10 Great WWE Feuds That Never Got A One-On-One WrestleMania Match

Fans were robbed of a Triple H and Rock one-on-one WrestleMania match!

Triple H The Rock
WWE

Shane McMahon and The Miz have had two different singles matches at WrestleMania. OK, technically their second bout also featured Snoop Dogg (Shane's leg exploded after about 30 seconds), but the point still stands. 

There have been some truly strange one-on-one matches to take place at WrestleMania, from the head of the company versus a Super Bowl finalist to a zombie versus a giant in a naked bodysuit. Yet, WWE never managed to give the following famous rivalries the spotlight they deserved. 

At a pay-per-view that has seen Austin fight Rock, Hart fight Michaels, and Hogan fight André, these famous foes weren't afforded the same luxury. 

All of these storied enemies did wrestle each other at least once at WrestleMania, but never in a traditional singles match. Triple threats, fatal four-ways, battle royals, ladder matches, and many other tricks were used to keep them from having the ring all to themselves. 

Sometimes this was a good idea, sometimes it wasn't.

WWE likes to tell us that WrestleMania is where the biggest rivalries in their history are blown off, but this list proves that very much isn't the case. 

10. Gunther vs. Sheamus

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 GUNTHER Sheamus
WWE.com

By 2022, Sheamus had been in WWE for over a decade and was getting stale. He could still go in the ring, sure, but many felt as if his best days were behind him. 

And then he met a giant man from Austria. 

The Celtic Warrior was booked to face Gunther for the Intercontinental Championship at Clash at the Castle. Did this event take place in Wales rather than Sheamus' home country of Ireland? Yes. Do WWE care? Or even know the difference? Not at all. 

The two behemoths slapped each other silly in front of a rabid crowd. The match received the full five stars from Dave Meltzer and was easily the greatest match of Sheamus' career. 

The stage was set for a rematch at the upcoming WrestleMania 29. Instead, WWE chucked in Drew McIntyre and made it a triple threat.

This sounds like I'm complaining. I'm not. The three-way was awesome, possibly even better than the original. However, it still felt weird that Sheamus didn't get his big solo moment. 

The Irishman hasn't had a 'Mania match since, which feels even weirder. 


9. Bret Hart vs. Davey Boy Smith

Summerslam 1992 Bret Hart British Bulldog Davey Boy Smith
WWE.com

SummerSlam 1992 is a WWE canon event.

The glitz and glamour of London's Wembley Stadium. A British hero in the main event. One of the best bell-to-bell matches in the company's history. It simply writes itself.

Davey Boy Smith defeated his brother-in-law Bret Hart to win the Intercontinental Championship on home turf. It was a beautiful moment, despite the fact that, according to Bret, Davey was zonked out of his skull on drugs at the time. 

Five years earlier, the pair had met at WrestleMania III under very different circumstances. They were on opposite sides of a six-man tag, where Hart was teaming with Jim Neidhart and Danny Davis, and Davey was part of a trio with The Dynamite Kid and Tito Santana. 

Even with one of the best WWE matches ever under his belt, Smith never got a singles match at 'Mania after '92. The company clearly didn't see him as a top star and had him toil away in tag teams for the rest of his career.

As for Bret, his career went from strength to strength, and by WrestleMania IX in 1993, he was the WWE Champion.

Just don't ask him how that ended. 


8. Chris Jericho vs. Chris Benoit

Chris Jericho Benoit Submission Match WWE Raw 2005 Japan
WWE

It's always difficult to praise Chris Benoit, given the things he did, but he had some incredible rivalries in his time. 

One of his best in WWE was with his namesake and fellow Canadian, Chris Jericho. The pair went from friends to enemies numerous times in the dying days of the Attitude Era, laying the groundwork for the workrate-heavy era of wrestling we live in today.

At 'Mania 2000, Benoit and Jericho were part of a three-way for both the Intercontinental and European Championships, where their dance partner (and double champ) was Kurt Angle. The pair actually pinned each other to win their respective belts, leaving Angle technically undefeated, but thoroughly belt-less. 

Over the course of the next year, Benoit and Jericho clashed a number of times on TV and pay-per-view, notably at SummerSlam 2000 and Royal Rumble 2001. 

They would share the ring one more time at WrestleMania 21 as part of the first-ever Money in the Bank ladder match. However, a one-on-one battle just wasn't on the cards.

Given the great matches both Chrises would have without each other, just imagine the WrestleMania magic they could have woven together.


7. The Four Horsewomen

NXT Four Horsewomen
WWE

Here's an interesting fact for you. There have been six different WrestleManias in which some combination of The Four Horsewomen of NXT - that's Charlotte Flair, Bayley, Becky Lynch, and Sasha Banks (Mercedes Moné) - shared the ring. 

As either opponents or partners, this quartet of revolutionary women dominated WWE throughout the mid-2010s and early 2020s. Between 2016 and 2020, there wasn't a single WrestleMania that didn't feature the Horsewomen going up against each other in some form or fashion.

And yet, there has never been a one-on-one match between any of them.

The first time they clashed was at WrestleMania 32. Flair, Banks, and Lynch fought for the newly minted WWE Women's Championship in what was easily the best all-women's match in 'Mania history up to that point. 

Three years later, Flair and Lynch shared the main event spot of WrestleMania 35 with Ronda Rousey. Yes, this should have absolutely been a singles match between Becky and Ronda, but that's a discussion for another time.

WWE loves to put women in multi-person matches at WrestleMania, so, in a way, this isn't surprising. It would have been nice to have had at least one, though. 


6. Triple H vs. The Rock

Triple H The Rock
WWE

This is arguably the most interesting entry on this list, because it's the one match that should have happened more than any other. 

In the lead-up to WrestleMania 2000, it looked clear as crystal that WWE Champion Triple H would be defending the gold against The Rock in the main event.

Then Vince McMahon realised that his family members needed a payday. 

The final match of the card was changed to the infamous 'McMahon in Every Corner' four-way. Big Show and Mick Foley joined The Game and The Great One, diluting what would have been an epic singles encounter. 

If you don't think that a singles match would have been better, just watch the main event of the following month's Backlash.

Trips and Rocky didn't even get to fight at WrestleMania during their earlier midcard feud. Their ladder match at SummerSlam 1998 is the only 'Big Four' showdown they ever had. 

There hasn't been a match between these two since the August 19th, 2002 episode of Raw. There were plans for Dwayne to team with Ronda Rousey against Hunter and Stephanie McMahon at WrestleMania 34, but Kurt Angle ended up taking his place instead. 


5. Triple H vs. Shawn Michaels

Triple H Shawn Michaels Summerslam 2002
WWE.com

If it had been down to Triple H, he would have fought every single one of his greatest rivals at WrestleMania. And he would have won every time.

However, if he was ever going to get his wish, you'd have bet your bottom dollar it would have been against Shawn Michaels. 

These long-time friends-turned-enemies-turned-friends, etc., held so much backstage pull across their careers, it's a minor miracle they never got their big 'Mania match. 

Remarkably, the only time they ever faced off at the biggest show of the year was to get someone else over. 

The Cerebral Assassin and HBK were joined by Chris Benoit in the closing match of WrestleMania XX. The Rabid Wolverine overcame all the odds to claim the World Heavyweight Championship and leave the former DX members empty-handed. 

The only other time they would share the ring at WrestleMania was in 2012. Michaels served as the special guest referee for his buddy's Hell in a Cell match against The Undertaker, even throwing a cheeky superkick the Deadman's way. 

It's probably for the best these two didn't go one-on-one at WrestleMania. The match would have lasted five hours. 


4. John Cena vs. Randy Orton

WWE Backlash 2025 John Cena Randy Orton
WWE.com

If WWE is to be believed, John Cena and Randy Orton are two of the greatest rivals in wrestling history. 

In reality, they just fought each other a lot in 2009.

The two OVW standouts were aggressively shoved down audiences' throats throughout the late noughties. Astonishingly, they never had a singles match at WrestleMania, even though the stage was perfectly set for one in 2008. 

Orton was WWE Champion, while Cena had won that year's Royal Rumble. Bafflingly, the future movie star chose to cash in his opportunity at No Way Out instead of WrestleMania XXIV.

Why? Your guess is as good as mine. 

As Orton got himself disqualified, Cena was given the WrestleMania match anyway. However, they were joined by Elimination Chamber winner Triple H, making it a three-way.

Did WWE sabotage this singles match just to give Trips something to do? I'm saying nothing...

This would be the only time Cena and Orton would tangle at WrestleMania, which is remarkable restraint on WWE's part. 

There's an alternative universe out there where these two fought each other at every WrestleMania for a decade.


3. John Cena vs. Edge

John Cena Vs Edge Unforgiven 2006
Copyright: WWE Top Rivalries 2005 Blu-ray

Randy Orton might be John Cena's most famous rival, but we all know who his best one was.

At New Year's Revolution 2006, Edge cashed in the first-ever Money in the Bank briefcase to beat John Cena for the WWE Championship. 

This was in January. WrestleMania 22 was just a few months away. Surely Cena would get his rematch at The Showcase of the Immortals.

Nope. He won the title back three weeks later at the Royal Rumble. Cena would fight Triple H at 'Mania, while Edge had his legendary match with Mick Foley. 

It would take another three years for them to finally get their big match, when Edge was the defending World Heavyweight Champion going up against Cena at WrestleMania 25. Alas, this bromance was crashed by the Big Show, who was also in the match. Cena famously lifted both men on his shoulders at the same time before pinning the giant to win the Big Gold Belt. 

Cena and Edge had one of the best rivalries of 2006, one that absolutely should have culminated in a WrestleMania match. Once again, though, Triple H needed something to do. You know the rules.


2. Trish Stratus vs. Lita

Trish Stratus Lita 2004
WWE.com

Trish Stratus vs. Lita is WWE's go-to example of a historical women's feud.

In that case, it might surprise you to learn that they only had three singles matches on pay-per-view against each other throughout their entire careers.

None of these battles ever took place at WrestleMania. The only time they opposed each other at the biggest show of the year was at 'Mania X8, where they were both challengers in a three-way battle for Jazz's Women's Championship. In one of the botchiest matches you'll ever watch, Jazz pinned Lita to retain.

This would be Lita's one-and-only WrestleMania match for 21 years, which is bonkers. 

The former Team Extreme member finally got her sophomore outing at WrestleMania 39 in a six-woman tag team match against Damage CTRL (Bayely, Dakota Kai, and Iyo Sky). Her teammates were her fellow tag team champion Becky Lynch (remember that reign?) and her old pal Trish Stratus.

Isn't that sweet?

The only 'Big Four' show to feature a Trish vs. Lita singles match was Survivor Series 2004, and that match lasted less than two minutes. 

It just doesn't sound right, does it? 


1. Hulk Hogan vs. Roddy Piper

Hulk Hogan Roddy Piper War To Settle The Score
WWE.com

Without the rivalry between Hulk Hogan and Roddy Piper, there would be no WrestleMania today.

The popularity of Hogan as WWE Champion in the 1980s, combined with Piper's outlandish heel persona, lit the fuse for the explosion of exposure the company would receive in that decade. 

The pair were destined to fight for the top prize on a big stage, but it wasn't WrestleMania. 

Instead, Hogan put the belt on the line against the Hot Rod at The War to Settle the Score, an MTV special that took place about a month before the first WrestleMania.

Piper got himself disqualified when his cornermen Paul Orndorff and Bob Orton Jr. got involved in the match. This led to The Hulkster's pals Mr. T and Cyndi Lauper coming to his aid, setting up Hogan and T. vs. Piper and Orndorff in the main event of the legendary Madison Square Garden show. 

WWE were always going to put a celebrity in the main event of the first WrestleMania. However, in an ideal world, Hogan and Piper would have gone one-on-one on the most important night in wrestling history.


Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.