10 MORE Storylines AEW Dropped Cold

Hair today, gone tomorrow: featuring Orange Cassidy, Matt Hardy, and more...

Matt Hardy
AEW

Tony Khan more often than not adheres strictly to continuity.

PAC Vs. Orange Cassidy was a consistent narrative thread for well over two years. While the cheating aspect was a bit much as it drew to a conclusion - particularly since Khan has ran this sort of thing into the ground across the entire card in 2022 - it made perfect sense in the context of its own story.

Initially, at Revolution 2020, PAC was disgusted that the irreverent slacker would even dare challenge him. It was no challenge. Over time, as Cassidy worked his rival out across various interactions, PAC grew desperate. He later tried to cheat Cassidy out of the All-Atlantic title at Grand Slam because he sensed this, and the crowd, encouraged to sense it too, got fully behind the quest and made waves of noise at the awesome final showdown in Toronto years after PAC first laughed in Cassidy's face.

The Elite tell stories that are almost unprecedented in their intricate continuity. MJF Vs. CM Punk was so rich that the first rejected handshake had so much heft, in retrospect, when the story fully unfolded.

The company is even faithful to storylines that developed in other promotions, even when it was a far better idea to simply ignore Malakai Black's disastrous WWE main roster run.

All of which makes it disappointing - and surprising - when certain developments just go away...

10. Orange Cassidy Vs. Matt Hardy

Orange Cassidy Jack Evans Head Shaved
AEW

Matt Hardy and Orange Cassidy feuded in the otherwise awesome AEW summer of 2021. Cassidy first defeated Hardy on August 25 in a very uneven effort.

Matt Hardy putting his hands in his pockets to reveal that he had loads of money stashed in them: silly but good character work.

Matt Hardy getting his face busted open the hard way, all for the sake of what, generously, was a gentleman's three: not good at all.

This somehow warranted a sequel, before which Matt indicated that he wanted to cut Cassidy's hair. This was made obvious when he took to brandishing a pair of scissors with a great big gurn on his face. To build interest in that, Cassidy defeated Jack Evans in a Hair Vs. Hair match on the September 29 Rampage, which was a prelude to...a Lumberjack match between Cassidy and Hardy on the November 12 Rampage, Jesus Christ.

If there was any interest in Cassidy Vs. Hardy II, and the roman numerals piss take indicates not, there certainly wasn't 79 days later. Technically, maybe, the Orange Cassidy Vs. Hardy Family Office feud was possibly concluded when Orange and Tomohiro Ishii defeated the Butcher and the Blade on November 17, but not really.

Orange Cassidy and Matt Hardy went 50/50 in a Hair Vs. Hair feud that ended in a Lumberjack match with only Jack Evans losing his locks. That legitimately reads like a match result from the infamous 'New York Rules' edition of WCW Thunder.


9. ReDRagon Vs. FTR

Bobby Fish Cash Wheeler
WWE

On the March 2, 2022 AEW Dynamite, FTR entered the Casino Tag Team Battle Royale, from which they were eliminated when the Young Bucks struck Dax Harwood with stereo Superkicks.

This was a rare, good distraction: ReDRagon, who had already qualified for the three-way Tag Team title match at Revolution the prior week, threatened to swipe Dax's feet from the apron. He wasn't fooled by some f*cker's entrance music or somebody acting obnoxious miles away on the ramp; he was moments from losing the match.

This was the genesis of FTR's face turn; when they vowed revenge, then-manager Tully Blanchard urged them to forget their conflict with the Undisputed Elite and pursue gold. They didn't listen. They wanted to fight with honour so that they could look their families in the eye. They gained a measure of revenge by beating the Young Bucks in April, but incredibly, a match against ReDRagon - guaranteed to be excellent - never happened. Happily, this did not dent FTR's credibility. They remain massively over.

In a worrying note, though, it feels at this point that the fandom is defying their actual booking under the insistence that they deserve to be in a better spot.

It's not quite Daniel Bryan/Becky Lynch levels of "promoter hates fans, fans in kind tell him to f*ck off", but still: as good a year as FTR have enjoyed, it could have been better even if they didn't win the AEW Tag Team titles in this slightly altered timeline.


8. Jungle Boy Proves He Can Hang With Chris Jericho

Jungle Boy Chris Jericho
AEW

In late 2019, when Chris Jericho needed a TV-level challenger to work before his PPV programme with Jon Moxley intensified, Jungle Boy was selected for the role.

It was an astute booking move. Jungle Boy was to benefit from the increased profile and lose in a super hard-fought effort - in the halcyon days where going out with pride was a key storyline driver - in order to encourage fans to stick with him under the belief that he'd make it one day. Inspired by the 10 minute challenge gimmick that made for legendary TV in Memphis, when Jerry Lawler so nearly unsettled Ric Flair in 1982, Jungle Boy survived the Liontamer and made it to 10:00 on the December 18, 2019 Dynamite. Those weren't exactly halcyon days, realistically, but the sense of ambition was arguably stronger. The build was great too; Jungle Boy put over the scope of the challenge by training for the match as if it was the biggest of his life.

If it did come to a conclusive end, it was rather unceremonious; the Inner Circle defeated Jurassic Express on the Jericho Cruise Dynamite on January 21, 2020.

The idea was to revisit the programme deeper into 2020, but the pandemic happened, and it was thought senseless to push such a prized prospect when there were no vocal fans willing Jungle Boy over the line.

This isn't a carny exuse, either; it's telling that Jungle Boy was given 'Tarzan Boy' when fans really started to filter back into Daily's Place in early 2021.


7. Christian Cage Feuds With Team Taz

Christian Cage Taz
AEW

When Christian Cage first arrived in AEW, he made his intentions clear: he wanted to win the AEW World title.

This was widely mocked at the time, at least by certain jaded fans wary of the TNA years. The idea that a former WWE star who wasn't quite a Bryan Danielson-tier name could waltz in and contend for it was a cause for concern, but

A) Every single wrestler should do this, because that's what every pro wrestling character should strive to achieve, and

B) Those concerns were unfounded; Cage was preoccupied in his quest by Taz who, after falling afoul of Cage, set his stable onto him, which allowed Cage to pick up the spree of wins necessary to contend for the gold.

Cage had to find a different set of opponents, since that programme went awry. It started promisingly - Cage and Taz were magic bantering one another off on the mic - and Cage defeated Powerhouse Hobbs in phase one. He never reached phase two because Ricky Starks, who remains a dream opponent, unfortunately suffered a neck injury.

Cage began his association with Jungle Boy shortly thereafter, which meant that there was nowhere to really go with his first storyline - but it made no sense for the hyper ornery Taz, of all people, to forget the disrespect.


6. Lance Archer And PAC Circle One Another

PAC Lance Archer
AEW

When PAC returned from his pandemic-enforced hiatus in late 2020, he went after Eddie Kingston and his "family" in a signature AEW storyline.

Before getting his hands on Eddie, in retaliation for him stealing the Lucha Bros. from him, he defeated the Blade (November 18) and then the Butcher (December 17) before succeeding in his mission at New Year's Smash. This was neat, tidy and logical enough, without being tremendously exciting in truth, but it doesn't qualify for this list. It was a boilerplate AEW narrative, but it concluded in a coherent and decisive way. What does warrant inclusion here is the subtle tease of a PAC Vs. Lance Archer programme.

On the December 16 Dynamite - preceded by what may be the greatest graphic drop in AEW history, and think of the ground that covers - Eddie Kingston Addressed His Enemies, plural. One was PAC, obviously; the other was Lance Archer, dating back to the events of the All Out 2020 Casino Battle Royale.

This drew out Archer, whose attack on Eddie drew out the warring members of the now-estranged stable. PAC also made his presence felt, but Archer was upset. Kingston was his. This led to a tense confrontation which, you guessed it, didn't materialise in a match of any kind.

And while it's true that Khan frequently dovetails his storylines in such a way, that tease was too thrilling not to deliver on.


5. Ethan Page Wants The All-Atlantic Title

Ethan Page AEW
AEW.com

In something of a concerning development, more than one entry on this list is drawn from the very recent future.

When Stokely Hathaway introduced the Firm, and discussed each man's ambitions, Ethan Page had his sights set on the All-Atlantic Title, which at that point was held by PAC. Absolutely nothing came of this: instead, the usually ambivalent PAC slowly turned heel before Orange Cassidy dethroned him. So what was the original plan?

Tony Khan often books on a regionalised basis. Perhaps Page was set for a major match in his home city of Toronto before Khan put the hammer down on the PAC turn. Happily for Page, he is set for a not insignificant role in the imminent World title eliminator tournament, the finals of which are set for Full Gear.

Page has entered into and is the narrative focal point of the tournament, and since Khan is very heavy-handed with these things, is probably going all the way. Is a babyface MJF Vs. Ethan Page match set for Winter Is Coming?

It would mean that AEW isn't doing an Aces & Eights storyline, and thank f*ck for that.


4. Eddie Kingston Hates Bryan Danielson

Bryan Danielson Eddie Kingston
AEW

Last year, as part of the Full Gear World title eliminator tournament, Bryan Danielson defeated Eddie Kingston in one the best TV matches in company history. They orchestrated a standing ovation five seconds before the finish. It was as if they had cast an actual spell on the audience.

As part of the build, Danielson ostensibly called Eddie a lazy sack of sh*t, and Eddie never forgot it: in what was great storytelling consistent with his proud, loyal and paranoid character, ahead of Anarchy In The Arena, he didn't trust Danielson but was more than willing to go to war with Jon Moxley. Near the finish, Kingston, so good he looked credibly intent on actual murder, poured worked gasoline on Chris Jericho, but some of it spilled on Danielson, who was close to tapping him out. The resulting brawl between Eddie and Bryan has never been explored since.

Danielson suffered what was all but directly said to be a concussion during the match, and since returning hasn't yet tried to kick Eddie's head in for costing them the match in May.

It's November.


3. ...And Claudio Castagnoli

Eddie Kingston Claudio Castagnoli
AEW

Eddie Kingston is the most relatable pro wrestler on the planet, at least to a specific sort of person.

The sort of misanthropic person who cannot let go of a grudge even if it isn't particularly healthy. The sort of person so hellbent on etiquette that it becomes disproportionate. The sort of person who will always fight for what's right, even if the victory is pyrrhic.

He never let go of his years-long problem with Claudio Castagnoli, so much so that it felt real even if it wasn't. In a great, truncated CHIKARA feud, Kingston was adamant that Claudio was the bad guy and was infuriated that nobody else saw it. It was such a great story beat; when Claudio revealed himself to be precisely that, Kingston was received as an intelligent man with an unwavering moral code: the embodiment of a great babyface.

He was instantly suspicious of Claudio when he arrived in AEW, although he teamed with him at Jon Moxley's urging. Kingston was pissed at the close of Blood & Guts, when both he and Claudio had applied submissions to Chris Jericho and Matt Menard respectively and Menard tapped first. Claudio thought he was doing the right thing; Kingston's expression suggested that Claudio had stolen his vindication.

This seemed to set up a uniquely compelling singles match premised on exorcising the old demons, but it never happened: they just sort of quietly made friends (and then barely interacted) in what was a nothing anticlimax.


2. Paul Turner Must Tighten Up The Officiating

Paul Turner AEW
Twitter, @AEW

The otherwise tremendous Dynamite Grand Slam this year was marred slightly by three consecutive unclean finishes: Chris Jericho cheated to defeat Claudio Castagnoli for the ROH World title, Billy Gunn interfered to assist the Acclaimed in dethroning AEW World Tag Team champions Swerve In Our Glory, and PAC defeated Orange Cassidy via hammer to the face.

It was quickly explained on Rampage that all of this was booked to inform a much-needed company-wide storyline: following months and months, at least, of cheap, weightless and cowardly booking that put more heat on the booker than any heel, Khan recognised that AEW was morphing into a sub-WWE in some ways and promised a return to a more bold, conclusive approach by tightening up the officiating.

It didn't happen, infuriatingly, and while Tony Schiavone is good value deadpanning about "systematic cheating", it would be preferable if AEW made cheating feel like a transgression again. Something that inspires outcry more than apathy.

The referees are still dumb even by the standards of a wrestling referee, and Turner discovering what the rules meant only served as an excuse to have Eddie Kingston lose.


1. Eddie Kingston Vs. Kenny Omega

Kenny Omega Eddie Kingston
AEW

Eddie Kingston has simultaneously enjoyed a tremendous, feel-good AEW career and been sh*t out of luck.

More than one exhibit of evidence indicates that he was set for a big TV match with then-World Champion Kenny Omega in the summer of 2021. What a prospect that would have been: Eddie refusing to sell a V-Trigger because he's too stubborn and wilful to acknowledge the pain, before his synapses register it just as he explodes back with the Uraken. Let's go!

They didn't go, despite strong teases on TV.

Also, it was Mox, not Eddie, who took the fall when they lost to the Young Bucks at Double Or Nothing '21. Mox rarely if ever gets pinned cleanly in AEW. They must have been protecting Eddie ahead of something big, and since the Elite had also messed up Eddie's ankle, he was out for bloody revenge.

It didn't end up happening.

Eddie's dispute with the Elite slowly fizzled out. Perhaps he was too popular, and threatened to undermine the next planned World title coronation. Interestingly, Eddie's favourite video essayist, Joseph Monticello, took to Twitter that August and expressed apathy over the imminent All Out '21 main event. Look who liked the tweet.

Was he annoyed that he could have deputised for Hangman Page?


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!