10 Most Repeated WWE Storylines

Stop me if you've heard this one before.

Austin McMahon Gun
Tumblr

Every story has already been told. Even the most exceptional writers lean on seven archetypal stories, recycling the same basic plots that define literature from today all the way back to ancient Greece. If our most talented storytellers fall back on similar narratives, where do you think that leaves WWE? Let's face it. Nobody's winning a Nobel Prize for this stuff.

And it's not entirely creative's fault. When you're responsible for producing thousands of hours worth of television a year, not every idea's bound to come out a winner. Yet that kind of sheer volume only provides so much of an excuse.

Even with that in mind, WWE still relies on formulaic storytelling to push feuds forward. Regardless of the stylistic and tonal shifts from the Golden Age to New Generation and Attitude Era, WWE has always clung to the same tried and tested storylines.

They might've dressed or sexed them up for a new era of fans, but the end result was all too familiar. And no, it wasn't your mind playing tricks on you, although after years of watching WWE tread water, you might wish it had. Whether they showcase patriotism, inner turmoil, or lurid romance, WWE loves coming back to these stories on a regular basis...

10. Turning On The Fans

Bayley Heel Turn
WWE

Not the Bayley Buddies! Is nothing sacred?! Oh, wait. This is WWE we're talking about.

A well-executed heel turn is an opportunity to freshen up a wrestler's character and push them back up the card. Plus, give them a new haircut for good measure. That last part's important. We're here for Bayley's bob.

Although a WWE fixture for decades, the heel turn is an emotional roller coaster like no other. The WWE Universe's initial rage shifts to curiosity at hearing their once-beloved superstar's explanation for turning to the dark side. We just can't help ourselves.

Yet WWE's heels repeatedly go over the edge for the exact same reason. A perceived lack of respect from the WWE Universe has driven numerous superstars like The Rock and CM Punk to turn their backs on the very fans who made them household names. So much for gratitude. You know they paid for your house, right?

In the pantheon of heel turns, rejecting the audience is rarely a home run storyline, no matter how many times WWE brings it back. We want to sympathize with our villain's motivation but stop just short of rooting for them. Lord knows we don't ask for much.

And hearing some entitled superstar with an Adonis physique moan about not getting enough love from the fans doesn't exactly make for a riveting storyline. Self-love is the best love, after all.


9. Corrupt Officiating

Cm Punk Wwe Ref Brad Maddox
WWE.com

Never trust a man in stripes. Especially when he's a WWE official.

Although the role of a referee calls for strict impartiality, WWE loves turning this idea on its head by thrusting corrupt officials into the company's major storylines. Because it's not like there's another wrestler out there who could use the TV time. No way Jose.

WWE's Golden Age featured memorable angles involving 'Dangerous' Danny Davis and Earl Hebner helping their heel allies secure tainted victories and championship gold. In the case of Davis, he dined out on his fallen referee status for years, winning a six-man tag team match with the Hart Foundation at WrestleMania III and advancing to the 1987 King of the Ring semi-finals. Half the roster would kill for a push like that today.

But Davis and Hebner's successful angles set a dangerous precedent for WWE, prompting the company to continually rehash the corrupt official storyline, much to the audience's dismay.

Rather than a vehicle for intrigue or suspense, the concept of the corrupt official has become WWE's poor booking fail-safe. Don't want your undefeated monster losing clean to your merchandise-pushing world champion? Easy. Have the referee nail your monster square in the !*$%. Problem solved?

And modern examples like Nick Patrick favouring The Alliance and Brad Maddox low blowing Ryback prove WWE is only going to keep revisiting this storyline for years to come. Heaven help us.


8. Passing The Torch

The Rock Hulk Hogan
WWE

Nobody can stay at the top forever. In fact, one of WWE's sacred traditions and most overutilized storylines is the passing of the torch, where the company's rising superstar defeats an established veteran for the keys to the kingdom.

It's usually a surefire recipe for success, so long as your red hot babyface's shine doesn't fade with the WWE Universe. Fame is a cruel mistress.

When done well, the end result is an emotional spectacle that solidifies an act poised for wrestling immortality. These moments live forever. Thankfully, even WWE gets this storyline right once in a while.

Jim Ross declaring "the Austin era has begun" at WrestleMania XIV indicated the magnitude of Stone Cold's first world title reign. And despite a frenzied crowd's yearning for Hulkamania, Hogan's clean loss at WrestleMania X8 cemented The Rock among WWE's all-time greats. They passed the absolute hell out of that torch.

But when mishandled, WWE gives the reins to someone who just isn't ready for the responsibility of carrying the company's weight on his back. Ultimate Warrior and Roman Reigns: this Bud's for you.

And more often than not, this kind of fumbling leaves WWE scrambling to re-establish its defeated legend as top dog. Surely, Hogan's numerous post-WrestleMania VI championship victories can speak to that. Boy, did those suck.


7. Family Drama

Linda McMahon Does Something Good
WWE

We don't get to choose our family. For better or for worse, we're stuck with them, and it's not as if Vince McMahon has any problem pitting family members against each other. He's practically made a career out of it. But this story doesn't start with him. For once.

WWE leaned hard into sibling rivalry when brothers Owen and Bret Hart engaged in a landmark 1994 storyline that saw them trade victories at WrestleMania X and SummerSlam. Built around a jealous Owen trying to escape his older brother's shadow, their matches relied on simple storytelling and an incredible workrate, not sensationalized drama.

Yet Owen and Bret's feud paled in comparison to the epic battles between the McMahon family or Undertaker and Kane during the Attitude Era. From crucifixions and higher powers to corporate buyouts and street fights, each McMahon family reunion was bloodier than the next.

Although bordering on the absurd, the McMahon family's defining moments made for addictive television. Surely, we can all remember our stomachs turning as Vince kissed Trish Stratus in front of his catatonic wife. Our eyes said no, our fingers couldn't change the channel.

Is it any wonder this storyline still has legs after so many years? It's easy to forgive our parents' misdeeds after watching WWE tackle family drama. Give your dad a break. At least he didn't sacrifice you to The Undertaker.


6. Adultery

Lita Edge Sexy
WWE.com

WWE is hardly known for depicting healthy relationships: like a stereotypical Hollywood love story, most WWE romances burn out in tumultuous fashion.

Instead of presenting mature, amicable breakups, WWE routinely torpedoes on-screen relationships through jealous rages and acts of infidelity, real or imagined. Maybe it's better to burn out than fade away?

Made famous by the seminal feud between Hulk Hogan and "Macho Man" Randy Savage over Miss Elizabeth, this is an evergreen WWE enjoys coming back to with sickening glee.

Whether exploiting the real-life drama between Matt Hardy and Edge or showcasing AJ lee betraying John Cena, WWE loves mocking the notion of a happy couple riding off into the sunset. What do you think this is, a fairy tale? Yet that's exactly why we love it.

Part of this storyline's ongoing appeal is the absolute train wreck of watching two star-crossed lovers fall apart like an episode of The Jerry Springer Show. Add a dash of adultery to the mix? Now you're cooking with real heat!

Being cheated on is bad enough, but when your supposed partner's two-timing plays out publicly on live television? That's cold. There's no wishing them well in their future endeavours when that angle plays out.


5. The Undefeated Streak

WWE Survivor Series 2015 Ryback
WWE.com

All right, who's next? Yes, welcome to the undefeated streak, where lazy booking meets tunnel vision. So lazy, in fact, that the undefeated streak has become one of wrestling's most common storylines. It's also one destined to fail, at least in the fickle hands of WWE Creative.

Picture this. An irresistible force or immovable object (take your pick) tears through the WWE locker room, racking up an impressive series of wins and perhaps even winning a major title. What could possibly go wrong? Better clear your schedule, we're gonna be here for a while.

Although a basic way of pushing a WWE superstar, the undefeated streak inevitably paints itself into a corner. The bitter taste of that first loss, while a potentially character-defining moment with the right booking, leads to swift burial in whatever passes for the WWE writer's room.

Mr. Perfect, Tatanka, and Ryback all boasted impressive undefeated streaks that teased the possibility of world title glory, yet they never fully recovered from defeat.

Even ignoring this poor booking pattern, the undefeated streak makes for a dull storyline we've already seen countless times. Avoiding a pin does not an enduring character make. Repeat that one, kids.

Forget a Shooting Star Press: coming down from the euphoric throes of victory without destroying one's push is the ultimate high spot. Just ask Braun Strowman or Asuka. Look out below!


4. The Invasion

nwo Titantron
wwe.com

It's an idea that always sounds good on paper. When a hot new faction arrives in WWE like Bray Wyatt's house on fire, riding roughshod over the entire locker room, we're bound to get our hopes up.

Yet through sloppy booking or a string of sobering defeats, these once-proud stables lose their dominant edge and gradually fade into oblivion. The Alliance, nWo, and The Nexus all arrived with plenty of intrigue and promise but suffered similar fates.

The major problem with an invasion angle is WWE never seems prepared to go all the way with it. After all, an invasion only poses a real threat is there's a genuine prospect of WWE being taken over and given Vince McMahon's love of humiliating his competition, there was no chance in hell of that happening, at least where The Alliance and nWo was concerned.

Further diluting any invasion angle is WWE's tendency to drag this kind of storyline out as long as possible, even when the end result is already clear.

Nobody could take The Nexus seriously after watching John Cena emasculate its entire membership ad nauseam. Stop adjusting their attitudes, John. They're already dead.

Rather than build to a dramatic payoff, WWE often prefers to let this oft-repeated storyline fizzle out like a bad romance. New Nexus and The Corre? How can we put this? Maybe it's time we see other stables.


3. Battles With Authority

Vince McMahon Higher Power Reveal
WWE Network

A little conflict with your boss is perfectly normal. Pointing a gun and assaulting them in a hospital? Not so much.

Almost from the company's inception, WWE has relied on the persona of an on-screen authority figure to generate tension with rank and file wrestlers.

Although earlier executives like Jack Tunney and Gorilla Monsoon played the role more or less down the middle, the concept of the authority figure in WWE took off in the aftermath of the Montreal Screwjob.

Seizing on the indignation of Bret Hart fans, Vince McMahon embraced his more sinister nature, becoming a corrupt caricature of himself who sought to rule his company with an iron fist.

This set the stage for an epic feud with Stone Cold Steve Austin that became the template for a litany of future babyface vs. authority storylines in the years that followed. Whether CM Punk taking on John Laurinaitis or Daniel Bryan battling The Authority, WWE loves going back to the well on this one.

Despite almost constant repetition, what makes this storyline so compelling is the emotional satisfaction of watching an underdog overcome the odds. Who doesn't relate to the idea of management holding them back? Nobody wants to root for a millionaire. We'd rather see them eat a Stone Cold Stunner or GTS - every day for the rest of their lives. Take this job and shove it!


2. Tag Team Implosion

Shawn Michaels Marty Jannetty Barbershop
WWE.com

No tag team is long for this world, no matter how much we love them. Whether owing to one member's rise to singles glory or just to shake things up, almost all WWE tag teams are destined to implode in a chorus of chair shots and superkicks. Long may it continue.

When a tag team reaches the end of the road, it's usually cause for excitement, so long as their breakup culminates in a dramatic meltdown worthy of a trashy soap opera or talk show. Throw in a good table spot and even better.

The tragic demise of Edge and Christian and The Rockers was made up for with compelling storytelling that produced some of WWE's most iconic moments. Who can ever forget Shawn Michaels tossing Marty Jannetty through the Barber Shop window? That one still hurts. You can feel it in your knees on a rainy day.

Although it's a moment WWE has since emulated countless times, the shock of watching an endearing team fall apart never gets old, at least when the story lands. Kevin Owens attacking Chris Jericho during the Festival of Friendship and Seth Rollins turning on The Shield confirmed there's plenty of mileage left in the tank with this storyline.

Just don't haunt us with the image of a dejected Jericho asking Owens why his name was on the list. Our hearts can't take it.


1. Defending The Flag

Hulk Hogan America
WWE

It's a story as old as time. An anti-American villain with a valid passport arrives on US shores. They manage to cross the border despite numerous red flags. Customs and immigration, do your bloody job!

Our heel's objective is simple: teach those allegedly lazy, slack-jawed Americans a lesson at their very own game. The pro wrestling game - because that makes sense.

And what could possibly be more humiliating than an American losing a wrestling match to a foreign foe? Exploiting the audience's latent xenophobia aside, the only problem is it never works.

Despite the heel's best efforts, America's indomitable spirit always prevails, leaving our villain soundly defeated. USA! USA! Next time save yourself the trip and stay home, pal.

That's right, WWE loves pitting a patriotic babyface against the latest heel determined to tread all over the American flag. Hulk Hogan's legendary battles with the Iron Sheik and Sgt. Slaughter allowed WWE a chance to turn the screws on whatever country happened to find itself on the wrong side of American foreign policy. In this case, Iran and Iraq.

Hulkamania's just the tip of the iceberg. From "Hacksaw" Jim Duggan and Lex Luger to Kurt Angle and John Cena, WWE repeatedly associates some of the company's biggest babyfaces with the Stars and Stripes. They defend the flag so the WWE Universe doesn't have to. God bless!


In this post: 
WWE
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Investigator and writer based in Vancouver, Canada. Fond of history, professional wrestling, and rock hubris. Once co-directed a Star Trek fan film with a budget of less than $200.