10 Match Quality Predictions For AEW All Out

In which AEW could TakeOver.

PAC Kenny Omega
AEW

It is imperative that All Elite Wrestling delivers an outstanding show.

Fyter Fest and Fight For The Fallen weren't that: baggy, uneven, and at times creatively inept, Fyter Fest did well to recover from the interminable and drastically unfunny Buy In, when even attempting comedy to set the tone was in itself a terrible idea. Virtually every match at Fight For The Fallen was too long, which hardly helped the creeping notion that the promotion is a billionaire-funded vanity project. Nor did it help AEW's mission to market itself as the alternative to WWE; that both shows in themselves were draining and overlong felt hypocritical.

It was a "WWE thing to do," to quote Cody's latest shot at the enemy.

Both shows featured excellent in-ring action and gripping storyline developments, but the patchy quality of each wasn't good enough, ultimately: AEW has promised its audience a manifest pro wrestling utopia.

All Out looks significantly better, and arrives at the perfect time: the new competition, NXT, just presented the most poorly-received TakeOver event in forever. From excellent to indulgent to disappointing to dismal, an already safe formula looks in danger of faltering.

There's no better time to start a revolution.

10. BUY IN: 21-Woman Casino Battle Royale

All Out Casino Battle Royal
AEW

The Casino Battle Royal format needs a rethink.

There were no onscreen cues to build anticipation, nor explain the convoluted rules. Performers seemed to arrive at random, diminishing any potential pops - the crowd was too busy looking for performers to react to them - and that weird group entrance format looked far too friendly. They weren't in teams, but they looked like they were. It just didn't work.

Except it did, somewhat, between every "shuffle of the deck" which, again, was never shown onscreen.

The action was more divisive than All In's meticulously laid-out fun, but it was agented very well. The in-ring component is there, and the match format should accentuate the positives of the announced entrants without being bogged down by a contradictory, tonal mess of farce and violence.

The raw but spectacular Sadie Gibbs should get over in a blitzkrieg cameo appearance. Awesome Kong will shift the atmosphere from fun to dangerous when she ragdolls a horde of also-rans over the top rope - a tone that should deepen when Nyla Rose enters the pissing contest and stares her down. You'd hope that the crowd will get behind Britt Baker, who is at least heading into the final four, following her recovery from a serious concussion.

Baggy, possibly confusing, but ultimately successful - a battle royal, essentially, but a d*mn good one.

Projected Star Rating: ***1/4


9. BUY IN: Private Party Vs. Angélico & Jack Evans

Private Party Jack Evans Angelico
AEW

This feels like a brazen move on the part of AEW's execs.

Too much meta comedy on the Buy In shows? Are you worried that style won't appeal to a casual audience? What about an absolutely warp-speed spot-fest that barely even pretends to tell one of your precious "stories"?"

Ackchually, we hate that too.

F*ck off, here's Private Party Vs. Angélico & Jack Evans lol.

Expect 10 minutes of relentless and creative and possibly a-bit-silly high spots in a raw, and rough, lung-bursting sprint that seeks absolutely nothing less nor more than a "This is awesome!" chant within the first two minutes. Expect, perhaps, something better than the expected frenzied but ultimately hollow athleticism; Private Party generated the biggest reaction of the night at Fyter Fest, arguably, so there's a sense that an undercurrent of emotion and genuine crowd support might elevate this into another showcase of the act, and not merely the style.

Angélico & Jack Evans haven't connected as well, but their quite irritating dancing bit will look very, very lame in contrast to Isiah Kassidy and Marq Quen's cool factor, which might give the crowd pause to jeer them.

Projected Star Rating: ***3/4


8. A Boy & His Dinosaur & Marko Stunt Vs. SCU

Luchasaurus Jungle Boy Marko Stunt SoCal Uncensored
AEW

If you despise Marko Stunt, and absolutely cannot reconcile the idea of a man with the body of a child going toe to toe with a shredded bruiser like Frankie Kazarian, then fear not: Christopher Daniels is going to laugh and strut in his face, Kazarian is going to implode that face with a slingshot springboard dropkick - preferably when he's flossing - and Scorpio Sky is going to send him flying across the ring, or perhaps into the fourth row, with an hilariously over-powered suplex.

Stunt is going to suffer a real beating, and the heels who administer it will think it's hilarious.

Even if the layout isn't quite as cruel as all that, there's an absorbing story underpinning what should be a choice undercard attraction if, unlike the bloated Fyter Fest and Fight For The Fallen cards, it does not peak before the finish. Stunt is either the tiny, schadenfreude-tastic punching bag or the surprise comeback kid. Jungle Boy, small but cut, is the face-in-peril that can be taken somewhat seriously.

Luchasaurus is the protective father figure who will avenge the murdered babyfaces, and it will be awesome, because he's a seven feet tall man who wears a dinosaur mask and can do a standing moonsault.

Projected Star Rating: ***1/2


7. Riho Vs. Hikaru Shida

Riho Hikaru Shida
AEW

A genuine potential undercard show-stealer, it helps that AEW's audience has been very receptive to the unfamiliar, imported joshi talent - and this match features the two most well-rounded performers the company has showcased thus far.

Riho has impressed across all three of AEW's shows, and did particularly well to hold the snake-bit Fight For The Fallen Buy In tag match together. She is a superb babyface, dazzling in her aerial work - her double foot stomp soars - and able to show a winning ingenuity with flying escapes from impact moves and finisher attempts she can leap into from anywhere. Her disposition is charming, too, which accounts for her bond with the audience.

Hikaru Shida is a great opponent because her persona stands in such contrast. More serious and more technically advanced, she can perform a more calculating role that will see her punish Riho's impetuous, emotion-driven approach.

That the company have even decided to place this on the main card - a meeting between two impressive relative unknowns - is a real indication of its potential.

Projected Star Rating: ****


6. Darby Allin Vs. Joey Janela Vs. Jimmy Havoc - Cracker Barrel Clash

Joey Janela Jimmy Havoc Darby Allin
AEW

This match is going to be absolutely, preposterously violent - a three-way dance that might see off Jim Cornette once and for all.

It is as close as anybody will ever get to his Nightmare Match - perhaps only Ricky Morton touching Joey Ryan's d*ck on a GCW show would inspire an even more apoplectic conniption fit - and as such should be a terrifying hoot, provided it doesn't go too long.

The 'Cracker Barrel Clash' deal - the match is sponsored by a corporation and may necessitate some sort of silly barrel roll spot, which might undermine the tone - is rather weird. Somebody is most certainly going to do something with that barrel, and it's going to look as painful as Homer Simpson breaking his back over a fire hydrant. Joey Janela enjoys landing in awful places after a missed senton. Perhaps he or Havoc will roll it in the way of Darby Allin when he performs his coffin drop signature. Whatever happens, this is going to explode immediately, and was essentially booked purely to allow all three men to badly hurt one another in a series of crazed, convoluted sequences.

As hot as the crowd will be, it might be best to watch this on mute, because Jim Ross will definitely complain out loud that the referee is pointless and they're all doing way too much.

Projected Star Rating: ***3/4


5. Best Friends Vs. The Dark Order

Dark Order Best Friends
AEW

This should be the opener.

The Dark Order are an excellent tag team who have struggled to transition from a copyright-triggering video game Indy act to an anachronistic supernatural bit that resonates as something even more phoney, under AEW's sports-oriented presentation. The Best Friends meanwhile were overshadowed in their babyface role at Fyter Fest, at which Private Party got themselves over as the cooler, more exciting and ultimately more popular act. If the match is placed in the midcard, the audience might take it as a signal to simmer down ahead of the boiling point that is the stacked upper card.

Should the match be given time to get over, it will.

Stu Grayson in particular is great - rapid in movement and crisp in execution, there's an explosive element to his work that lends it real credibility. This serves the dynamic he shares with agile hoss Player Uno very well. The blistering exchanges between Grayson and Beretta should tear the house down, where Chuck Taylor is so endearing that Player Uno's heat spot shouldn't slow things down too much as to betray the point.

It's a significant night for the Dark Order, and as such, they require a significant spotlight.

Projected Star Rating: ***3/4


4. Cody Vs. Shawn Spears

Cody Shawn Spears
AEW

Cody famously smashed Triple H's throne at Double Or Nothing, but he has flexed more impressively over his Executive Vice President rival by advancing his methodical, story-driven traditional epic and making it far more interesting.

The Road To All Out has built this match tremendously; Spears, driven to brutality by what he perceived as the ultimate disrespect, brained Cody with a steel chair in a notorious Fyter Fest angle, before hiring the services of the sinister, authoritative Tully Blanchard. Cody has no-sold all of this, perhaps in an attempt to infuriate his opponent into a mistake. Cody is over as hell with the AEW audience, and he knows exactly where to position himself on the card to extract the maximum reaction. Spears is untested in such a high-profile role - and only broke through after an eternity in WWE's developmental system as a spirited babyface - but the drama on the outside of the ring, Cody's ability to lay out a heated old-school war, and the blood that will inevitably piss from his face, should elevate Spears over the course of one rapturously-received match.

Cody's corner person should be unveiled on the night, spiking additional drama before the bell even sounds.

Arn Anderson for the roof-blowing spinebuster spot, or the anxious threat of MJF's imminent heel turn?

Projected Star Rating: ****1/2


3. The Young Bucks Vs. The Lucha Brothers - Escalera De La Muerta AAA World Tag Team Championship Match

Lucha Brothers Young Bucks
AEW

As terrifying a proposition as it is spectacular - the inherent allure of the stipulation has been restored through the dynamic alone - this is going to be absolutely deranged. Absurdly violent. A match that, if it reaches its potential, should rank among the most brutal, expressive and breathtaking ladder wars ever.

Fénix enters the match with a leg injury, the extent to which is currently unknown. This is worrying, for the performer obviously, and in terms of match quality. Fénix and Nick Jackson work incredibly well together. Their chemistry is so outstanding that their exchanges at times defy physics, and if their work is ever so slightly convoluted, it hardly matters: even if the sausage is being made right in front of your eyes, it's still impossible to work out how, exactly.

There's a very strong possibility that Fénix and Nick Jackson construct an all-time great high spot, possibly via some kind of outrageous lucha bump off a ladder, leading to a flying headscissors to their other opponent on the outside. They're going to do something hugely convoluted - so convoluted that there's an equally strong possibility of an all-time ugly, dangerous botch. It will require much suspension of disbelief - and a hardened bloodlust - to get over, not that that will pose a risk to the Sears Center hardcores.

A Canadian Destroyer on a ladder is happening - possibly several times.

Projected Star Rating: ****3/4


2. Kenny Omega Vs. PAC

PAC Kenny Omega
AEW

Kenny Omega Vs. PAC is pro wrestling's preeminent dream match.

Both performers are out of this world; Omega is known as such a spectacular artist that his brutality announces itself by surprise every time. It's no wonder he cultivates that reputation with his talk of being a God; when he drives his knee with such force into the skull of his opponents, the dramatic impact is as powerful as the physical impact. Omega is both artist and killer: pro wrestling's Hannibal Lecter.

PAC is just awesome in the strictest sense of the word. Impossibly ripped and impossibly fast, he is one of pro wrestling's modern athletic superman bursting forth from a 1980s mega body. Both performers are incredibly skilled at fusing classic and modern sensibilities - everything they do looks as cool as it feels dangerous - and so much has converged to make it a genuine event.

PAC's Double or Nothing transgression. His long absence from U.S. soil. The loudest city in wrestling. The determination on Omega's part to make up for the disappointment of his major grudge match with Jon Moxley.

What's key is that both men boast the two most protected finishers in all of wrestling. The teases alone, much less the drama of a near-fall, should elevate this as an epic waged between two of the most well-built and talented wrestlers on the globe.

Projected Star Rating: *****


1. Hangman Page Vs. Chris Jericho - AEW World Championship Match

Hangman Page Chris Jericho
AEW

Contrary to the consensus, AEW on the Road To All Out has reheated the Chris Jericho Vs. Hangman Page programme.

The less interesting of the double main events - worryingly, the same is true even in spite of the entire lack of build towards the Kenny Omega Vs. PAC replacement match - it was ice cold in the wake of Fight For The Fallen. AEW chose the wrong attraction entirely to put over the time limit draw concept. Page did not look like World Champion material in a muddied failure of a match.

But, when Jericho cut open Page's eye in fairly routine post-match attack, AEW used the resulting injury to put over Page as a badass. AEW has stressed the importance and the stakes of the match very well - Chris Jericho loses his legendary aura in the event of such a huge, early loss, whereas Page confirms his simmering reputation as a failed experiment if he fails to capture the title - but the complexion of the card might undermine it.

The AAA Tag Team Title match is going to be insanely violent. Cody is going to juice heavy in what will be a JCP-indebted old school war. The Cracker Barrel Challenge features three men with acts that rely on batsh*t insane ultra-violence. And, since Jericho and Page can't match the explosiveness of Omega and PAC, both versions of the main event - traditional wrestling or smoke-and-mirrors brawl - may succumb to diminishing returns.

Hangman Page, helpfully, is batsh*t, which should see him bump around Jericho's bloody fun new formula with the unhinged danger of Tetsuya Naito - but will it be too late in the day?

Projected Star Rating: ***1/2


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!