10 Most Underrated WWE Ruthless Agression Era Stars
Ruthless Aggression is often ruthlessly underrated in the WWE history books.
When wrestling fans think of WWE's Ruthless Aggression era, certain names immediately spring to mind: the likes of Randy Orton, Brock Lesnar, Dave Batista and, of course, John Cena. Ultimate superstars of the industry, they didn’t just break through the glass ceiling, they totally shattered it.
All would become a multi-time World Champions in WWE, leading the WWE out of the Attitude Era and into the future. However, for every Randy Orton, there’s a host of Tyson Tomkos; for every John Cena, there’re ten Rodney Macks; for every Dave Batista, there’s countless Ricos; and for every Brock Lesnar there’s a whole line of Simon Deans.
Not every wrestler can make it to the promised land of the WWE Title picture and, for some, it’s a real crime they didn’t. Whether they were a victim of circumstance, wrestling politics, or just poor decision making, there are dozens of main event worthy talents that never made it to the WWE Championship and their respective careers have since been all but forgotten by WWE.
Let’s look back at ten examples of the most criminally underrated stars of the WWE’s “Ruthless Aggression” era.
10. A-Train
With a killer look, a physically imposing build and a believable style, Matt Bloom had everything Vince McMahon could want in a monster heel.
After several failed gimmicks in the years prior, the former Prince Albert bounced back from a number of mid-card partnerships to become an imposing force in Paul Heyman’s SmackDown of 2002. The badass from Boston finally looked set for his big push in 2003.
Teaming up with Big Show and Paul Heyman, the newly christened A-Train would become a force to be reckoned with in 2003 and see Bloom have his first match on the main card of WrestleMania since 2000. Better still, he was booked opposite The Undertaker, immortalising him as one of the names on ‘Taker’s legendary WrestleMania streak.
Placed in marquee matches on SD throughout 2003, Bloom looked on course for a lengthy run as a top heel; however, he was traded to Raw the following March and suffered a torn rotator cuff that ended his WWE career at the time.
Bloom would make a name for himself as Giant Bernard in Japan in the years that followed, returning to WWE in 2012 as Lord Tensai. The gimmick, though well built prior to his arrival, soon flopped and he was back to his losing ways within months, eventually retiring in 2014.
9. Montel Vontavious Porter
Entering the WWE in 2006, MVP was presented as a big deal to the Smackdown audience upon his arrival. Immediately going into a feud with Kane, MVP got off to a successful start by defeating his larger foe on several occasions.
2007 saw MVP move his focus to gold, setting his sights on the United States title held by Chris Benoit. Benoit would help carry the newcomer to arguably some of the best matches of his WWE career, including a memorable US Title bout at WrestleMania 23. MVP would eventually win the title from Benoit at Judgement Day ‘07, before entering into perhaps his most renowned series of matches with Matt Hardy.
During the course of the feud, MVP would win the Tag Titles with Hardy as well as racking up a 343 day US Title reign that was at the time a record for the WWE version of the US Championship. He would eventually lose the belt to Hardy at Backlash ‘08 and consequently head into a dreaded “losing streak” angle that lasted six months.
MVP regained the US Title before jumping ship to Raw in April '09. His stay was largely uneventful and he moved back to SmackDown the following year, before eventually leaving WWE in late 2010 to begin a successful run in New Japan.
8. Shelton Benjamin
When Shelton Benjamin made his main roster debut in late 2002 as part of the brilliant Team Angle stable, it was clear that 2003 was going to be a big year for the newcomer.
Aligned with Angle - the WWE Champion at the time - Benjamin was teamed with Charlie Haas (eventually christened The World’s Greatest Tag Team). At the side of the champ heading into WrestleMania season, Benjamin was given the dream start to his WWE career.
The duo of Haas and Benjamin claimed the WWE Tag Team Titles within a month of debuting on the main roster and went straight into a high profile match at No Way Out that same month. The pair would continue their winning ways at WrestleMania XIX by retaining the tag team titles on the grand stage; however, they would eventually relinquish the gold at Judgment Day in May.
After another run with the tag straps, Benjamin moved to Raw and scored a huge win over Triple H. A feud with Evolution soon developed and Benjamin won the IC Title from Randy Orton shortly after. However, despite great matches, he lacked the mic skills necessary to break the main event barrier.
With three IC Titles, two Tag Team Championships and a US Title run, Benjamin left WWE in 2010 after floundering on the ECW brand.
7. Carlito
Winning the US Title in his debut match against John Cena, Carlito Colon came in to WWE with a huge amount of momentum in October 2004. However, warning signs emerged when he was quickly booked to drop the title back to Cena in less than 30 seconds, bringing to an end his one month run as US Champ.
From there, his days on Smackdown were hit and miss, prompting a switch to the Raw brand and an Intercontinental Title victory over Shelton Benjamin. His initial time on Raw in 2005 had some clear highlights, notably teaming with Kurt Angle to battle Hulk Hogan and Shawn Michaels (the infamous bout that saw HBK turn heel on Hogan), while also allowing Carlito to challenge old rival Cena for the WWE Championship.
A feud with Ric Flair would follow and a brief pairing with Chris Masters showed promise, but his WWE career would reach its final peak with his involvement in the Elimination Chamber main event of New Year’s Revolution 2006. Carlito would mainly challenge for the IC and Tag Team Titles after that, forming a successful team with his brother, Primo, before appearing mainly on third string show Superstars.
He was released in 2010 following a violation of the Wellness Policy.
6. Chris Masters
A world-class physique, a great gimmick and a natural heel, Chris Masters looked to be on course for stardom when he debuted in 2005. Despite a rocky start by breaking Stevie Richards’ nose in his very first outing, Masters was seemingly the second coming of Paul Orndorff in style and presentation.
Using the Full Nelson as his finisher, Masters renamed the classic hold as “The Masterlock”, claiming it to be unbreakable when applied by himself. This set up the introduction of the “Masterlock Challenge” - a recurring contest on Raw during which Masters would challenge fans and peers to break the hold.
Used as a vehicle to push his feuds, the challenge got Masters over as a heel in short order. Several high profile rivalries followed and saw Masters lock horns with the likes of Flair, Michaels, Angle, and Mysterio, all during his rookie year. Furthermore, he would also challenge for John Cena’s WWE Championship twice during that time.
Masters would be his own worst enemy during his WWE run, taking a leave of absence in 2006 due to a drug problem. When he returned, he had dropped a considerable amount of weight and it was all downhill from there. Masters was released in November 2007 following multiple violations of the Wellness Policy.
5. Umaga
Eddie Fatu made his TV debut in WWE as part of Eric Bischoff's bruising tag team, 3 Minute Warning. Teaming up with relative Matt Anoa’i, the Samoan duo were renamed Rosey and Jamal and made an immediate impact on Raw.
Eddie (Jamal) was released in 2003, bringing an abrupt end to the pairing; however, he would return in 2006 as the savage Umaga. With the guidance of Armando Alejandro Estrada, 'The Samoan Bulldozer' would go on to score wins over the likes of Ric Flair, DX, and Kane, leading to an undefeated streak that lasted until he was defeated by John Cena at New Year’ Revolution.
In the wake of the Cena feud, Umaga would win the Intercontinental Championship before getting the biggest push of his career. Placed in the middle of the “Battle of the Billionaires” between Vince McMahon and Donald Trump, Umaga was chosen as McMahon’s representative and set to face Bobby Lashley at WrestleMania 23.
Despite losing the match, the bout helped make the event the largest grossing WrestleMania in history at the time. Aside from challenging Triple H for the WWE Title at No Mercy, Umaga would never achieve this level of profile again, and would remain an upper mid-card attraction until his dismissal in mid-2009. He died just months later.
4. Paul London
A standout on the independent circuit, Paul London quickly made a name for himself in Ring of Honor in 2002 with his impressive aerial skills and great matches, facing off with the likes of Bryan Danielson, AJ Styles, and Samoa Joe.
As such, it didn’t take him long to get noticed by WWE and London was signed by the company in 2003. Making his mainstream debut in memorable fashion, London’s first SmackDown appearance remarkably came opposite Brock Lesnar in a bout for the WWE Championship. Not so remarkably, it would last just one minute.
After a short-lived tag team with fellow Lesnar victim, Brian Kendrick, and a brief tag title run with Billy Kidman, London received a decent push as Cruiserweight Champion. However, he was rarely given the green light to perform on the main event stage.
London would soon find himself thrown back into the tag ranks with the returning Brian Kendrick. The determined twosome would go on to make the tandem a surprising success, clocking the longest tag title reign in SmackDown history at 331 days.
While his partner would go on to greater prominence as The Brian Kendrick on SmackDown, London wasn’t so fortunate. At the very same time his partner was amid the biggest push of his career, London received his marching orders.
3. Mr. Kennedy
A gifted talker, a charismatic individual, and a good wrestler to boot, Kennedy had everything going for him when he made his main roster debut in August 2005. His insistence on announcing himself to the ring quickly him got over as an antagonistic heel. Kennedy suffered a serious lat injury in December which would keep him out of action for almost six months.
Upon his return, Kennedy picked up where he left off, accepting the challenge of Batista and making his PPV debut at The Great American Bash. Kennedy would go on to win the US Championship later that year before entering into a feud with The Undertaker, who he defeated by DQ at No Mercy.
Following the bout, Kennedy would drop the US Title to Chris Benoit on the very next SmackDown, thanks to distraction from ‘Taker, allowing Kennedy to continue to feud with 'The Deadman' in several high-profile matches for the rest of the year.
From there, Kennedy would challenge for the World Heavyweight Title a number of times and win the Money in the Bank briefcase at WrestleMania 23 along the way, before once again succumbing to injury. Kennedy would enter into one final headline feud against Shawn Michaels to close out 2007 before a largely uneventful 2008.
Kennedy was released in 2009 amid controversy after Randy Orton allegedly complained to management that he was reckless in the ring.
2. Maven
Thanks to his time on the inaugural Tough Enough competition in 2001, Maven had a pre-existing relationship with the audience by the time he debuted, making him a strong babyface character right out the gate.
Maven would go on to achieve the unthinkable at Royal Rumble 2002 when he shockingly eliminated The Undertaker from the Rumble match... before taking a colossal beating for his insolence. The elimination would lead to good things for Maven, namely a WWF Undisputed Title shot against Chris Jericho the next week.
Unsuccessful in his title challenge, Maven would miraculously go on to defeat The Undertaker for WWF Hardcore Championship a week later and defended the title at WrestleMania X8 the following month. However, Maven’s momentum stalled dramatically following his switch to SmackDown and the young superstar faded away from the spotlight for much of 2003.
Despite the setback, Maven received two more World Heavyweight Title opportunities in his WWE career, both against Triple H. His feud with Evolution in late 2004 would also see him rack up a win over Batista. Alas, he was back on job duty immediately after Survivor Series ‘04.
Relegated to Sunday Night Heat for the first half of 2005, Maven was released in July and, after appearing on a handful of house shows for TNA in 2006, has wrestled only sporadically ever since.
1. Muhammad Hassan
Possessing an athletic build, a solid main event style, and a truly heat-seeking gimmick, Muhammad Hassan seemed destined for the main event. So much so, that he would find himself sharing the ring with Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania 21, just four months after he debuted.
Hassan would subsequently enter into a feud with Hogan and fellow legend, Shawn Michaels, in a dream start to his WWE career. Tagging with manager, Daivari, the Arabian-American team opposed the All-American tandem at Backlash ‘05, losing the high-profile bout.
Continuing the momentum, Hassan faced both the World Heavyweight Champion and WWE Champion in the space of a month, interacting with'Stone Cold' Steve Austin in the weeks in between. Drafted to SmackDown, Hassan was immediately programmed with The Undertaker, setting up a match for The Great American Bash PPV.
Sadly for Hassan, WWE went too far with its anti-US angle, booking an in-ring mugging of ‘Taker by several of Hassan’s henchmen - all dressed in black balaclavas and camouflage resembling terrorists. To make matters worse, this happened to air on the same day as the 7/7 bombings in London when terrorism was not only fresh in the memory bank, it was at the very forefront of public consciousness.
Hassan’s character was immediately pulled and given the last rites at the Great American Bash ‘05, less than a year after making his debut.