically over the years - such as Bob Backlund and Doink the Clown - while others had become recurring fixtures in backstage skits and legends segments - such Sgt Slaughter and IRS. However, the bout also saw the return of several long-gone Attitude Era stars: including Gangrel, Bart Gunn and Steve Blackman. Even Gillberg made an appearance, complete with security and sparklers in tow.
The pop of the match came for the surprising return of Jim ' The Anvil' Neidhart. Despite his ten year hiatus from WWE, the fans hadn't forgotten him and the bullish member of The Hart Foundation received a warm reaction from the crowd.
2. Greg Valentine - Heat 2005
Greg Valentine was a big name in the industry during the 1970s and '80s. The son of legendary grappler, Johnny Valentine, 'The Hammer' was one of the few men to participate in both the inaugural Starrcade and the first WrestleMania. Valentine also went on to have a memorable run as an Intercontinental and Tag Team Champion.
While he made sporadic appearances over the years that followed, it's surprising to see that WWE actually booked him in a fully fledged match against Rob Conway in 2005. To put it into perspective, Valentine's two championship reigns in WWE happened in the mid-'80s, so seeing Valentine back in WWE action 20 years later is almost mind-blowing.
Nevertheless, that's exactly what happened when legend-hating chauvinist, Rob Conway, battled 'The Hammer' in one-on-one competition on the October 21st edition of Heat. Conway had a point to prove, having been made a fool of by a host of legends at WWE Homecoming on October 3rd. However, the crowd were firmly behind the legend and Valentine held nothing back in his own homecoming match.
Sadly, for the veteran, Conway wound up winning by DQ after inadvertent interference from Eugene. The very next week, Conway would continue his assault on the legends of old by squaring off with Koko B. Ware.
1. Lance Storm - Heat 2005
Despite opting to retire from full-time active competition in mid-2004, it didn't take long for Lance Storm to go back on his decision and don the tights once more. In fact, less than one year later, Storm would be back in WWE for the hugely memorable ECW One Night Stand PPV. However, he also made an often overlooked stop over one week prior to that as well.
With Maven's planned opponent, Tajiri, pulled from their bout on the 5 June 2005 episode of Heat, Maven laid out a challenge to any ECW alumni that thought they could take him on. That man turned out to be Lance Storm himself. In a typically short opening bout on the Sunday night show, the Canadian picked up the victory with a springboard cross body.
While Storm's return to WWE TV just seven days before his PPV return seems like an odd booking decision on paper, there is logic behind it. The Heat taping took place in Calgary, Alberta (Storm's hometown), so it seems to have been more of a geographical situation more than a consciously planned return. Maven's involvement in Raw's anti-ECW "crusade" also played well into the overall story a made for a great bonus for the Canadian fans ahead of the ECW reunion.