10 Great Wrestling Feuds With Awful Payoff Matches

Examples of how to turn an intense, engaging rivalry into the drizzling sh*ts.

Kane Undertaker WrestleMania XIV
WWE

When wrestling is at its best, so often there's a white-hot character or believable, engaging rivalry at the centre of the action. Even now, if fans look back at their favourite wrestling memories, the chances are that those memories will be built around a great rivalry. 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin vs. Vince McMahon is the classic example.

Throughout the decades however, these intense and fascinating rivalries haven't always fared so well when it was time to step between the ropes and get a match underway. In fact, some once-brilliant rivalries have ended up completely falling apart, the conclusive contest designed to give some semblance of a payoff fell flat and stunk out the place.

While we could easily go on about the greatest matches from the greatest wrestlers in the greatest feuds in history, it's far more fun to take the low road and highlight those times when it all turned sour once a brewing rivalry finally made it to bell-time. And when it comes down to it, it's in the ring that so often the famed payoff of an angle or feud is meant to happen.

Keeping that in mind, here are some examples of great wrestling rivalries that ultimately ended in horrendous payoffs or awful in-ring action.

10. AJ Styles Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura

AJ Styles Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

For anybody with even a passing interest in New Japan Pro Wrestling, the prospect of seeing AJ Styles square off against Shinsuke Nakamura – at WrestleMania, no less! – was a mouth-watering proposal.

Finally, with Styles running SmackDown as the WWE Champion and Nakamura having won the 2018 Royal Rumble, the pair were put on a collision course for WrestleMania 34. Surely this was the match that would steal the show, right? It absolutely, undoubtedly, impossibly could not be a dud, yeah?

When all was said and done, the Styles vs. Nakamura match was “okay”. The thing is, with the genuine chemistry and history between the two, audiences were expecting a whole lot more than “okay” for this battle at the Showcase of the Immortals. Styles got the victory, then the King of Strong Style turned heel by giving AJ a post-match shot to the balls.

Several other PPV matches between the pair would follow WrestleMania 34, yet all of them were frustratingly average and largely built around Shinsuke’s fascination with slamming his forearm into Styles’ little Phenomenal One.


9. Triple H Vs. Randy Orton

Triple H Orton
WWE

Even the thought of Triple H vs. Randy Orton at WrestleMania 25 is enough to get your eyes feeling a little heavy.

While the match itself was boring as all hell, the build to this ‘Mania bout was actually entertaining. Orton had won the 2009 Royal Rumble and decided to challenge for Triple H’s WWE Championship at the Showcase of the Immortals. As a way to mess with Hunter, The Viper began to beat the snot out of the entire McMahon family. Homes would be broken into, people would be thrown through windows, and Randy would get all kinds of creepy with Stephanie. Pretty intense, for sure.

After having simmered for months, this rivalry all came to a head at WrestleMania 25 in what was expected to be an intense, all-out fight. The thing is, that intensity was replaced by 25 minutes of rest holds.

Like so many Triple H matches, this was an overly long bout that saw fans lose interest. On a PPV that featured The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels, a Money in the Bank Ladder Match, John Cena defeating Edge and Big Show in a brisk and fun contest, and the hugely entertaining Chris Jericho vs. Ricky Steamboat, Roddy Piper and Jimmy Snuka offering, the WWE Championship match between Triple H and Randy Orton was one of the worst matches on the card.

Even now, the Hunter/Orton rivalry is one that rears its head every so often – inducing cold sweats on those who remember WrestleMania 25.


8. Brock Lesnar Vs. Dean Ambrose

Lesnar Ambrose II
WWE.com

Heading into WrestleMania 32, it was hoped that Brock Lesnar and Dean Ambrose could make the most of the No Holds Barred stipulation to steal the show at that edition of the Showcase of the Immortals. Instead, we were left with a match that became a lacklustre afterthought.

In the build, the rivalry was ignited as Ambrose and Heyman exchanged the sorts of barbs that got people genuinely intrigued in a match that they initially didn’t really care for. All of a sudden, it was as if a lightbulb went off in the collective consciousness of the wrestling world at the prospect of the unhinged lunatic going up against the merciless wrecking ball.

The match teased fans with extreme action and Ambrose getting to let loose with some weapons, yet the bout soon fell into the standard Lesnar formula: The Beast dominates, the opponent makes a comeback, plentiful more German Suplexes follow, and Brock gets the 1-2-3.

Having now reverted back to his Jon Moxley moniker after leaving WWE in his dust, the former Dean Ambrose has not been shy in revealing just how disinterested Brock was about making this match anything special.


7. Bret Hart Vs. Jerry Lawler

Bret Hart jerry lawler
WWE.com

Initially, this was a feud that wrote itself. Bret Hart had just won the 1993 King of the Ring, while trash-talking heel Jerry Lawler had long been known as The King. Lawler saw himself as the only person worthy of the crown, and so he took umbrage with Hart’s new status. Ta-da!

While this rivalry started off on such simple footing, the payoff to this feud was absolutely painful to watch. After Lawler was able to talk his way out of several matches with The Hitman – such as faking injury at SummerSlam ’93 or having the villainous Hakushi go after Hart – the pair eventually met at the 1994 edition of King of the Ring. In a stipulation nobody asked for, the loser of the match would have to kiss the victor’s feet.

Yes, you have the greatest technical wrestler in history (bold yet true) in a feud against one of the most charismatic brawlers the business has even seen, yet the hotly anticipated match between the two is built around crusty feet and dirty socks. *Sigh*

Unfortunately, that King of the Ring ’94 match – which Bret won – wasn’t the end of this rivalry, as Lawler brought in his own personal dentist to feud with The Excellence of Execution. You might know him better as Kane, but back then he was simply Isaac Yankem.


6. Bray Wyatt Vs. Everyone

Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

Right now, many savvy wrestling fans – or is that what we refer to as smarks? – are getting all kinds of excited about the return to in-ring action of Bray Wyatt. With his new Firefly Fun House schtick and the ominous Fiend now in his arsenal, Bray is surely a can’t-miss talent who is destined to be inserted into the main event picture instantly. That’s the thought of many. But, for those many, it’s time to have a brief history lesson.

Since debuting on the main WWE roster, Bray Wyatt has this strange habit of having so many fantastic feuds and rivalries that ultimately end in drab, bland matches – which usually end with Wyatt staring at the lights as his opponent gets the spoils.

Bray is an enigma of sorts, in that he talks such a great game, the majority of his rivalries are cleverly thought out, crowds always go nuts for his entrance, and yet the end result is usually some awful payoff for the one-time Husky Harris.

Whether it was against The Shield, John Cena, Daniel Bryan, Randy Orton, Finn Bálor or countless others, Bray’s feuds have this horrible pattern of ending in an awful payoff that’s either a losing effort for Wyatt or simply a dud match.


5. The Undertaker Vs. Brock Lesnar

The Undertaker Brock Lensnar
WWE.com

While The Undertaker has embarked on legendary WrestleMania battles with Shawn Michaels, Triple H, CM Punk, and, err, Giant González, one of best built matches of The Phenom’s famed WrestleMania streak was his WrestleMania XXX match against Brock Lesnar.

In the build, Paul Heyman was at his Paul Heyman best as he talked us into wanting to see his Beast facing off against The Deadman. Sure, ‘Taker had somehow managed to best all other ‘Mania opponents, but how could he be expected to put a stop to the sheer aggression and brutality of the former UFC Heavyweight Champion? Famously, of course, that question was answered by Lesnar hitting multiple F-5s and pinning The Undertaker in the middle of the ring.

Some may take umbrage with Lesnar being the one to end the streak – or even the streak being ended at all – but it was the way that it ended which really fell flat. The match was awful, The Undertaker was knocked loopy moments into the bout, and the two real-life buddies just didn’t click in the slightest. The Undertaker’s streak had ended with a whimper.

Skip forward to the following year’s Battleground event, and we saw Undertaker return to kick Lesnar in the d*ck. Literally.


4. Chris Jericho Vs. Goldberg

jericho goldberg
wwe

Back during their time together in WCW, Chris Jericho famously stirred up a huge amount of interest in seeing him getting his ass kicked by Bill Goldberg.

Despite zero input or interest from Goldberg himself, Jericho would take constant jabs at Da Man, as the Canadian began to amass his own particular winning streak against Goldberg. Of course, this wasn’t a real win streak and Jericho was simply claiming random victories, but that perfectly played into his jackass persona of the time. Jericho was a heel, chatting sh*t, outright lying, and brilliantly getting the fans eager to see Jericho and the former NFL star butt heads in a match. Granted, Goldberg would likely destroy Jericho in a matter of minutes with his trusty Spear/Jackhammer combo, but it would at least be some semblance of payback for all of the BS Jericho had been spouting.

What was the payoff to all of this? Nothing at all. Goldberg – who was clearly a big-time power player in WCW by that point – shot down any idea of working with Jericho, deeming the size difference between the two as making any match unrealistic. Instead, all we got was a brief Spear on Jericho during a TV segment. No match, no ass-kicking, no promo exchanges, no payoff.

The pair would later meet in a WWE ring, with Goldberg getting the best of Jericho as Bill began his climb towards Triple H’s World Heavyweight Championship.


3. Hollywood Hogan Vs. Roddy Piper

Hollywood Hogan vs. Roddy Piper - Starrcade 1996
WWE

No, not WrestleMania I. In fact, forget about any of Roddy Piper and Hulk Hogan’s WWF matches. What we’re focusing on here is the pair’s battle at WCW Starrcade in 1996.

Having formed the New World Order earlier that year, Hogan and his nWo buddies had ran roughshod through WCW. Nobody could stop this faction as they amassed more members, more power, and by this point in time were even shown to be in cahoots with Executive Vice President Eric Bischoff. But who’s that figure stepping out of the shadows? No, it wasn’t Sting (more on him later). It was, in fact, “Rowdy” Roddy Piper.

The long-time rivals would go face-to-face as Piper looked to be the one to put a stop to Hollywood Hogan and the nWo at Starrcade. After some fantastic promo segments in which the pair discussed their iconic status and lengthy history with each other, the match at Starrcade was dire for several reasons.

First up, this 15-minute bout was built around rest holds. Secondly, you could tell that the two didn't want their rival looking too good. Thirdly, and most frustratingly, Piper’s submission victory over Hogan was revealed to have been worth nothing. You see, despite Hogan being WCW Champion at the time, the fall-out from Starrcade saw WCW squirming out of a title change by confusingly stating that the belt wasn’t actually on the line.

Placating both men's egos, this finally gave Piper a victory over Hogan while keeping the championship on Hollywood.


2. The Undertaker Vs. Kane

Undertaker, Kane, WrestleMania XIV
WWE.com

If somebody said to you that Kane’s WWF debut was the very best debut in the history of the wrestling business, even if you didn’t completely agree with that statement, you wouldn’t think it unrealistic. The build and initial impact of Kane’s debut in 1997 was simply the stuff of legend.

Paul Bearer had revealed to the world that The Undertaker’s long-dead brother was actually alive and well. And not just that, but he would soon be making his presence known. Said presence would be felt at October ‘97’s Badd Blood PPV, with Kane attacking The Phenom during his Hell in a Cell match against Shawn Michaels.

Undertaker and Kane would eventually square off at WrestleMania XIV, and the end result was a stinker of a match. Regardless of how great the brewing rivalry had been between the brothers, the ‘Mania match was enough to send audiences to sleep.

This wouldn’t be the last time that an Undertaker/Kane rivalry culminated in an awful payoff. Years later, Undertaker would famously ditch his American Badass persona to return to his familiar Deadman character and face Kane at WrestleMania XX – that match being a dud. Then, there was the whole “vegetative state” angle that culminated in a drab SummerSlam 2010 match between the Brothers of Destruction.

Despite being two of the WWE’s greatest ever characters, and despite working on-camera so well together, matches between The Undertaker and Kane often ended up being major let-downs.


1. Hollywood Hogan Vs. Sting

Sting Hogan Starrcade 1997
WWE Network

Since its formation at Bash at the Beach ’96, the New World Order decimated the entire roster of WCW for the next year or more. Whomever the nWo set their sights on, the group would either completely destroy that person or somehow convince them to join the famed back ‘n’ white.

Away from the in-ring action, one man slowly started to cast his steely gaze on what Messrs Hogan, Hall and Nash were up to. That man, of course, was the WCW’s franchise player, Sting.

Having undergone a drastic revamp, The Stinger was now a mute who sat in the rafters. In an example of just how great WCW’s storytelling was at one point, week by week audiences would see this tale play out at a methodical pace. From Sting sitting in the rafters, to Sting picking off certain wrestlers, to Sting’s eventual match with Hollywood Hogan at Starrcade ’97.

This was it, this was the big one, this was finally the time that Hogan and the nWo got their just desserts for all of the carnage they’d caused throughout WCW. And technically, yes, it was. Sting did indeed step up and defeat Hogan for the WCW Championship on that night, but the match was utter garbage.

Quite frankly, this hotly anticipated battle between two behemoths was awful. Despite Sting being the avenging babyface, Hogan dominated the entire match bar the final sequence - the eventual payoff to this being Sting's victory looking like an undeserving fluke.


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.