10 Great Matches That Inadvertently Ruined Wrestling

BAH GAWD they've killed it!

The Rock Hulk Hogan2
WWE.com

Has WWE ruined the Women's revolution by having a man win the first ever all-female Money In The Bank ladder match?

On Sunday, James Ellsworth climbed the ladder and literally handed the briefcase to Carmella. This was controversial. The idea that a man, even one who barely warrants the designation, won what was trumpeted as something progressive upset many for reasons that should be obvious. The story had been subverted - until next Tuesday's SmackDown, at least - into yet another pound shop cheap heat tactic of infuriating viewers into watching out of pure FOMO obligation.

It could be argued that WWE ruined the Women's revolution by ceaselessly referring to it as such. That, and the b*llocks booking to which Bayley has been subjected. And Sasha Banks, for that matter. And Emma. And...

This is the match that virtually confirmed the return to the slapstick days of Santina Marella. Whether or not WWE tapped or stumbled into the wider conversation of gender is almost irrelevant. Would you ever see a slapstick manager unhook the carabiner in a men's match?

It could also be argued that the Money In The Bank concept itself had already let out a depressing death rattle long before Ellsworth set back women's rights further than a certain p*ssy-grabbing president.

10. Goldberg Vs. Hulk Hogan - WCW Monday Nitro (July 6, 1998)

goldberg hulk hogan
WWE.com

You can almost - almost - forgive WCW for giving away the first-time meeting between Goldberg and Hulk Hogan on free television.

Goldberg was white hot at the time. The ceiling on his undefeated streak had lowered; much more of undercard and midcard squashes would have adhered to the law of diminishing returns. The July 6, 1998 edition of Monday Nitro took place at the Georgia Dome. The epic stage was set by a confluence of irresistable factors.

WCW got it half-right. In order to install Goldberg as number one contender, he first ran through Scott Hall. This should have acted as the main event. It was certainly a big enough attraction in its own right. Instead, this virtual number one contendership bout was a precursor to the biggest match WCW had at its disposal. That match was easily one of Hogan's greatest ever, and the euphoria surrounding Goldberg's win was a fantastic moment. But momentary it was; the success was all but forgotten the very next week, when the cycle began anew.

The objective was achieved - WCW won the ratings war that week - but the idea of attracting viewers, ultimately, was to persuade them to purchase pay-per-view events. WCW squandered millions by giving this away for free, and everything presented on pay-per-view after the fact paled in comparison. The audience had been conditioned not to bother with paying.

It wasn't the death rattle, but the first sign of a tumour.


9. The Shield Vs. Ryback & Team Hell No - WWE TLC 2012

TLC Spanish Announce Table
WWE.com

Roman Reigns was the odd man out of the Shield when the faction first appeared on TV screens in November. Message boards everywhere bemoaned the fact that indy darlings Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose were not joined by a third in Kassius Ohno.

To his credit, Reigns performed the destroyer role so believably that, by December, fans accepted him in it, thanks in no small part to a fantastic, much-imitated sequence in their debut pay-pay-view offering. As would become the norm, Rollins and Ambrose sidelined Daniel Bryan and Ryback with their respective rabid assaults and precise aerial game. Then Reigns, the scavenger, smashed the prone Kane through the ringside barricade with a brutal-looking spear. It was at that point fans chanted "This is awesome!"

It seems you will never again hear those words in conjunction with Reigns ever again, at least un-ironically. The favourable reactions he received after essentially performing the five moves of doom for which John Cena was criticised in parallel enabled WWE to continue with his insidious push. Eventually, his aura had been so well built that he generated massive split reactions on a consistent basis. He was a singles star by 2014. Three years later, WWE is still positioning him in the same stale mode.

Reigns is actually a dynamite performer on his day. He's just not a very good nor sympathetic babyface.


8. Hulk Hogan Vs. The Ultimate Warrior - WWF WrestleMania VI

Hogan Warrior Wrestlemania
WWE.com

"Inadvertent" is something of a stretch.

Hogan didn't so much pass the torch to the Ultimate Warrior at WrestleMania VI as clobber his headliner credentials with it. Hogan kipped up a nanosecond after the referee struck the canvas for a third time following Warrior's match-winning splash. The only thing Hogan sold was complete shock that he had let himself down. He fell to his knees and pointed at the skies, incredibly cross at himself and God, presumably, for this unfathomable turn of events. He portrayed his loss as a total fluke - that it just wasn't his night. It was; Hogan was so hysterically magnanimous that the story was of how graceful the former Champion was.

Hogan, in one night, made himself bigger than the WWF. Not only had he carried Warrior - his supposed successor - to a match far better than it had any right to be, his politicking made fans mourn his absence more than they anticipated Warrior's reign. It was a complete failure. Hogan made sure of that.

Hogan would return to Toron-. To Toron-. To run roughshod over another less popular babyface opponent.


7. Kenta Kobashi Vs. Takeshi Rikio - Pro Wrestling NOAH Navigate For Evolution 2005

Kenta Kobashi
Pro Wrestling NOAH

Kenta Kobashi's reign as GHC Heavyweight Champion was a critical and commercial smash success.

His passionate army of fans had awaited his coronation as Ace for over a decade. His first singles victory over Mitsuharu Misawa, on March 1, 2003 - at the umpteenth time of asking - heralded his long-awaited stint as the man of Pro Wrestling NOAH. This was no mere sentimental victory; the NOAH faithful literally bought into the idea of Kobashi-as-Ace in their droves. Kobashi did what Misawa and Toshiaki Kawada could not and pulled in excess of 60,000 fans to the Tokyo Dome at the 2004 height of his epic reign, in which he amassed countless awesome and lucrative matches with all manner of opponents, deviating with ease from the All Japan King's Road style to attract new fans to the NOAH product he had defined.

It came to an end at the hands of Takeshi Rikio on March 5, 2005. It was a good match. Good was nowhere near enough.

Rikio was obviously a talent. NOAH would not have selected him to end the reign if he wasn't. The problem was that the gulf in quality was immense. NOAH needed to build to the future, but the new generation was either nowhere near as talented nor over (as with Rikio) or the NOAH fandom had not been conditioned to accept men of their slight proportions in headliner roles (KENTA, Naomichi Marufuji).

NOAH, simply, did not do enough work in the background. The state in which the promotion exists today is thoroughly depressing.


6. Diesel Vs. Bret Hart - WWF Survivor Series 1995

Diesel Hart Table
WWE Network

Bret Hart heralded a tradition both thrilling and dubious when he took the first WWF table bump in his match with Diesel at Survivor Series 1995.

That was such an unprecedented sight that many of the ghoulish Maryland fans bum-rushed the guardrail to survey the car crash. Now, the spot is part of the Big WWE Match fabric. Nary a stipulation bout goes by without one of its combatants crashing through the Spanish announce desk. It has become a meme - an insurance policy to pop the crowd, more checklist item than moment of genuine drama.

More galling than the almost defensive transparency is the borderline polite manner in which such spots are set up. If you wish to harm your opponent to such an extent that you are willing to throw them through some furniture, why remove the monitors from it, with those nice, sharp, jagged edges? If the objective is to inflict pain on your opponent you couldn't otherwise administer in a straight singles bout, why remove the most painful-looking apparatus?

In those moments, the jig is up.

The contrivance is invariably supplanted by the still-spectacular visual, sure, but few of these spots really put anybody more over than they were prior to them. It is just something that happens.


5. Randy Savage Vs. Ricky Steamboat - WWF WrestleMania III

Savage Steamboat
WWE

Legend has it that Randy Savage faxed pages upon pages of sequences to a mystified and put out Ricky Steamboat, more accustomed to gauging crowd reaction and crafting his matches using that barometer, ahead of their famous match at WrestleMania III.

That premeditated match was a classic - at least by the standards of 1987. The athleticism, pace and purity of wrestling form was antithetical to anything the WWF promoted at the time, which in truth has likely enhanced its mythical reputation among modern fans, many of whom consider it the best match in history.

Irrespective of how great it actually was, on its own merits, its unfortunate influence cannot be denied. Savage's quest for perfection ultimately resulted in mundanity, insofar as his successors go. In a micromanaged WWE landscape, every match you see on television and pay-per-view is mapped out, move for move, in advance, creating an environment of standardised predictability. Most everybody in WWE pulls off a dive in 2017. Most every dive acts as a segue to a commercial break. Rinse and repeat.

The rote learning process has become so entrenched that the majority of modern performers are not permitted, much less capable, of using their initiative to rescue themselves from disaster, creating a Randy Orton Vs. Sheamus-shaped paradox of tedium.


4. The Rock Vs. Hollywood Hogan - WWF WrestleMania X8

The Rock, Hulk Hogan
WWE.com

"The Rock Vs. Hollywood Hogan" was how the Icon Vs. Icon match was originally billed. Within minutes, through expert politicking, a more apt description was "The Rock Vs. Hulk Hogan," for Hogan turned himself babyface within minutes.

Hogan was so touched by the massive reaction he commanded that he flexed his muscles and roared in Rock's face - a total babyface move. It reconciled the split reaction and swung the near-uniform sentiment in his favour. The Toronto crowd had been swept up in a wave of nostalgia.

So too, just as quickly, had the WWF. An audible was called; Hogan's New World Order stablemates were despatched to the ring to formalise the turn. Hogan Fever had reached such a height that he was handed the WWF Championship at the very next pay-per-view, Backlash. To underline the short-termism of the endeavour, another switch took place at the next pay-per-view after that: Judgment Day. The 400,000 buys Backlash '02 drew fell well short of projections. The Attitude Era bubble burst. This new, nostalgia-heavy WWF/E alienated much of the young crowd.

The 'Mania match itself was a minimalist masterpiece. Hogan and Rock occupied the space between moves as masterfully as anybody else before them. Less successful was the stupidly OTT build, but it didn't matter.

This new "dream match" sold itself, and still does now. The promise of a "moment" is meant to be enough to attract viewers. The half-hearted approach to episodic TV was born from this singular attraction.


3. Money In The Bank Ladder Match - WWE WrestleMania 21

Edge Money in the Bank 2005 WrestleMania 21
WWE.com

The Money In The Bank ladder match concept was utterly brilliant - note the use of past tense.

It allowed WWE the luxury of grouping together main event prospects, tired veterans and aimless midcard acts alike into a bulletproof stunt match that guaranteed both quality and, in theory (and initially in practise) a new main event act.

The returns diminished, as they often do in wrestling. WWE misread Edge's initial smash success as the Ultimate Opportunist as if the briefcase he held possessed magical properties, allowing all who held it a literal ticket to main event stardom. Rob Van Dam's chances went up in smoke (ahem), but WWE at least had the nous to have him announce his title shot in advance. CM Punk's babyface character was allowed no such protection in 2008. He looked like a weakling when he cashed in on Edge.

Soon, WWE couldn't even bother itself with using the briefcase to fortify the men who held it. It was instead used as a building block unto itself. Jack Swagger's powerfully terrible 2010 World Heavyweight Title run indicted the trope as a shoddy creative shortcut. Match quality degenerated in parallel with the briefcase's prestige; the (still exciting) match became synonymous with total over-selling and contrived spots of oneupmanship.

In 2017, it is still utilised as a makeweight. Current holder Baron Corbin has a dire record against Sami Zayn, but it's apparently fine because he has it. That's not really how it works, but there you go.


2. Bret Hart Vs. Shawn Michaels - WWF Survivor Series 1997

Montreal Screwjob Bret Hart Shawn Michaels
WWE.com

This match enjoys the curious distinction of both elevating pro wrestling to its former commercial heights and diminishing its legendary finish to eventually infuriating returns.

The heat McMahon generated through screwing Bret Hart on his way to WCW was so immense that it engulfed him; he had to disappear from screens altogether or embrace it. He chose the latter route, thus positioning himself as the perfect antagonist to wrestling's hottest protagonist. The Austin Vs. McMahon feud was a deliriously entertaining sensation.

Perhaps because of that - or an inability to create a new paradigm in the face of so much TV time to fill - WWE continues to structure shows around authority figures both malevolent and benevolent. Vince didn't just screw Bret Hart that night; he screwed Jack Tunney and the realistic and immersive notion that TV wrestling cards were finalised in advance, which why wouldn't they be?

The Screwjob Finish trope still hasn't died a death, either. The horse hasn't so much been beaten as utterly disemboweled.

Some might balk at the classification of this match, totally overshadowed and defined by the finish, as "great". Those first ten minutes remain absolutely incredible, however; the searing arena-wide brawl, flanked by high-ranking WWF officials in an unprecedented production technique, are as gritty and realistic as any sequence in company history.


1. The Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels - WWE WrestleMania 25

Undertaker, Shawn Michaels
WWE.com

So many speak of The Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania 25 as the greatest match in pro wrestling history that it might as well be. Wrestling is funny like that.

It was a fantastically structured and paced battle between two inseparable legends putting on the performance of their careers to put the other away. The layout demanded that level of performance, and we received it. Never had the Undertaker struck his choke slam with such velocity. Never had Michaels reached the height he did to sell it with such conviction.

Michaels Vs. 'Taker wasn't just a open air festival of massive moves. The psychology was so impeccable that the Texans rendered a fairly obvious outcome doubtful. The famous visual saw 'Taker, having failed to put Michaels away with the Tombstone, plaster a look of complete incredulity across his face. He almost looked silly, but that was the point. The failure humanised him. He made you believe that Michaels just might end his Streak of immortality.

'Taker did eventually win - but only after he and Michaels assembled roughly fifteen false finishes. Not one of them stretched disbelief. This was WrestleMania, the Showcase of the Immortals. 'Taker and Michaels lived up to that better than anybody with their sublime if on-the-nose story.

Unfortunately, its tropes have been borrowed to such an extent that many WWE matches since read as a parody of them. Every major near-fall requires a version of that kickout face. Every main event requires at least three false finishes to get over the idea that it is a Big WWE Match.

All matches have to follow a template they do not have a hope of living up to.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!