10 Most Boring WWE Wrestlers Of 2018
An excuse to visit the merch stalls.
WARNING: the internet is about to have an aneurysm.
Finn Bálor, the man who will challenge Brock Lesnar for the Universal Title at 2019's Royal Rumble, was almost on this list. It's true, and the only thing saving poor Finn from being here is the fact he's damn good when the bell rings. Matches against Drew McIntyre, his performance in last year's Rumble and that Ladder war at 'Mania 34 saved his bacon.
Still, Bálor's lack of character depth and feuds with Baron Corbin, Jinder Mahal and Bobby Lashley were terribly dull in 2018. He, arguably more so than any other, is the archetypal example of a truly excellent wrestler who's constantly undermined by WWE's writing staff. That's probably why he gets a pardon when most of his opponents don't.
This article looks at in-ring skill as well as the creative surrounding those matches though. That criteria is important to remember, because whilst some aren't fully to blame for how lifeless their work was last year, they could've (like Finn) done a better job with the crap they were given.
Now, time for aneurysm 2.0...
10. Bayley
NXT's one-time golden gal and all-round huggable sort Bayley had a torrid 2018.
Her character, one that switched between girl-next-door sweetness and bratty teenager with a pet lip, failed to satisfy, and her matches took a backseat to her on and off frenemy snorefest with Sasha Banks. Neither woman came across as likeable, which is a problem, and they were barely relatable for the young girls the tale was aimed at.
In-ring, Bayley has had flat matches with Ruby Riott, Alicia Fox, Sasha and more. The spark that existed in her work on NXT and the same pep in her step when she first joined the main roster has disappeared. Now, Bayley is a heat vacuum even when the heels are kicking lumps out of her.
If anyone requires an update in 2019, it's Bayley and her side-pony. She cannot afford to have another year as empty, stuttering and inconsequential as 2018 was, otherwise she's in real trouble.
9. Natalya
You'll quickly spot a trend in most of the entries here. The vast majority (if not all) have one thing in common: they were handed just one character trait by creative and expected to make the best of a bad, mundane situation. Natalya, as solid as she can be with the right opponents, is the perfect example.
What did she do in 2018 aside from pal around with Ronda Rousey and try in vain to get The Riott Squad over?
When researching this piece, this writer revisited some of Natalya's work from a few years ago, and the results were surprising. At Roadblock 2016 (the house show special that aired on the Network, not the later pay-per-view), she dazzled opposite Charlotte Flair in a match for the Divas Title that showed the way for women going forward. That was Nattie leading by example.
There was little of that leadership last year. Instead, Natalya showed up, grinned like a goof about her friendship with a celebrity incomer then worked matches that lacked true passion. Something is missing from her act and her own work.
8. Mojo Rawley
According to one Mojo Rawley, the days of 'Hype Bros' are very much over. Mojo claimed over the early summer months that he was no longer hyped, he was "focused". Since then, he's done pretty much nothing other than work the house show circuit and do a one-off job to Seth Rollins.
His move to Raw in the shakeup has been a total disaster.
Rawley's mini-feud with fellow no-hoper No Way Jose (who almost got an entry all on his own too) was dire, and the guy has no definable trait to help him stand out. Without the modest rub gained by having Zack Ryder in his corner, Mojo looks lost out there; if these were the days of post-'Mania WWE spring cleaning, he might be atop the list.
Between Rawley's unremarkable appearance, ring work and the lack of any sort of long-term plan to speak of for him, he's really struggling. There are loads of workers on NXT who could do more with his spot on the main touring crew.
7. Titus O'Neil
Titus O'Neil seems like a nice dude. He'll pose for selfies with happy kids and their parents at live events, can be relied upon to represent WWE with class in the media and enjoys putting in a shift. All that's admirable, and it only makes his inclusion here all the harder to justify.
Then he appears on Raw in deadbeat segments and it all makes sense.
41-year old O'Neil would be best-served working an ambassadorial role for the company in 2019. Before anyone jumps on us mentioning his age there, that's not really his main problem. Titus has never been Kurt Angle between the ropes, which is fine, but the in-ring product has moved on a bit since he was on the original NXT or part of The Prime Time Players.
Whenever O'Neil is in a match, audiences tend to hit the toilets or check out the merch stand. That's because they know he won't be doing anything major, and people gotta' find a time to pee during epic 4-hour TV tapings.
6. The Riott Squad
Before getting stuck into this one, it's time to admit something: there is a chance this fan could be getting a little curmudgeonly when it comes to newer acts aimed at a younger audience. That must be why he doesn't get The Riott Squad's childish high-school bully antics or their lack of cohesion aesthetically as a group.
Or, it could be that nothing The Riotts do has any impact beyond the next segment they're booked in.
Throwing paint around the place or ruining Christmas trees in festive WWE photoshoots isn't enough, and it made Ruby Riott, Sarah Logan and Liv Morgan one of 2018's least-effective heel acts. Ruby (in particular) can wrestle like hell, but her faction has an often incredible lack of menace that conflicts with how announcers describe them.
Seeing Ruby do something juvenile then watching Logan and Morgan giggle like they're still 10 years old is boring. Sorry, but it is. It might be less so if the stable were actually written to follow up on their bullying ways with some meaningful wins.
5. Curt Hawkins
Curt Hawkins: the anti-Bill Goldberg.
This former Edgehead's win-loss record currently sits at around the 0-150 mark. Losing has become his sole purpose for showing up, and at least the man has tried to make something out of his jobber status. That's cool, but how long is this gonna' roll on for until it gets boring? "Until".
Sadly for Hawk-lovers everywhere, the thrills stopped a while ago. WWE haven't grasped the heartfelt connection needed between wrestler and audience to make this gimmick work, and there's so sign of it happening in 2019 either. When Curt comes out for his matches, people know he's going to job. There's no drama.
This is a bit of a missed opportunity, being honest. If Hawkins was cutting promos about how proud he is of being a father and how much he wants his little girl (whom he posts so much about on social media) to see him win, then there'd be some emotion in there.
Even Barry Horowitz' losing streak had some theatre to it, for crying out loud.
4. Alicia Fox
Pre-Evolution, thoughts turned from a one-on-one match between returning legend Trish Stratus and Alexa Bliss to a tag match involving Lita and Mickie James. Then, suddenly, Bliss was removed from the bout due to injury and fans collectively wondered aloud who WWE would bring in as her replacement.
Alicia Fox, that's who.
Not only was this a bit out of left-field, it was as uninspiring a choice as the promotion could've made. Whether she's been eating up air time on the overlooked Mixed Match Challenge with Jinder Mahal or main-eventing Raw for the first time against Ronda Rousey, Alicia has been uninteresting and tiresome.
It might sound harsh, but no amount of flashy, themed ring outfits can change that. WWE were on the right track with Fox when they cast her as a psycho girlfriend (as dumb as some of the histrionics were in promos, at least she got to cut them) with Noam Dar and Cedric Alexander. That played to her strengths. Working featured spots didn't.
3. Jinder Mahal
Hey look, it's Alicia's MMC tag-team partner, and he had just as rough a 2018 as she did.
Acting like some sort of spiritual yogi and being creamed by Brock Lesnar do not a good year make. For Mahal, everything post-shock WWE Title reign in 2017 has been awful, and he's gone from WWE Champ to out his depth on Raw. Whispering "Shanti" over and over is hardly the apex of creativity.
When he wasn't saying that, talking to anyone who'll listen about his WWE Title success or the fact his match against Brock Lesnar at the 2017 Survivor Series was put on the scrap heat, Jinder was sucking hard in feuds with Roman Reigns, Finn Bálor and others. Literally nothing he did in 2018 helped ease his pain.
Mahal's push to the top of SmackDown should have counted for more than glorified jobber status on Raw. No, he wasn't ever going to sustain that, but he could probably expect to be doing more than breathing exercises and putting over R-Truth.
2. Tamina
She's been in WWE for close to a decade now, and we're yet to see a storyline, match or feud that's rekindled Tamina's early fire as hard-hitting backup for The Usos. Alliances with Santino Marella, AJ Lee, Team B.A.D, Lana and more have all suffered from the same issues. Tamina, despite her wrestling heritage, just isn't a very captivating on screen personality.
If she's now going to be portrayed as a slightly smaller version of Nia Jax and her tag-along buddy, then what's the point?
2018 was another year that happened in the life and times of Tamina, and she definitely wrestled a bunch of matches against other professional wrestlers. Yep, that sentence is about as thrilling as her actual exploits were. Without meaning to sound cruel, it's the truth. She's there to make up the numbers.
A little context wouldn't go amiss. Hearing from Tamina about her goals, early memories around the business and why she picked Nia as a partner would be nice. WWE clearly disagree. They think it's best she stands around quietly looking bored.
1. Baron Corbin
"Where's your crown, King Nothing?"
Those lyrics, taken from a 1996 Metallica track, perfectly sum up Baron Corbin's year. Other lines, like, "All the wants you waste, all the things you've chased; then it all crashes down and you break your crown, and you point your finger but there's no one around" also suit.
Corbin was elevated to temp Raw GM status in 2018, cut his hair to go for a new chrome dome look and was given mic time most could only dream of on a weekly basis. After months of stifling segments with tedious dialogue (something creative have to take some blame for too), Baron was removed from power and blamed for Raw being naff.
The funny thing here is that the flagship was so stale and humdrum because WWE were the ones booking him to cut 10-minute promos and work feuds nobody wanted to see. All that potential Corbin showed when he first came up and won the annual Battle Royal at WrestleMania 32 has been lost.
Maybe this is the real him and those fluctuations of promise were a mirage. After all, he was the one boring fans to tears as 'Constable', both in-ring and out.
-
Which other wrestlers do you believe were 2018's most boring? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!