10 Huge Mistakes WWE Have Made With The WWE Network
Stream of Unconsciousness.
The WWE Network is often a wrestling fan's biggest gift, but can at times be a hand-wringing source of frustration.
With separate confirmation from both Renee Young and Daniel Bryan that their (company endorsed) renegade broadcast 'Smacking Talk' had been discontinued after just one hilarious episode, it brought a conclusive end to the weekly variant of the cult hit they've fronted through the over-the-top subscription service since the 2016 Draft.
Those who watched the daft skit featuring the hosts and Chad Gable openly mocking the Kurt Angle/Jason Jordan storyline with the thin veneer of spoof likely weren't surprised by the news. Though only gentle comedy, it was still a shot across the bow both at a major creative direction on Monday Night Raw, and WWE as a whole for taking away what they almost certainly perceived to be the most fun aspect of their diverse roles within Vince McMahon's organisation.
By all accounts, Talking Smack was binned because viewing figures simply did not stack up to budgetary investment, but a loud vocal majority's protestations in the aftermath of its cancellation highlighted a more complex challenge for WWE to overcome as it attempts to grow the Network into something that will stabilise the entire financial future of the organisation.
Though all requisite 1980s-style graphs have largely pointed in the right direction since it's 2014 inception, a total lack of strategy almost from the off has hampered what should have been a monstrous success, rather than a hefty commitment that only tiptoes towards mediocre targets.
10. (Not) Talking Smack
Briefly touched upon but worth repeating, Talking Smack's cancellation highlighted a much wider problem with creative oppression in present day WWE.
Along with sagging ratings, rumours abounded that Vince McMahon had caught snatches of the broadcast and lost faith in the performers to work without the net of the fiercely tight scripting now considered a company-wide norm.
In pulling the rug out from under the blue brand's sister act though, he served only to further restrict their progress. It may indeed be somewhat nerve-wracking to work the show, especially with the knowledge that one verbal misstep or sideways veer has the potential to be shared and seen by millions on social media seconds after broadcast. However, the same reach also applies when a performer shines.
Two powerful performances from The Miz early in the show's lifespan drew huge attention, whilst similarly strong efforts from Naomi, The Usos and Baron Corbin brought their personas on lightyears in comparison to what they were then permitted to display on the main show.
'The Lone Wolf' in particular exuded sensational confidence earlier this year, pledging at the time to win both the WWE Title and the Royal Rumble match in order to raise his own hand at WrestleMania and take the night off. His believable belligerence only grew from there, and helped him turn a gimmick into a character that now wields a Money In The Bank briefcase. Similar opportunities will no longer exist for his contemporaries.
9. Going Live
No longer promoting pay-per-views as the one-off purchases they used to be, WWE adjusted their model significantly with the birth of the Network by guaranteeing each subscriber at least one monthly supercard, then increasing that output following the 2016 Draft.
Arguments of creative overkill are normally silenced by the apparent need to super-serve, but the organisation have perhaps overlooked a more nuanced way to introduce original content.
With live specials such as 'The Beast In The East', the original 'Roadblock' and the UK Championship Tournament, WWE were able to present first-time extravaganzas that strayed from the traditional sights, sounds and stagnation of the weekly television churn. Each broadcast represented something that genuinely felt like a rewarding reason to subscribe and a pleasant distraction from Raw and SmackDown's seasonal lethargy.
It's perhaps why NXT TakeOvers remain wildly popular despite a notable downturn in interest for the weekly show. The cards represent an escape from the monolithic WWE, and largely deliver at least one excellent match to boot. Part of that perception is wrapped within the company's attitude towards the cards being at least a little different, and it's an avenue they should explore far more often than they do.
8. Antisocial Media
Once an endless frustration on Raw and SmackDown thanks to Vince McMahon's sudden fascination with the medium, Twitter exploded onto WWE television with the company's traditional hamfisted delivery. Drenching the product in hashtags, trends and superstar feeds in a desperate attempt to catch up with a world already starting to tire of the second-screen audience engagement tricks, the show was enamoured with becoming the force-fed talking point of social media at large.
This spawned a brand new way of delivering breaking news and shocking stories. Rather than saving everything for television, the company employed Twitter, Instagram and Facebook as mechanisms for the reveals, acutely understanding the possibility of the shared tidbits driving viewers to the main show.
The model hasn't really changed since, but positively should have the day WWE launched their own network. That the Network exists as a static repository rather than a living, breathing product is spellbinding.
WWE has the capacity to utilise the vehicle for additional views, and yet still chooses to broadcast news snippets from online reporter Cathy Kelley on Twitter whilst revealing a surprise return, Hall of Fame inductee or injury update in full on Instagram.
Every single one of these should be broke exclusively on the Network, with the various media channels directing subscribers to log in immediately and check out the latest hot topic. It would create a culture of urgency and immediacy around the vehicle that has sadly lacked since its inception.
7. Looking After Number One
Chris Jericho's return on the post-Battleground edition of SmackDown Live! opened a magnificent edition of the show that also featured a stellar triple threat main event and the announcement of Shinsuke Nakamura vs John Cena the following week.
Wrapped around that broadcast were episodes of Raw that featured the reveal of Jason Jordan as Kurt Angle's son, and a pay-per-view quality Braun Strowman/Roman Reigns/Samoa Joe clash that helped set the table for SummerSlam's blockbuster Universal Title match also featuring the champion Brock Lesnar.
Whilst most assessments suggested that WWE were perhaps experiencing some insecurity over their internal standing with USA Network due to steeply decreasing viewing figures over the past several years, the overloaded episodes only served to sabotage the blue brand's pay-per-view, which was widely and rightfully panned as the worst supercard of the year. It fell even below the low bar set by April's turgid Payback event, which suffered similarly at the hands of some remarkable television robbing it of drama that could live up to the same pedigree.
The pattern is likely to continue, with WWE attempting to serve both masters and simultaneously failing both. The monthly fee warrants significance on the monthly shows, but the USA's hefty rights fee renewal in 2014 may not be quite so substantial the next time if figures continue to circle the drain.
6. Table For Three Hours
A surprise hit from the Network's inconsistent 'original content' block, Table For 3 has offered a keen insight into numerous tales as told by the people that lived through them in a digestible 20 minute session.
Astonishingly though, the programme actually remains one of the few occasions where Vince McMahon hasn't subscribed to his 'more is always more' philosophy.
According to Jim Cornette, AJ Styles and others that have spoke about their experiences during the meal-time tapings, the conversations last for hours, with the performers having no idea what'll make air until they see it themselves. As enjoyable as the shorts have been thus far, it's remarkable to consider what may have ended up on the cutting room floor as a result.
With a mix of legends and present day stars featured, the company appears to take advantage of mass gatherings such as WrestleMania to bottle up as many episodes of the format as they can, so in contrast to a vehicle such as Talking Smack, it hopefully returns much from a relatively small investment. An extended edition for subscribers wishing to dine longer would be a welcome add-on to the already-delectable venture.
5. Baby Steps
There was bound to be a feeling out process with such an enormous new endeavour when WWE launched the Network in 2014, but the misplaced commitment to low quality productions such as Jerry Springer's Too Hot For TV and the already-shot Legends House completely misrepresented what the service had an offer.
Boasting an enormous range of pay-per-views and telecasts that have continued to increase, the company made a big leap forward with The Monday Night Wars docu-series, though the subject matter was weathered and well-worn.
What it did show was the company's willingness to mine archive footage more for Network content than DVD releases, as had previously been the case. The success of the format in general also triggered the eventual creation of the phenomenal Breaking Ground series that walked hand-in-hand with NXT during the developmental brand's most triumphant spell, and the ongoing fly-on-the-wall concept 24, which even recently caught Vince McMahon in an extremely rare moment of candour as he embraced Kurt Angle upon the Olympian's return to WWE headquarters.
It was unfortunate that early misunderstandings of their core demographic's needs threatened to undermine the potential of an excellent service, but the recovery rate was at least impressively quick.
4. Zero Hour Contracts
Amongst the litany of reasons why CM Punk walked out of WWE in January 2014 was an unanswered question about how wrestlers will be reimbursed for their work on 'Network specials' in comparison to the percentage fee previously creamed from pay-per-views.
It was a salient point worthy of response then, and remains something of a mystery now as buyrates continue to diminish, nearly reaching the point to where standalone purchases are completely obsolete.
Though gradual at first, the earning potential of virtually every roster member has continued to drop, with WWE mainlining more dollars into company coffers rather than superstar paycheques despite constant demands for improving workrate and continued character development.
It's led many talented individuals on the independent circuit to look beyond the prism of WWE for financial reasons, something once considered unthinkable in the North American wrestling scene. That in turn risks the company as a whole becoming the homogonised bore it was throughout much of the 2000s, with a low-ceilinged level of main roster stars emerging from the unproven Performance Centre.
If WWE wishes to continue providing not only the most but also the best wrestling content through the Network, the company must reimburse talent for their incredible sacrifices accordingly.
3. The YouTube Dilemma
WWE's current relationship with YouTube has resulted in just about every segment from Raw, SmackDown Live! and NXT getting a near-full airing on the site the next day, allowing many fans to pick and choose the bits they're interested in rather than facing the daunting task of watching over five hours of original first-run content every week.
It's naturally become a matter of a concern in relation to declining ratings, but the problem also extends to how regular users engage with the WWE Network.
Though the company works tirelessly in removing archive footage and limiting the content available to view on the biggest video sharing site in the world, YouTube remains the first port of call for the type of quick searches and segment snapshots the Network simply cannot provide. Stone Cold Steve Austin (himself an occasional WWE 'podcast' host) even recommends watching classic matches through it rather than directing fans to go to the trouble of tracking down the show and the match buried deep in the Network's archives.
Unfortunately, the mutually beneficial relationship with YouTube looks here to stay, which will continually render the Network a lesser option if fans go hunting for a quick fix. Only an enormous overhaul of the Network's search system would bring the services remotely closer together.
2. Speculate To Accumulate
The great sadness around Talking Smack's cancellation was mirrored in quieter fashion by Edge and Christian's revelation in their own podcast that a second series of their hit show (...'that totally reeks of awesomeness') was unlikely due to budgetary demands elsewhere.
It joined the SmackDown sister show alongside Legends With JBL and Breaking Ground as once-popular vehicles that got the chop, but begged the question as to why WWE feels the need to run its subscriber service as if they were a stereotypically evil television network. Why go to the trouble of 'cancelling' anything? Or for that matter, even announcing the intention to do such a thing?
Though impossible to hide Talking Smack's abandonment, fans would just wait patiently for new episodes of their other favourite shows safe in ignorance that they may not make a comeback, especially whilst distracted with brand new and exclusive content offered in the meantime.
Furthermore, if money does magically appear available in the future, it avoids having to go back on a cancellation if the best way to spend it is with brand new editions of popular favourites. The abject sh*t-canning of some of the aforementioned programmes unnecessarily buries them with crushing permanence, attacking subscriber optimism that the service will continue to be worth time and financial investment.
1. Destination Unknown
There has been an irrefutable lack of long term vision for the WWE Network since the day it launched.
Countless different subscription strategies gave way to the relentless push of the price-point on television, but the company foolishly left in the opportunity to dip in and out of constantly free trial periods that allow irregular users to claim events such as Royal Rumble or WrestleMania completely gratis.
Ironically, it is those that pay for the Network's supposed convenience that often suffer most. As recently as last month, there were multiple complaints of feeds dropping or merely not loading for Battleground, and as a streaming service in general, the software on virtually every device drastically pales in comparison to Netflix, Amazon Video and other market leaders.
Indecisiveness over the direction of the Network at large continually plagues its overall growth, and a dissonance between the hollow soulless robots on television and the actual human beings on a 24 Special or Table For 3 creates the persistent viewer strife for those that indulge in every aspect of WWE's bloated offering.
The Network can no longer remain a video archive and a purveyor of innovative new content without ending up dissatisfying at least one strand of subscribers. The sooner the company focus that process (or at least redesign the layout around it), the better it'll be at attracting brand new customers and sustaining problematic casual fly-by-nights.