10 Most Notorious WWE Urban Legends Involving Celebrities

Rey Mysterio dated Jennifer Aniston? It was a rumor. We try to see if it's true.

Rey Mysterio Jennifer Nai World Wrestling Entertainment loves involving celebrities. Whether they are in the ring having matches, guest ring announcing, singing the national anthem, guest hosting Raw to plug whatever movie they're in or just hanging out in the crowd, the celebrity involvement has always been important to WWE. It's smart of WWE to want to involve celebrities. They built the WrestleMania brand around the use of celebrities after all. The presence of big stars like Mr. T, Muhammad Ali and Cyndi Lauper really put WrestleMania on the map. It caused casual fans to watch because of those people, but then they kept watching because they liked what WWE was doing. Some celebrities are great guests on wrestling shows. Others look lost out there. The ones that usually show that they belong are people that grew up as wrestling fans or maybe they're still fans. If you watched WWE during the guest host era in 2009-10 then you saw how great people like Bob Barker and Shaquille O'Neal were while Al Sharpton and ZZ Top were absolutely terrible at it. Normally when we do the "notorious urban legends" feature it's about a particular wrestler. This time, though, we're changing it up. It's all about the urban legends surrounding celebrities in wrestling. We'll let you know all about the story, then why people believe it to be true and then we'll figure out if we should believe it. There are so many stories to pick from that it's tough to capture them all, but we narrowed it down to ten. Here they are.

10. Ben Stiller Was Late For Raw Appearance Due To Smoking Pot

Story: Actor Ben Stiller appeared on Raw in 1999 at a time when he was one of the biggest movie stars in the world. It was a big get for WWE and this was at a time when they really weren't using a lot of celebrities on the show all the time. What we didn't know about the appearance is that they couldn't find him. This comes from WWE's former writer Vince Russo in a feature here at WhatCulture this past June where he let us know why they couldn't find Stiller: "When we had Ben Stiller on €˜Raw€™, I couldn€™t find him to produce the pre-tapes we needed. Where was he? How about smoking the WACY-TABACKY with Road Dog and X-Pac behind the trailers!!! When we finally found Ben, who was promoting 'Mystery Men' at the time, he was more than willing to take on a direct blow to the head courtesy of Double J€™s, Jeff Jarrett€™s guitar. To this day I don€™t know if Ben agreed so willingly because he was a 'mark', or simply still high due to his earlier escapades with Sean Waltman and Brian James." Smoking pot in wrestling isn't anything new. However, it's interesting that Stiller was late for a segment for that reason. His segments were a GTV bit and also the in-ring segment with Jarrett. Why People Believe It: Russo was WWE's head writer, so it makes sense that he would be privy to that kind of info. Should We Believe It: Yes we should. Stiller told Jarrett that his favorite superstar was Debra's "puppies" and then received the guitar shot from Jarrett, who was doing his gimmick where he hated that she was getting all the attention that he thought he deserved.

9. Freddie Prinze Jr. Hated Working For WWE

Story: Freddie Prinze Jr. is an actor that had some mild success working in some teenage movies and some other roles. In 2008, he worked for WWE as part of their creative team. It led to a lot of people wondering why he was even there. It was probably because his acting career wasn't going well, so he needed a job. This past July he was doing promotion for a Disney XD series called Star Wars Rebels (what?) and brought up how much he hated working with Keifer Sutherland on 24. He also mentioned WWE in a comment: "I went and worked for Vince McMahon at the WWE for Christ's sake and it was a crazier job than working with Kiefer. But, at least he was cool and tall. I didn't have to take my shoes off to do scenes with him, which they made me do. Just put the guy on an apple box or don't hire me next time. You know I'm 6 feet and he's 5'4." He's not ripping on WWE in the comment, but saying it was a crazy job and the "Christ's sake" expression makes us think he didn't really like it. Why People Believe It: They think he hated it because he was a film and TV actor that was reduced to working on WWE's creative team. It seems like a step down. Should We Believe It: He likely enjoyed some parts of the job because he is a wrestling fan, but it must have been rough for him having to take that kind of job when you're used to starring in major motion pictures.

8. Jeremy Piven Dated Kelly Kelly After Guest Hosting

Kelly Kelly Jeremy PivenStory: Jeremy Piven is an actor best known for his work in the TV show Entourage and a number of films. He guest hosted WWE Raw on August 3, 2009 and famously botched a line when he said "the Summerfest" instead of SummerSlam. He really wasn't a good guest host, but he was memorable because of his botch. Shortly after his appearance, Jim Ross noted in an online blog that Piven actually attempted to get phone numbers of various WWE divas. Guess which one he got? The number of Kelly Kelly. She's the diva that had the rep for sleeping around with the most guys in WWE when she was in the locker room, so it's not that much of a surprise. A few weeks after his appearance on Raw, Piven was photographed at a New York Jets NFL preseason game with Kelly Kelly sitting in the stands with him. They were also photographed outside of a hotel room. Why People Believe It: The pictures tell the story. Should We Believe It: Yes. They didn't date for that long and maybe it was just a one time thing, but it did happen. As an aside, Piven is 22 years older than Kelly Kelly. Way to go, Jeremy. Kelly "retired" from WWE when she was only 25 years old and is now engaged to former NHL player Sheldon Souray.

7. John Morrison's WWE Career Was Doomed After Teaming With Snooki

Story: Nicole "Snooki" Polizzi is a celebrity because she was on the very popular reality show Jersey Shore that was on television from 2009 to 2012. Even though it wasn't the kind of show that was great for having interesting content, it was very popular. Those of us that didn't even watch the show knew who Snooki was just because the people on the show were a part of pop culture. At WrestleMania 27 in 2011, WWE brought Snooki in to be a part of a WrestleMania match. She teamed up with John Morrison and Trish Stratus as the babyface team against the heel duo of Michelle McCool & Layla (aka Laycool) as well as Dolph Ziggler. They had a very forgettable match that went about four minutes where Snooki hit a couple of moves, but that was it. Despite the fact that it was a short match, it was controversial because Morrison wasn't happy to be a part of it. He didn't want Stratus to be on the team. He wanted his girlfriend Melina on the team instead even though she really wasn't a featured diva by that point. When a celebrity is involved in a match, wrestlers are supposed to accommodate them. Not make things difficult. Morrison had heat because of it. Why People Believe It: He got a mild push post-WrestleMania, but it's not like he became a full time main eventer. People believe the heat story because he was gone from WWE later that year and hasn't been back since. Should We Believe It: Yes it's true although his issue was with Stratus more than Snooki. Morrison left WWE in late 2011 while his girlfriend Melina was released a few months before that. Coincidence? We think not. He has always maintained that he was on good terms with WWE. You can see him these days on Lucha Underground as Johnny Mundo. A WWE return seems unlikely for him.

6. David Otunga Only Has A WWE Job Because Of Jennifer Hudson

Story: Jennifer Hudson is an Academy Award winning actress and former star from American Idol that has been dating WWE Superstar David Otunga. Remember him? The rarely used Otunga was signed by WWE in 2008 and debuted on NXT in 2010. The couple has a five year old son together named David Jr. They've been engaged for a few years now. Since Otunga is barely used by WWE, there's a belief that he's only a WWE employee because of who his fiancée is. Why else can they justify paying a guy that's an average wrestler? If you're wondering, Otunga isn't out with an injury. He's just not used anymore although as of this writing he remains a WWE employee. Why People Believe It: He's not on television, yet he still works there. This seems to be a likely reason. Should We Believe It: It's one of those things where it's probably part of the reason, but not the whole reason. It's not like WWE brings Hudson to shows when he's in the ring. They don't even mention her. However, if her career blows up and Otunga is on her arm on the red carpet then in WWE's eyes that's a good thing.

5. Porn Star Jenna Jameson Linked To Undertaker

Jenna Jameson UndertakerStory: Jenna Jameson might be the most famous porn star ever. She wrote a best selling book called "How To Make Love Like A Porn Star" where she revealed a story with one of the most famous WWE performers ever: The Undertaker. She noted that Undertaker would hang out with her when he was in Las Vegas even though he was only 16 years old at the time. She was working at a tattoo parlor and every wrestling fans knows that The Undertaker loves tattoos. Some of the info Jameson shared was weird because she said "the character he played was not an act" and that sounds like something a total wrestling mark would say without knowing how the business works. She probably just embellished that to try to get attention. She added that once she was a bit older (legal age), Undertaker tried to woo her, reportedly saying: "I€™m going to kick your boyfriend€™s ass and take you away with me." She added that she knew he was serious: "I ran upstairs and told Jordan we had to leave, because this guy was going to beat the f*** out of him and kidnap me. So I never saw him again." There's no romantic link between them although it's interesting that they knew each other. As far as we know, Undertaker has never talked openly about it. That's no surprise since he maintains a very private life. Why People Believe It: A famous wrestler befriending a famous porn star? It's definitely possible. Should We Believe It: Consider the source. She's a porn star that seeks attention, so she could definitely lie about some things although she probably knew Undertaker to some degree. Whether he threatened her boyfriend and she took off out of fear is true is something that is questionable. There's probably some truth to it, but not all of it.

4. Shawn Michaels With Pamela Anderson?

Story: WWE brought actress and Playboy cover girl Pamela Anderson into the company in 1995 when they felt like they needed celebrities to boost interest in the company. She was at the 1995 Royal Rumble won by Shawn Michaels and was supposed to accompany him to the ring at WrestleMania 11 as well. Instead, Shawn was accompanied by another Playboy model Jenny McCarthy while Anderson accompanied Diesel, who was the babyface. Around this time, there were rumors that Anderson dated Michaels or had some kind of affair with him. Apparently this item appeared in Star magazine, which is a gossip magazine that often posts incorrect information just as a way to entice people to buy their magazines. http://youtu.be/Hc_tGK7yuWY When they were booked together on screen, Anderson was told to have no interest in Michaels because he was a heel. Why People Believe It: They're good looking people that were together on camera momentarily, so you never really know. Should We Believe It: No. This one seems to be a fake story. There's no proof of them hanging out or anything of that nature, but people will always believe what they want to.

3. Mr. T Had Legitimate Heat With Roddy Piper

Story: Roddy Piper had a boxing match with Mr. T at WrestleMania II. It wasn't very good. If you've seen it then you know. It was based off their interaction from a year earlier. Mr. T was a huge celebrity, so it was a major coup for WWE to get him for a second WrestleMania in a row. What we didn't know back then is that they didn't like each other. There was a legit feud between them. Earlier this year, Piper was on Steve Austin's podcast and he talked about problems with Mr. T: "Mr. T wants to come in and he€™s probably the world€™s biggest TV celebrity at the time, and he won some kind of bouncer contest. He came in with, 'I pity the fool I€™m T' with that, and he wanted to come in and slam our heads, and make fun of us, and go (laughs). You got the wrong guy. He had zero respect. I€™m on the stage in Rockefeller Center and he blindsides me and leg dives me off of the stage. I come off and (Vince) McMahon said, 'I saw those eyes of yours. Thank you for being a pro.'" In other words, Vince knew Roddy hated him, but he was thankful that Piper didn't legitimately try to hurt him. There were more stories told by Piper. Basically, they had trouble agreeing on what they should do in the boxing match and they didn't get along well. Following this year's Hall of Fame where Mr. T was inducted, Piper told a story about how they both had their sons with them, then started talking to Mr. T and they shook hands, ending their rivalry after nearly 30 years. Why People Believe It: Piper is a guy that always took wrestling a bit too serious and if he felt disrespected by somebody then he was going to let that person know. It's understandable that they had issues. Should We Believe It: Yes. Absolutely. Piper's one of the best wrestlers ever, but he's also somebody that is very hot headed. WWE is lucky that Piper was able to keep his composure to the best of his abilities.

2. Mickey Rourke Wanted To Fight Chris Jericho

Story: This is a story that Chris Jericho detailed in his new book "Best In The World" where he talked about how he was supposed to have a match with actor Mickey Rourke at WrestleMania 25. Instead, Rourke's people got him to back out of it because they thought it would hurt his chances of winning an Oscar for his performance in The Wrestler. Prior to their interaction, they did a segment on the Larry King Live show on CNN where Jericho was doing his heel character schtick. He stayed in character the whole time, insulted Rourke repeatedly and figured he was just doing his job. Rourke wasn't in on the plan, though. Apparently he legitimately hated for it. On the night prior to WrestleMania 25 in 2009, Rourke was waiting for him in the ring on the Saturday night before WrestleMania with three bodyguards (one of them was MMA legend Frank Shamrock) at his side. Jericho explained that he was just acting on the Larry King show. Rourke had no idea. He wanted to fight Jericho because of his comments and brought bodyguards with him in case other WWE people got in their way. Cooler heads prevailed. Everything was okay after Jericho explained it. As Jericho bragged in his book, he "out-acted the actor" in that instance. Rourke ended up not working the match, but he knocked Jericho following Jericho's match against three older wrestlers. Why People Believe It: People that aren't in wrestling like Rourke may not have understood that Jericho was only acting, so it's believable that he may have wanted to legitimately fight him. Should We Believe It: Yes. It's in Jericho's book and he's known as an honest guy. It's silly that Rourke didn't know it was just a work, though. Somebody should have informed him before they were on the Larry King show to prevent any problems.

1. Rey Mysterio Dated Jennifer Aniston?

Story: There was a story in the mid-1990s in the National Enquirer that said that one of the top actresses in the world, Jennifer Aniston of Friends fame at the time, had fallen in love with Rey Mysterio Jr., who was in WCW at the time. When Mysterio wrote his autobiography several years ago, he mentioned the story: €œI remember in 1997 there were some stories going around that I was dating Jennifer Aniston. The National Enquirer even printed a story about how we were an item. I have no idea what that was about or where it came from. Maybe somebody wanted to get my name out there and started the rumor. Anyways, I thought it was funny. I even showed the story to my wife €“ best coming from me, no? One thing I never let on about: I was the first guy to grab the magazine. And I still have a copy.€ Like a lot of things in the National Enquirer, its legitimacy was questionable. Mysterio never even met Aniston and we have no idea if she even knew who he was. Why People Believe It: Any time a celebrity is linked to a wrestler it's something wrestling fans want to believe just because it sounds cool. Aniston is one of the most famous actresses in the last 20 years. Should We Believe It: No. It's the National Enquirer. They post a lot of stuff that is garbage. It's pretty funny that Mysterio even mentioned it, though.

Contributor
Contributor

John wrote at WhatCulture from December 2013 to December 2015. It was fun, but it's over for now. Follow him on Twitter @johnreport. You can also send an email to mrjohncanton@gmail.com with any questions or comments as well.