10 Most Feel-Good Title Wins In Wrestling

Wrestling offers fan service unlike any other sport, which is shown by these memorable title wins.

The Acclaimed AEW Tag-Team Titles
AEW

Wrestling is unlike any sport in that its scripted nature can guarantee the satisfactory ending that fans have been anticipating. Despite this, there have been numerous examples of promoters squandering the delivery of something that looked certain to be thrilling. Whether it be a promo, match, or an entire feud, not all expectations can be realised in the extremely fragile world of wrestling.

However, when it is done well, there is nothing quite like the action found inside the squared circle, as a gratifying outcome can reduce any staunch critic to an excited fan once again. The most obvious occurrence of this is when wrestling delivers a feel-good win for fans to celebrate, as happiness is ultimately what all spectators are looking to receive from their chosen sport.

The recent AEW World Tag Team Championship win for The Acclaimed was a perfect example of this, as the homegrown talents of Max Caster and Anthony Bowens deserved the accolade for garnering so much popularity.

Their matches against Swerve In Our Glory were the hottest on the card at All Out and Grand Slam, which made the title change at the latter an obvious decision for the promotion to make.

As was also the case when...

10. Christian (WWE Extreme Rules 2011)

Christian WWE Title
WWE

In 2011, the unfortunate retirement of the Edge helped grant an overdue world title reign in WWE for his best friend Christian. Shortly after retaining his World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania 27, the 'Rated-R Superstar' had to vacate the title due to his career-ending injury. To crown a new champion a ladder match between Christian and Alberto Del Rio was set for the Extreme Rules pay-per-view.

It was difficult to tell which competitor would come out on top, as both had good enough reasons to be the next champion. Del Rio was one of the company's fastest-rising young stars whilst Christian had predominantly been performing in WWE's reincarnation of ECW since returning to the company in 2009.

In the end, the sentimental support for 'Captain Charisma' prevailed as the tag-team specialist claimed his first world title in the company. The win felt right for two reasons, it was nice seeing Edge's legacy live on through his best friend, whilst Christian rightfully earned the accolade for his years of hard work inside and outside of WWE.


9. Johnny Gargano (NXT TakeOver: New York)

Adam Cole Johnny Gargano NXT TakeOver New York
WWE

NXT was the most critically acclaimed North American wrestling brand towards the end of the 2010s, arguably hitting its peak in 2019 before the beginning of the 'Wednesday Night Wars' with AEW. TakeOver: New York embodied this as the event was the last example of the black and gold brand operating at its best, with a card that was excellent from top to bottom.

The main event of the show saw the 'Heart and Soul of NXT' Johnny Gargano face off against the leader of the Undisputed Era, Adam Cole, in a two out of three falls match for the vacant world title. The underdog Gargano had been chasing the title for some time, coming up short against the likes of Andrade 'Cien' Almas, Aleister Black, and his former friend turned nemesis, Tommaso Ciampa, who had to forfeit the NXT Championship due to injury.

The match was tremendous and played on Cole's UE stablemates interfering to create a plethora of false finishes that garnered even more support for Gargano. In the end, 'Johnny Wrestling' overcame the odds to cap off an all-time great match and TakeOver event.


8. Randy Savage (WWE WrestleMania IV)

Randy Savage Wrestlemania 4
WWE.com

WrestleMania IV may not be looked back on so fondly by WWE fans, as it was far from an in-ring spectacle and failed to live up to the same event a year before. The show at the Boardwalk Hall in Atlantic City, New Jersey, was built around a 14-man tournament for the vacant WWE World Heavyweight Championship.

The title had been stripped from Andre the Giant for attempting to sell it to the 'Million Dollar Man' Ted DiBiase after defeating Hulk Hogan in a television spectacle. All three men would compete in the tournament alongside stars such as Jake Roberts, Rick Rude, Ricky Steamboat, Honky Tonk Man, and the incomparable 'Macho Man' Randy Savage. Savage had been a heel alongside his partner Miss Elizabeth for a long time, but fans had grown so fond of the zany superstar that he was forced into a face turn in the lead-up to WrestleMania.

'The Hulkster' and Andre were eliminated due to double disqualification, which led to an eventual final between 'Macho Man' and DiBiase for the world title in the main event. Savage prevailed to a rapturous reception which completed his journey to being a fan favorite WWE Champion on the same level as Hulk Hogan.


7. Jon Moxley (AEW Revolution 2020)

Jon Moxley Chris Jericho AEW Revolution 2020
AEW

Jon Moxley's legendary AEW run has made him synonymous with the brand as he has arguably been the most valuable performer over its three-year existence. The former Dean Ambrose had been stigmatized as a limited performer during his WWE run, as the company never seemed to want to push him as the top guy alongside his former Shield stablemates Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns.

Moxley surprised the wrestling world by appearing at the inaugural Double or Nothing in 2019, before participating in that year's G1 Climax where he asserted himself as one of the best wrestlers in the world. AEW's new show Dynamite launched later that year, where it was clear that the Cincinnati native was being positioned as 'Le Champion' Chris Jericho's successor for the world title.

The two faced off at Revolution 2020 after a great build that involved Moxley having to wear an eyepatch after he refused to join Jericho's Inner Circle, leading to the latter blinding his challenger with a spike. There was some concern about having the first two AEW champions be former WWE stars, but this turned out to be ridiculous in hindsight given how tremendous the title change was on the night.

The three-time AEW Champion's first reign remains the best in the company's history, as Jon Moxley carried the company throughout the early stages of the pandemic.


6. Bayley (NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn)

Bayley NXT
WWE

The Four Horsewomen of NXT helped blaze a trail for women’s wrestling in North America, which was facilitated by the retooling of the black and gold brand into a weekly developmental show run by Triple H. NXT offered a new chance for WWE to develop their talent more successfully but also gave the 'Women's Revolution' the foundation it needed to grow.

Talents such as Paige, Emma, Charlotte, and Becky Lynch had some memorable moments on the brand and would go on to have a meaningful impact on the wrestling business. The feud between Sasha Banks and Bayley summed up this transformation for women's wrestling, as the pair put on a series of matches that are amongst the best in the company's history.

The perennial underdog Bayley was beloved by the NXT fanbase, which made her a sentimental favorite going into her match against 'The Boss' at TakeOver Brooklyn in 2015. The match that followed was incredible and defied the highest expectations for the two burgeoning superstars, which was made even better by the fact that 'The Hugger' came out on top to win her first world title.


5. Eddie Guerrero (WWE No Way Out 2004)

Eddie Guerrero
WWE

Eddie Guerrero, one of the industry's most iconic wrestlers, winning his first and only world title remains a special moment to this day. It is arguably one of the most shocking title wins ever too, as he defeated the unstoppable Brock Lesnar during his first run in WWE just before 'The Next Big Thing' disappeared from the company for almost a decade.

'Latino Heat' had always been admired for his charm, charisma, and technical ability, but had never been pushed as a main event star in either WCW or WWE. That was until Guerrero won a battle royal that gave him the opportunity to face the dominant champion, Lesnar, at No Way Out 2004.

It was great to see the former United States and Intercontinental Champion in a world title fight in the first place, but having him defeat the 'Beast Incarnate' was inspired. Brock was on his way out of the company so dropping the belt was necessary, but choosing Eddie to carry the torch into WrestleMania 20 was a rewarding decision for the performer and fans alike.

Guerrero had worked his way back to the top of the industry by gaining an overwhelming amount of fan support.


4. Mankind (WWE RAW, January 4, 1999)

Mankind Wwe Title
WWE.com

Mick Foley is the embodiment of a wrestler succeeding against the odds, as the journeyman became a multiple-time world champion during WWE's Attitude Era. His Mankind persona underwent a renaissance throughout 1998, where the grotesque monster figure became an oafish comedy character vying for the affections of Mr. McMahon.

After trying to assist McMahon in his pursuit to halt the rise of 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin under the guise of Dude Love, Foley transitioned back into the more comedic version of Mankind. In a number of memorable television segments, Vince resisted Mankind's attempts to befriend him, which involved the invention of the 'Mr. Socko' gimmick. The pairing was successful in helping Foley turn face, which was cemented when he was screwed out of the WWE Championship in the final of the 'Deadly Game' tournament at Survivor Series 1998.

The Rock had been selected as the corporate champion, which garnered a great deal of support behind Mankind who managed to defeat his adversary on the 4th of January, 1999 episode of RAW. The title change was made even more historic due to the all-time great error made by WCW trying to spoil the result. This led to many of their viewers changing channels to see Mick Foley win his first world title.


3. 'Hangman' Adam Page (AEW Full Gear 2021)

Hangman Page
AEW

The near three-year-long storyline between The Elite and 'Hangman' Adam Page was AEW operating at its best, which made the 'Anxious Millennial Cowboy's' title win feel incredibly special. The former AEW Tag Team Champion was part of the inaugural world title match against Chris Jericho at All Out 2019, where he ultimately failed leading to a downward spiral that ostracized him from his friends Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks.

Hangman found form once again as a singles performer in 2021 when his former tag partner Omega reigned as the AEW World Champion. It was clear that the two former stablemates were on a collision course but Page had to restore faith in himself and gain back his confidence, which he did with the help of the Dark Order.

The long road back to the AEW title for Hangman came at Full Gear 2021, where the cowboy bested his old friend for the belt. His coronation paid off nearly three years' worth of character development for all of The Elite, whilst concluding one of the best feuds the promotion has ever booked.


2. Kofi Kingston (WWE WrestleMania 35)

20190405 WM35 Show Kofi  B27677f7fb8245447fb2a9673879be5a
WWE

The past two decades have seen many superstars come and go from the WWE, many of which don't make it to the very top of the company despite their best efforts. Kofi Kingston is the embodiment of how hard work can pay off even after a decade of working for Vince McMahon.

Kingston began his WWE career very promisingly, winning a number of mid-card and tag titles and being profiled in a feud against mainstay Randy Orton. However, his early push only got him so far as Kofi became a normalized part of the roster and never made it to the main event of the company.

That was until 2019 when the New Day member went on a blistering run of form that took him all the way to a WWE Championship against Daniel Bryan at WrestleMania 35. The rise was aptly referred to as 'Kofi-Mania,' with fan support for Kingston reaching an all-time high hoping that he would dethrone the 'Planet's Champion.'

Thankfully, WWE followed through on the build-up and crowned Kofi Kingston as the world champion, over a decade after he first debuted in the company. Having the New Day by his side as he won the gold made Kofi's moment even more special as the group added another moment to its already rich legacy.


1. Daniel Bryan (WWE WrestleMania 30)

Daniel Bryan Wrestlemania 30
WWE.com

The 'Miracle on Bourbon Street' is perhaps the greatest moment in WrestleMania history and is certainly the most rewarding title win that fans have witnessed at the 'Show of Shows'. Daniel Bryan is undoubtedly one of the greatest wrestlers of all time, but he also had to become an elite sports entertainer so that he could make it to the top of WWE.

Bryan did just that after adapting his hard-hitting, technical style for a mainstream audience, despite Michael Cole repeatedly calling him boring on commentary. The 'American Dragon' became World Heavyweight Champion in late 2011 after cashing in his Money in the Bank contract but lost the title in an embarrassing fashion at WrestleMania 28 to Sheamus. Losing the title in 18 seconds could have spelled disaster for Bryan's prospect as a main-event talent, but he got over again as part of Team Hell-No and in 2013 seemed destined to be a world champion again.

He fulfilled this promise by defeating John Cena for the WWE Championship at SummerSlam 2013 but lost the title immediately to Randy Orton after he cashed in his Money in the Bank contract. This gave rise to the 'YES! Movement' where fans defiantly campaigned for Bryan to compete for the title he lost at WrestleMania 30.

The rest is history, as he defeated all three members of Evolution in one night to win the WWE World Heavyweight Championship and cement his legacy as one of the best and most beloved performers of the century.


Contributor
Contributor

I like wrestling a lot and writing about it is fun. Thanks for reading!