10 Most INFURIATING Wrestling Narratives

The 1-2-3 Kid was the best. The best.

X Pac Heat Thumb
WWE

A narrative, in this context, is a collective opinion formed through consensus.

Since wrestling fans are not as dumb as WWE believes them to be—in case you missed what just happened, here it is again, and Michael Cole is here to guide you across the road because those big lorry things aren’t to play with, they will hurt you—the broader narrative paints a true enough picture of this worked industry. The British Bulldog is possibly the best pro wrestler ever who wasn’t capable of carrying an opponent. Fair. Bret Hart was a wrestling genius, even if he took himself that bit too seriously. Fair. Shawn Michaels was a wrestling genius, even if he was a bit of a c*nt.

Fair.

We are are a reasonable lot, aren’t we, when we’re not ceaselessly imposing our fantasy booking scenarios onto WWE and crying in rage when the company instead opts to take on the suggestions of a promoter who has drawn in mega stadium-sized crowds at WrestleMania for the last 13 years. Sometimes, however, the same wrestling fans who chant DUH CM PUNK at storyline developments they don’t like, yet cheer IRL panto villain Vince McMahon whenever he returns to screens don’t have the best collective takes, oddly enough.

Sh*t prevails that should not prevail.

This list collects those meconium narratives, and aims to scrape them from the bowl.

10. X-Pac Heat

123 kid
WWE.com

The phenomenon of 'X-Pac Heat' isn't just ancient or inaccurate.

It's an insult.

X-Pac's star faded throughout the Attitude Era because the trendy in-ring norm had little use for his genius. In the broader, brawling-heavy environment to which he returned, X-Pac, slight in frame, didn't feel much like a threat in opposition to the massive punchers. And, when the working midcard roster improved considerably around him, those he paved the way for dated his style with their cultural and athletic update on it. All of this, combined with a puerile jock comedy shtick the irreverence of a Kurt Angle rendered old hat, too, made Pac something of a relic—and thus the prevailing ‘X-Pac Heat’ narrative was born.

And it is bullsh*t, for the 1-2-3 Kid was an outstanding, influential and important performer. Watch his match with Owen Hart—not even the famous one—on the August 15, 1994 RAW. He bumped like a bullet for Owen throughout a full-on ripper, complementing Owen’s nascent singles act as something truly formidable in itself, and not just jumped-up little sh*t foil for his brotherly rival.

The Kid enhanced all of your brilliant childhood favourites, and yet, too many wrestling fans have forgotten just how superb he was, tossing about the phrase far too casually, not aware, perhaps, that it shapes his legacy.

It’s Baron Corbin Heat. Baron Corbin was never the 1-2-3 Kid.


9. Push Cesaro

cesaro ricochet
WWE.com

Cesaro is amazing. Of course he is.

On this week’s RAW, he excelled in an impossible situation; Ricochet looked like a bit of a thicket issuing a challenge to him on Monday, with his bad back helpfully put over with a massive bandage, but the sheer height at which Cesaro threw him powerfully, majestically into the air made for exciting action in spite of the b*llocks scripting.

It’s not just Cesaro. “Push X Workrate Guy” is an impossible projection.

Vince McMahon doesn’t push pure wrestlers because he literally does not run a wrestling company; he runs a sports entertainment conglomerate that favours the performers he considers TV stars. The tall, smug, eloquent Baron Corbin; the expressive and beautiful Alexa Bliss; the fundamentally shocking but hugely charismatic Miz: broadly, WWE insists on “cosmetically pleasing” talkers, because literally every opening 20 minute segment requires talking, and that’s something a Cedric Alexander can’t do.

If a talent can’t waffle on for minutes on end, they are f*cked, and so are you, if you watch WWE expecting them to “finally do something” with a Killian Dain. Doesn’t matter that Alexander is an unreal athlete, or that Dain looks so gloriously capable of ripping the weak to shreds.

They cannot do 20 minute opening verbal segments. Literally every episode of WWE TV begins with a 20 minute opening verbal segment. It is kind of impossible to watch every episode of WWE TV and still think they should and might push a guy who can’t much talk…

…throughout a 20 minute opening segment, the same 20 minute opening segment of RAW that opens, every time, with a 20 minute opening segment.


8. It's Not The Writers' Fault

natayla promo
WWE.com

So many editorials and think-pieces taking aim at WWE’s woeful and chaotic recent output might as well run for just the two words: Because Vince. Or maybe three: “Because Vince, pal!”

But that joke is wearing as thin as his patience for the ideas he conceived of 10 minutes ago, and there is very little click-based advertisement revenue in it.

It’s also not entirely accurate.

No writer could possibly hope to thread together Vince’s flailing narrative, which is as old and as childish and as shattered as Humpty Dumpty, which, incidentally is the nickname he will bestow upon the horny and stout Otis on next week’s RAW, before writing him out of the show eight minutes into the opening segment.

Week-to-week WWE TV is incomprehensible and fake, but it is also deeply lame, something for which the writers must be held to account. Vince doesn’t write the copy word for word—he’s too busy doing exactly that with commentary—and so it is their fault. Relentlessly sh*tty patter like ‘Ken Dostick’ and ‘Hey-where’d-you-get-that-outfit-TGI Fridays?’ and ‘OK-I-go/No, glow!’ is the fault of the failed sitcom hacks littering that writer’s room.

It’s not David Mamet in there getting a b*llocking off Vince.


7. [Wrestler X] Was Actually Really Good

Mark Henry 1999 European Champion
WWE.com

Mark Henry wrestled for WWE over a span of 21 years.

Across three of those years, he got it. A terrifying colossus throughout his Hall Of Pain run, Henry’s awesome update on the monster archetype informed his legacy forever. The guy who once shagged Mae Young became, through his guttural roars and thudding ring work, the intense wrecking machine Vince McMahon paid so much money for.

And, in wearing a goofy salmon jacket during his seminal faux-retirement speech, he literally added shades of nuance to his act, using his cuddly bear reputation to snatch our expectations from the stream and rip them to shreds.

Mark Henry was really good…

…for 14.29% of the time.

The years everybody has suppressed - because bland workrate guys are now unfashionable - still happened. Henry didn’t evolve from comedy act to injury-prone to belated, matured investment; for years, a man built to be a credible destroyer often betrayed that aura to a literal extent in lumbering, error-strewn performances.

And now, because hoss battles are in, Henry has become something approaching a great. Honestly, they’ll tell you that Austin Aries was tall in five years. Mark Henry is also a wonderful and inspiring man, which helps shape his career legacy.

So is X-Pac.

You worm-sucking idiots.


6. [Wrestler X] Can Bring Prestige Back To The Intercontinental Title

Luke Harper Intercontinental Championship
wwe.com

The Intercontinental Title and the long-time WWE fan share a special relationship.

As beautiful a belt as the legendary matches that contested for it, those fans came of age when watching Savage Vs. Steamboat, Hart Vs. Perfect, Michaels Vs. Razor—genuine, immortal classics that doubled as a generation’s pure education throughout their pro wrestling adolescence.

That relationship is now toxic.

Where we yearn for the days where it meant something, Vince isn’t particularly fussed about our beloved concepts of sublime wrestling and mapping the trajectory of prospective headliners that we really care for—and if he did, Baron Corbin probably wouldn’t appear on a third of Monday Night RAW every single f*cking week. Nobody is going to bring prestige back to the Intercontinental Title; it’s copy-and-paste scripted promo material. Luke Harper is a former holder, and he can’t even do a southern accent. And yet, many people continue to project this sentiment onto a company that isn’t particularly sentimental.

“Who died, again? Oh. Did they enjoy a kinship with unapologetic racist Hulk Hogan, thus allowing us to bring him back? No? Memorial graphic. Unless I don’t care on a given day.”


5. Older Wrestling Looked More Realistic

Ric Flair Flop
WWE

It’s all flips and gymnastics and no-selling now, isn’t it?

Stupid vanilla midgets doing acrobatics in the Tokyo Dome for the express purpose of inseminating their critical cache with that massive mark Dave Meltzer’s fanboy milk. It’s pathetic. Five star matches ruined wrestling. It isn’t like it was in the 1980s, when everything looked real.

1980s wrestling was so awesome, subjectively and critically and in terms of its mainstream pull, but it didn’t look more realistic. If anything, the flailing arms, jelly-legged selling beloved of the heels looks fairly comical viewed through a 2019 lens. The old ten punches to the head spot was very effective for its time, since the fandom at largely legitimately despised the villains, but now, it looks a bit silly and very, very painful. They are getting the brains beaten out of their skull, which theoretically should hurt more than a padded kick to the wide surface area of the back.

The Irish whip automatically disqualifies any pro wrestling from realism, and while selling was perhaps more pronounced within that long-forgotten context, the style of it, broadly, no longer looks authentic.

People go on like JCP and Mid-South were W*ING.


4. Brock Lesnar Is Bad For WWE

Brock Lesnar Holds Onto The Briefcase All Year
WWE.com

Brock Lesnar is symptom.

This narrative has reappeared in the wake of his Money In The Bank cash-in, as if the Beast Incarnate is Vince McMahon’s Cersei Lannister. He could fundamentally change, if it weren’t for his stupid sexy beetroot sister, into whose arms he runs away from patient, coherent long-term storytelling and a product not riddled with fake, fake bullsh*t.

The Universal Championship match at Money In The Bank really was incredible, but the TV was decidedly not. Seth Rollins and AJ Styles traded the same workrate guy barbs at each other within prehistoric tropes, and it didn’t matter, because the pre-scripted soundbites made for a compelling enough video package on the night. Brock Lesnar’s absence did not create the opening for a truly compelling feud between two top stars because Brock Lesnar isn’t a glass ceiling unto himself.

Brock Lesnar is a performer who in the last six months has entered three quality stints in matches and quasi-matches that enhanced his opponents. WWE squandered any momentum Finn Bálor may have built following the Royal Rumble by putting the heat on Bobby Lashley the very next night with no comeback. Lesnar is the über-heel, onscreen and off, but WWE is inherently focused on heels and heat spots and rest holds.

Lesnar is simply the top heel of a heel territory.


3. You Should Stop Watching If You Hate It So Much

Mick Foley, 24/7 Title, Monday Night Raw
WWE

This one is trotted on out article comment hosting services the Internet over, often if somebody dares express a criticism. Just stop watching. Do something else with your life.

No?

Part of the perverse appeal of WWE, particularly now, is to view it as if trapped by the evil scientists of Mystery Science Theatre 3000 and riff on the bullsh*t to stave off total insanity. You are not trapped, of course, but you sort of are, by the constant promise of Fascinating Bullsh*t and other non-traditional pleasures equivalent to ripping one’s arm hairs from the skin. Some people simply skew masochistic.

Besides which, those Disqus add-ons and SquaredCircle threads are places in which to engage with the community and or scream, cathartically, into the void. It’s nice to be a part of something, even if that something calls you a c*nt.

It’s routine. It’s the fear of missing out. It’s sometimes even really quite good.

Some people just have this as a kink. Some people enjoy and are free to enjoy harmlessly hate-watching WWE TV (the pay-per-views are often very good) because their spirit animal is George Costanza, and actively being miserable is simply an ingrained personality trait that does not overtly hurt anybody else.

This is not specific.


2. PG WWE Sucks

savage cobra
wwe

Otherwise known, in YouTube comment sections everywhere, as BRING BACK TEH ATTITUDE ERA.

WWE was better back in the day because of the t*ts and the blood and the swearing and the hot broads, obviously, but the thing is, the Ruthless Aggression Era traded in more of the same, and the company’s popularity waned. The charm just wasn’t there; yes, there were scantily-clad women in there being “sexy”, which they don’t do anymore because the SJWs won’t allow it those cucks—but Vince McMahon mostly had his tongue halfway down their oesophagus, and it was all rather unpleasant. 2002’s Katie Vick business didn’t get numbers. They should “bring back” stuff that actually got over, no?

And isn’t it funny that an army of ripped, red-blooded men’s men exist out there, and they choose to spend their time trawling through pirated WWE vids from years and years ago?

The Golden Era of the WWF was rated PG. Killer snakes paralysing heroes with venom and fear; reprehensible betrayals in the barber shop; the palpable, proper grown-up drama of the Mega Powers explosion: all of these legendary moments transpired without so much as a protest from conservative America.


1. Competition Will Magically Make WWE Better

Vince McMahon
WWE

Matt Riddle is the latest wrestler to welcome the arrival of a AEW under the belief that it will magically improve WWE. He was probably high, so must be given the benefit of the doubt, and this take in general is unleashed in a warm haze of half-remembrance. The WWF was better when WCW pushed back, people recall, as if the last 20 years haven’t fundamentally changed everything.

Think of WWE as a house with mould on the walls—the mould of 50/50 booking and over-production and assorted other total nonsense.

You remove mould by bleaching that sh*t with elbow grease. You don’t just paint over it, with dropped recent weekly exercises in T&A segments, NXT call-ups, more NXT call-ups, more NXT call-ups, a Superstar Shake-Up, an ongoing Superstar Shake-up, a permanent Superstar Shake-Up, a whacky new 24/7 Championship, or the genius move of…dimming down the arena lighting system because that’s what RAW once looked a bit like when it was popular.

The wall is f*cked. WWE needs a new wall.

For a more in-depth take on this fallacy, please read this recent editorial on the subject.


In this post: 
x pac
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!