10 Former WWE Stars Who Deserve Another Shot

Superstars WWE gave up on way too easily.

If you're ever such inclined to do so, a glance through the "Alumni" page on WWE.com will tell you several stories about the booking history of the company over the last say, 15 years or so. You'd be forgiven if you had a chuckle at some of the names on there and wondering how they were ever employed by the WWE; think Gilberg, Psicosis and the recently-released Yoshi Tatsu. But for all the joking and laughing and joking we can have about the calibre of people employed by WWE, you could equally get upset at the people who really shouldn't have been let go. Sure, there are some who simply had to go - for reasons that have nothing to do with their abilities and actions inside a wrestling ring. But even then, you always wonder what would happen if the WWE extended an offer for them to come back and do it all over again. Providing lessons have been learned, the olive branch should be offered to plenty of guys that have exited the company in the past. And even those who were released for wrestling reasons shouldn't be discounted from an emotional reunion, too. It's widely accepted that in professional wrestling, everyone makes mistakes. Be it wrestlers, management or even executives, nobody is exempt from making the odd howler. So for all the stars who have been let go, there were always bound to be a few who should get another chance. Here are ten such examples.

10. Ezekiel Jackson

The WWE have a remarkable track record of employing absolutely huge wrestlers and booking them poorly; we're even seeing a modern day example in the case of Big E. But whilst Big E was a young buck in developmental wrestling, the WWE were doing exactly the same to "Big Zeke" - Ezekiel Jackson. Guyana's finest wrestling export (probably their only one, in fact) was incredibly unlucky throughout his time in the WWE, and another shot would be more than justified. When Ezekiel Jackson made his move onto the main roster in WWE back in 2008, things started off pretty smoothly. He was initially brought in as a bodyguard for The Brian Kendrick (an appropriate gimmick, given how Jackson is a man mountain), but it was his move to the ECW roster where things really started to pick up. There he won the ECW Championship, and in fact, he's still recognised by the WWE as their last ever ECW Champion. That's not a bad little accolade to have next to your name when you factor in the men who have won the title in the past. But it didn't stop there; a move into the ill-fated The Corre stable ultimately led to Jackson winning the Intercontinental Championship after turning on Wade Barrett - but he lost it shortly after to Cody Rhodes. From then on, injuries and poor booking led to him going on a terrible losing streak (he lost to the likes of Jinder Mahal and David Otunga), before having a year out of the wrestling business with injury. The WWE released him in April this year, but the way it all ended was a bit of a disappointment. And if Jackson can prove his fitness to earn another deal with the WWE, there's more than enough to suggest he could make a real go of it. After all, the WWE gave him enough of a push to believe in him in the past.

9. Evan Bourne

In many ways, Evan Bourne and Ezekiel Jackson's last few months with the WWE are very similar. They were both released in 2014 after horrific spells out with injuries, but the release of Bourne came as much more of a surprise earlier this year. When he burst onto the scene he immediately found his place on the WWE roster. He was quickly thrust into matches against the likes of then-WWE Champion Sheamus, which perhaps best illustrated just how highly he was regarded by those backstage. He had a real in-ring presence too; wrestling fans are a real sucker for a daredevil high-flier, and that's exactly what Evan Bourne is when he enters a wrestling ring. That's why a tag team with Kofi Kingston was another smart move, and it was rewarded with a reign as tag champions in 2011. Two midcard guys coming together to inject some enthusiasm in the tag division was exactly what was required (and is a move that is often explored by the WWE) - and it paid off big style. Unfortunately for Bourne, two suspensions for violating the WWE's Wellness Policy put several nails in his coffin, before a lengthy lay-off confirmed that his future would lie away from the WWE. Clearly his track record with the Wellness Policy isn't great, but there are plenty of other stars who have done exactly the same. So why not give Bourne another chance?

8. David Hart Smith

Whenever you're a second, third or even fourth generation wrestling star, it can be tough to make your own mark on the WWE without continually being compared to your relatives. There are plenty of examples of guys struggling to break out of the limelight their predecessors created in years gone by, and David Hart Smith certainly falls into that category. In truth, Smith was overshadowed by two of the greatest wrestlers of all-time - given how his father is The British Bulldog and his uncle is Bret Hart. He was hamstrung by a 30-day suspension not long after initially making his WWE debut, but The Hart Dynasty concept was a good one, and it certainly paid dividends for a lengthy period. However, after the stable split the booking of both Smith and Tyson Kidd was absolutely disastrous, and although Kidd is still with the company, Smith left way back in 2011. He's since cut his cloth accordingly in the wrestling world, remaining active by competing in New Japan Pro Wrestling. He had a Shawn Michaels 'lost my smile' moment before he left, saying he had lost the passion for wrestling during his time in the WWE. That was no doubt due to poor handling from the WWE, and if he did get another go, you'd have to hope the company appreciate what a talent they have on their hands. Smith is a damn fine wrestler, and could still have a successful career with the WWE if they went around together again.

7. Elijah Burke

Sometimes, you wonder if the WWE look at a wrestler they released making a success of it elsewhere and wonder exactly what went wrong. Now, Elijah Burke wasn't exactly a legend in Total Nonstop Action, but he definitely made more of an impact in TNA than he did during his time with the WWE. In all fairness, he got the same treatment Drew McIntyre got from Vince McMahon, getting pinned with a tagline that would haunt him for the rest of his time with the company. Whereas McIntyre was "The Chosen One", Burke was dubbed "The Future of ECW' by McMahon on a show in 2007. That caused him to be beaten down by the likes of Tommy Dreamer, Rob Van Dam and Sabu - all ECW legends - so how the WWE thought that would get Burke over is anyone's guess. A dismal angle involving Burke forming a stable called The New Breed followed (alongside Burke were Matt Striker, Kevin Thorn and Marcus Cor Von, hardly a who's who of professional wrestling), before he floated around the main roster until his release in 2008. In TNA though, his gimmick as "The Pope" D'Angelo Dinero was a roaring success, and he enjoyed plenty of high points during his spell with the company. He was unfortunate in that he suffered a nasty shoulder injury during a world title match against AJ Styles in early 2010 - not long after beating him in a non-title match. Clearly TNA understood what a talent they had on their hands in the shape of Burke - so maybe the WWE could give him another crack? If a potential angle involving the Nation of Domination was to make a comeback, someone like Burke would be a great outside fit for a role in the stable.

6. Brian Kendrick

In the mid-2000s, Paul London and Brian Kendrick were probably more renowned for their in-ring competition alongside each other, rather than as singles stars. Their record-breaking reign as WWE Tag Team Champions (331 days, longer than any other team who have held the belts) was a sterling effort, and showed that both London and Kendrick had plenty to offer the WWE. However, it is his run as The Brian Kendrick (a nice little gimmick that the WWE failed to fully exploit) which perhaps sticks more firmly in the memory. That gimmick saw him get a pretty substantial push by the company as a major heel - with some interesting results. Hell, he was that highly thought of that he was put into a Championship Scramble match for the WWE Championship at Unforgiven 2008 - he didn't win, but he had the longest run as "interim" champion throughout that match. Clearly The Brian Kendrick was going places - but then the WWE applied the breaks rather sharply. He went on a real dismal run of form, forming several tag teams with partners he had no real right to be teaming with. A slow, gradual run towards his eventual release became more and more evident by the week, and it was a real shame to see Kendrick's unique gimmick ultimately fail. Spells in TNA and New Japan Pro Wrestling have followed since his release - but that gimmick has unfinished business in the WWE. Time for the WWE to give Kendrick another shot.

5. Chris Masters

Chris Masters is a pretty unique case compared to the rest of the guys on this list, for a couple of differing reasons. First of all, he's still ridiculously young for a wrestler, aged just 31. And whilst most of the guys on this list deserve a second chance with the WWE, Masters has already had his second chance - but it's time for a third run on WWE TV. In all honesty, WWE fans should (some probably do) completely disregard his second run with the company. It was a real disaster, as Masters was shockingly booked at the lower end of the card. That led to little momentum, and very little success. But go back to the mid-2000s, and the WWE had a certified main event star on their hands who had something that nobody else had at that time. The Master Lock challenges that Masters rolled out on a weekly basis were great, and gave him a real distinct place on the WWE roster. He actually has the record for most Full Nelson submission victories in WWE history, and it led to a run for the WWE Championship not long after his WWE debut. A feud with Shawn Michaels also proved what a talent Masters was, as did his first feud for the title against John Cena. We all know what Cena's gimmick about never giving up consists of, but Masters actually became the first WWE wrestler to render Cena unconscious. These were all clear signs that the WWE were going to pin a major belt on Masters at some point, but it simply never happened. He's been in the news away from wrestling of late, after saving his mother's life following an arson attack at her home. Masters broke a ten-foot tree with his bare hands, before using it to free her from the burning building. Now, if that isn't worthy of Masters getting another shot, I don't know what is! Could the Master Lock challenges make a return to WWE in the near future?

4. Ted DiBiase Jr.

When you're a second or third generation wrestling star, it's never a good idea to use their gimmick when you're trying to make an impact on the wrestling world. And that's exactly what happened to Ted DiBiase Jr. for the most part of his first run in WWE, starting with his debut back in 2008. He cut a promo stating how he was going to emulate his father - not a good idea. Sure, The Legacy were a decent tag team and flourished under the leadership of Randy Orton, but he had to have a good run as a solo star to cement himself as a star. Unfortunately the WWE felt it was appropriate to drag up his father's gimmick once he split from Rhodes and Orton - they even pinned the Million Dollar Championship around his waist. They even brought back Virgil to even further emphasise how much they wanted him to copy his father - but it was always doomed to end in failure. By the time DiBiase publicly acknowledged copying his father's gimmick just didn't work, he had suffered a pretty nasty fall from grace. Whilst Cody Rhodes went on and enjoyed a successful run as Intercontinental Champion, DiBiase was gradually heading towards his release from the company, which was confirmed in September 2013. That year, he had only wrestled once on WWE TV, beating Michael McGillicutty. A talented wrestler that's still young enough to have a prolonged run with the company, if he was open to a return, Ted DiBiase, Jr. should be on the radar of WWE officials once again.

3. John Morrison

John Morrison was with the WWE from 2002 (when he competed in Tough Enough) right through to 2011, but there was always a feeling that he could have achieved so much more during his first run with the company. He was a three-time Intercontinental Champion and a five time tag champion, but a main event push should have arisen at some point throughout his time in WWE. Morrison quickly became notorious for his ability to entertain the crowd with some incredibly exciting spots, and he had a pretty substantial level of popularity amongst wrestling fans. However, as is often the case with the WWE, they didn't really book him all that well. When he left in 2011, he said he was planning to retrain with a view to returning to professional wrestling in the future. An acting career has got in the way of that, but you feel that the door should always be open for Morrison to eventually come back and entertain once again.

2. Carlito

It's amazing to think that it's been four years since we last saw Carlito on WWE TV (in a wrestling sense), so isn't it about time he comes back and has another run with the company? He's still very much an active wrestler, competing all around the world for various promotions, but Carlito's gimmick is one that could find a place in today's WWE once again. There's a distinct lack of Latino representation on the WWE card these days; Sin Cara is nowhere to be seen, and Rey Mysterio's injury problems continue to see him ruled out of action. Alberto Del Rio is going nowhere (which is a crime), so a return for Carlito would at least see him get a decent push upon coming back. When he first debut back in the WWE, his gimmick involved simply spitting apple in the face of people who "didn't want to be cool". Naturally that's a pretty unique gimmick to have, so there was no surprise when it worked out pretty nicely. He beat John Cena on his debut (yes, you read that right) for the United States Championship, and it seemed like a star had been born. Carlito was no stranger to speaking out about poor booking from WWE officials though, even requesting his release on a couple of occasions, before being convinced to stay. His record with the infamous Wellness Policy wasn't great either, and it was his refusal to enter rehab that led to the termination of his contract. However, the WWE have welcomed back stars with greater problems in the past, so perhaps it's time to forgive and forget, and have the apple spitting Latino back on our screens for another run? In the year his father was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame, it would be an incredibly apt time for him to come back, too.

1. Shelton Benjamin

I'll just cut loose here and shoot straight from the hip - Shelton Benjamin could quite easily be the most underused star in the last 20 years of the WWE. Things started nicely enough, being thrown into "The World's Greatest Tag Team" with Charlie Haas. But forget Haas for a moment (sorry Charlie), Benjamin was working alongside Kurt Angle. That's when Angle was arguably at the peak of his powers in WWE, so the plan was clear for both Benjamin and Haas - build them up into credible stars. When they eventually split and Benjamin went alone, his career went to even brighter, better heights. Runs as Intercontinental and United States Champion followed, and the sky literally looked like the limit for Benjamin in the WWE. His gimmick as "The Gold Standard" pushed him even higher, and he backed up all the hype with some excellent in-ring performances. PWI recognised him as the ninth best wrestler in the world back in 2005 - that was well deserved. So what went wrong? Well, his draft to the ill-fated ECW roster was where things started to go sour. The roster wasn't exactly blessed with top stars, as perhaps best summed up by his allegiance with Vladimir Kozlov. His performance at WrestleMania 26 (where he competed in perhaps the best Money in the Bank ladder match of all-time) was incredible though, but he was bizarrely released just a few weeks later. You can only assume there were non-wrestling issues that led to the release of Shelton Benjamin - because if you're talking about guys with natural wrestling talent, Shelton Benjamin still ranks as one of the very best. Time for the WWE to make a call, and bring back "The Gold Standard". The quality of wrestling we'll see in a WWE ring will jump up massively if they took the plunge and signed him up again.

Contributor
Contributor

Freelance sports journalist from Bradford, West Yorkshire. Specialize in primarily Rugby League and Football.