10 Most Absurdly Mismatched Gimmicks In WWE
The square pegs being jammed into round holes.
“Nobody knows anything... Not one person in the entire motion picture field knows for a certainty what's going to work. Every time out it's a guess and, if you're lucky, an educated one.”
That’s Hollywood legend William Goldman on making movies - and it seems that, as on the silver screen, so in the squared circle.
The fact is, no one really seems to know what works and what doesn’t, what makes a hit angle or a household name. How many heavily pushed Next Big Things have crashed and burned over the last twenty years or more?
Of course, that hasn’t stopped everyone and their monkey from declaring that they know what gets over. There’s one supposedly cast iron truth, however: characters and gimmicks that are the performer turned up to eleven feel more authentic and connect better with the crowd.
So, if that’s a truism you can take to the bank... why is it that so many talented wrestlers are given roles to play that blatantly don’t fit who they are or what they do? Why ask an already sceptical fanbase to suspend their disbelief further still by selling them apples and calling them oranges?
These are some of the most absurdly mismatched gimmicks, characters, roles and wrestling personas in WWE.
10. Hardcore Holly Was Not A White Meat Babyface
Love him or loathe him, Robert ‘Hardcore Holly’ Howard is the very definition of glowering badass - but although he’s a tower of menacing, sculpted muscle, it’s his reputation that does the work for him.
Everyone knows that, in character and out, ‘Hardcore’ Holly is a no nonsense, stiff son-of-a-gun, big on respect and the old school traditions. That’s why it seems so utterly absurd that, faced with this dude - a former bouncer and bar fighter, built like a heavyweight boxer, who once wrestled a bear - Vince McMahon chose to give him the character of happy-go-lucky NASCAR driver, Thurman ‘Sparky’ Plugg.
Leaving the cheesy occupational gimmick aside - hey, this was 1994, and the real life Bob loves to race, so you can at least see the thought process going on - can you imagine Bob Holly as a white meat babyface, kissing babies and high-fiving college kids? You don’t have to. Here he is:
With the benefit of hindsight, you can see every thumbs-up, every flash of cheerful teeth destroying a piece of Bob’s soul. Unconvincing and awkward in the role, it took four years and a fierce performance in the car crash Brawl For All shoot tournament for ‘Hardcore’ Holly to finally make an appearance.
9. Bray Wyatt Is Not A Monster Heel
On his debut, the Bray Wyatt gimmick was solid: a fresh, sinister take on the megalomaniacal cult leader. That was before he began exhibiting actual supernatural powers. As a solo act, Wyatt claims to be a demon in human form: a god or a devil, or both. Unfortunately the man under the beard, Windham Rotunda, simply isn’t large or intimidating enough to be a terrifying monster heel.
If he was booked to be some implacable, unstoppable fiend, that wouldn’t matter so much. Sadly, Bray Wyatt is constantly beaten, often cleanly, by ordinary men in ordinary ways, losing two out of three matches and coming off worst in every feud.
How many times has he threatened to destroy the body and soul of an opponent only to skulk off with his forked tail between his legs? He’s had his lunch money stolen by every major babyface on the roster. To make matters worse he’s gullible, far too easily conned by people claiming to join his crusade only to turn on him.
All of that works just fine for a demagogic villain like Kevin Sullivan, Raven, or James Mitchell - a menacing, charismatic but ultimately cowardly charlatan with some devoted muscle. But ranting loser Bray Wyatt is no demonic monster.
8. Dolph Ziggler Was Not A Babyface Champion
WWE have booked Nick ‘Dolph Ziggler’ Nemeth to be the conquering hero on multiple occasions, albeit inconsistently. He was a fan favourite for nearly four years, doing well in the big moments - like his towering underdog win at the 2014 Survivor Series.
That haphazard babyface push wasn’t his only problem. Nemeth originally got over as the hardest working heel on TV, but neither he nor the Dolph Ziggler character have it in it in them to be the good guy 24/7.
You see, hero or villain, Nemeth is one of those guys playing an amplified version of himself… same tune, higher gain. Nemeth’s own smart alec, smart mouthed persona has never been far from the surface. Sarcastic and egotistical, the 'Show Off' is not a natural babyface.
His booking hasn’t helped - remember the Ziggler-Lana-Rusev-Summer love triangle? Or when he 'retired' only to appear unceremoniously a few weeks later at the Royal Rumble?
It always comes back to the guy playing the part, and Nemeth is too desperate for validation as a ‘great performer’ to convince as a good guy.
His role model Shawn Michaels used to have the same problem. The difference is that Michaels eventually figured out how to play the hero: by leaving his ego at home. Until the 'Show Off' learns to do likewise, he’ll never be the 'Showstopper'.
7. Kofi Kingston Is Not A High Flyer
Let’s be realistic: Kofi Kingston isn’t now, and never has been a high flyer.
It’s no knock on the man himself. Kofi Sarkodie-Mensah is a fine wrestler and performer, far better as a character and a promo than he’s ever given credit for. He was a convincing uppercard opponent for Randy Orton in 2009, and he's always been a credible presence in the midcard (and perhaps even the main event, as his recent showings opposite Daniel Bryan have demonstrated).
But as a top rope performer - especially one earmarked to pull off dicey spots in gimmick matches - Kofi just doesn’t fly.
He can certainly jump. His vertical leap is incredibly impressive. Actually, much of Kingston’s moveset is prefixed by the word ‘leaping’: the leaping clothesline, the leaping back elbow, etc. Then there are the various crossbodies and splashes, which essentially involve jumping from high things onto people: what CM Punk refers to as ‘throwing yourself at the ground’.
All of that might have qualified him as a high flyer in the eighties, or even the early nineties. Today? When Pac, Ricochet and countless other men can regularly pull off reverse 450 shooting star corkscrew plancha moonsault ranas, throwing themselves into perfectly formed complex kamikaze shapes like they were bitten by radioactive lemmings… well, Kofi’s enthusiastic bounding about doesn’t really cut it.
6. Wade Barrett Was Not The King Of The Ring
By 2015 the King Of The Ring concept had been significantly devalued from its heyday, when it was an annual tournament with its own pay-per-view, booked to crown the Next Big Thing.
The 2006 tournament was SmackDown only. The 2008 and 2010 versions were held on a single episode of RAW - in 2010, this included the qualifying matches, and that was before the show went to three hours. 2015’s version? A Network-only show with three short TV-style matches.
But even as an entertainment angle, shorn of the prestige that made it a kingmaking gimmick, the King Of The Ring had still been a role handed to important men. The last three winners - Booker T, William Regal, and Sheamus - were all highly regarded uppercard players.
And then there was Wade ‘Bad News’ Barrett: a hugely talented contender with a massive upside in 2010 whose star had fallen since. In 2015 Barrett pretty much defined the word ‘undercard’. He was a man defeated so often and so quickly that he had people wondering whether he’d run over the McMahon family dog.
The inexplicable coronation of King Barrett was the end of the line of succession for the King Of The Ring - as a tournament, as a title, and as a booking concept.
5. Emma Was Not A Valet
Four Horsewomen be damned: it was Tenille ‘Emma’ Dashwood’s storming matches with Paige in mid-2013 that persuaded the company to improve the profile of women’s wrestling on NXT.
A cheerfully goofy presence with a competitive streak, NXT Emma was a badass submission expert with a sunny disposition, and had the crowd eating out of her hand. However, when WWE creative - an oxymoron on a par with ‘Microsoft Works’ or ‘military intelligence’ - brought her up to the main roster in January 2014, they stripped out everything but the goofball aspect to the character and paired her with midcard comedy act Santino Marella, effectively as his valet.
Naturally, given nothing to work with, the WWE Universe gave nothing back. An underwhelming year later, Emma was back in NXT. For a while, she was regaining momentum as a bitter heel, but injuries would keep setting her back.
Finally, with the Women’s Revolution in ascendance, Emma was due a comeback… but was repackaged as Emmalina, an Instagram model. The gimmick was delayed by months, and finally abandoned as a terrible idea.
She was gone from the company soon after, having been utterly wasted - through no real fault of her own.
4. Roman Reigns Is Not A Big Man
The 'Big Dog'... he isn’t very big, is he?
Let’s be clear – he’s larger than most normal people. No one’s suggesting that Joe Anoaʻi is a tiddler, or that there’s anything at all wrong with wrestlers of average height or less.
However, this is a man who was marketed as a tank from day one: the Juggernaut, the powerhouse of The Shield. Yet he’s, what, six two? He’s not a huge slab of muscle, either. From what can be seen underneath his succession of flak jackets and vests, although he has good definition, he’s actually pretty lean.
Comparisons make the whole thing weirder. He’s not much bigger than Ambrose or Rollins, and The Rock (who was never once billed as a powerhouse during his wrestling career) is clearly taller and larger, practically dwarfing him at the 2015 Royal Rumble.
When The Shield debuted, Reigns was the rookie that they were developing on the job. It’s understandable that back then, they needed to give him something… but the 'juggernaut' nonsense simply didn't make sense once he was going up against the likes of Brock Lesnar and Braun Strowman.
3. Dean Ambrose Is Not A Wildman
There’s not usually much of the lunatic about Dean Ambrose, the 'Lunatic Fringe'. The issue isn’t Jon Good’s work as a character guy. The man is old school through and through. Scuttlebutt says that he even got a little backstage heat due to insisting on staying in character when he doesn’t necessarily need to.
No, the issue is that WWE’s dangerous, unpredictable wildman wrestles like he's made of salad. Balloon animals have had more impact. His Thesz Press is a limp handshake. His ‘gentle push’ suicide dive is more of a cry for help.
Worst of all is that rebound lariat, where he falls awkwardly back into the ropes, often having to stagger into position first, and then kind of flails his way back up with no momentum at all. Or is it that nonchalant hop into the corner to set up the running forearm/bulldog combo in the opposite corner - a step so casual that, if anything, it would slow him down, not speed him up?
Without wanting to be mean, because Lord knows someone online should give it a try, it wouldn't take Nia Jax to fight Dean Ambrose out of the company. Try a wet paper bag.
2. Giant González Was Not A Monster Either
Bray Wyatt may be difficult to take seriously as a monster, but he’s got nothing on the late Jorge González, aka El Gigante, aka Giant González, one of several men with acromegaly - the adult version of pituitary gigantism - who managed to parlay their immense size into a career in pro wrestling.
Supposedly seven foot seven inches tall, González was billed as an eight footer - but even at his legit height, he should have been an imposingly monstrous presence. So what went wrong?
Well firstly, while Andre and Big Show were hefty bear-like men, and Khali was a hugely muscled beast, González had an ordinary physique. The WWF dressed him in a furry bodysuit with the muscles airbrushed on. Photographed without markers of scale to demonstrate his true size, he could have been anyone.
Secondly, González was an awful wrestler, grasping little of the craft and none of the art. He gurned and grimaced for the crowd, but couldn’t really perform at all. Watching him interact with other wrestlers was like watching kids climbing a haunted tree.
So there you have it: a very tall, slow man going “rarrr” and making Scooby-Doo-monster shapes with his hands. There have been garden gnomes more menacing.
1. Daniel Bryan Was Not An Underdog
When Bryan Danielson was given the main event in summer 2013, his Daniel Bryan character was presented as an underdog: insecure, worried that he’d been the weak link in his tag team with Kane, and determined to prove himself.
That tag continued into autumn as he faced off with John Cena and Randy Orton for the WWE Championship. However, although WWE loved to tell us how much of a scrappy underdog battler Bryan was, that wasn’t what they showed us.
Daniel Bryan was consistently booked as a badass: a fearless, intense brawler, technical virtuoso and lethal submission expert. He ran gauntlets of far bigger men and emerged victorious. He was handpicked by Cena to face him for the title at SummerSlam in August, and pinned him clean to win the title, going on to do likewise with Orton at Night Of Champions only weeks later.
The fact that both victories were sabotaged by heelish machinations is irrelevant, as is the fact that Danielson clearly wasn’t WWE’s first choice to headline WrestleMania XXX and become WWE Champion proper.
Daniel Bryan was booked to take on the establishment and fight it to a standstill… and he did it like a damned Viking. Underdog? To quote the Bard: that’s no moon. That’s a space station.