10 Insane WrestleMania Main Events That Nearly Happened

Deep in the multiverse, somebody squashed a butterfly and these matches headlined WrestleMania.

John Cena Jerry Lawler WWE Raw Royal Rumble 2011
WWE

Are you ready to enter the multiverse of 'Mania? 

The history of WWE is filled with famous what if moments. These hypothetical scenarios explore how different decisions, injuries, or unexpected events could have dramatically altered the course of wrestling history. Imagine if "Stone Cold" Steve Austin had never suffered his career-altering neck injury, or if The Rock hadn't chosen to pursue a full-time career in Hollywood. How would the landscape of the business have changed? We'll never know, which is why speculating is so much fun.

With WWE holding a pay-per-view between Royal Rumble and 'Mania, there's a chance to pivot from one plan to another. Sometimes it's agonisingly obvious which direction the company is going on the way to the Showcase of the Immortals, like when Roman Reigns was being forced down our throats in 2015, but Vince McMahon and Triple H have changes lanes on the Road to WrestleMania and switched things up at the last minute too.

You might have to don your tin cap for this one, as the door to the multiverse is opened and main events that WWE were a single moment away from having at WrestleMania in our universe are laid bare with disastrous consequences.

10. Austin Theory Vs. Roman Reigns

Brock Lesnar Austin Theory WWE Elimination Chamber 2022
WWE.com

Austin main evented the first night of WrestleMania 38, but could another Austin have headlined on the Sunday as well?

Back in the days when Vince McMahon decided that cheeky egg thief Austin Theory was the next big thing, the man who was only promoted to the main roster because of injuries on the Road to WrestleMania a year earlier was suddenly in one of WWE's most famous matches.

Not only was he there, but he was in the last two, with the WWE Championship on the line. The only problem: he was across the ring from Brock Lesnar. He might've had a shot; Lesnar had just won the Royal Rumble match, plus nobody had ever stamped their ticket to 'Mania in January and won the WWE title before the Show of Shows.

The Beast Incarnate made short work of Theory in reality. A brutal F5 from the top of an Elimination Chamber pod and there was no questioning that Theory wouldn't be going to 'Mania to face Roman Reigns. Fans cried out with joy, then quickly realised they were about to see Lesnar-Reigns for the 50th time...


9. Kurt Angle Vs. Steve Austin

The Rock Kurt Angle No Way Out 2001
WWE.com

The stars aligned at WrestleMania X-Seven, when the two biggest starts of the Attitude Era main evented the Granddaddy of Them All.

Six weeks earlier, it didn't look as simple at that.

Just over a year after making his debut, Kurt Angle was riding high as the WWE Champion. Vince McMahon had strapped a rocket to the most legitimate wrestler in the company and, having come through a six-man Hell in a Cell match against some of the biggest stars in the business, then beaten Triple H a month later, there was no sign of this push coming to an end.

Enter The Rock.

Despite Angle proving he could hang with the big boys, nobody wanted to see him face the Texas Rattlesnake in his hometown. The contrast of Kurt's technically and Steve's brawling could've made a compelling Granddaddy main event, but in 2001, as the Attitude Era came to an end, It was the right decision to end the Angle experiment and give us the two biggest stars of the 2000s slugging it out in the main event again.

The Rock was out of WWE a week after X-Seven; with Angle as Austin's opponent, they might've carried on the feud into Backlash, erasing "Stone Cold" teaming with Triple H from history.


8. The Miz Vs. Drew McIntyre

WWE Elimination Chamber 2021 The Miz Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

Drew McIntyre's WWE Championship reigns during the pandemic were bizarre.

First, he randomly lost the title to Randy Orton, just to win it back a few weeks later. Then he was dethroned again one month before WrestleMania in the most painful of circumstances.

When The Miz cashed-in his Money in the Bank contract and won the belt, it was a real gut punch to fans who knew the Scottish lad was a month away from finally getting to stand in front of a real crowd as the face of the company. For a hot second it seemed like McIntyre-Miz was on the cards for 'Mania. The A-Lister had been sniffing around the main event scene for a few months; perhaps it was time he was rewarded for going one of the most consistent stars in the business, even it was just so he could be fed to Drew a month later. 

Nope. The Miz dropped the gold to Bobby Lashley, who'd helped him win it in the first place.

But it was all so fans could finally cheer Drew winning the gold, right? 

Wrong.

After rained stopped play in Tampa, McIntyre finally entered the ring with Lashley and lost.


7. Ricochet Vs. Drew McIntyre

WWE Super ShowDown 2020 Brock Lesnar Ricochet
WWE.com

Oh, where to start with Super ShowDown 2020...

This entry could've been what if Goldberg was the one to defeat "The Fiend" Bray Wyatt and go to WrestleMania as Universal Champion, but they actually booked that.

No, this one comes from a contest that fans were excited to see. Some of Brock Lesnar's best bouts have been against smaller wrestlers, so when Ricochet helped Drew McIntyre eliminate the Beast Incarnate from the Royal Rumble match, the WWE Universe was optimistic about a competitive match between the two.

That didn't happen.

It was a pointless squash, only slightly longer than when Brock did the same to Kofi Kingston on SmackDown three months early.

Part of building McIntyre into a new star was having him defeat Lesnar at 'Mania, but, at a time when the WWE Universe was getting sick of Lesnar, how many people would've minded Ricochet going over here? Sure, the match at the Showcase of the Immortals wouldn't have had the same star power, but in the end there wasn't an audience at WrestleMania 36 anyway.

Any dreams of this being a reality were dashed in 1:35. Ricochet was a three-count away from headlining 'Mania, but really he was a world away.


6. Mustafa Ali Vs. Daniel Bryan

Mustafa Ali
WWE.com

There's a lot of what if here.

Firstly, Mustafa Ali was meant to be in the Elimination Chamber match for the WWE Championship in 2019. He picked up an injury just before, which took him off TV long enough to miss the pay-per-view but come back a month later. There's always been rumours that he was meant to go all the way with WWE title holder Daniel Bryan, then lose in the final moments.

Ironically, it was Kofi Kingston who did just that. The former-Jamaican was drafted in for the injured Ali and the fan reaction to the veteran star was electric. 

After that match, the rocket that should've been strapped to Ali was redirected to Kingston. Kofi winning the WWE belt at WrestleMania 35 was a feelgood moment, after he'd been with the company for so long, but it wasn't the original plan.

Road Dogg has confirmed that Ali-Bryan was the original match, but the injury meant they had to pivot quickly. Instead, Ali's Road to WrestleMania meant taking the fall in a consolation WWE title match at Fastlane, having his first name taken away, then spending the Show of Shows marooned in catering.

Fans were so close to seeing a brand new star emerge.


5. Scott Steiner Vs. Booker T

Triple H Scott Steiner Royal Rumble 2003
WWE.com

A rematch from the very last episode of WCW Monday Nitro, Scott Steiner Vs. Booker T for the Big Gold Belt at WrestleMania XIX would've been the perfect send off for World Championship Wrestling.

Ha! As if Vince McMahon was ever going to do that.

Despite huge applause when Big Papa Pump returned at Survivor Series 2002, fans quickly realised they weren't seeing the same Steiner from a year earlier. Something changed over the previous 15 months and even though he was immediately thrown into the main event scene with Triple H , it didn't work.

Steiner had the chance to take the World Heavyweight Championship from Triple H twice, but after his first match against The Game at the Royal Rumble wasn't well received, the rematch was just a way to blow off the feud.

This was a period where Triple H went through the everybody who was anybody in WCW, but fans didn't know that yet. Imagine if Steiner had been the one feuding with Booker T, Kevin Nash, and Goldberg in 2003. He could've taken the belt all the way to WrestleMania XX and feuded with Chris Benoit, another former WCW Champion, although that would be considered a reign of terror that fans didn't want to see.


4. Rey Mysterio Vs. Edge Vs. John Cena

Edge Rey Mysterio Elimination Chamber No Way Out 2009
WWE.com

WWE flipped the world title scene on its head a month before WrestleMania 25.

Edge and John Cena walked in the belts, but Triple H and Edge left with them. The weird thing was that Edge walked in with the WWE strap, but left as World Heavyweight Champion. The Ultimate Opportunist at his absolute best. After the Rated-R Superstar lost his belt in the first Elimination Chamber match, he forced he way into the second, with Rey Mysterio, John Cena, Chris Jericho, Mike Knox, and Kane. After Edge pinned Cena it was another match where a new champion was guaranteed. 

Rey Mysterio was the final participant, and arguable should've won had it not been for Edge inserting himself into the match.

Having Rey walk into 'Mania as champion wouldn't have been too strange because he was always popular. Besides, they shoved Big Show into the match because he was having an affair with Vicky Guerrero... wrestling! Without the shenanigans, WrestleMania was gearing up to be Edge Vs. Randy Orton, meaning the choice was between a Rated-RKO showdown or an Evolution one. Both seem like the wrong decision looking back.


3. Cactus Jack Vs. Big Show

No Way Out 2000 Cactus Jack Mick Foley Triple H
WWE.com

Big Show was robbed in 2000.

Everybody knows he won the Royal Rumble match because his feet touched the floor after The Rock's, but WWE pivoted to a Fatal Four Way match.

The two men people wanted to see fight were the other pair in the match: The Rock and Triple H, although it could've been different. The Game walked into WrestleMania on the back of a star-making feud against Cactus Jack, but Mick Foley could've just as easily put over another rising star.

Let's be real: HHH had already been WWE Champion a few times at this point, but the matches at Royal Rumble and No Way Out proved he was a main event star. That rub could've gone to the World's Largest Athlete instead. Imagine a world in which Cactus Jack defeated Triple H and didn't have to retire, WWE didn't change the number one contender from The Rock to Big Show to The Rock again, then Paul Wight won the WWE strap at 'Mania 2000.

Sure, it's a stretch, but WWE was only a couple of moves away from this being a reality. Fortunately, everybody was spared this happened, then didn't have to sit through Show in a 60-minute Iron Man match a few months later... 


2. Jerry Lawler Vs. John Cena

WWE Elimination Chamber 2011 The Miz Jerry Lawler
WWE.com

Jerry "The King" Lawler was 61-years-old when he faced The Miz for the WWE Championship at Elimination Chamber 2011.

That's quite the achievement for a man who held the AWA Southern Heavyweight Championship an astonishing 58 times, but never raised gold above his head in WWE. When he finally got his shot, live on pay-per-view, fans were invested. Absurdly, it was all part of the feud between Lawler and Michael Cole (yes, the WWE title was just a prop to setup a match between commentators), and the man who was living in his "Cole Mine" at ringside had cost "The King" in a match on Raw a few weeks earlier.

Obviously, one of the oldest ever challengers for the WWE strap didn't go to WrestleMania, but he was a rope break away from walking into the biggest show of the year to both commentate and main event. Taz could never...

Would The Rock have still interfered to cost John Cena the match? Let's not forget that Cena-Miz was another match where the WWE belt was pushed aside for a different feud, so giving the belt to Lawler doesn't seem outside the realms of possibility. 


1. Santino Marella Vs. Sheamus

Santino Marella Daniel Bryan Elimination Chamber 2012
WWE.com

Everybody wanted Santino Marella to win the World Heavyweight Championship at Elimination Chamber 2012, but nobody realised it until it was too late.

When the Milan Miracle was thrown into the Elimination Chamber match for Daniel Bryan's Big Gold Belt, he was the odd man out in a contest that included two former world champions in Big Show and The Great Khali, as well as up-and-coming Cody Rhodes and Wade Barrett. Marella had spent most of his career as a comedy act, so it was downright bizarre to see him thrown into a match for the biggest prize in the company.

But after Marella pinned Barrett and Rhodes, like KofiMania a few years later, the crowd made it perfectly clear who they suddenly wanted to win.

Could Bryan losing here still have kickstarted the Yes Movement, our would fans have rallied behind Santino if he lost in 18 seconds to Sheamus at WrestleMania? In the end, Marella was in the Team Johnny Vs. Team Teddy match to determine the General Manager of both Raw and SmackDown, along with a load of other thrown together wrestlers without anything else to do. 


Watch Next


Contributor

Christopher Sharman hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.