10 Most Controversial Wrestling Match Finishes Ever
Can create cash. Often makes a hash.
If you're to believe a certain silver-haired former general manager and one-time mobile meat merchant, controversy creates cash (or more specifically, "ca$h").
As Eric Bischoff attested, wrestling has raked in a tidy profit as a consequence of controversy - whether by artifice or by accident. Many of the industry's highlights are an imbroglio of high drama, talking points which glued eyes to the screen and suffocated box-offices. Talk may be cheap, but its golden when magnified by the thousands.
Often, it's the finish of a match which gets gossip into gear. On more than one occasion in wrestling's rich history, savvy bookers have taken advantage of its status as a pseudo-sport to engineer an outcome leaving piqued punters asking: "was that supposed to happen?" Brock Lesnar bashing Randy Orton's skull open with his elbow springs to mind.
Sometimes, this ambiguity is by error. When Batista and John Cena clumsily crashed to the ground at Royal Rumble 2005, a predictably tedious ending suddenly became a fascinating - albeit farcical - one.
And then there are those times when it is impossible to know either way. Just over a week ago, Joe Hendry bested Martin Kirby for the WCPW title after an apparent concussion, with many fans appalled the match wasn't stopped. But was the controversy all part of the script? Had fans been cleverly worked in the great pro-wrestling tradition?
Of course, controversy can just lead to chaos. Whatever the circumstances though - if not cash - it always creates comment.
10. The Fingerpoke Of Doom
A single finger was all it took for Hulk Hogan to defeat Kevin Nash on a night when WCW pointed one straight at their audience.
Throughout the show, Eric Bischoff’s hyperactive commentary had all the restraint of a town crier high on glue, but it was his suicidal booking where things really came unstuck.
The ever-orange Hogan was far from evergreen, and few wanted to see him dominate the top of the WCW landscape at the end of the millennium. Elsewhere, rivals WWF were set to put their belt on Mick Foley in a pre-taped episode of Raw.
With a degree of foresight comparable to an myopic mole, Nitro’s lead shill Tony Schiavone announced WWF’s plans in an attempt to dissuade fans from turning over. It didn’t work: they switched channels in their droves.
Those who stuck around soon wished they hadn’t. After a preliminary stare-down, Hogan stepped up to Nash before flooring him with a poke to the chest, claiming the title and tediously reuniting the warring nWo factions in the process. A series of run-ins followed, with Schiavone’s words, “Thank goodness for Lex Luger,” perfectly capturing what a farce this was. Never since or before has such a phrase been spoken.
Did the ‘Fingerpoke of Doom’ presage WCW’s downfall? It took more than a single bait-and-switch finish to turn cheated fans off the product for good, but it was the start. After all, it only takes one digit to push that first domino over.
9. Royal Rumble 2005
Lex Luger comes in for a lot of stick by wrestling fans - some of it admittedly deserved - but one area where he's head and shoulders above the rest of the industry is in simultaneous Royal Rumble eliminations.
WWE tried the trick at the '94 iteration as a means to poll the audience on whether they preferred 'the Total Package' or perennial fan-favourite Bret Hart. There was a lot of room for error, but the pair pulled the stunt off flawlessly. Obviously, there was only one 'winner' the fans were prepared to cheer for, but it served its purpose.
Luger demonstrated rare competence in managing to fall out of a ring, but it was quite the opposite which led to a similar - entirely unplanned - repeat of the finish 11 years later.
When John Cena and Batista hurtled over the ropes like a couple of lummoxes at the 2015 show, WWE had a problem on their hands. Big Dave had originally been set to win the contest outright, but being such a clumsy oaf he managed to tumble to the floor at the same time as fellow finalist Cena. The feet of both men touched the outside simultaneously, and the conclusion was thrown into turmoil.
An irate Vince McMahon charged down to ring with such over-exaggerated ire that he managed to tear both of his quads in the process of entering it. What followed was an utterly ludicrous spectacle, as the chairman sat on his arse on the canvas, angrily deliberating with officials, before the match was finally restarted. Batista claimed the run-off - as originally intended - and the farce finally concluded.
8. The Danbury Fall (And Fallout)
Less a 'controversial' finish and more an 'utterly stupid' one. The furore arising from the ending of Vic Grimes' and New Jack's Living Dangerously 2000 'match' wasn't the result of any misguided wrestling booking or misplaced egos, but rather the inevitable consequences of gravity plus the temporary lunacy of two workers a few bananas short of a bunch at the best of times.
Instead of the planned finish which would see both men crash through a stack of tables from atop a balcony, the pair missed completely and plummeted to the ground below. Hard concrete rarely mixes well with soft, squidgy humans, and the consequences were predictably dire: New Jack was blinded in his right eye when Grimes fell on top him, suffering brain damage in the process.
The bout was declared a no-contest, rendering it a completely pointless exercise in masochism. Yet the repercussions didn't stop there - or so New Jack alleged.
In a gratuitous cash-grab, XPW unwisely decided to have the duo contest a rematch at their aptly named Freefall show in 2002. Anyone with even a gram of sense could have predicted it wouldn't pass without idiotic incident.
The big stunt for their return leg mimicked that of Living Dangerously, only with the stakes - and tables - raised that much higher. To complete the throwback, it went t*ts-up, with the furniture again acting as little more than set dressing. Fighting atop a scaffold with New Jack, Grimes was sent hurtling 40 feet to the ring, clipping only two of the tables on his way. Miraculously, he *only* suffered a dislocated ankle after colliding with the ring ropes.
Careful review of the footage clearly shows the near-tragedy was a botch rather than sabotage, but a grandstanding New Jack later claimed otherwise, boasting during a shoot interview of his attempts to settle the score with Grimes for the Danbury debacle. In the same session, Jack made the contradictory statement that the Living Dangerously affair was accidental. Funny how such stunts can affect your memory.
7. Goldberg Vs. DDP (Halloween Havoc '98)
The finish between WCW champ Goldberg and DDP at Halloween Havoc '98 wasn't controversial because of what people saw go down in the ring - but rather for what they didn't.
Following a bloated card featuring no fewer than two ten-minute long Disco Inferno matches and a quarter-of-an-our snooze-fest between former Outsider buddies Kevin Nash and Scott Hall, the show finally approached its closing contest. After the travesty that was Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior's WrestleMania VI rematch, the long-suffering fans fighting back the yawns were at last rewarded for their patience. Big Bill and, er, Medium Dallas prepared to lock up, and a proper wrestling match beckoned, rather than the fireball-throwing farce of the last encounter.
And then... everything went black.
For many paying customers, that was that. The torridly tumescent show had overrun the standard three hours, and consequently a number of PPV providers cut the feed automatically. In a bout of cruel irony, buyers missed a thrilling finale, their lasting memories instead being the retirement home fight over the last Werther's Original that was Hogan and Warrior.
WCW, possessing all the PR dexterity of a Volkswagen systems analyst, decided to air the missing match for free on the following night's Nitro. Predictably - and justifiably - those who'd bought the show felt robbed. More trick, than treat.
6. CM Punk Vs. John Cena (Money In The Bank 2011)
By the time CM Punk blew Vince McMahon a big wet kiss goodbye after snatching the WWE title from John Cena at Money in the Bank 2011, the ink on his hastily rewritten contract had already dried. But many fans didn't know that.
The situation surrounding CM Punk's successful title win was equal parts reality on the one hand and storytelling sublimity on the other. As far as everybody knew, when 'The Voice of the Voiceless' cut that incendiary promo with his legs-crossed on the Raw ramp in Las Vegas, he was legitimately gambling his own future. The famous 'pipebomb' diatribe was so chock full of inside references and genuine grievances that it seemed for all intents that Punk had gone rogue, and when he announced his contract was set to lapse at the upcoming Money in the Bank PPV, almost everybody bought it.
With so much ambiguity surrounding Punk's future, the wrestling world was abuzz with anticipation before the show, which saw the apparent want-away contest John Cena for the WWE title. One of the all-time great WWE matches followed, and when Punk put Cena to sleep, his hometown of Chicago went ballistic.
Of course, the whole thing was a work - there was never any chance Punk would win the match unless he was set to remain with the company - but for a moment, they had people going.
5. Brock Lesnar Vs. Randy Orton (SummerSlam '16)
With kayfabe as thoroughly decomposed as the last dodo, it's almost impossible in this century to produce an angle which leaves wrestling fans asking: "was that supposed to happen?"
That fact contributed to make the violent conclusion of Brock Lesnar and Randy Orton's SummerSlam marquee match far more controversial than the generally underwhelming bout merited. After ten minutes of standard fare between two performers hare-like in the long-in-the-tooth department, a tiring audience's attention was suddenly alerted to Lesnar bludgeoning 'The Viper's head with the corner of his elbow. A stoppage victory followed, as the conquering 'Beast' stood triumphantly in a pool of his foe's blood.
Such finishes are a rare bird in WWE, and as a result many shocked fans quickly began to speculate that Lesnar had gone into business for himself. Of course, that was exactly what the company hoped - and they'd managed to pull the wool over the eyes like a bandit in a balaclava.
In fact, the outcome was entirely pre-mediated. However, the method itself was equally the cause of controversy: in an era when blading is strictly prohibited on account of its apparent barbarism, how could a man smashing a pointed bone into someone's skull to create the same effect be any safer?
(A cheap, shameless plug: I wrote in depth on the subject of blading safety in Issue 3 of our lovely magazine.)
4. Hulk Hogan Vs. Sting (Starrcade '97)
Even before he was unsuccessfully auditioning for You've Been Framed, Hulk Hogan was no stranger to controversy, albeit largely limited to his professional machinations.
A Machiavellian politician with a Mugabe-esque lust for power, like the Zimbabwean dictator, the similarly superannuated Hogan would stop at absolutely nothing to cling onto his peak position.
Wrestling history is littered with examples of 'The Hulkster's' legendarily self-serving style oppressing the fortunes of his contemporaries, but few were as so seemingly visible as his contest opposite a returning Sting at WCW's Starrcade '97 supershow.
Since the formation of the nWo, former WCW symbol Sting was notable by his non-committal to either side of the intra-promotional 'war'. Instead, he took to hanging about in the rafters, wearing face-paint, and acting like a moody teenage goth. After months of silent gestures and general oddness, the transformed Stinger eventually made his motivations clear: he wanted to wipe out Hogan and the nWo. WCW's hero had finally returned.
The match was booked for the company's traditional December blow-off, and with fans desperate for an end to Hogan's hegemony, there seemed only one rational outcome.
Except it wasn't so simple.
Instead of allowing Sting to shine, Hogan dominated the encounter, making the supposed saviour look like a busted flush, The Stinger's comeback barely materialised, and 'The Hulkster' looked just as dominant as always.
The finish made poor Steve look even worse.
Originally - in a hackneyed attempt to echo the Montreal Screwjob and capitalise on the recent travails of a freshly signed Bret Hart - Sting was scheduled to succumb to a fast count, only for 'the Hitman' to contest the decision, after which WCW's prodigal son would claim victory on the restart.
Apparently, Hogan had other ideas. Though the match technically went as planned, it's alleged the Big Orange Machine privately instructed ref Nick Patrick to count the fast count, um, slowly. So a slow fast-count, then. Whatever the reason for Patrick's regular slapping of the mat, it appeared as if Hogan had registered a perfectly legitimate win, and when a livid Bret emerged to argue the call, 'The Stinger' was made to look like a right pudding. Instead, Double-H looked cheated in defeat, and Sting's returning momentum was summarily buggered.
3. Hulk Hogan Vs. Jeff Jarrett (Bash At The Beach 2000)
In 2000, the ailing WCW drafted Vince Russo on board in a desperate attempt to keep their ship afloat, a move akin to patching up the Titanic with etamine. Amongst his bag of terrible tricks, Russo's most cherished was the worked shoot, something he'd conjure up at any and every moment for a cheap talking point, regardless of any long-term, substantial damage to the product.
Generally speaking, however, it was the audience who were supposed to be worked, not the wrestlers themselves.
Russo's grand plan for WCW's Bash at the Beach PPV was to have champ Jeff Jarrett 'lie down' for perennial headliner Hulk Hogan, whose reputation for manipulative backstage politicking had acquired such currency that by 2000 it was ripe as the basis for an entire angle. After the 'match', Hogan was to grab a mic and rip into Russo in a barbed 'shoot' promo, raising eyebrows - and hopefully, interest.
What wasn't in the scripted 'off-script' script was for Russo himself to hit Hogan with a rejoinder after 'Hollywood's exit. The head booker began shooting from the hip - and his bullets weren't mere blanks. Russo 'fired' the champion and declared the prior contest void. Had it ended there, it might have been fine.
But things got messy when Russo called Hogan a "piece of sh*t", and delivered an extraordinary, defamatory tirade against the 'Hulkster', promising WCW fans they'd never have to see him again.
He was right: so incensed by the promo, Hogan refused to return to work, and later sued Russo for the diatribe. Did Russo's stunt heal WCW's ailing health? We'll let you decide that one.
2. The Original Screwjob
Although rare, double-crosses had been a part of wrestling long before the term 'screw-job' was inseparable from the city of Montreal.
As far back as 1911, George Hackenschmidt found himself on the wrong end of a shoot finish, having previously agreed with Frank Gotch to fix the outcome of their much anticipated match after a knee injury threatened to scupper the event. That someone could be screwed even when the sport was a legitimate contest is testament to the thread of deceit running through the industry's poisoned veins.
Screw-jobs have popped up infrequently ever since, but perhaps the most famous - and visible - example prior to 1997's Survivor Series occurred on 25 November 1985.
Having played a crucial role in marrying WWF with MTV, there was almost no bigger star during the height of the company's 'Rock 'n' wrestling' boom than Wendi Richter. As the reigning women's champion riding a wave of momentum, Richter rightly felt she was worth more than her paltry $25 per show guarantee. After lengthy contract negotiations, the under-remunerated champ deferred signing a new deal whilst she consulted her lawyer.
She needn't have wasted her time; WWF already had plans in place to settle her future.
Working through her contract dispute like a pro, Richter should have known something was awry when she was booked to face a mysterious unknown by the name of 'The Spider Lady' at MSG. Adding to the suspicious circumstances was The Fabulous Moolah's backstage presence - despite the fact she had no involvement in the show.
Except she did. Beneath the mask of Richter's incognito arachnid foe, Moolah cinched her opponent into a small package, allowing the ref to count a legitimate three. The belt was snatched from the champ - for real - and she never worked for the company again.
1. The Montreal Screwjob
What more can be said about the infamous 'Montreal Screwjob'? No, seriously, what more can be said about it? Over the past two decades, literally millions of words have been written, spoken, and in a very rare instance, sang, about the subject. Every person in the world with even the vaguest connection to wrestling has had their say on the intricacies of what went down at Survivor Series '97, and many more besides.
With the 20th anniversary of the debacle perilously close, we can expect the dead horse to be dragged out for another round of beatings. Can't wait...
So I'll just leave it at that. We all know what happened: Bret had title, Vince wanted title back, 'Bret screwed Bret'... something like that.
See you all again in November!