10 Most Soul-Destroying WrestleMania Moments

Goldberg vs. Brock Lesnar became one of 'Mania's most pointless matches...

WWE Hall of Famer Bret
Ric Scuteri/AP

"The boyhood dream has come true", gushed Vince McMahon as Shawn Michaels defeated Bret Hart to become the new WWF Heavyweight Champion. The match-concluding 'Sweet Chin Music' at WrestleMania XII has been played time and time again, and for good reason; it was an extremely heartfelt moment.

In similar fashion, seeing genuine tears roll down the cheeks of both Chris Benoit and Eddie Guerrero at the close of WrestleMania XX was seriously emotional. Fans couldn't help but join in, recognising the hard work and sacrifice the pair had consistently made to get to that point.

Moments such as those outlined above are undoubtedly ones consumed by sheer, unadulterated joy. When these moments occur, fans can't help but punch the air in delight. Unfortunately, WrestleMania has also been home to moments after which those same fans want to punch holes in the nearest wall out of frustration.

The overwhelming letdown caused by the moments featured on this list cannot be forgotten. They were soul-destroying for different reasons - perhaps wrestling fans were disappointed in the company itself for select creative decisions, or maybe a big match just fell flat and left everyone deflated as a result - but soul-destroying nonetheless. 

WrestleMania is the grandest stage WWE can provide, but that only makes the disappointment even bigger when things go wrong.

10. Vince McMahon Takes Potshots At WCW (WrestleMania XII)

890022

In the mid-1990's, Vince McMahon put a lot of emphasis on the idea of the 'New WWF Generation'. The idea was simple, to make the WWF look cutting edge and youthful. Meanwhile, over in the retirement home known as WCW, guys McMahon had created like Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage were embarrassing themselves.

That was the general idea of the 'Billionaire Ted' skits, but they backfired terribly on the WWF. Contrary to what fans of the company were being told, neither Hogan nor Savage could be called past their prime with any real accuracy. Things all came to a head at WrestleMania XII.

On the WWF's grandest stage, the 'Free For All' portion of the broadcast featured a 'match' between 'The Huckster' and 'Nacho Man'. Played by actors, both were portrayed as relics the WWF no longer needed. It wasn't nice to see the promotion take potshots at stars who had helped build the company by breaking their backs. 

Further to this, Roddy Piper, The Ultimate Warrior and Jake 'The Snake' Roberts were all on the 'Mania card, discrediting the youth movement message that McMahon was trying to promote.


9. The Undertaker Hangs The Big Boss Man (WrestleMania XV)

Big Boss Man
WWE.com

Generally speaking, WWE usually attempt to stay away from the concept of death. Obviously, the idea comes with extreme finality, and it's also an incredibly sensitive subject. Looking at things another way, the company presents a TV show no different to the rules that govern others, so fatalities aren't out of the question entirely.

That said, they are treated with disdain by fans when handled badly. At WrestleMania XV, The Big Boss Man was set to face The Undertaker in a Hell In A Cell match. Fans had been conditioned to expect something memorable from the stipulation, but they were left with a sour taste in their mouths following this one.

Firstly, the match itself was pretty !*$% poor for the most part. For the lasting image after the matches conclusion, the promotion chose to have 'Taker hang Boss Man from the top of the structure, before having it rise up into the rafters. 

This was quite the ill-conceived idea.

People like to lose themselves in the moment when tuning into WWE programming, and certainly don't want to see people hanged. Making a mockery of the concept even further, Boss Man later returned to TV, as if nothing had happened.


8. Hulk Hogan Squashes Yokozuna (WrestleMania IX)

Hulk Hogan WrestleMania IX
WWE.com

As early as 1992, Vince McMahon was already dabbling with elements of what would become known as the 'New WWF Generation'. Smaller, more athletic stars like Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart were being championed, succeeding the more typical main event styles of musclebound guys like Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior.

It was said that the days of the giants had come and gone, and the WWF began favouring a more wrestling-centric product in main events. McMahon quite quickly changed his mind, largely due to the comeback of Mr. Nanny himself.

Months before WrestleMania IX, Bret Hart had been installed as the new WWF Heavyweight Champion. Fans were re-energised by this idea, because Hart represented something different in top bouts. Facing Yokozuna at 'Mania IX, the feeling was that he'd still play a major role even if he lost. 

Hart did lose, but then the man who beat him promptly lost to Hulk.

Hulkamania was running wild again, but the idea had lost a lot of sheen. Instead of enthusing fans, Hogan's latest title win at WrestleMania set the company back a few steps and only helped to cause more disquiet in the locker room, too. 


7. Booker T Vs. Triple H Racism Angle Ends With Heel Victory (WrestleMania XIX)

Booker T Triple H Wrestlemania
WWE.com

Angles which deal with the subject of racism are a truly tough sell. Whereas fans appreciate bad blood between performers in a storyline context, it's genuinely difficult to incorporate unsavoury topics from real life - like war, race and religion - into things and make it work. 

That didn't stop WWE from trying in the run up to WrestleMania XIX. Admittedly, things may have worked had the organisation not completely flunked their own idea. To hype up a World Heavyweight Title bout between Booker T and Triple H, the latter assessed that "people like Booker" didn't belong in the upper echelons of wrestling.

Instantly, this came across that 'The Game' was belittling Booker because of his skin colour. It's not hard to imagine people across the world immediately getting more than a little uncomfortable at his verbiage. 

Things could have been rectified by having the babyface rally and vanquish the bigot, but that didn't happen.

Come 'Mania, Triple H handily defeated his foe. Worse, he stalled for an unnecessary amount of time post-Pedigree before he decided to pin the challenger. It was a dispiriting loss for Booker, and the race angle felt shoe-horned in and unnecessary. 


6. Steve Austin Aligns With Vince McMahon (WrestleMania X-7)

Steve Austin, Vince McMahon, WrestleMania 17
WWE.com

As soon as he felt his hand press into Vince McMahon's, Steve Austin greatly regretted what he was doing. The unthinkable had happened: 'Stone Cold' had joined forces with his most hated rival. 

Incredibly, Austin wasn't even upset as a character, he just knew it didn't feel right.

Following Austin's WWF Title match against The Rock at WrestleMania X-Seven, McMahon and his nemesis shook hands. On commentary, Jim Ross went crazy, claiming that the wrestler was shaking hands "with the devil himself". It was quite the moment, but not one to be remembered for wholly positive reasons.

Austin had turned heel, but it wasn't something he or his vast fan base could say they were particularly comfortable with. People still wanted the beer-drinking, foul-mouthed character of before, but they didn't get it for a while. 

Instead, Austin had a confusing run as an often-comedic heel, and it can all be traced back to his handshake with McMahon. WrestleMania X-Seven went off the air with controversy and intrigue, but also a lot of sunken hearts.


5. Goldberg Vs. Brock Lesnar Becomes Pointless (WrestleMania XX)

Brock Lesnar Goldberg WM 20
WWE.com

WrestleMania is  the culmination of WWE's entire year, the definite focal point for management. Dream matches are (hopefully) made, and the event should act as a springboard for the rest of the year. This was certainly a hope when Bill Goldberg faced Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania XX.

The company even positioned Steve Austin as the Special Guest Referee, helping make the match feel even bigger. Unfortunately, officials were hit with a pair of big announcements from talent right before the pay-per-view. Following 'Mania, neither Goldberg or Lesnar would be sticking around.

As soon as this became clear, the scheduled match between both men didn't feel quite as important. After all, who cared about the outcome when neither guy was going to be on Raw the next night? The impassioned Madison Square Garden crowd felt the same.

People were clearly irritated by Lesnar and Goldberg's refusal to stay with WWE. This should have been a match that helped Goldberg have a better 2004 than 2003, but his victory didn't mean a thing. 

Fans callously booed and jeered both men out of the building and the dream match turned into a nightmare. 


4. Michael Cole Vs. Jerry Lawler Goes Long (WrestleMania XXVII)

Jerry Lawler Michael Cole Steve Austin
WWE.com

On the undercard of WrestleMania XXVII, The Big Show, Kane, Kofi Kingston and Santino Marella defeated The Corre in just over 90 seconds. Later, Michael Cole toppled Jerry 'The King' Lawler in a little under 14 minutes. 

There's something wrong with that situation, because Michael Cole is (I'm sure you don't need me to tell you) not a professional wrestler.

Admittedly, his heel persona was something the announcer put a lot of effort into, but the fact he was still a commentator with no wrestling experience cannot be ignored. On the flip side, Lawler was once a fantastic in-ring performer, but he couldn't be expected to drag a non-wrestler to a decent match in 2011, certainly not with that amount of time.

Once again, WWE relied on Steve Austin to act as Special Guest Referee. If the bout had only lasted a few minutes, it could and probably would have been viewed in a more favourable light. But giving them close to 20 minutes (including entrances) of pay-per-view time just felt like too much. 

Even Cole himself later said during interviews that he was stunned by the length of time given to the pair.


3. Santino Marella Wins A Women's Battle Royal (WrestleMania XXV)

Santina Marella
WWE.com

Nowadays, WWE are peddling the idea that they are fully behind women's wrestling. The term 'revolution' has been thrown around willy nilly since the Summer of 2015, even extending a little before that thanks to the hard work of girls like Charlotte, Sasha Banks and others in NXT.

The term 'Diva' still remains, which surely discredits the concept of taking women more seriously in professional wrestling. Going back just a few years, WWE didn't give a !*$% about presenting females as serious wrestling attractions.

Conversely, they were little more than eye candy or whimsical acts to help break up the more meaningful male portions of the show.

At WrestleMania XXV, this became evident once again when Santino Marella - a man - won a women's battle royal on the show. Cast as 'Santina' Marella, the guy hurled Beth Phoenix from the ring and was declared 'Miss. WrestleMania'. 

Hopefully, 2016 is the year when WWE's women finally get the treatment they deserve at 'Mania, because this was entirely deflating. After all, if WWE cared so little about the entire female roster to let a male performer win their showcase 'Mania bout, why should fans care about the division at all?


2. Sheamus Pins Daniel Bryan In 18 Seconds (WrestleMania XXVIII)

Sheamus Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

Almost exactly a full 12 months on from Michael Cole vs. Jerry Lawler going 14 minutes, Sheamus and Daniel Bryan were handed just 18 seconds to work with. This was actually the second time both men had been left disappointed by their positioning at WrestleMania, after only working the pre-show at 'Mania XXVII. 

For 'Mania XXVIII, Bryan was defending the World Heavyweight Title against his Irish peer. One quick Brogue Kick later, he was staring at the lights and no longer the champion, Sheamus was. Fans reacted more out of shock than anything else, some hadn't even properly taken their seats before it was all over.

WrestleMania is the kind of event made for amazing in-ring workers like Daniel Bryan, so it's upsetting to think one of his appearances on the show was in such a lowly role. Effectively, Daniel Bryan was treated like a jobber on the biggest event of the year, and that can't sit well with any wrestling fans.


1. Bret Hart Destroys Vince McMahon (WrestleMania XXVI)

bret hart vince mcmahon
WWE.com

The events of the 1997 Survivor Series became known as the 'Montreal Screwjob'. It became the most controversial incidents in WWF/WWE history, one that's still commonly discussed today. It also provided the crux of a 2010 bout between Bret Hart and Vince McMahon at WrestleMania XXVI.

Fans didn't really know what to expect heading into the show, because it was well-known that Hart, due to his health, couldn't take any bumps. Therefore, the decision was made to have the Canadian cream his boss, battering him senseless with punches, kicks and stiff steel chair shots. 

At first, fans cheered, but then the whole situation just became uncomfortable to watch. Outnumbered by the rest of the Hart clan cheering on Bret from ringside, Vince looked helpless. Had such a beating happened just weeks after November 9, 1997, the reaction would have been huge.

By 2010 however, Bret was no longer a pro wrestler. It was pretty depressing to see him stumble around the ring and beat his elderly opponent mercilessly.


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.