10 Gimmick Changes That Saved A Wrestler's Career
The Ringmaster vs. Rocky Maivia just doesn't have the same ring to it.
The late, great Randy Savage once said "The cream will rise to the top". He also said, "funky like a monkey, skies the limit and space is the place" but, for the purpose of this list, we'll stick to the first comment.
For the ten men in this list, the cream definitely did rise to the top. While it may have taken a little longer than some had hoped for, a simple gimmick change proved to be the difference maker and allowed them to get their careers back on track almost instantly - such is the importance of a solid wrestling persona.
In fact, some of the biggest stars in the history of the industry began their wrestling careers shackled to a dead gimmick. As such, the cream of the crop on the following pages happen to be a revered mix of former champions, Hall of Famers, and present day superstars.
Luckily for the wrestling world, these men broke free of their respective restrictions and transformed from ailing would-be superstars into bona fide main event talents. The results are a creamy cocktail of gimmicky goodness without a Shockmaster, Gobbledy Gooker, or Mantaur in sight.
10. Spirit Squad To Dolph Ziggler
If there's one gimmick that will probably never get over as a badass wrestling character, it's that of a male cheerleader. Which is exactly what Vince McMahon was looking for in 2006, when The Spirit Squad made their debut on Raw.
Consisting of OVW standouts Ken Doane, Nick Nemeth, Nick Mitchell, Johnny Jeter, and Mike Mondo, the green-clad group became a weekly addition to WWE's Monday programming. The five-man team even became a key part of the Vince McMahon/Shawn Michaels feud after WrestleMania 22 and held the Tag Team Titles for seven months.
Nevertheless, the group's feud with the reunited D-Generation X ultimately led to their downfall. After losing a 5-on-3 handicap match to D-X and Ric Flair, all five members of the Spirit Squad were placed in a crate, labelled "OVW - Louisville, KY". The unceremonious exit saw them written off TV immediately.
While Ken Doane would find a modicum of success on SmackDown, he and the rest of the squad would be gone from WWE the following year. All except Nick Nemeth that is, who returned to the main roster in late 2008 under the name Dolph Ziggler.
As the bleach blonde heel, 'The Showoff' has become an asset to WWE and is widely regarded as one of the best in-ring performers today.
9. Husky Harris To Bray Wyatt
With a family tree that includes Mike Rotunda, Blackjack Mulligan, and Barry Windham, it's fair to say that wrestling is in Bray Wyatt's blood. However, it hasn't all been plain sailing for 'The New Face of Fear'.
After a year in FCW, the would-be Wyatt made his mainstream debut on the second season of NXT as Husky Harris. Sadly, the original NXT format was a doomed concept and one that did very little to help any of it's participants. His subsequent promotion to the main roster saw him naturally join The Nexus stable of former NXT "rookies".
As a background player in the renegade group of newcomers, Harris became a Raw regular; however, CM Punk's introduction to the group saw The Nexus soon fizzle out. After being written off TV as part of the Punk/Orton feud heading into WrestleMania XXVI, the group quietly disbanded and Husky Harris was never seen on WWE TV again.
Demoted back to FCW, Harris became Bray Wyatt and continued his evolution into the new NXT format of today. Forming The Wyatt Family with Luke Harper and Eric Rowan, Bray soon made it back to the main roster and reached the pinnacle of his wrestling career when he won the WWE Championship for the first time in February 2017.
8. Matt Hardy To Broken Matt
When Matt Hardy was let go from the WWE in late 2010, it was the beginning of a downward spiral for the older Hardy sibling.
A short, forgettable run in TNA in 2011 saw the former 'Sensie of Mattitude' sporting dreadlocks and looking like a troubled man. His online presence at the time confirmed this and his YouTube videos were becoming increasingly bizarre and worrying - including one that was interpreted as a suicide note. Hardy was also later arrested three times in one month, all of which led to his inevitable TNA release.
The multiple time champion was on a slippery slope and retired from full-time competition in late 2011. Luckily, it wouldn't last and, after rebuilding his reputation considerably through his work on the indies, Hardy returned to TNA in 2014.
After continuing in his usual guise, Hardy eventually became a heel and entered into a feud with his brother, Jeff. Following a number of physical battles together, Matt began to refer to himself as being "broken". The transformation evolved into the 'Broken Matt' character and made him the talk of the wrestling world.
The success of the gimmick saw him and Jeff return home to WWE at WrestleMania 33, where they have continued to be successful ever since.
7. 1-2-3 Kid To Syxx
Sean Waltman made his WWF debut as a jobber on Raw way back in 1993. Jumping from Kamikaze Kid to Cannonball Kid, Waltman settled on simply The Kid by the time he squared off with Razor Ramon on the 17 May 1993 edition of Raw. After shockingly upsetting 'The Bad Guy', Waltman adopted the 1-2-3 Kid name and became a fixture of the WWF's mid-card.
Clean-shaven with a slight build, Waltman was a natural underdog; however, these attributes didn't translate well when he turned heel in late '95. After a stint in rehab, the 1-2-3 Kid was gone from WWF by mid-'96.
By the time Waltman reappeared in WCW in September, he was sporting a totally new look, complete with goatee beard, bandana, and shades. Sat in the front row on WCW Nitro, Waltman looked like a badass - a stark contrast to his 1-2-3 Kid persona. Waltman was soon revealed as the sixth member of the New World Order. As such, he was renamed Syxx and went on to become one of the most memorable members of the early nWo.
By the time he returned to WWF 18 months later, 1-2-3 Kid was dead and, in his place, X-Pac was alive and well. Still using the look and attitude of his Syxx persona, X-Pac was a key ingredient in D-Generation X and the WWF's Attitude Era.
6. Dustin Rhodes To Goldust
As the son of the legendary Dusty Rhodes, Dustin Runnels had some big shoes to fill when he followed his father's footsteps into the wrestling industry. Taking his dad's gimmick surname, the son of a son of a plumber soon became Dustin Rhodes and began honing his craft in World Championship Wrestling.
After briefly stopping off in All Japan and the USWA, Dustin soon found himself in the WWF. Despite a notable bout at Royal Rumble '91, teaming with his father, Dusty, against Ted DiBiase and Virgil, Dustin followed his dad back to WCW, where he remained a mid-card performer until he was fired in 1995.
After varying success in WCW under his standard gimmick, Dustin underwent a dramatic overhaul when he returned to the WWF. No longer the happy-go-lucky cowboy that had left the WWF '91, the former 'Natural' traded the leather waistcoat and trunks for a complete reboot and debuted as the bizarre Goldust in September '95.
With overtly suggestive mannerisms, sexually allusive verbiage and covered in gold from head to toe like an Oscar statuette, Goldust immediately got over as a heel and the mid-'90s crowds took great offence to the androgynous superstar. While the gimmick has undergone several modifications since, the ever-evolving Goldust character has been a recurring part of WWE for over 20 years.
5. Hulk Hogan To Hollywood Hogan
After initially coming into the company with a tonne of momentum behind him, Hulk Hogan's run in WCW was as stale as a day-old beer by the time 1996 rolled around. Having defeated everyone that stood in his path, the fans were growing tired of 'The Hulkster's' shtick as the unbeatable babyface.
Hogan's cartoon antics were nothing new to long-time wrestling fans and the red and yellow was clearly on life support by '95. Luckily for Hogan, two WWF main eventers were about to breathe new life into Hulkamania with a dose of '90s monochrome.
Scott Hall and Kevin Nash left the WWF in April '96, making their successive WCW debuts shortly thereafter. Dubbed The Outsiders, Nash and Hall were booked to face the team of Sting, Randy Savage, and Lex Luger at Bash at the Beach. Professing to have a mystery "third man" for the night, the eventual revelation of Hulk Hogan as that conspirator was simply groundbreaking.
Instantly turning heel, Hogan ditched the red and yellow of Hulkamania for the black and white of the nWo, re-branding himself as Hollywood Hogan. Despite his advancing years, the reinvention made Hogan the hottest act in wrestling once again and saw WCW become the biggest company in the wrestling world.
4. Hunter Hearst Helmsley To Triple H
After spending six months in WCW under the generic Terra Ryzing gimmick in 1994, Paul Levesque underwent an interesting persona change when he became Jean-Paul Lévesque, an upper-class Frenchman playing off the origins of his shoot surname. The run was brief and he quickly made the jump to the WWF in early 1995.
The snobbish heel character of Jean-Paul Lévesque was modified to become Hunter Hearst Helmsley, an aristocratic snob from Connecticut. The gimmick got over as a typical mid-'90s heel, however, losses to Duke 'The Dumpster' Droese and Ultimate Warrior in early '96 did nothing to help his momentum. Meanwhile, the infamous "curtain call" incident at Madison Square Garden saw his career stumble further and his planned victory at King of the Ring '96 was delayed for another year.
By mid-1997, Levesque started to drop some of the snobbish antics of his Helmsley persona and began replacing them with a cocky swagger. His feud with all three of Mick Foley's personalities helped evolve his character even further and his union with Shawn Michaels sealed the deal.
The riding jacket was replaced with a leather one and Hunter Hearst Helmsley became simply Triple H. Michaels and Triple H formed D-X, the 'Connecticut Blue Blood' was confined to history, and 'The Game' had only just begun.
3. Rocky Maivia To The Rock
From CFL cast-off with with just seven bucks in his pocket to the biggest movie star in Hollywood, The Rock's career has been an unending incline since his mid 20s. But would he be where he is if he was still sporting a grass skirt and an awful haircut?
After a cup of coffee in the USWA as Flex Kavana, Dwayne Johnson was brought up into the big leagues and rechristened Rocky Maivia in 1996. An amalgamation of his family history, the persona merged the names of his dad, Rocky Johnson, and his grandfather, Peter Maivia, the blue-chipper made his debut at Survivor Series '96.
Despite being given a solid push, the fans rejected the white-meat babyface character. Fans were no longer looking for a cheesy, smile and slap hands good guy; they were looking for a rebel and the tide was noticeably turning into what would become the Attitude Era.
After chants of "Die, Rocky, die" and "Rocky sucks" began to frequent his matches, a change of direction was needed. The WWF used the crowd's negativity to their advantage by turning Maivia heel when he joined the Nation of Domination in late '97 as The Rock.
A brash, arrogant baddie, The Rock was everything Rocky Maivia wasn't. His charismatic personality made him an instant hit and he was WWF Champion 15 months later.
2. Fake Diesel To Kane
Glenn Jacobs had a tough introduction into the World Wrestling Federation. After initially being handed the awful Isaac Yankem persona based on a psychotic dentist, Jacobs was subsequently lumbered with the equally awful Fake Diesel gimmick in late 1996.
With an imposing frame, an even more imposing physique, and good in-ring ability for a man of his size, Jacobs' wrestling career was rapidly becoming a criminally wasted opportunity. After debuting as Fake Diesel in September '96, the big man was predictably viewed by fans as nothing more than a Kevin Nash knock-off - which is exactly what the gimmick was.
The Fake Diesel gimmick died a slow and painful death, making its last appearance on TV at Royal Rumble '97, incredibly making it to the final four. After a handful of house show appearances and an international tour to Kuwait, Fake Diesel was resigned to the scrapheap for good.
Luckily, the WWF had one last proposition for Jacobs - the gimmick of The Undertaker's demented and demonic brother, Kane. Making his re-debut six months later under the mask of 'The Big Red Machine', Jacobs made an emphatic statement at IYH: Badd Blood by tearing off the Hell in a Cell door and costing The Undertaker victory.
The new persona completely revitalised his career and he is still going strong 20 years later.
1. The Ringmaster To Stone Cold
Having debuted in the USWA in 1989, Steve Austin went on to make a big splash in WCW as a member of Paul Heyman's Dangerous Alliance and one half of The Hollywood Blondes with Brian Pillman. A triceps injury saw his run in Atlanta come to a premature end, however, and he was fired while nursing his wounds.
A brief spell in ECW saw Austin really develop as a performer and the world got its first glimpse of the 'Stone Cold' persona we would come to know and love. Sadly, the WWF paid little attention to his stellar work in Philadelphia and he was brought into the New York territory as The Ringmaster.
Given Ted DiBiase as his mouthpiece, Austin was seldom given the chance to show his personality and was used primarily as a mechanic simply to produce good mid-card matches. While he was given the Million Dollar Championship as part of the gimmick, the character had very little depth to it and DiBiase's presence was more of a hindrance than a blessing.
After watching a documentary on Mafia hitman, 'The Iceman' Richard Kuklinski, Austin was inspired and saw himself as a ruthless, cold character in the WWF. A few weeks later, 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin emerged from DiBiase's shadow, and that's the bottom line.