10 Great Matches Starring Dud Wrestlers

'Boy, you gotta carry that weight...'

Sid Shawn Michaels Survivor Series 1996
WWE.com

Wrestling, as we all know, is an odd old vocation.

A strange mixture of theatre, sport, magic, comedy and horror, little about it holds up to scrutiny when one really thinks about it - so it's sometimes best not to. For example: why do wrestlers suddenly become worse when they turn heel, what with their begging off and sudden inability to score clean wins? Why would they bother donning the black hat in the first place?

Another curious aspect of wrestling is how certain matches just click - despite featuring one or more wrestlers who usually bore fans to tears with their immobility or rank mediocrity. There are ten such examples featured here.

Royal Rumble matches, long the preserve of many a ham and egger, are exempt from inclusion on this list. The stipulation is sufficiently bulletproof to withstand even protracted showings from the clunkiest grapplers. So too is something like the World Heavyweight title match from WWE Elimination Chamber 2012. The Great Khali was in the match, but he was only in there for all of a minute. He didn't contribute a jot to its relatively unheralded quality.

Shockingly, however, he is included here in a singles bout. Read on to find out which...

10. Shawn Michaels Vs. Sycho Sid - WWF Survivor Series 1996

Sid Survivor Series 1996
WWE.com

Sid was a guy custom-built for a squash match, and the caption for Jim Ross' famous "he doesn't get paid by the hour" cliche.

Clumsy and uncoordinated, his offence somehow didn't look too threatening for such an imposing physical specimen, but there were a few occasions on which he used his natural menace to engage the crowd over a sustained amount of time.

He did that in this WWF World title match, rendered well above passable by the preternaturally gifted 'Showstopper'. Sid was cheered at the expense of Michaels, despite being lightyears beyond him in terms of work-rate, in a crowd dynamic inconceivable in 2016.

He didn't even have to move to generate this reaction; in the early exchanges, he simply stood flat-footed and chopped Michaels on the top of the head, who bumped around the ring like his life depended on it to sell his foe as a credible threat to his hard-earned WWF title.

Michaels would later describe Sid, with some justification, as "the most expensive piece of luggage in WWF history", but it's difficult to damn him with too much in the way of faint praise here. He actually performed a more-than serviceable kip-up here before he cut HBK's own off with a brutal clothesline in the best spot of the match.

And, despite his notoriety as one of the dumbest wrestlers in history, he remembered to sell the wear-down of his legs in consistent and believable fashion in order to help craft an engaging 20 minutes.


9. Ahmed Johnson & The Legion Of Doom Vs. The Nation Of Domination - WWF WrestleMania 13

Ahmed Johnson Legion of Doom WrestleMania 13
WWE.com

A multi-man match with a shortcut-enabling stipulation is an easy method of concealing the negatives of a dud wrestler - but this Chicago Street Fight featured two, ensuring its place on this list.

Ahmed Johnson was an uncoordinated worker whose rare feats of athleticism were counteracted by frequent botches and timing issues. Crush was even more irredeemable. Seemingly kept on in myriad incarnations purely as a result of his real-life friendship with The Undertaker, his upside was nonexistent.

He couldn't wrestle his way out of a paper bag, he couldn't talk, and he didn't even possess that exceptional a look.

Even so, both entered commendable* performances in this all-action war, which did very well to sustain audience interest given the preceding all-time classic fought between Steve Austin and Bret Hart.

Johnson, on the other hand, had a fire in his belly on the night, flattening Crush with a somersault plancha over the guardrail and smashing Faarooq with a powerbomb through the announce table. It was an uncontrived-looking version of a spot which is rendered unbelievable nowadays, what with WWE talent having to politely move the monitors out of the way beforehand.

*Commendable in Crush's case meant that something he did looked like it might actually hurt.


8. Macho Man Randy Savage Vs. Ultimate Warrior - WWF WrestleMania VII

Randy Savage Ultimate Warrior WrestleMania VII
WWE.com

The Warrior, along with Hulk Hogan, jointly holds the record for the lowest-rated wrestling match in history. Their travesty at Halloween Havoc 1998 was awarded -***** by the Wrestling Observer Newsletter. He was better in the ring during his original WWF run, but not by much.

Ironically for a match predicated on a forced retirement stipulation, its quality is mostly attributed to the choices made by Savage throughout. This wasn't a back-and-forth encounter between two equals, like Warrior's match with Hogan the previous year.

From the outset, Savage in the heel role positions himself as inferior and desperate, relying almost entirely on Sensational Sherri's interference and ref bumps to snatch the advantage away from the Warrior, who isn't merely a passenger here.

His selling is first rate and his comebacks are timed impeccably, and he moves with a hitherto rarely seen smoothness under the expert guidance of his peerless opponent.

Unlike Hogan, Savage didn't undermine Warrior by reacting to his loss as if it were an aberration. Like the pro he was, he allowed Warrior to beat him soundly in an attempt to revive his standing as the man.

Warrior would never reach these heights again, but his once in a lifetime performance to this day remains one of the most memorable in the company's history.


7. Lex Luger & Sting Vs. The Steiner Brothers - WCW SuperBrawl 1991

Steiners Luger Sting SuperBrawl 1991
WWE Network

Lex Luger was - at least in WCW - an incredibly over talent, which often helped disguise the drudgery of his matches.

He had the look beloved of promotors in the halcyon, steroid permissible days of the Rock n' Wrestling era, but his offence never looked befitting of it. That said, he could transcend his limitations when paired with the right opponents - and the Steiners were at their formidable peak in 1991.

The exchanges between Scott Steiner and Sting are absolutely electric - Steiner throws himself across the width of the ring at one point in order to take a slingshot onto the top rope - but Rick and Luger's contributions are not inconsiderable.

Luger, with his unbelievably smooth selling of Rick Steiner's top rope bulldog, is the one who transitions this match from being a respectful, high-paced exhibition of the tag art form fought between four friends into a frenetic brawl. Tensions boil over after a series of blind and missed tags create an environment of distrust, removed entirely from the handshake which initiated proceedings.

The screwy finish, which sees Nikita Koloff's unwelcome interference gift the Steiners the win, is only a slight blemish on what is a masterwork of both content and story.


6. Bob Holly & The 1 2 3 Kid Vs. Bam Bam Bigelow & Tatanka - WWF Royal Rumble 1995

Bob Holly Dropkick Tatanka Royal Rumble 1995
WWE.com

Tatanka was an average pro wrestler at best. His dubious claim to fame is that he was one part of the best match at WrestleMania IX. Elsewhere, he bored audiences to tears during his matches, many of which made up the most interminable winning streak of all time.

He naturally wasn't primarily responsible for the quality of this one, a cracking entry in the Rumble's loaded undercard canon. Those honours go to Bigelow and the Kid, who carried and performed the move of the match with a pop-up powerbomb into a Frankensteiner reversal, which was unbelievably realistic given the size difference between the two.

Tatanka more than held his own, maintaining audience interest throughout the quieter, heat-building portions of the match with his underrated facial expressions and arrogantly dismissive body language. He fared slightly better in the heel role.

Proceedings became overwrought towards the finish. Holly had been beaten down to such an extent by the more physically imposing heel team that he purportedly forgot where was he and attempted to tag in Tatanka at one point, in a sequence which hasn't aged well at all.

Beyond that, though, the action is so unexpectedly gripping that it holds up as yet more evidence that 1995 wasn't quite the death rattle of a fallen behemoth.


5. Curtis Axel Vs. The Miz Vs. Wade Barrett - WWE Payback 2013

Axel Miz Barrett
WWE.com

Curtis Axel isn't a dud, necessarily. He's smooth between the ropes, is a passable seller, and possess a dropkick which, while not quite up to the standards of Owen Hart and Kazuchika Okada, is mostly very well executed.

He's just deeply, deeply average. JBL is fond of saying that, if you were to build a WWE superstar from the ground up, he'd resemble Randy Orton.

If you were to build an FCW wrestler from the ground up, he'd look like Curtis Axel. Possessing nothing in the way of intangible star quality, Axel has mastered the kick and punch-based WWE style of old, but is so endemic to Stamford that he's incapable of transcending his cookie cutter template.

Here though, assisted by the Triple Threat stipulation and the subplot of his not entering the match until advised to do so by manager Paul Heyman, Axel hints at the storytelling potential which saw him thrust prematurely into the spotlight in the first place.

The smart and inventive finish, which saw Axel pin Barrett as he was locked in Miz's figure four, also goes some way towards colouring Axel's character as a cerebral opportunist.

WWE never followed up on this in their impatient quest to push every shiny new toy at their disposal at the expense of those who failed to get over within a matter of months.


4. Mankind Vs. The Big Show - WWF Backlash 1999

Big Show Mankind Backlash 1999 Boiler Room Brawl
WWE Network

It would be pithy to describe The Big Show, taking the whole of his career into consideration, as a dud - but he damn sure was in 1999.

A fattened husk of the man who could perform a Moonsault back in 1997 (sadly but understandably, nobody was willing to take it), Show's conditioning was so shoddy that he was sent to a weight loss farm early on in his gigantically disappointing early WWF career.

His non-gimmicked singles matches were uniformly rotten - but he had the help of a unique stipulation and and an opponent who was selfless to a fault here. The chaotic backstage environment allowed the WWF to depict him in a more positive light than they had done previously. Show at one point lifts heavy-looking table with jaw-dropping ease, before naturally cracking Foley over the head with it.

There's one glaring botch. Show at one point inadvertently traps Foley under some staging, which would have allowed him to win the match by escaping the boiler room in which it was contested - but it wasn't finished, so he senselessly lifted it up.

That can be forgiven since Foley then smashes Show in the face with a pane of glass, in the sort of spot which, while guilty, is a pleasure nonetheless.


3. 2 Cold Scorpio & Marcus Bagwell Vs. Shanghai Pierce & Tez Slazenger - WCW Beach Blast 1993

Tex Slazenger
WWE Network

Dennis Knight didn't have much in the way of positive attributes.

As smooth as gravel and possessing a Weeble-like physique, he's equally known for helping to sound the death knell of the WWF's tag team division in the mid-1990s and polluting Attitude Era undercards by wheezing his way through five minute matches.

Proving the old adage that every dog has his day to be true, Knight before his dreadful run in the Federation once participated in a choice tag team effort during his days as Tex Slazenger in WCW. Helped considerably by their agile - and in the case of Scorpio, massively talented - opponents, Slazenger and Pierce (Mark 'Henry O. Godwinn' Canterbury) direct the flow of the action, cutting off Bagwell's comeback spots with a deft sense of timing.

Compensating for the lack of presence betrayed by his tall frame, Slazenger instead impresses with his use of body language, slapping fan favourite Bagwell around with a dead-eyed stare to deafening jeers. Like any tag tussle worth its salt, through their psychological shortcuts Pierce and Slazenger ensure that Scorpio's hot tag spot at the finish tears the house dow.

The selling is slightly histrionic viewed through a 21st Century lens, but the scintillating crowd heat justifies and makes up for it.


2. John Cena Vs. The Great Khali - WWE One Night Stand 2007

John Cena Great Khali One Night Stand 2007.jpg
WWE.com

John Cena might have curried some favour over the last couple of years, especially with his enjoyable string of U.S. Title Open Challenge matches - but he's still no Ric Flair in there, let's face it.

His selling remains almost offensively suspect. He applies zero pressure on his STF. Every new addition to his repertoire, be it a clumsy Frankensteiner or horrendously-mistimed springboard Stunner, helps forgive him for perfecting just the Five Moves of Doom. The Great Khali, however, is even worse than that...

Facetiousness aside, this is a string to the bow of the argument that Cena is a more than respectable worker in his own right. Though there are natural counterarguments - Cena made The Miz and R-Truth look like the midcarders they were in his 2011 matches with them - Cena here did the inconceivable and made Khali look Great for the only time in his putrid WWE career.

Theirs was a simple tale of David Vs. Goliath. It's not as if Khali were capable of an athletic back and forth contest. That said, they deepen the resonance of every basic exchange with a stiff variation. Khali clubs Cena with blows to the back instead of the top of his head, and with elbows to the side of his neck, astutely-considered small details which compensate for the lack of dynamism elsewhere.

Khali's cartoonishly powerful offence even excuses Cena's overwrought selling in a match which is impervious in its execution.


1. King Mabel & Sir Mo Vs. Razor Ramon & Savio Vega - WWF In Your House 2

King Mabel
WWE Network

Has there ever been a more awful main event talent than King Mabel?

Alongside The Great Khali and Vladimir Kozlov, Mabel represents the third point of the triangle of dross - but at least his two successors weren't allowed near the top spot of the second biggest show of the year.

This match was a stop on the road of 'King' Mabel's monster push - one so inexplicably good that it must have convinced WWF officials that they were headed in the correct direction. Mabel's notoriously awful match with Diesel at that year's SummerSlam finally saw common sense prevail. He wasn't a main event talent.

But, in this environment, when he wasn't required do all the heavy lifting, it was easier to accentuate his few positives - not least of which his formidable power game.

Throwing a game (and underrated) Savio Vega around menacingly, Mabel also impresses with his unbelievably athletic enziguri kick, which looks far more devastating being delivered by a man of his mammoth proportions.

As bad as Mabel was when not protected in tags, Mo was arguably worse. The sole weak spot in this otherwise meticulously worked match sees him practically vibrate on the top rope, such is his hesitance to land a moonsault. And with good reason, too - his version of it is bowling shoe ugly.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!