10 Most Infamous Matches In Wrestling History

Shambolic shadenfreude sh*t-shows.

Chamber Of Horrors
WWE.com

There are so, so many dishonourable mentions to consider.

Al Snow and the Big Boss Man's Kennel From Hell match at Unforgiven 1999 was an obvious contender, but it was really more dull than it was shambolic, despite the best efforts of some drugged-up rottweilers. "Donald Trump" versus "Rosie O'Donnell" from the January 8, 2007 RAW wasn't a wrestling match but a publicity stunt. Bret Hart Vs. Vince McMahon, at WrestleMania XXVI, was under serious consideration - but ultimately it was too depressing to reach the near-shadenfreude tone elsewhere.

That's not to say every match contained herein has taken on a so-bad-it's-good quality. Some are so naff that they can't help but become hypnotising car crashes, appealing to the grimly curious side of the human condition - but others, which demand inclusion, remain so painful, so infuriating, that when the referee's hand strikes three the viewer might as well need scraping off the windshield.

Incredibly, several of the men included here have also been awarded ***** matches by the Wrestling Observer - then again, those matches weren't insanely one-sided cage collisions which narrowly avoided severe distress to an entire ethnoreligious group.

10. Hulk Hogan Vs. Kevin Nash - WCW Monday Nitro (January 4, 1999)

Fingerpoke Of Doom Nash Hogan
WWE Network

By early 1999, WCW's status as North American top dog was in critical condition, but contrary to WWE's revisionist history, the competition for ratings supremacy was very much alive - until WCW managed to commit suicide twice in one night.

Tony Schiavone gave away the result of the taped Rock Vs. Mankind match which aired on RAW that night. "That'll put some butts in the seats," he oozed. It was, of course, deeply ironic. Viewers flocked in their droves to witness Foley's moment of triumph. It wasn't quite the watershed moment it has since been portrayed as; those viewers returned in almost the same number to watch the three hour Nitro's main event.

The WCW World title match between Kevin Nash and Hulk Hogan was a catastrophe. It was a major, much-anticipated match between two former allies and massive stars. It was never going to be a classic, but that much was beside the point. It was huge. It was epic.

It didn't happen. After Nash pushed Hogan into the turnbuckle, detonating the crowd, Hogan responded by gently poking Nash in the chest with his finger. Nash flopped to the mat exaggeratedly. The ruse was revealed; the New World Order - the very faction WCW fans were sick at the sight of - had been reformed.

It was meant to generate controversy, and relaunch the storyline, but the angle only underlined to fans that WCW was manipulative and entirely devoid of original thought. Never again did the company win a ratings battle.


9. Gerald Brisco Vs. Pat Patterson - WWF King Of The Ring 2000

gerald brisco pat patterson
WWE.com

"This is going to be different," promised Jim Ross on commentary. It was that.

Incredibly, the match was even promoted with a hype video vignette, in which the stooges were presented as robots (!) with stated missions. Patterson, who turned on Brisco to claim his Hardcore title under the 24/7 ruling, had an objective to retain the title at "any cost". Brisco's mission was to "kick Pat Patterson's a**" which was funny - as opposed to the comedy "action", which decidedly was not - because how was he meant to do that in a match in which the actual mission was to remove the evening gown from the body of your opponent?

There was at least a logical storyline reason for the Evening Gown portion of the Hardcore Evening Gown stipulation. To avoid Brisco, Patterson dressed up in drag and took refuge in the women's locker room, before Brisco donned a dress to infiltrate his sanctum.

Actually, hold on. No. Pat Patterson was put in a dress because he's gay. Ah, yes. That was it. He tried to get out the match with a stream of innuendo - "I'll lay down in the middle of the ring, you can get on top of me..." - to which Jim Ross and Jerry Lawler reacted with repulsed guffawing.

He then tried to force a banana down Brisco's throat because it is vaguely similar in shape to a penis. It was somehow the most exciting spot.


8. John Cena Vs. John Laurinaitis - WWE Over The Limit 2012

Cena Lairinaitis
WWE.com

In 2012, John Cena was meant to have experienced the worst year in his professional career. He somehow needed to be redeemed from beating a returning Brock Lesnar and remaining firmly in the WWE Championship picture ahead of his WrestleMania 29 rematch with The Rock.

He also had a whale of time bullying and thrashing onscreen authority figure John Laurinaitis in the main event of Over The Limit 2012. He was the only one.

For seventeen migraine-inducing minutes, the very worst of the Cena character was distilled and elevated above everything else in the company. He gurned his way through a comedy performance played for the most juvenile laughs imaginable. He spun Laurinaitis around and made him dizzy. He then rang the ring bell next to his ears, before dragging the disoriented "Big Johnny" into the commentary area, at which point he "hilariously" thought he was Booker T. The Big Show turned up at the end, telegraphing the most obvious ever of his frequent and contrived heel turns. It was as conspicuous as his garish yellow shirt.

Worse than the fact that it headlined over CM Punk and Daniel Bryan's technical masterclass, worse than the fact that it dragged on for nearly twenty minutes, worse than the blindingly obvious finish, was that it existed to both set up another Cena/Show retreated.

Scratch that; even worse was the portrayal of Laurinaitis as a bumbling fool. It was too close to home. The man oversaw the dismal developmental system for years, and was directly responsible for the dross that was WWE in the pre-NXT era - and this match was a near-affectionate acquittal of it.


7. Hulk Hogan & Randy Savage Vs. The Alliance To End Hulkamania - WCW Uncensored 1996

Doomsday Cage
WWE Network

At Uncensored 1996, WCW conceived of a solution to get the Hulk Hogan babyface character over to the industry-defining extent he was in the WWF.

You could call it the Final Solution, if it weren't for the unfortunate association with mass Jewish genocide. WCW actually did; the character played by the grotesquely muscled Robert Swenson - one of eight heels positioned to end Hulkamania once and for all - was named just that before some WCW staffer recalled the most familiar chapter in modern western history.

The match - a triple decker cage abomination, an anti-exercise in wrestling psychology - was a so-bad-it's-genius highlight reel of unadulterated sh*t. Hogan and Savage were positioned as both impossibly hard babyfaces, shrugging off a slew of heel monsters, and dastardly heels. Hogan tried to casually kill Kevin Sullivan by throwing him off the scaffold supporting the convoluted structure.

Before he made it that far, he blanked G.O.A.T candidates Ric Flair and Arn Anderson (dressed, naturally, as a ninja) in a scene more befitting Streets of Rage than a pro wrestling match. The Ultimate Solution and fellow non-wrestling monstrosity Z-Gangsta (Zeus) were portrayed as the greatest threat to the intrepid heroes, who almost defeated them with the power of their grunts and posing.

In the end, Lex Luger inadvertently turned the tide by accidentally punching Ric Flair (after stalling and then going through with it, anyway) before, underscoring the farce beautifully, Hogan and Savage battered the heels with frying pans.

And people moan that Roman Reigns is booked to look too strong.


6. The Bushwhackers Vs. The Iron Sheik & Nikolai Volkoff - Heroes Of Wrestling

In a match opposite the New Zealand tandem of the Bushwhackers, the Iron Sheik threatened to disqualify himself if the fans maintained their chants of “USA! USA!”. The fans could be forgiven. The show on which the match was promoted, Heroes Of Wrestling, was the most stupefying of all time.

After Volkoff and Luke Williams exchanged a sequence several notches below respectable, Butch Miller remonstrated with the referee to set up a cheat heap double team spot. The problem was that the Iron Sheik was almost literally immobile. He had to win the Gimmick Battle Royal at WrestleMania X-Seven because he was incapable of taking a bump. He wasn't much better eighteen months prior.

He naturally took an eternity to get in the ring. Miller was forced to drag out an already one-note comedy spot when feigning to punch the ref in retaliation. His wind up punch made him look like a broken toy. It was an unflattering comparison. A broken toy would have wrestled a more athletic and exciting match.

The Sheik’s in-ring contributions were actually worse; he almost fell on his a*se exerting himself to perform something approximating a body block. He almost fell over again when attempting to deliver a kick. The mere act of lifting one foot off the ground was enough to affect his equilibrium - and yet, he was being paid to simulate athletic combat.


5. The Chamber Of Horrors Match - WCW Halloween Havoc 1991

Chamber Of Horrors
WWE.com

The Chamber of Horrors was one of those unfortunate occurrences that WCW invited upon itself with eye-bleeding frequency.

The titular “Horrors” were the weapons and assorted halloween paraphernalia enclosed in the domed cage, but the name took on a pejorative irony almost immediately when Rick Steiner picked up a chainsaw, revved it up, and carefully put it back down. It was a neat visual metaphor for the four-on-four match. The action in it was nonexistent.

The objective of it was to place a member of the opposing team in the “chair of torture”, which realistically could have referred to any seat in the arena, so ghastly was the match as a viewing experience. Masked zombies popped out of caskets, only they just looked like generic luchadors. The eight men had to narrowly work around the confined environment which created scope for nothing other than kicks, punches and tame weapon shots. The novel “Refer-eye” camera caused nausea, and again, it was fitting, if unnecessary. There was already enough idiocy to make you sick.

The electrocution switch (of course) for said chair was accidentally switched into the "on" position midway through the match, and nothing happened. At the finish, a referee was captured fixing it before Cactus Jack saw teammate Abdullah the Butcher place Rick Steiner in the chair of torture. He didn't think to give it a second glance, as if electrocuting and ostensibly murdering your buddy is something you just leave to chance.

Steiner reversed Abdullah's attempt, put him in the chair, and that was it. Pyro was set off presumably to symbolise Abdullah's death. He came back to life within seconds.


4. Daniel Bryan Vs. Sheamus - WWE WrestleMania XXVIII

Daniel Bryan Sheamus WrestleMania 28
WWE.com

Daniel Bryan was incredibly over in late 2011/early 2012. His self-congratulatory chants of "Yes! Yes! Yes!", borrowed from UFC fighter Diego Sanchez's pre-fight pysch-up routine, were a hit of audience interaction and character development. They captured perfectly his oblivious chancer persona.

None of that mattered. He might have gotten himself over, but he wasn't the man WWE wanted to get over. WWE's tone deaf way of doing that was to depict Sheamus as a chancer, by having him Brogue Kick Bryan when he was distracted by valet AJ Lee's kiss at WrestleMania XXVIII. The sham was meant to create a 'Mania moment, to get Sheamus' finish over, but it backfired spectacularly. WWE achieved the exact opposite of what was intended.

Bryan emerged with even more fierce crowd support, whereas Sheamus struggled to live up to his top face billing. That he was booked as a bully and an opportunist did not help his cause. It exists in hindsight as the most fitting symbol of the company's detachment from the wants of its audience. It's ironic; the match was meant to elevate Sheamus, but it stigmatised him forever. He is known as the man who did not deserve what was handed to him too quickly. That perception exists to this day.

What's even more ironic is that Sheamus doesn't deserve that. He's a talented, consistent and very credible performer - albeit a victim of circumstance.


3. Trish Stratus & Bradshaw Vs. Chris Nowinski & Jackie Gayda - WWE RAW

Gayda Stratus
WWE Network

Known in the immediate aftermath as "That Jackie Gayda match," Trish Stratus & Bradshaw Vs. Chris Nowinski & Jackie Gayda was a total trainwreck - a business-exposing botch festival.

"They're green, as they" said Jim Ross on commentary. No sh*t. Nowinski and Gayda were fresh off Tough Enough and really had no business being on national television. That might be a slight on Nowinski: his exchanges with Bradshaw were more than passable. He sold well enough and his positioning was adequate.

Gayda was the chief culprit; her sequences with Gayda were beyond abysmal. They weren't a complete shambles initially. Gayda managed to sell a dropkick as if she was on the same continent as her opponent. Stratus then picked her up and tried to deliver a forearm, but Gayda reacted with such a delay it was as if Stratus had delivered the move on SmackDown. Stratus then tried to vault over the ropes, presumably to sell for a back body drop, but Gayda was nowhere to be seen. They then collapsed in a heap on the mat. You can watch it back ten times and still have no clue whatsoever as to what Gayda was thinking, but it's a pointless exercise. She didn't either.

"And mercifully, it's over," said Ross at the conclusion, which saw Gayda again exist in a completely different time zone to Stratus. As Stratus dove from the top rope, to deliver a bulldog, Gayda took a full second to collapse in a heap. Her arms still flailed helplessly as Stratus struck the mat.


2. Sting Vs. Jeff Hardy - TNA Victory Road 2011

Sting, Jeff Hardy
ImpactWrestling.com

Sting Vs. Jeff Hardy promised much and posed an interesting question. How would the two men mesh what was a seemingly dissonant clash of styles? It never was answered.

As Jeff's music struck, the camera hovered around the stage before panning out. Hardy took an age to emerge, and the reason behind the delay soon became apparent. His walk to the ring was subdued, shaky. He just stopped short of falling off the ring steps after a wobbly ascent.

Sting made his appearance, and the contrast between the two men was shocking. The much older Champion paced around the ring with far more poise and guile. It became apparent then that something definitely was off. Jeff's personal demons had engulfed him once more. At that point Eric Bischoff ran to the ring and relayed revised instructions to Jeff - something along the lines of stay down. It mustn't have registered with him, which under the circumstances is no real surprise. Jeff then stalled, threatening to throw his balled up t-shirt in the ring. When the bell rang, an incensed Sting punched Hardy twice and drilled him with the Scorpion Death Drop. Hardy tried to kick out, but Sting held him down for the three count.

As he exited the IMPACT Zone, Sting responded to the loud cries of "Bullsh*t!" with a firm "I agree". That Jeff Hardy was even allowed to go out there is an indictment of TNA as a wrestling organisation - or a company, full stop.

The ending was a happy one. Jeff's disgraceful actions served as a wake up call to him. To date, there has not been a repeat of the debacle.


1. Booker T Vs. Buff Bagwell - WWF RAW July 2, 2001

Booker T Buff Bagwell
WWE.com

The overriding perception - that the WWF fans were going to reject anything cloaked in WCW iconography - was rooted in truth. They for years had been conditioned to accept WCW as a lowly and derivative bush league. But some fans held WCW signs aloft. The appearance of the company logo on the titantron drew a pop.

The WWF took a half-a*sed and thrifty approach approach to recruitment, but went all in on the presentation of this WCW showcase bout, at least. WCW mainstays Scott Hudson and Arn Anderson were despatched to the ring for commentary duties. The ring curtain was changed to bear the WCW slogan, even if it was the WWF's new version of it. Buff Bagwell later suggested that the match was intentionally sandbagged - and he might have a point. It was as if the muted response had lulled him and Booker T into a fall sense of security before the opening bell rang. As soon as it did, the boos followed. Chants of "Boring!" boomed around the arena. If the match was any good, they might have turned it around.

It wasn't. The atmosphere grew yet more toxic. Many fans left. Those who remained witnessed an abomination, one which the increasing volatility could not have helped. Bagwell's positioning was all over the place. His confidence had been shot.

The match was as boring as it was botched - a dull exchange of basic slams and rest holds devolved into farce as Bagwell both bumped for and avoided Booker T's dropkick towards the finish.

Hilariously, it was at that point Norton decided to proclaim the match "the very best WCW had to offer."


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!