10 Outrageous WWE Experiments That Failed
He's got a gun!
The 'Attitude Era' is considered by many to be the most creative time in WWE history. Pushing the envelope further than ever before, there wasn't much Vince McMahon wasn't prepared to try in order to cause a stir and draw more eyes to his product.
Something that's often forgotten is that McMahon didn't suddenly develop this mindset during that particular era and, in fact, he had it for years.
Long before he was appearing in promotional videos advertising the then-WWF's hot new marketing slogan of 'Attitude', McMahon liked to test the waters.
Sometimes, his experiments worked, but other occasions proved that not everything pushed by the 'Sports Entertainment' juggernaut was a guaranteed money-maker.
Even now, Vince enjoys throwing things out there to see what might stick. Such maverick behaviour is admirable, but it doesn't always elicit positive reactions from his core WWE audience. Still, at least McMahon has had the bravery to try these things and experiment with his product.
From grown men acting like farmyard animals, rough and tough Chicago natives suddenly believing themselves to be African, and clear insults to those vertically-challenged, WWE have failed with their experiments more than once.
Let's look at some of the most notable examples...
10. Constant Slew Of Raw Celebrity Guest Hosts
Dr. Phil's recent Monday Night Raw appearance won't be the last time WWE pull in outside celebrities to appear on the show. Vince McMahon has always enjoyed the idea of mixing mainstream entertainment with his own product, but sometimes it's handled very poorly.
Just look at the celebrity 'Guest Hosts' for Raw from 2009-2010.
Looking to spark outside interest in what was happening on WWE programming, McMahon decided the best way to do that was to have various musicians, actors (and actresses) and TV stars converge on his flagship show.
The resultant episodes were amongst the worst the promotion ever presented, and the celebrities were largely to blame.
A clear lack of product knowledge hampered proceedings. On the August 3, 2009 episode, Jeremy Piven couldn't even remember the name of SummerSlam, calling it 'Summer Fest' instead. Worse, NASCAR drivers like Kyle Busch and Joey Logano barely even came across as celebrities to most of the watching world.
Having different 'celebrities' dominate portions of Raw each week actually served to hurt the show, not help it. Decent idea at first glance to use celebrity rub, yet seriously flawed in execution.
9. The One Man Gang Transforms Into Akeem
Complete with Mohawk-style hairdo, piercings, tattoos and biker gear, The One Man Gang looked like a street brawler.
Upon his arrival in the WWF in 1987, the character had already earned a reputation in companies like the NWA and Mid-South for being a great heel. That didn't mean much in the cartoon-like world of the WWF.
At first, The One Man Gang was protected as a viable top villain. Then in September 1988, his manager Slick announced to the world that the guy actually had African heritage.
Suddenly, The One Man Gang was no more, the 'African Dream' Akeem was in his place. This just had to be a rib on the 'American Dream' character of Dusty Rhodes.
Acting like he did indeed have African roots, Akeem looked and sounded ridiculous. The hokey gimmick didn't stop him from forming an effective heel unit with The Big Boss Man, but it's utterly bizarre to look back on now. Singing and dancing in his yellow outfit, Akeem looked close to being a parody.
The One Man Gang is the kind of heel WWE could really do with now, so it's fascinating to think they turned such a cool character into a colossal dork.
8. The Red Rooster Literally Acts Like One
Speaking of colossal dorks, would anyone have admitted to showing support for Terry Taylor as The Red Rooster?
A fine in-ring performer, Taylor surely deserved better than the chance to pretend he was a farmyard animal in front of the massive WWF audience in the late-1980's. The gimmick was severely flawed from the start.
Even with Bobby 'The Brain' Heenan as his manager, there was something lacking about the man's name to begin with. Monikers like The British Bulldogs and Jake 'The Snake' Roberts were similarly animal-based, but they sounded menacing. What was foreboding about a heel rooster? It was all very strange.
Later, Taylor ditched Heenan as his manager and feuded against him. For the purpose of his babyface run, he combed his hair to resemble a literal rooster and even strutted around like the animal.
Better performers than Terry Taylor would have struggled with such nonsense, and fans just couldn't take him seriously whatsoever.
Who can blame them? The Red Rooster was a preposterous concept from the word go.
7. Vince McMahon's Outside Ventures
Each one of these ideas could be torn to pieces individually, but it makes sense to lump them all together.
After all, that's exactly what those who follow the industry have done, grouped ICOPRO, the World Bodybuilding Federation and the XFL together as collective failures. They were all ventures attempted by Vince McMahon away from his bread and butter, the WWF/WWE.
McMahon deserves praise for attempting things outside his comfort zone, but they were all ill-advised. Money was taken away from his core product, pro wrestling, and pumped into bodybuilding, supplements and American Football leagues.
They were bold experiments, yes, but ones which all collapsed relatively quickly after launching.
The WBF and ICOPRO also suffered from bad timing, falling around the same time as McMahon's troubles with the U.S Federal Government over alleged distribution of steroids. As for the XFL, it didn't appeal to wrestling enthusiasts or those who loved pro football.
Competing with the NFL was always going to be a challenge, but it was a hurdle too high for the wrestling organisation to jump.
6. Gene Snitsky Is A Baby-Killing Maniac With A Foot Fetish
Standing around 6ft 8 inches tall and sporting a thick, muscular frame, Gene Snitsky should have been a dream for WWE. Vince McMahon had a track record of promoting men exactly like Snitsky long before he came down the line, but he was never portrayed as anything more than a complete buffoon.
Instead of coming across like a vicious, threatening heel, Snitsky was consistently booked to look foolish and cartoon-like. His involvement in the onscreen romance angle between Lita and Kane was dreadfully done, especially when Gene apparently caused Lita to suffer a miscarriage whilst pregnant.
His catchphrase then became 'It Wasn't My Fault', after he claimed he wasn't to blame for the baby-related mishap.
Making things even more out there, Snitsky later developed a foot fetish. On television, he lusted after the feet and toes of various WWE Divas, again interacting with Lita. The whole premise of his character was convoluted, and it really didn't help the guy get over.
Snitsky could have been a solid, upper card heel, but he was mired in silly gimmicks and personality traits that did nothing for him.
5. Michael Cole's Heel Turn
Signing on in 1997, Michael Cole has almost been with WWE for 20 years. Working at first as a backstage interviewer, he has progressed through the system to become the promotion's top announcer.
For many years, Cole was a chirpy commentator who would decry the actions of heels and encourage fans to root for the babyfaces.
In 2010, he began to show signs of change behind the announce desk. Suddenly, Cole could be heard cheering on the villains - in particular The Miz - and spouting venom the way of guys like Daniel Bryan.
From there, he was turned into a full-on heel announcer and ignited a feud opposite Jerry 'The King' Lawler.
Cole put his all into the heel role, but it was more than a tad over-the-top at times. Using the death of Lawler's mother as a plot point felt tawdry, and it was hard to see who WWE were trying to please by booking both men to go 15 minutes in a match at WrestleMania XXVII.
Nowadays, Cole has returned to being unbiased, making his near 2-year heel run all the more wacky.
4. 'The Artist Formerly Known As' Goldust
It could be argued that the original conception of the Goldust gimmick was an outrageous experiment to begin with.
Dustin Rhodes put a lot on the line by agreeing to play the androgynous character, one which introduced elements of homosexuality and homophobia (from opponents) into the mix. Fittingly, given his nickname, it was all very bizarre.
Things incredibly got even more strange by 1997, when Rhodes started to mess around with the established formula. No longer did Goldust strictly wear gold, it now wasn't uncommon to see him don colours such as pink and green to the ring.
The character was rechristened, now called 'The Artist Formerly Known As' Goldust.
Segments like reciting Dr. Seuss poetry at In Your House: D-Generation X were frankly odd, and the character - who hadn't exactly been sane to start with - went completely off the rails. Later, the WWF would return Goldust to his more traditional look, doing away with the 'Artist' moniker.
The whole thing had been outlandish, and people seemed to have a hard time latching on to this new incarnation of Goldust. By the time Rhodes returned to the original incarnation of the gimmick in 1998, it was long overdue.
3. WWE Juniors Division
In today's WWE, sensitivity is a big issue. Over the years, the company have been taken to task by groups such as GLAAD for supposedly promoting intolerance against the gay and lesbian community. Nowadays, WWE try to ensure they come across as respectful to everyone they can.
It wasn't always this way, the promotion have at times completely disregarded the opinions of others. This was never more evident than when they hyped up the introduction of the 'Junior Division' in 2005.
Confused fans must have wondered what was in store, but they wouldn't have to wait long. WWE were about to begin a midget wrestling division on SmackDown.
Calling it the 'Midget Division' would have been bad enough, but WWE didn't help themselves by referring to little people as 'Juniors'. The graphic used to accompany matches involving guys like Mascarita Sagrada had a child-like feel to it, one which likely insulted those of smaller stature watching shows.
The insinuation was clear; these mini-grapplers were akin to kids. Naturally, the Junior Division only lasted a few months before it was abolished, never to be seen again.
2. 'Fake' Razor Ramon & 'Fake' Diesel
Wrestling fans are not stupid, that's something the then-WWF found out to their detriment in late-1996. Both Scott Hall and Kevin Nash had departed a few months earlier to join chief rivals WCW, leaving a sizeable hole on the roster that the McMahon family were struggling to fill.
To plug the gap, the WWF made the worst decision imaginable. Believing the success of the Razor Ramon and Diesel characters played by Hall and Nash respectively was more due to the gimmicks themselves, McMahon made a grave mistake.
Other wrestlers were drafted in to play the roles, completely infuriating fans who must have wondered what planet management were on.
Glenn Jacobs (better known today as Kane) played the part of Diesel, and Rick Bognar awkwardly mimicked the mannerisms of Razor. The WWF audience was left far from impressed, and the cheap knock offs fooled nobody.
It was brazen of the company to expect fans to buy into such an idea, and both 'Razor' and 'Diesel' were off television just a few months into 1997. The experiment had been a miserable failure, which many could have forecast before it began.
1. Brian Pillman Pulls A Gun On Steve Austin
A feud between former partners Steve Austin and Brian Pillman should have been an in-ring classic. Unfortunately, by 1996 Pillman was a shadow of the performer he had once been.
Shattering his ankle during a car accident, the previously dynamic, high-flying Brian lost a lot of his speed.
Nonetheless, he was a hot topic following his release from WCW, and the WWF felt like they had pulled a fast one on their rivals by signing him. A program with Austin felt like a great way to introduce Pillman, but it wound up being one of the most controversial ideas in WWF/WWE history.
On the November 4, 1996 episode of Monday Night Raw, Austin attempted to invade Pillman's home. WWF cameras were there, under the guise of conducting an interview with Brian. The skits looked much more gritty and real than anything fans had ever seen on WWF programming before.
Things took a turn to the dark side when Pillman pulled a gun out and shots were heard over the backdrop of a blank screen. This would be the first time a firearm had been used in the company, and it was not an experiment Vince McMahon was keen to replicate.
Even before the 'Attitude Era', things were getting rather out of hand.
What other outrageous WWF/WWE experiments can you think of? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!