10 Most Surprising PPV Headliners In WWE History

What do King Mabel, Ron 'The Truth' Killings, and Tatanka all have in common?

Tatanka headdress
WWE.com

In WWE, only a limited number of superstars manage to break the glass ceiling and reach main event status. As such, the list of names at the top can, at times, lack variety; inevitably, it becomes commonplace to see the same faces in the same spot year after year.

Outside of Elimination Chambers, Survivor Series matches and Royal Rumble bouts where multiple personalities clog up the ring, very few men get the honour and privilege of closing out a WWE PPV. Instead, the likes of Hulk Hogan, Steve Austin and John Cena have dominated in their respective eras and become synonymous with the PPV top spot.

Luckily, modern day WWE has seen a slew of new headliners over the course of the last couple of years. 2017 alone featured the main event debuts of Samoa Joe, Braun Strowman, and Jinder Mahal, while 2016 also saw two women main event a WWE PPV for the first time.

While unusual, these examples are by no means alone when it comes to new talent being trialled at the top of a card. In fact, there have been several anomalies that stand out in PPV main events over the years. Some are deserving, others are questionable, yet all are, at the very least, something different.

10. The Dudley Boyz - Great American Bash 2004

The Undertaker Dudley Boys 2004 Great American Bash
WWE.com

In one of the most bizarre PPV matches in the last 15 years, the main event of The Great American Bash 2004 saw The Undertaker square off with both Dudley Boyz in a handicap Concrete Crypt match.

For those wondering, a Concrete Crypt match is like any other match, except for the fact that 'Taker's manager, Paul Bearer, was perilously sat in a glass "crypt" underneath a cement funnel. If 'The Deadman' lost, Bearer would be buried beneath the cement and 'Taker wouldn't be the only dead man in the building that night.

After a typically back and forth main event, The Undertaker was victorious, pinning D-Von after the Tombstone Piledriver. Despite winning, 'Taker wound up pulling the lever himself, releasing the cement and burying his own manager alive - all the while making the entire match that preceded it completely pointless. A head-scratcher if there ever was one.

Aside from the ten-man tag at Invasion 2001, this was the first and only WWE PPV that Bubba Ray and D-Von ever headlined. However, they would return to the main event scene for ECW One Night Stand in 2005.


9. Goldust - In Your House 8

Goldust Undertaker
Uproxx

In Your House 8: Beware of Dog was one of the more interesting PPVs in WWE history. The notoriety was nothing to do with the action, matches or results, but instead because the lights went down mid-show due to a thunderstorm.

As a result, Vince McMahon made the decision to present Beware of Dog 2. Taking place two days later, the show consisted of the two matches that were successfully recorded at the original event, followed by three fresh matches recorded live.

The main event of Beware of Dog 2 was a casket match between Goldust and The Undertaker. 'The Bizarre One' and 'The Phenom' made for strange opposition indeed, while the bout itself marked the first time ever that 'Taker had challenged for the Intercontinental Championship on TV.

In a surprising turn of events, Goldust was victorious after Mankind appeared in the casket and dragged Undertaker inside with a Mandible Claw. Goldust retained his IC Title, while 'Taker went full steam ahead into the feud of the summer.

Goldust would only appear in one more PPV main event, as part of the huge ten-man tag at the Canadian Stampede the following year.


8. Cody Rhodes & Ted DiBiase - Hell In A Cell 2009

Legacy DX Hell in a Cell 2009
WWE.com

During the second coming of D-Generation X in 2006, a number of promising young superstars found themselves on the wrong end of the W column when they stepped in the ring with Triple H and Shawn Michaels.

Most notably, The Spirit Squad saw their WWE careers virtually killed altogether at the hands of the degenerates and the return of DX in 2009 raised similar worries among fans and workers alike.

Nevertheless, those fears were unfounded and their second return saw the veterans feud with Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase Jr - collectively known as The Legacy - for a number of months. With DX winning at SummerSlam and Legacy winning at Breaking Point, the feud called for a rubber match at Hell in a Cell 2009.

At just 24 and 26 respectively, Rhodes and DiBiase surprisingly headlined the PPV when they faced DX inside the Hell in a Cell structure. With great psychology, non-stop action and enough violence and high impact spots to do the cell justice, the match turned out to be one of the better cell matches of the last decade.

Despite a great showing, it was the only PPV Rhodes and DiBiase would ever headline. Should Rhodes return, it likely won't be his last.


7. Brian Lee - SummerSlam 1994

undertaker vs undertaker
WWE.com

When Brian Lee was contacted by WWF officials to be part of the main event of SummerSlam, it was likely the best news of his fledgling career. However, the revelation that he would play a faux version of The Undertaker was surely an immediate buzzkill.

Nevertheless, Lee took the gig and Brian Lee became The Undertaker's doppelganger (affectionately rechristened since as The Underfaker). A member of Ted DiBiase's Million Dollar Corporation, The Underfaker was DiBiase's attempt to convince the world that he had secured the services of the absent Undertaker - proving, once again, that everyone has a price.

The angle led directly to the SummerSlam main event and saw Lee square off with the real Undertaker. In what was sadly a disappointing climax to the angle, 'Taker pinned Lee after several Tombstone Piledrivers, before Bearer's druids rolled Lee into a casket, leaving him to rest in peace.

While it was believed that Lee would continue the role as Underfaker post-SummerSlam, the storyline was dropped immediately after the event and Lee found a new home in ECW. He didn't reappear in WWF until 1997, when he returned as Chainz of the Disciples of Apocalypse stable, alongside Crush and his real-life cousins, The Harris Brothers.


6. Tatanka - King Of The Ring 1995

Bearer Undertaker Mankind SummerSlam 1996
WWE.com

By King of the Ring 1995, Tatanka had been a member of the WWF roster for over three years, had never held a championship and never headlined a PPV event.

Joining Ted DiBiase's Million Dollar Corporation in late '94, the heel Tatanka was a breath of fresh air for the character and saw the stale act receive a subtle yet notable revamp. With Bam Bam Bigelow fresh off a face turn for similar reasons, the two made a natural fit as rivals.

With Diesel and Sycho Sid already amid a feud post-WrestleMania XI, the stars aligned for a big time tag match at King of the Ring 1995 and allowed Tatanka to get a rare taste of the PPV main event scene. Meanwhile, an elbow injury to Diesel also necessitated a cover measure to help mask the ailing champ. The tag match scenario ticked all the boxes.

Sadly, the show itself featured one of the worst King of the Ring tournaments of all time, won by Mabel of Men on a Mission fame (later known as Viscera/Big Daddy V). Nevertheless, the tag presented a fresh bit of booking and saw a rare headline spot for Bigelow, as well as Tatanka's one and only PPV main event.


5. Mabel - SummerSlam 1995

diesel mabel
WWE.com

The biggest event of the calendar outside of WrestleMania, SummerSlam has long been seen as the height of WWF programming during the summer months. If that was true in '95, then the quality of programming left a lot to be desired.

While the semi-main was a huge rematch of the WrestleMania X ladder match between HBK and Razor Ramon from 18 months prior, the rest of the card seemed uninspired at best. Bret Hart beat Isaac Yankem by DQ, while elsewhere Barry Horowitz went over ten minutes with Skip. All of this, while Owen and Bulldog weren't even on the card.

The main event was a nine minute snorefest between defending champ, Diesel, and lumbering giant, King Mabel. The bout seemed more reminiscent of an In Your House main event, and actually seemed like a downgrade from Diesel's various title defences at the In Your House events that year.

Nevertheless, the main event of WWF's second biggest show of '95 was a clumsy offering, that saw Diesel legitimately hurt as a result of Mabel's reckless working style. Needless to say, Mabel never saw the main event again.

A week later, WCW Nitro launched and Eric Bischoff must have been licking his lips at the scent of blood in the water.


4. R-Truth - Capitol Punishment 2011

John Cena R Truth Capitol Punishment
WWE.com

Having turned heel at the Extreme Rules event the previous month, R-Truth was amid the biggest push of his WWE career in 2011. With a more vicious, serious and maniacal edge to his character, the character was more reminiscent of the Ron 'The Truth' Killings persona from NWA: TNA, back when he was also NWA World's Heavyweight Champion.

Sadly, the seriousness didn't last and the finish of the WWE Championship match between Cena and Truth at Capitol Punishment was a shining example of just that. Truth grabbed a drink off a "fan" with the intention of throwing it in the fan's face, only to have second thoughts. The "fan" reacted by throwing the drink back in Truth's face allowing Cena to hit the AA for the win.

Despite the emasculating manner of the loss, Truth would go on to main event one more PPV that same year. However, on that occasion, it would be as a supporting player in the on-going Cena/Rock WrestleMania feud. Teaming up with The Miz as Awesome Truth, Killings would face The Rock and John Cena in the main event of Survivor Series at MSG, in what must be considered the pinnacle of his career.


3. Zeus - SummerSlam 1989

Zeus WWE
WWE.com

In an era long before WWE Films, Vince McMahon made his first foray into the movie business with 1989's craptacular No Holds Barred. The story revolved around Hulk Hogan (essentially playing himself) in a feud against fictional wrestler, Zeus (AKA Tom 'Tiny' Lister).

To coincide with the film's theatrical release, the Zeus character transitioned from silver screen to WWF TV. With an in-ring act that consisted of a bear hug, slapping himself on the chest and generally no-selling everything, his arsenal was virtually non-existent. Nevertheless, Zeus managed to main event two different PPV events in 1989 - one of which was SummerSlam. During a time when Vince McMahon only promoted a handful of PPVs a year, that is some feat.

Teaming up with Randy Savage, Zeus took on Hogan and Brutus Beefcake at the summer spectacular; meanwhile, the bout also had a PPV rematch in the form of the No Holds Barred 'The Match/The Movie' PPV. That particular show consisted of the movie in its entirety followed by a single match, pitting Hogan and Beefcake against Savage and Zeus inside a steel cage.

Zeus would eventually follow Hogan into WCW for a brief run as Z-Gangsta. Incredibly, he would add another PPV main event to his resume at Uncensored '96.


2. Lawrence Taylor - WrestleMania XI

bam bam bigelow lawrence taylor
WWE.com

1995 was a year of transition for the WWF. Hogan and Savage were part of WCW and Vince McMahon was vehemently behind WWF's "New Generation". Despite this fact, the main event spot of WrestleMania that year didn't feature Bret, Shawn or Razor; instead, it went to the NFL's Lawrence Taylor.

A magnet for mainstream media attention, celebrity involvement in WWF programming has varied from God awful to surprisingly good - Lawrence Taylor lies somewhere in between. Luckily, his WrestleMania opponent was legendary big man, Bam Bam Bigelow.

While 'The Beast From The East' was more than deserving of the WrestleMania main event role, his opposition was completely inexperienced inside the ring. Bam Bam did a tremendous job carrying Taylor through the bout, while LT kept up his end of the bargain from an athletic standpoint - even if he was visibly blown up by the end. By no means a five star classic, it was still a lot better than many predicted.

In an interesting trivia note, LT was accompanied by several NFL personalities that night. One of those players was Steve 'Mongo' McMichael, who would go on to become part of WCW as a member of the Four Horsemen.


1. John Laurinaitis - Over The Limit 2012

Big Show John Laurinaitis Over the Limit 2012
WWE.com

By the time Over The Limit 2012 had arrived, John Laurinaitis was 49 years old and had retired from active competition 12 years earlier. Meanwhile, John Cena was 35 years old and in the prime of his career - quite the mismatch to say the least.

Nevertheless, the bout itself went over 17 minutes and consisted primarily of comedy spots, as Cena gave his superior a hefty beating. When considering that Daniel Bryan battled CM Punk for the WWE Championship on the undercard, how this match closed the show is anyone's guess.

Luckily, the bout was booked as a 'No DQ' match, which opened up the parameters considerably. As a result, the bout was better than it deserved to be, if not an interesting bit of evidence for detractors of WWE's own anti-bullying campaign.

Just when it looked like "People Power" was done for, the former Johnny Ace shocked the world. With a gigantic assist from an interfering Big Show, Laurinaitis turned the tables and defeated the future 17-time World Champion.

Who would have thought that five years later, with Cena engaged to Nikki Bella and Ace married to the Bella Twins' mother, these two combatants would be on course to become part of the same extended family?

Only in the wrestling business.


In this post: 
Tatanka
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Occasional wrestler, full-time gym rat and lifelong lover of the grapple game. Would probably buy you a shot of Jack at the bar in exchange for witty banter...and preferably more Jack. @MartynGrant88 for more wrestling-related musings and weight room wisecracks!