10 Most Important Days In The Creation Of AEW
Timeline of a pro-wrestling revolution.
With the promotion's TNT debut on 2 October and next pay-per-view, Full Gear, on 9 November (featuring the re-booked Jon Moxley vs. Kenny Omega clash), All Elite Wrestling fans have a couple of big dates to look forward to over the next few months.
2 October is particularly important. Mainstream professional wrestling hasn't had a true ratings clash since TNA's knuckle-headed decision to air Impact opposite WWE Monday Night Raw, resulting in a predictably disastrous defeat. The experiment was abandoned after nine weeks. This time, WWE are the aggressors, having moved NXT to USA Network months after AEW's weekly Wednesday slot was announced, sparking this new Wednesday Night War.
While show quality is always subjective, following AEW's growth has made the past 12 months infinitely more interesting than the 12 before them. This will only intensify once All Elite start airing their weekly shows. Wrestling wars are fun and with WWE sending their most acclaimed brand to compete with AEW, Wednesdays should leave viewers spoiled for choice.
Let's take a look at the days that shaped this pro-wrestling revolution. Even if All Elite Wrestling fails, it'll be one hell of a story...
10. Cody Rhodes Leaves WWE (22 May 2016)
Stardust became "the star that left them on the dust" on 22 May 2016, when Cody Rhodes was granted the WWE release he'd tweeted about the day before:-
Professionally, Rhodes was in a rut. Competing primarily on Main Event and Superstars at the time he was let go, Cody was frustrated by his perceived misuse, citing WWE's decision to persist with the Stardust character long past its sell-by date and the refusal of several pitched ideas amongst other peeves. Thus, he was released during a period of major roster upheaval, with Wade Barrett, Damien Sandow, Hornswoggle, and others all leaving during the same month.
Cody's departure was a big story that year. A smart worker and tenured second-generation star, he had floundered in an environment that should have allowed him to flourish. None of it was his fault, so of course he valued himself more than WWE's push.
Afterwards, Rhodes' marketing nous came out as he released a list of wrestlers he'd like to face upon his no-compete clause's 19 August expiration. The likes of Adam Cole, Kurt Angle, and The Young Bucks all featured, and he wrestled Zack Sabre Jr. in his first post-WWE match that very day.
9. Cody & Meltzer Place Their Bets (16 May 2017)
If Cody Rhodes doesn't leave WWE, it's highly unlikely that he ever goes to New Japan Pro Wrestling, meets Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks, joins The Elite, and helps form AEW.
If Dave Meltzer doesn't tweet this on 16 May 2017, the "what if?" is similarly huge:-
The idea of a non-WWE group accomplishing such a thing was inconceivable at the time. While Ring Of Honor were doing tremendous business, New Japan Pro Wrestling's US expansion was taking shape, and The Elite were one of the sport's most buzz-worthy groups, true competition had been dead for close to two decades. It was a crazy idea.
That didn't stop Cody from responding:-
Thus, the seeds for All In were sown.
It took a while for the show to come to fruition. The potential event went from an ROH pay-per-view to a self-promoted affair during this time, with Cody, The Young Bucks, Kenny Omega, Brandi Rhodes, and Stephen Amell all confirmed. December 2017 brought the announcement that they were looking for venues. In January 2018, a 1 September date was confirmed, with Chicago's Sears Center named as the venue two months later, setting the game-changing event's wheels in motion.
8. All In (1 September 2018)
Tickets for All In went on sale on 13 May 2018. That only a single match had been announced for the show didn't stop it from being an immediate, unprecedented box office hit, with all 10,000+ tickets selling out within 30 minutes.
Cody had won his belt with Dave Meltzer.
The build-up saw names like Kota Ibushi, Kazuchika Okada, Pentagon Jr., and countless more confirmed. A YouTube series, All Out, was put together to accompany Being the Elite's build before the show hit Chicago on 1 September, becoming the first non-WWE or WCW event to break 10,000 ticket sales (they shifted 11,263) since 1993.
All In had hitches (major timing issues saw the main event's runtime slashed in half, for one), though it was still a colossal success. Already a business smash, matches like Kenny Omega vs. Pentagon, Cody vs. Nick Aldis, and Okada vs. Marty Scurll drew widespread critical acclaim. The excitement coming out of Chicago that night was unreal and while The Elite's long-term future remained unclear, though a post-show promo saw Cody promise "we're sticking together. Not one entity, not one company owns pro-wrestling. We own pro-wrestling!"
He was on the money.
7. Trademarks, Filed (5 November 2018)
The months following All In were rife with rumours of what was coming next, until "All Elite Wrestling" officially became A Thing in November 2018.
This day saw a number of telling trademarks filed in Jacksonville, Florida. Among them were All Elite Wrestling, AEW, AEW All Out, All Out, Double Or Nothing, AEW Double Or Nothing, and Tuesday Night Dynamite, along with a whole bunch of logos. At this point, it was pretty obvious what was going on - though fans were made to wait for official confirmation.
The Jacksonville location was telling, too, and attention immediately turned to the billionaire Khan family, who own the city's Jaguar's NFL team. Shahid Khan's son, Tony, was a lifelong wrestling fan and had reportedly been planning on entering the wrestling business for a long, long time. If they were indeed attached to The Elite and their apparent new promotion, Cody, The Young Bucks, and co. had the financial backing the match their astronomical ambitions.
6. Cody & The Young Bucks Turn WWE Down (December 2018)
December 2018 brought several important developments in AEW's creation, though the specific dates are unclear.
An appearance on Bruce Prichard's Something to Wrestle podcast saw Cody claim that he'd turned down a fresh WWE contract offer. One week later, Dave Meltzer reported that The Young Bucks had done the same, suggesting that yes, the were on the verge of starting their own promotion.
If the reports that surfaced in early 2019 were accurate, it sounds like WWE pulled out all the stops to get hold of Cody and the Bucks. Seven-figure salaries were mentioned, as was a supposed "invasion" angle in which the trio plus Kenny Omega and Hangman Page would run roughshod over the company ahead of WrestleMania 35. Meltzer also mentioned a clause allowing Matt and Nick Jackson to back out of their deals after just six months if they were unhappy. It was unprecedented.
December 2018 also saw The Elite say goodbye to Ring Of Honor. Their contracts had expired, and they wrestled farewell matches at the Final Battle 2018 tapings. There was now nothing stopping them from entering the American market as promoters.
5. Being All Elite (1 January 2019)
Finally, after much speculation, All Elite Wrestling came to life on Being the Elite's 1 January 2019 episode:-
It was the most important episode in the popular web series' history and they saved the big news 'til the end, building up to it with All In clips and footage of Cody walking through the Tokyo Dome Hotel. Outside, he met Hangman Page and The Young Bucks. It looked like they were counting down to the new year until the penny dropped. The Elite walked in front of the camera, music hit, and the excited quartet held their phones to the lens, unveiling AEW and Double or Nothing at the same time.
Further details emerged in the aftermath. An AEW rally was confirmed for Jacksonville, Florida on 8 January, where further details would presumably be announced. Dave Meltzer and Bryan Alvarez also reported that while Cody and The Bucks weren't signed to AEW, they would be soon, adding that Tony Khan was the company presented, wrestlers were being tied down to multi-year contracts, and All In' success "wasn't lost on TV people."
Cue: all the hype in the world.
4. Hiroshi Tanahashi Defeats Kenny Omega (4 January 2019)
While the rest of The Elite were seemingly free to pursue their dreams with All Elite Wrestling, Kenny Omega was not. 'The Best Bout Machine' was almost six months into his reign with the prestigious IWGP Heavyweight Championship when the promoted was unveiled, having engaged in an acclaimed long-term feud with Kazuchika Okada to claim the belt, complicating his situation.
Though Omega's NJPW contract was set to expire later that month, his long-held affinity for Japanese wrestling and huge spotlight raised further doubts. These were eradicated when he faced New Japan ace Hiroshi Tanahashi at Wrestle Kingdom 13.
A typically stunning encounter saw Tanahashi claim his eighth IWGP Title reign by vanquishing Kenny in the Tokyo Dome. While this made sense within the compelling era vs. era storyline crafted in the build, it all but confirmed Omega's next move for many. Kenny's future, with his expiring contract, was now untethered.
Further suspicion was aroused when Omega failed to appear at New Year Dash the following day, making it clear that 'The Cleaner' was almost certainly joining his boys in their new venture.
3. The Big Reveal (8 January 2019)
Held outside the Jacksonville Jaguars' 68,000-capacity TIAA Bank Field in 8 January, AEW's big press conference was marred only by shoddy presentation and a handful of uncertain promos. Though the YouTube stream was stable, the camerawork and production values were lacking, hosts Conrad Thompson and Alex Marvez meandered, and some of the wrestlers stumbled, but the content more than made up for the imperfect delivery.
Executive Vice Presidents Cody and The Young Bucks planted their flag with the promise to "change the wrestling economy," claiming their promotion would listen to the fans, make wins and loss matter, and cast a wide net in their global talent search. Brandi Rhodes claimed pay parity for women's wrestling and introduced Britt Baker as AEW's first female signing. Elsewhere, the likes of Hangman Page, Joey Janela, PAC (who showed up in full gear), SoCal Uncensored, and others were introduced, as was Chris Jericho, whose unexpected arrival made for a perfect way to close the presser.
It was hard not to feel excited about AEW coming out of this, and the announcement that Double Or Nothing would go down on 25 May gave fans the next big date to look forward to.
2. TV Deal, Secured (15 May 2019)
The excitement for All Elite Wrestling's genesis was always tempered by one small (read: major) stumbling block after the Jacksonville press conference: the promotion's lack of TV deal.
While WWE had recently signed bumper new contracts for Raw and SmackDown, the past few years had seen smaller promotions struggle, with Impact's plight particularly notable (they currently broadcast to around 10,000-15,000 viewers on Pursuit). This suggested a difficult quest for AEW.
Fortunately, the promotion exceeded all expectations when they announced a deal with WarnerMedia described as "unprecedented for a startup" on 15 May. It was confirmed that AEW television would air on TNT, WCW's old home during the Monday Night Wars, complimenting the previous week's news of a British TV deal with ITV nicely.
The nascent promotion finally had the platform they needed to take off. The chance to broadcast on a station available in close to 90 million homes across America was a huge get for a company that hadn't held an official show yet, with TNT paying for production costs and dealing AEW a slice of advertisement revenue. Realistically, it was the best-case scenario.
1. Double Or Nothing (25 May 2019)
All Elite Wrestling set sail on their maiden pay-per-view voyage on 25 May and while quality is subjective, key metrics show Double Or Nothing was a complete, objective success.
The vast majority of the show's 11,000 tickets were sold in around half an hour during the presale. What little remained lasted just four minutes of general sale. A pay-per-view buyrate of something between 98,5000 and 113,000 greatly exceeded expectations and may have betterd ECW's best-selling show (99,000 buys), thus making it the most successful wrestling PPV ever produced by a company not named WWE or WCW. Per Dave Meltzer, it achieved a buyrate that nobody had hit without regular TV exposure since 2004's Tito Ortiz vs. Chuck Liddell UFC fight.
Double Or Nothing's critical response was largely glowing. Negative appraisals are just as valid as positive ones, of course, but matches like Cody vs. Dustin Rhodes, The Young Bucks vs. Lucha Brothers, and the six-person joshi tag generated tremendous buzz. Jon Moxley's big debut was one of the year's hottest wrestling moments, too.
A perfect show? Absolutely not, such things don't exist, but AEW hit a home run when it mattered.