10 Most Extreme Rules In WWE History

The most over-the-top, overblown or just plain overbooked match gimmicks ever seen.

Chyna Jeff Jarrett
WWE.com

Continuing a series of articles (very) loosely based around the titles of upcoming WWE Network special events (I understand they’re also available on pay-per-view, but really, unless you’re working a retro Luddite gimmick in real life, why would you?) we had Extreme Rules grace our screens last night.

That means it’s time to take a look at those WWE matches which suffered from the most extreme rules you’ve ever heard of: gimmicks that overcomplicated simple stories, stipulations that were so overblown that they swamped the match.

It’s a fairly recent phenomenon: up until the advent of the Monday Night War and the Attitude Era upping the ante, feuds still tended to be capped by a simple cage match. Back in 1992, Vince McMahon considered the idea of a two-person ladder match between Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels in 1992 a daring novelty.

Special mention needs to go to the entirety of the WrestleMania 2000 card: featuring nine matches but only one straight singles bout (a two minute catfight between two non-wrestling valets), it’s the dictionary definition of overbooked and undercooked.

So, here they are: the most pointlessly complex, over-the-top and poorly thought through match gimmicks on the WWE’s books.

10. The Gulf Of Mexico Match

chavo guerrero cm punk gulf of mexico
WWE.com

Taking place as the main event of the ECW taping on February 5th 2008, the Gulf Of Mexico match could easily have been a throwback to the real ECW: a street fight, with the participants (CM Punk and Chavo Guerrero) in jeans and t-shirts, that escalated into a brawl throughout the arena, out into the grounds and over to the boardwalk.

The twist was that the match could only be won by one participant throwing the other into the Gulf Of Mexico. This wasn’t the Cannonball Run style cross-country adventure that implies (that would have been amazing). The taping took place at the American Bank Center in Corpus Christi, Texas, and the water’s edge was only a hundred yards or so from the WWE’s front door.

There’s a lot wrong with this match - aside from the fact that, strictly speaking, said water was not the Gulf Of Mexico but Corpus Christi Bay, a good fifteen miles from the Gulf Of Mexico and completely separated from it by a series of barrier islands.

For a start, this wouldn’t be like other rule-free melees, careening all over the place before reaching a climax back at ringside. The completely unnecessary overbooked finish required the pair to be outside the arena. Even a Falls Count Anywhere match can return to finish in front of the audience but here, once they left they weren’t coming back.

Secondly, this kind of match needs time to build the drama. Punk and Guerrero’s encounter was eleven minutes long from bell to bell, meaning that they were forced to bail from the ring and start brawling their way offstage in the opening seconds of the match.

Booking the main event to play out without a live crowd is like going to a gig and having the headline band play out on the big screen instead of on the stage. The crowd isn’t getting what they paid to see, and the band might as well be soundchecking.

WWE had booked the main event for the night to take place outside the arena - once the crowd realised that, they began leaving in droves. After ‘GTSing’ Chavo into the murky water, Punk posed and ‘roared’ for the camera for long, awkward seconds on a darkened pier in front of no one but an amused cameraman.


9. The Pink Slip On A Pole Match

Pink Slip On A Pole Match
WWE.com

A throwback to the kind of matches that Vince Russo touched himself over, the Pink Slip On A Pole match took place between The Rock and Mankind on the December 27th 1999 edition of Monday Night RAW.

The McMahon-Helmsley Faction - the Attitude Era’s precursor to the Authority, with less corporate double-speak but more moustache-twirling evil and moronic henchmen - had only just debuted, and been opposed by Mankind, playing the underdog-speaking-truth-to-power babyface role against Triple H and Stephanie that Daniel Bryan took on fourteen years later.

As payback for publically opposing them, Mankind and The Rock, who had been teaming together as The Rock N’ Sock Connection for the last few months, were forced to face one another, with the loser being fired. Strangely enough, the winner would be the one to tear down the pink slip and keep his job, despite the ‘receiving a pink slip’ being a figure of speech for losing it.

The Rock would win the six-minute match in the middle of the show, and Foley was fired, delivering a heartfelt retirement speech in the middle of the ring to a standing ovation as Jim Ross put him over. However, making a run-in from the crowd to save The Rock in the handicap-match main event the following week, he would be reinstated the week after that when The Rock and the rest of the roster threatened to go on strike unless the McMahon-Helmsley Regime changed their minds.

So there you have it: a short match that made no sense, with a manipulative finish that didn’t stick and a storyline that didn’t go anywhere. Welcome to the Attitude Era.


8. The Championship Scramble Match

Championship Scramble Match
WWE.com

Multi-man matches can often suffer from a lack of focus: either everyone’s just waiting around to get their stuff in, or everyone gets their stuff in all at once. The former is slower and clumsier but easier to understand, while the latter is dynamic and frenetic but often incredibly confusing. To make matters worse, multi-man matches where the champion doesn’t have to lose to lose the title tend to devalue that title, not to mention the stories that led to that moment.

A multi-man match that’s not been seen on WWE programming since 2009, the Championship Scramble was a clusterf*ck of a concept, pairing the Royal Rumble’s staggered entrance times, the elimination match’s multiple falls/submissions and the tension and dramatic heft of a game of Pass The Parcel.

The Championship Scramble has a twenty minute time limit. Two men start the match off, with a third being introduced after five minutes, a fourth at the ten-minute mark and a fifth at fifteen minutes. The match then carries on for a further five minutes after all five men are in the ring, with the objective being to have been the last person to have scored a pinfall or submission before the time runs out.

2008’s Unforgiven pay-per-view would see all three world titles held up in Championship Scramble matches, in the gimmick’s debut on WWE programming. Unfortunately, RAW General Manager Mike Adamle made such a spectacular !*$%-up of explaining the above simple rules that no one - including the announcers - fully understood how the match was supposed to work. With time to reflect the next day, some critics claimed that a clearer focus on the rules would help the next time… but even contested properly, the gimmick is hopeless.

Removing the elimination aspect meant that literally none of the falls mattered except the last one. There was no earthly reason for the staggered entry, and the way in which the match worked encouraged people not to bother kicking out, while desperately trying for a fall every second they had, which devalued the whole concept of the pinfall or submission. Not only that, but given that it didn’t matter who you pinned, the low hanging fruit should have been in a constant state of pinfall as the big hitters used them like punching bags.

The Championship Scramble accentuated every negative element of the multi-man match while providing no positives. No wonder it’s been used so rarely.


7. The First Blood Match

Stone Cold Steve Austin Kane
WWE.com

At first glance, the First Blood match seems like a no-brainer. Back before PG rules forebade the use of blood as a storytelling tool, red meant green: blood added drama, and if the objective of the match was to make your opponent bleed, then you’re essentially telling your audience to be on the edge of their seat, looking out for the first sign of blood. That’s money! Or is it?

No, it really isn’t. If blood is supposed to sell the drama of a hard-fought grudge match, then why would a match where the first sign of blood causes the bell to ring be dramatic in any way?

Blood is supposed to up the ante, to take the match to a new level. That’s why wrestlers blade at a specific point in the match’s layout, to take the story up a notch and increase the crowd’s investment in the action. Unless it’s the post-match beatdown that’s supposed to be the focus of the match, no one’s should be gigging at the finish. It makes no narrative sense.

Having the first instance of bleeding be the end of the match is also a bugger to plan for. What if someone gets busted open hardway, something very possible in the kind of brutally stiff match that First Blood tends to be a part of? What if the match relies on hardway juicing but the eyebrow won’t pop?

Whichever way you look at it, a First Blood match is idiotic and a waste of time.


6. The Good Housekeeping Match

Good Housekeeping Jeff Jarrett Miss Kitty
WWE Network

The circumstances of Jeff Jarrett’s second and final departure from the WWF for WCW in October 1999 and his subsequent erasure from WWF/E history has taken up much of the narrative concerning that departure in the sixteen years since then.

His opponent Chyna has flat out stated that Jarrett held his former employers up for hundreds of thousands of dollars to work the match and drop the title outside of a contract. .Jarrett himself has been magnanimous in victory ever since, insisting that he was only ever paid what he was owed (which is a very vague way of saying almost nothing), while the WWE have never publically discussed the matter.

The match that cost so much money, however, has mostly remained lost in the shuffle. The feud itself had been a lot of fun, with babyface Chyna the victim of Jarrett’s outrageous misogyny, leading to the world’s first - and only - Good Housekeeping match for the title and the blow-off.

The idea of the gimmick was over-blown but at least it was well thought through. Chyna’s limitations in the ring would be completely obscured by the vaudevillian action on display, while Jarrett’s personal credibility was of little interest to anyone: and it fitted perfectly with the theme of their feud to date. It was the execution that was off, and off by some considerable margin.

The ring was surrounded by household appliances, utensils and groceries, all of which were used to comic effect, including a ‘hit him with everything but the kitchen sink’ gag by the Ross/Lawler announce team that was telegraphed a mile off.

Ridiculously, Jarrett would have his pinfall victory nullified in an almost Russoesque bit of booking when it was decided that the title belt shot to Chyna’s head that scored the pinfall wasn’t allowed by the rules, as the Intercontinental Championship belt wasn’t a household item. Despite the fact that this logic meant that Jarrett should have been disqualified, the pinfall was disallowed and the match resumed.

Chyna would then hit Jarrett with his own gimmicked guitar for the pinfall and the title, despite a guitar clearly being a household item in exactly the same way that a title belt would be. Even the announcers called bullsh*t on that one.


5. The Over The Top/Off With The Top Match

A match so horrible that most people, performers and fans alike, would prefer to pretend never took place. In June 2000, uber-sleaze Triple H pressured feuding Divas Terri Runnels and The Kat into participating in the gimmicked match in which they would be represented by Dean Malenko and Jerry ‘The King’ Lawler, respectively. With the two women standing on podiums on the stage, they would have to remove an item of clothing every time their guy was thrown over the top rope.

Poor old Jim Ross, alone on commentary, was forced to narrate the proceedings like the straight-laced family man he was in the absence of his lewd partner-in-crime, whose bugeyed, leering antics every time Terri took off an item of clothing amply illustrated the kind of comments he’d like to have been making.

The match would be won when one of the two women, down to her fundamentals, was forced to remove her ‘top’: an odd euphemism, but essentially what was meant was that her breasts would be exposed. Of course, the WWF/E were and are masters of the bait and switch, even in the more risque Attitude Era: Steven Richards from the Right To Censor heel stable ran out with a board to cover Terri’s modesty.

Now, we’re all adults here: and since, as adults, the idea of the naked female form doesn’t instantly devolve us into snorting, panting cartoon wolves, we can appreciate that a televised wrestling match between a world-renowned technical marvel and a genuine legend which exists purely to get two women down to their skivvies is a massive waste of everyone’s time, as well as offensive and puerile.

Back in 2000, Lawler and Malenko could go like mice on a subway line, but this nonsense was one of only three times that the two would ever face each other in the ring, and one of those was a house show. Criminal, really.


4. The Three Stages Of Hell Match

Three Stages of Hell - No Way Out 2001
WWE.com

This match is a case study in stupidity. The two-out-of-three-falls match is usually telegraphed so far in advance that the announcers are calling the match in Morse Code just to try and keep up: if one man wins the first fall, invariably his opponent will win the second because if not, there will be no third fall.

That’s even more the case in a match in which each of the three falls is heavily gimmicked and/or overbooked. There aren’t three stories taking place here: the Three Stages Of Hell match is a single bout split into three acts. Of course Cena is going to win the tables match when Ryback wins the lumberjack match - if he doesn’t, then there won’t be any ambulance match to round it all off.

Austin and Triple H’s attempt at No Way Out in 2001 is, of course, the most famous and successful example of the Three Stages Of Hell match there is - and even that screwed the pooch something massive. Since there was no way in hell that the cage wasn’t coming down for the third part of the match, the finish of the street fight in the second match was a foregone conclusion.

Of course, the ending to Triple H and ‘Stone Cold’ Steve Austin’s trilogy was fudged too. The double knockout finish was ridiculous, and given the inconclusive ending, the match failed to blow the feud off properly.

The babyface out for bloody vengeance didn’t get it… and that babyface had a rep for being the most vicious, unforgiving SOB in the company. It made no sense for the Rattlesnake to consider his grudge with the Game concluded after this.


3. The Punjabi Prison Match

Punjabi Prison Match
WWE.com

The Punjabi Prison is a lovely one-two combination punch of stupid. Why exactly the WWE felt that it would be appropriate to have a giant two-cage structure made entirely of bamboo for an Indian wrestler’s signature bout is baffling… as if Punjabi convicts live in giant cages in the jungle having bananas smuggled to them by friendly anthropomorphic Disney monkeys. Talk about casual racism.

The structure of the Punjabi Prison itself is key to determining how the match was supposed to go. The ring was surrounded by one cage with four doors, and a much larger cage with no doors surrounded that. The idea was that a wrestler would ask for one of the doors to be opened and have one minute to leave via that door. If he was unable to do so, the door would be closed and padlocked, leaving only three doors remaining. Once the first cage was escaped, the second cage would then have to be escaped to win.

Of course, a participant can just climb to the top of the first cage, and leap to near the top of the second cage: which is exactly what Batista (never the world’s most agile of men) did fairly easily to win the second iteration of the match. In doing so, he beat the Great Khali, who was beginning to climb the second cage while Batista was still trapped in the first. Fans in attendance could barely see any of this, of course: there were two massive yellow cages in the way.

Given that the antagonist in both Punjabi Prison matches to date was a seven-foot pituitary giant, it does seem strange that they were thrown into a match which relied upon their ability to climb tall bamboo cages. Neither the Big Show nor the Great Khali could have found that easy or comfortable.

It’s especially peculiar that this was designed to be the Great Khali’s signature match: I mean, you don’t order satay chicken if you’re allergic to peanuts, let alone tell everyone it’s your favourite.


2. The Kennel From Hell Match

Al Snow Kennel From Hell
WWE.com

The blow-off match to a peculiar little midcard feud between the late Big Bossman and Al Snow in summer 1999, this gimmick was screwed up on so many levels that it’s still astonishing to this day that the WWF greenlit it in the first place.

I understand that the grudge was so personal - the Bossman had killed Al’s pet dog Pepper and somehow tricked him into eating it - that it needed a big moment to end it, but this was ridiculous.

Because a simple cage match just wouldn’t be enough (when is it ever enough these days?), the traditional blue-barred cage was surrounded with a larger cell - literally, the Hell In A Cell structure - and half-starved and crazed attack dogs would patrol the no-man’s land between the two structures.

The trouble was that the animals were docile, easily bored and far more likely to p*ss and sh*t around the ring and attempt to have sex with one another than snarl viciously for the cameras.

For the first ten minutes or so, the bitter enemies tried to avoid one another, clambering around the cages. As with the Punjabi Prison years later, the two cages made it nearly impossible for the audience and cameras outside to see what was going on inside.

Meanwhile, the awkward and inappropriate behaviour on the part of the dogs meant that the cameramen could rarely (if ever) get them in shot, so the WWF television producers couldn’t even get a cool visual out of them.

Finally, both men completely blew the finish, and the climax to this clusterf*ck led to Al Snow simply leaving the cage and slamming the door to win. Behind him, his arch-nemesis the Bossman had somehow made his way to the top of the Cell. To this day, whoever knows how it was supposed to end isn’t telling.


1. The Extreme Elimination Chamber Match

Extreme Chamber Br
WWE.com

WWE’s December to Dismember event in very late 2006 was an absolute mess in almost every conceivable way, certainly long before the main event.

The Extreme Elimination Chamber main event match must have seemed like a no-brainer - have the already intimidating Elimination Chamber set-up augmented by weapons - but nothing worked as it was supposed to.

Prior to the match, ECW Original Sabu was stretchered off following ‘a backstage attack’ (in real life, Terry Brunk failed a drug test), and Hardcore Holly took his place. Bob Holly is and always has been a far better hand than anyone’s given him credit for, but this was nonsense. Sabu’s reputation was such that no one would have bought one of the most fearless, stoic wrestlers in the world being unable to compete unless his legs had fallen off: the crowd chanted “BULLSH*T”, and they were right.

It got worse. Heyman’s pick to win the match and the Big Show’s ECW title had been CM Punk, the clear rising star, but Vince McMahon had his heart set on the rookie behemoth Bobby Lashley, and Punk would be the first eliminated instead, barely getting any offense in at all and eliciting more crowd displeasure.

Holly went ten seconds later, but so poorly laid out was the match that he kicked out and was sent home anyway. Even the announcers called that one out for being screwed up. Next out was Rob Van Dam - and the crowd was more than rumbling this time, as this left an overweight, sluggish Big Show, the clearly ‘roided up Test and human cucumber Bobby Lashley to finish the match. Lashley would end up taking Big Show’s ECW title to the sound of complete indifference.

As a showcase for ECW, the main event was a colossal failure, burying the C-brand’s most over babyface in CM Punk, kicking to the curb the two ex-ECW mainstays in Sabu and RVD, and pushing three men the crowd couldn’t care less about.

As for ‘extreme’? The table couldn’t be used properly within the confines of the Chamber and was abandoned inside Lashley’s pod. The crowbar and the barbed wire bat were next to useless: the chair was the only international object that worked as intended. What a waste of everybody’s time.


Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.