10 Mistakes WWE Are Still Paying For
Actions have consequences.
WWE takes a lot of flak for its creative mistakes, but many of them are probably unavoidable. Running a wrestling show, after all, entails having to predict how fans are going to react to something, which is no small task given how quickly their minds can change about a particular performer or storyline.
That said, sometimes it seems like they are almost deliberately shooting themselves in the foot. Once you've established who the fans do and don't like, it makes sense to book your product accordingly, presenting the popular guys as likeable good guys and the not-so-popular ones as detestable heels. That's pretty simple, right?
It's generally also a good idea to keep the young up-and-comers on whom you're banking to become the headline acts of tomorrow looking relatively strong while they wait their turn in the main event. Otherwise, you could find yourself a little bereft of star power a couple of years down the line when all of your major box office draws have deserted you.
Sadly, the WWE creative team doesn't always remember these cardinal rules, leading to one or two mistakes whose long-term effects are still being felt today.
10. CM Punk's Ill-Timed Dismissal
It might be argued that Punk is so capricious and thin-skinned that the explosive way he bowed out of WWE four years ago was completely inevitable - regardless of how many steps Vince McMahon and Triple H took to diffuse the situation.
But one thing kept coming up during that famous appearance on Colt Cabana's The Art of Wrestling: he was absolutely furious about the timing of his dismissal, which just so happened to fall on his wedding day.
WWE have always denied that they intentionally fired him on the morning of his nuptials, claiming that it was merely an unfortunate coincidence - but either way, the whole ugly situation was easily prevented had they properly thought it through.
Instead, Punk now appears to be consumed by bitterness, potentially killing any hope we might have of seeing him return at some point in the future. Unless he has a dramatic change of heart, they could wind up paying for this mistake for the next decade or more.
9. Bobby Roode's Low Key Introduction
This time last year, Bobby Roode was one of the biggest stars on NXT. Now, he's little more than a lower mid-carder on Raw, with little or no prospect of ascending the ranks in the immediate future.
To what do we owe this dramatic fall from grace? It might be blamed on the sheer size and depth of the current WWE roster. Roode is one of several talented stars who might have main evented in another era, but in today's are left languishing at the bottom of the show.
On the other hand, The Glorious One is also a victim of, if not poor, then at least sub-par booking. He arrived on SmackDown in a totally low key way, spending weeks competing opposite jobbers before he got a run at the US Title.
You compare this to the way in which fellow NXT recruits Kevin Owens and Finn Bálor were introduced to the main roster, and there's a massive difference. It's little wonder that fans have lost interest in him: they've given us absolutely no reason to care.
8. Burying Finn
WWE had their reasons for burying Finn Bálor back in October, namely: they needed Kane to be strong for a mega feud opposite Braun Strowman, which lasted just a couple of weeks before climaxing on Raw.
All of that makes you wonder if it really had to be the Demon King, one of the company's brightest up-and-coming young stars, to take the fall. Couldn't they have just had Kane plough through Apollo Crews instead? He's always losing.
The long-term effect on Bálor's career has been pretty catastrophic. For one thing, it meant that he was robbed of the opportunity to battle Brock Lesnar for the Universal Title at the Royal Rumble, in turn giving rise to a sense of inertia around his WWE career as a whole.
There's every chance he could force his way back into the main event in the future, but he's probably been set back a good year by the decision to make him a sacrificial lamb for a mayoral candidate who likely won't wrestle ever again.
7. Batista's Return Run
Another man with an axe to grind with the WWE hierarchy is Batista, who departed the company under similarly frustrating circumstances following a disappointing return four years ago.
In subsequent interviews, The Animal has made no bones about who he blames. The way in which he was booked, he says - knowing that the crowd wanted Daniel Bryan to win the Rumble instead - was desperately ill-thought-out, and bound to result in heavy boos.
The consequence of all of this is that Batista is no longer in any mood to negotiate. If and when he walks through the WWE door again, he wants to do things on his own terms, and if they don't accede to them he will likely just pull the plug altogether.
This could be great news for the fans - the Guardians of the Galaxy star, after all, appears to have a solid nose for the business - but it's not so good if you're Triple H or Vince McMahon, who generally prefer to maintain complete control over their on-screen product.
6. Burying Bayley
Burying Finn Bálor was pretty egregious, but it at least it did serve some wider purpose, albeit a wider purpose that didn't really make any sense.
Bayley's humiliation last year, on the other hand, seemed to be for absolutely nothing. Alexa Bliss, her conqueror, was already running the Monday Night Raw women's division, and didn't really need another scalp to cement herself at its helm.
Even if she did, they could have perhaps gone about it in a way less damaging to The Huggable One, whose own credibility was left completely shot after the embarrassment of "This is Your Life" followed by a dismal showing in their subsequent Extreme Rules encounter.
Granted, Bayley is still plenty popular among the audience - but there's been a definite climb-down from where she stood this time last year. She's nowhere near the level of leading female lights Charlotte Flair, Asuka, Alexa Bliss or even Ronda Rousey, the latter of whom has only been around a couple of months.
5. Neville In The Cruiserweight Division
It's been more than six months since Neville walked out on WWE amid alleged creative frustrations, and despite murmurs every now and then that crunch talks are moving the situation along, we still appear to be no closer to seeing him back in the ring.
It seems that The Man That Gravity Forgot has one or two trust issues, which is perhaps understandable given that he spent the latter part of his time with the company competing in the dead-end cruiserweight division, despite being one of their most gifted stars.
That's not to imply that the guys currently performing on 205 Live have no future in the business. Many of them are extremely talented themselves, and may yet benefit from spending a year or two down in the developmental ranks.
But it's obviously an affront to consign an established wrestler with buckets of main roster experience to such a small platform. Virtually anyone in the same position would have thrown their toys out of the pram, and WWE could end up losing Neville altogether.
4. Cena Over Rusev
At this point, Rusev has now fallen so far down the WWE ladder that it's barely even worth discussing where this terrible run all began. But let's do it anyway, for the sake of closure.
The Bulgarian Brute debuted on the main roster in early 2014, going on to enjoy a year-long undefeated streak in which he was rightly pushed in the grand tradition of unstoppable monster heels like Yokozuna and Umaga.
Then came the turn of John Cena at WrestleMania 31. Not only did Big Match John get the better of him in their climactic encounter on the Grandest Stage of Them All, he went on to pick up consecutive victories at Extreme Rules and Payback.
Suddenly, Rusev was no longer being spoken about in terms of a future main event star. Instead, he started doing things like having a brief love affair with Summer Rae, and form a forgettable "League of Nations" stable with Sheamus and Wade Barrett. And it's all Cena's fault.
3. Cena Over Bray
Cena burying Rusev was bad, but not nearly as bad as the time he buried Bray Wyatt, a man who looked set to break out as one of WWE's biggest main roster stars before running into Big Match John four years ago.
The problem at WrestleMania XXX was that the creative team prioritised a satisfactory ending (read: the face winning) over the long-term prospects for one of their brightest young stars, in turn depriving Bray of a potentially career-defining win.
It wasn't a total death knell for the Eater of Worlds' career, admittedly. He went on to enjoy another headline feud against The Undertaker the following year, and sealed his maiden WWE Championship in 2017 with victory at Elimination Chamber.
But the perception of him as one of the industry's perennial bridesmaids is now proving difficult to shake. He does everything right in the build-up, but consistently comes up short on the night itself. He's like Tottenham Hotspur.
2. Jason Jordan Is Kurt Angle's Son
A long-term injury suffered by Jason Jordan earlier in the year has conveniently taken this glaring error out of the spotlight over the last couple of months, but it's likely to rear its ugly head again the second he returns to fitness.
It's still impossible to see how the storyline will end without seriously harming Jordan's long-term career prospects. He's either going to come out of it a Roman Reigns-style baby-face (i.e. one who the fans absolutely loathe) or a heel with virtually no credibility.
Mostly, this is a consequence of the initial decision to shoehorn him into a major storyline before he had the opportunity to get the crowd on side by himself, the result of which is that his sudden main event push feels forced and undeserved.
There's also the dilly-dallying that followed, though. For a while, it seemed like the writers couldn't make their mind up about whether he was supposed to be a whiny, entitled second-generation star or a wholesome good guy. How were we supposed to know how to react to him?
1. Roman's Booking
In truth, Roman's dreadful booking is an ongoing mistake. He may not have taken the title at WrestleMania, but the mere fact he was given yet another headline bout proves WWE haven't quite learnt their lesson just yet.
You wonder whether things might have turned out differently had the initial approach that followed his split from The Shield four years ago been more slow and steady. If he hadn't, in other words, been pushed to the moon straight away.
Two of the biggest mistakes here were having him win the 2015 Royal Rumble, and then the following year, setting him up in a hackneyed triumphant babyface versus the world scenario when he came up against Triple H and The Authority.
The intent here was to generate organic fan support, but it had the opposite effect. People feared that he was being groomed for the same role John Cena had occupied a decade earlier, and it led to a backlash of a kind that is almost impossible for him to overcome.