10 Lessons WWE Could Learn From Their Own History

Vince McMahon built WWE, and yet he's forgotten some of his own tricks.

vince mcmahon
WWE.com

Love him or hate him, Vince McMahon is responsible for a lot of what's great about wrestling today. His deranged mind barreled its way into the business and changed the game. What was once his daddy's wrestling company is now a global brand, and he can be proud of that.

And while Vince is obviously a shrewd businessman, a huge reason for that was his talent as a wrestling booker. He created a product that a casual audience wanted to watch and despite the internet's complaining, they still do to this day. Characters like Stone Cold, The Rock, and Hulk Hogan were all at least partly created by Vince Jr. It's one hell of a history to draw on.

So you have to wonder why he doesn't.

In 2017 you can tune into WWE TV and pick out twenty mistakes in every show, and we are not just talking about the obvious ones either. We all love wrestling, but it could be so much better, and one way that it could be better is if it remembered what it used to be.

This isn't a Rip Roger style 'things were better in those days' rant because in many ways they weren't, but over the years Vince has forgotten the tricks that brought him to the table - the tricks which made him stand out from the crowd. WWE have a history that no one can compete with and maybe it's time they learnt from it.

10. Tag Team Wrestling Sells

Raw Hardys
WWE.com

The return of The Hardyz has given WWE’s tag team division a much-needed boost.

Their history in the company hasn't been forgotten, and their recent work outside of WWE saw them come in as stars. But with the cracks already beginning to appear in Matt's character, it feels likely that that star power will be taking them away from tag team wrestling. We can only hope that The Hardyz' brief returns to those roles will have reminded WWE of what they did in the past.

Back when The Hardyz, Edge and Christian, and The Dudleys were doing their thing every week, tag-team wrestling was more than just a bonus feature of WWE TV. Their epic rivalry was a reason to tune in all by itself. In fact, some fans were more excited about tag wrestling than they were the World Title.

This is something WWE seems to have forgotten. The biggest problem with bringing back The Hardyz is it highlights the lack of stars in the division at the moment. The New Day are over but no one buys tickets for them, and while people like other teams, they don’t love them. You can't blame the tag-teams either; they aren't being given a chance to steal the show.

WWE has some brilliant teams, and while they might not be able to headline WrestleMania, they could easily do Raw, SmackDown, and a few B-tier PPVs. History shows us that tag-team wrestling can shine, so let it shine.


9. Managers Hide Weaknesses

Brock Lesnar Paul Heyman
WWE.com

Take Paul Heyman away from Brock Lesnar and what do you have? He’s still a terrifying beast, but he’s a much less eloquent one. Without his advocate, the man who killed the streak is turned into a tongue-tied mess.

Lesnar is not alone in this either. Countless wrestlers throughout history could get it done in the ring but when it came to cutting a promo fell to pieces. Bobby ‘The Brain’ Heenan played a key role in half the rosters' careers back in the eighties, and his work both with and against Andre the Giant is legendary. Managers were an important part of WWE, and they made stars.

And yet in 2017, WWE’s main roster only has Paul Heyman, Lana, and Maryse - and Lana seems to be moving towards becoming a wrestler. If we include NXT, we also have Paul Ellering. You could maybe throw James Ellsworth in there too. That’s five managers, not an awful number, but each of them has only one client/team.

It’s not that they lack stars who need a helping hand either. Lesnar is not alone in getting flustered when he’s handed a live mic. Someone like Eric Rowan could benefit immeasurably from having a reassuring figure stood beside them to sing their praises. It not only adds to the wrestler’s mystique but it gives them a character wrinkle that helps them stand out.

Teaming a wrestler up with a manager doesn’t always work - just ask Curtis Axel - but it can make a career.


8. Secondary Titles Are Important

Dean Ambrose
WWE.com

When was the last time Dean Ambrose did something good with the Intercontinental Title? It’s becoming boring to complain about, but WWE’s secondary titles have never meant less. Now and then someone comes along to give them importance - Cena with the US Title and Miz with the IC - but the second their reign is over they slip back into obscurity.

It's a fact that never stops being annoying, especially at a time when the Universal Title is only being defended on big shows. There’s a gap at the top of the card, and an IC title that people care about could fill it nicely. Instead, we have Dean Ambrose doing dodgy comedy segments with The Miz.

It’s a far cry from Razor Ramon and Shawn Michaels or even John Cena’s Open Challenge. These were moments that made the secondary belts feel like they were the most important thing in the world. They were still stepping stones to the big time, but when you were stood on that stone, you were a proud champion, with the world at your feet.

AJ Styles and Kevin Owens feuding for the US Title seems to hint at it becoming a belt worth caring about but it’s what happens after that feud that is important. Titles don’t gain prestige from one match but a year’s worth of them. This isn't news to WWE either - they’ve done it before, and they can do it again. The question is: do they want to?


7. Gimmicks Don't Have To Be Silly

Razor Ramon 1994
WWE.com

Fandango, Tyler Breeze, and Adam Rose: All examples of modern WWE stars who were given a gimmick. Dancer, male model, and party boy - pretty standard stuff in the world of wrestling. However, each one took the man straddled with it down the same path - to comedic lower card obscurity.

It doesn’t have to be that way, though. Dive into history, and you will find plenty of silly gimmicks. From Razor Ramon aping Scarface to Mr Perfect being, well, perfect. Both of those things could have been as cheesy as a week-old brie and yet they weren’t. Because despite how silly they could be, they were treated like genuine threats rather than jokes. Their strange ticks were character flourishes rather than the whole story.

Which isn’t to say that every gimmick needs to be serious, there is room for comedy in wrestling. But having a slightly out there character shouldn’t instantly confine you to that world. The Million Dollar Man was an arrogant millionaire, and Edge and Christian were once mates with a vampire, but it never held them back. The gimmicks were part of the characters, but they were never the full deal.


6. Competition Breeds Success

Vince McMahon WWE Title
WWE.com

When WWE began to embrace independent wrestling, fans were naturally delighted. Suddenly, Samoa Joe and AJ Styles being on Raw didn’t seem that crazy. It was an actual possibility, and our favourite wrestlers were given a chance to shine.

A few years down the line and shine those stars did. Not only have Joe and Styles made their way to New York but they’ve been joined by the best of the best. Chris Hero, Roderick Strong, KENTA, Nakamura, and Austin Aries are all active parts of WWE’s roster. On top of that, they've highlighted the UK scene with a tournament and a belt and given a whole bunch of cruiserweights the chance to strut their stuff. On the surface, it’s great.

That is until you dive into history and remember the first stage of Vince McMahon’s dismantling of the territories. Back then, Vince began highlighting the talent on his show before slowly stealing them all away. Sound familiar?

What makes it worse is that history shows that when left with no competition, WWE stagnates rather than flourishes. When Vince McMahon is at his best, he is being challenged. Surely the best thing for everyone is to allow these companies to do that?

Most of these companies aren't even real competition for WWE. They aren't on the level WWE are and are tiny fish swimming alongside the Great White. So, before Vince and co strip them of everything that makes them great, maybe they need to question whether it’s worth it.


5. Hold Back On The Stars

roman reigns
WWE.com

There was a time in WWE’s history when a sighting of Hulk Hogan or Andre the Giant was a treat. They didn’t do every show, and because of that, it felt like a real event when they turned up.

In contrast, some of the three-hour editions of Raw can see stars appear three or four times on the one show. It’s not out of the realms of possibility for Roman Reigns to open Raw with a promo, appear in a backstage segment half way through, and then wrestle the main event. It’s no surprise that fans are fed up with him.

This is made all the worse when you are trying to push a guy like Roman. When he was at his best, he was the silent badass in The Shield, standing in the background before delivering the killer line. He was used sparingly and (although some of them have forgotten it now) fans loved him because of it.

Three hours is a long time to fill so you can understand why WWE wants to use their stars more than once. However, for the Roman Reigns of the world, it does them no favours. His face is already plastered across WWE’s advertising and fans are quite frankly sick of him. Turning him into a unique attraction might not transform him into a mega face, but it could quieten some of those boos.


4. Not Everyone Needs To Be Involved

WWE WrestleMania 33 Bayley Charlotte
WWE.com

This year’s WrestleMania had thirteen matches. In those thirteen matches, 71 wrestlers appeared, not including managers. By contrast, WrestleMania X-Seven, considered by many to be the best, had 52. Can anyone claim that those nineteen extra wrestlers improved anything?

Now, let's make something clear: we don't begrudge anyone their WrestleMania paycheck, but at the same time, not everyone deserves it. The World Cup isn't contested by the third and fourth best team and the player knocked out in the first round doesn't get to play the Wimbledon final. You earn the chance to compete, and wrestling should be no different. If by the time ‘Mania comes around you aren’t in that position, then you shouldn’t. It’s that simple.

Take the Raw Women’s Championship match. Can anyone make a serious argument for why it was a four-way rather than a one on one? Bayley vs. Charlotte was the story, and Sasha Banks and Nia Jax were tacked on so that they could appear. Both of those women are great wrestlers, but it hurt the show as it meant that instead of a great twelve-minute singles match, we got an alright twelve-minute four-way.

By filling up the card with people that don’t deserve to be there, WWE adds a hell of a lot of fluff to their shows. It turns them into long-winded affairs that honestly test the patience. Cut that out, and you suddenly have a product that is a lot more fun to watch.


3. Story Can Trump Ability

hulk hogan andre
WWE.com

Have you ever gone back and watched Hulk Hogan vs. Andre The Giant? The iconic moment that WWE likes to tell us is one of the biggest of all time? If you have, you’ll have discovered that rather than an epic clash their WrestleMania III match was lumbering at best.

Yet, that moment is etched into every wrestling’s fans head. It’s THE WrestleMania moment, and Hogan still dines out on stories about it today. That’s the power of storytelling, and too often WWE seems to forget it.

Take Roman Reigns; there is a very vocal part of WWE’s audience which thinks he can’t wrestle. Even if we ignore the fact that isn’t true, there are still a lot of issues with that complaint. For one thing, it wasn’t only against Andre that old Hulk put on stinkers - most of his matches were awful. While even Stone Cold (who was a good wrestler back in the day) spent most of his time on top relying on running around the ring punching people. Even if Roman can't wrestle (though he can), why should it stop him being the man?

What makes you the man is not what you do in the ring but the stories you tell outside it, WWE seems to have forgotten how to tell a story with Roman Reigns. They have failed to turn him into a sympathetic character, and as long as that is the case, he will continue to be booed.


2. Sometimes, Less Is More

payback chris jericho
WWE.com

Last year WWE held fifteen PPVs, and there is every chance that this year there will be more. On top of that, they produce three hours of Raw each week, two hours of SmackDown, one hour of NXT, one hour of 205 Live, and one hour of Main Event. That's enough wrestling to make you sick.

Then there’s the way that they present that wrestling. Everything involved is the most important thing that could ever happen or the most incredible moment of all time. It’s never just a normal match. It’s a blood feud or an epic war. It’s like a kid in a candy shop of clichés, and it’s exhausting.

So what if you stripped it all back? What if you had half that number of PPVs and half the hours of television? What if some of the lower card matches were presented as not life or death but instead as wrestlers going out there and trying to outdo each other? What if everything was a bit simpler? Does that not sound nice? Would any of you have missed Payback?

Of course, it will never happen. WWE makes too much money off the things they do and cutting back on that is not good for business. However, you have to wonder if in the long run, the current method of doing things is going to hurt them. More and more wrestling fans suffer from WWE fatigue each year, and a return to the days of less wrestling sounds mighty tempting.


1. The Art Of The Vignette

Tye Dillinger Aiden English
WWE.com

Mr Perfect playing horseshoes, Kharma dismantling dolls, and Scott Hall talking in a dodgy accent - there have been a lot of memorable vignettes over the years, and a sense of excitement almost always joins their appearance on TV. They are the bat signal of professional wrestling but rather than hooded justice they proclaim that someone new is coming.

Except, that doesn't happen anymore. If we ignore the months of build-up for Emmalina, WWE seems to have forgotten how to use vignettes, and that's a damn shame. Having a crowd care about a competitor before they even debut can make all the difference.

Take someone like Tye Dillinger. Dillinger is a great wrestler, and down in NXT he was over despite rarely getting a chance. However, on the main roster in front of a casual crowd, he’s a guy who shouts ten a lot.

Now imagine if the month leading up to Dillinger’s debut had featured vignettes. You could use footage from his first run in developmental and talk about him leaving the company. Then, move on to narrate his return and follow him on his journey through NXT as he becomes the Perfect Ten. It's so simple, but it introduces the crowd to a character they can love.

Not everyone needs a month worth of vignettes before they debut. AJ Styles had enough of a name that a surprise appearance was enough. But for wrestlers like Dillinger, an early introduction to the crowd can be the difference between taking off and falling flat.


Contributor
Contributor

A lover of wrestling, heavy music and films with disturbed minds. Follow me at https://twitter.com/Iversen83