10 Pay-Per-View Concepts WWE Needs To Bring Back
It's safe to say, all of these would have been better options than Great Balls of Fire

WWE announced the name of its Raw brand pay-per-view Great Balls of Fire to howls of derisive laughter from all quarters. Few could believe that they had actually gone ahead and named a show after a Jerry Lee Lewis song. Once can only hypothesise that Vince McMahon was driving to work in his Bentley one morning and heard the song on the radio, then declared, “Dammit, that’s a helluva name for a pay-per-view.” It’s not of course, but he is 71 so let’s indulge him and his crazy ideas.
With an increased pay-per-view output due to the brand split, WWE creative bods are clearly struggling for ideas when it comes to naming these new shows. In many cases they reverted to the past, bringing Backlash and No Mercy back from the ethers of time as SmackDown Live events. Well why not delve a little deeper into the rich pay-per-view back catalogue?
There are some brilliant concept pay-per-views forgotten by time or cruelly ignored, all of which could generate interest, and in many case provide fresh, never-before-seen-in-WWE scenarios.
10. Bash At The Beach
For the most part, WCW’s Bash at the Beach was just another pay-per-view, albeit one on which several notable moments occurred (Hulk Hogan’s first WCW match, the formation of the New World Order, Dennis Rodman wrestling two consecutive years, the Hogan-Jarret-Russo screwjob), but the one I am specifically focusing on here is 1995’s event.
That show was held on an actual beach, with the ring erected on the sand, the sea in the background, and fans dotted all over the place. It was an incredible, memorable spectacle that made what was an otherwise fairly shoddy event seem like something important, big, and different. It was WCW’s equivalent of WrestleMania IX, if you will.
WWE could make a real party out of an annual beach show, giving a much-needed fresh look to one of its pay-per-view events, rather than the carbon copy cut and paste jobs that we see month after month now. They could even do the go-home Raw or SmackDown Live at the Club La Vela, home of WCW’s famously great spring break Nitros. WWE has plenty of experience with outdoor events (several WrestleMania’s, SummerSlam 92, the annual Tribute to the Troops), so there is no reason they could not pull this off.
9. Championship Scramble
Last seen almost a decade ago at The Bash 2009, the Championship Scramble was a stipulation rather than a pay-per-view, but there is no reason it could not become one. The idea behind the match was that two men (or women) started in the ring, then every 5 minutes a new wrestler entered.
If anyone scored a pinfall or submission during this time they became the ‘interim champion’, which at Unforgiven 2008 led to a brief, wonderful moment where The Brian Kendrick was WWE Champion. When all of the competitors were in the ring the match would continue for 5 further minutes, then once the time limited expired whoever got the last pinfall or submission was declared champion.
It was fun, frenzied, and exciting – exactly what WWE needs at the moment. With so many titles floating around these days and such a mammoth roster, WWE could do a Championship Scramble pay-per-view featuring only scramble matches. It might be overkill, but if it was a mix of cruiserweights, tag teams, women, and both major titles it would be different enough that it might just work.
8. Survivor Series - Grand Finale
In 1990, WWE experimented with the tried and tested but tired Survivor Series format (they abandoned it almost entirely two years later) by having the survivors from each of the five 4-on-4 elimination matches compete again in the ‘Grand Finale’. In that bout, the babyfaces who survived united against a union of heels who had won earlier in the night, which on this occasion meant a 3-on-5 elimination match. To the surprise of no-one, Hulk Hogan and WWF Champion the Ultimate Warrior emerged victorious.
The concept is often maligned, but it shouldn’t be. The Grand Finale gave all of the other elimination matches a purpose, and it ultimately produced a winner (or winners) who had done what the name of the show suggests: survived.
Booked right, the Grand Finale could be an excellent way of giving someone new a taste of rubbing shoulders with main event talent, or be used as a way of strapping a rocket to someone and giving them a super-push.
7. BattleBowl
Another WCW idea, BattleBowl was a one-night tournament with a twist. 32 men competed, with the first round consisting of randomly drawn tag teams fighting each other, and both members of the winning team going through to a show-closing 16-man battle royal. It was quirky and ridiculous, but where else could you see the team of Rick Rude and Henry Godwinn teaming against Buff Bagwell and Phineas Godwinn on pay-per-view!?
For WWE, BattleBowl could add a much-needed freshness to a very stale and formulaic pay-per-view calendar. The random tag pairings could lead to the formation of long-term units, or at the very least create some unseen match-ups rather than relying on the same programmes for two or three major shows running.
6. King Of The Ring
WWE has had an on-and-off relationship with King of the Ring, a concept which dates back to 1985. The premise is simple: a one night single elimination tournament in which finalists compete in two or three matches, with a ‘King’ crowned at the end of it. The winner then gets a nice little gold crown, a sceptre, and a purple cape to walk around in, which is embraced by some (Booker T, Bad News Barrett) and ignored by others (Brock Lesnar, Ken Shamrock).
The company held the event annually, untelevised each year up until 1989, inexplicably skipped 1990, then brought it back in 1991. After ignoring the tournament in 1992, the WWF added King of the Ring to their pay-per-view calendar in 1993, where it ran annually until getting canned in 2002 for pulling poor buy rates. That wasn’t the end though. WWE revived the idea in 2006, 2008, and 2010 on free television, then most recently in 2015 as a Network special.
Rumours continue to swirl that the event will be brought back on the Network in 2017, which would be a good thing if true. While KOTR has never really ‘made’ a star in its own right (no, Steve Austin was not made at King of the Ring, don’t believe the retcon rhetoric), it has certainly helped push people up the card. The likes of Bret Hart, Brock Lesnar and Kurt Angle were all given a massive career boost by winning the tournament.
It could do be an excellent vehicle for giving someone in the current WWE midcard the rub they need to move up to the next level. With buy rates no longer a factor, there seems to be no reason not to bring it back.
5. In Your House
The quintessential ‘B-show’, In Your House was a concept dreamed up by WWE in 1995 to combat WCW increasing their pay-per-view output. It was a simple enough idea – a two hour show which was often subtitled after the main event, which helped progress storylines and angles in the off periods between the ‘Big Five’. So in other words, not much different to what we have now.
So what’s the point of bringing it back then? Well, the shorter running time, for one thing. The current WWE fan is bombarded with more content currently than it is possible to consume. That leads to jadedness with the product and overfamiliarity with everyone on the roster. In Your House events would not need everyone competing on them each time; WWE could pick and choose who appeared from month-to-month and give some of its overused performers a rest. The company used to do that in the 90s, often having one or two of its major stars sit out of the show if there was nothing meaningful for them to do.
And just think of those potential subtitles. In Your House: House of Horrors (okay, bad example), In Your House: The Big Dog’s Yard, In Your House: The Demon Rises. You get the idea. There are literally hundreds of ideas that could work, all with their own unique logos and slightly altered set design. Other suggestions on a postcard.
4. World War 3
Yet another WCW concept, the mad-as-a-box-of-frogs three-ring, 60-man battle royal World War 3. This was a short-lived Eric Bischoff and Kevin Sullivan creation which survived for four incarnations, and allowed the likes of jobbers Bobby Walker, Pez Whatley, and James Earl Wright to get an unlikely appearance in a pay-per-view main event under their belts.
The concept was far from simple. Firstly there were three 20-man battle royals – all randomly assigned - contested in each of the rings simultaneously, all broadcast to baffled viewers at home on a three-way split-screen. Depending on the year, eliminations could occur via being thrown over the top rope, leaving the ring in any manner, and - in 1997 only - pinfall and submission. When 20 men remained they would all move to the central ring and the last man standing was declared the winner. It’s bonkers, utterly bonkers, but what a visual three rings was! It made for interesting spots during the singles matches contested earlier in the card too, as all three rings could be used.
The return of World War 3 (which would likely need rebranding due to corporate considerations) would be an opportunity for WWE to utilise all of their massive roster on one event. It could also be used to promote all three brands at once, with Raw, SmackDown, and NXT given one ring and 20 participants each, leading to never-before-seen clashes and intriguing confrontations. While it is unlikely that WWE would be willing to present such a similar show to the Royal Rumble, it would be some spectacle if they did!
3. Taboo Tuesday / Cyber Sunday
We live in a digital age where WWE quantifies success based on the number of social media followers their brand has, they encourage social interaction with constant hashtag plugs, and they have actually created their own Network on the internet. Why then, have interactive shows Taboo Tuesday and/or Cyber Sunday never seen a return?
On those events, viewers would be responsible for what they saw on the screen, given a choice of three options to choose from be it for title match contenders or match stipulations. It was a great concept, it just happened to be executed really poorly when WWE tried it previously.
With fans more vocal than ever about what they do and don’t want, now is the time to exhume it. For one night, WWE would be booked by the fans, who could finally have their often-ignored voices heard. If WWE allowed full creative freedom to the voting audience, the results could be spectacular. With no pay-per-view buy rates to worry about anymore, and with the nature of the show encouraging, nay demanding social interaction, it seems win-win for WWE.
2. Halloween Havoc
The much-loved WCW creation Halloween Havoc is a wonderfully tacky concept, replete with bouncing pumpkins, cheap graveyard sets and, in one glorious instance, Eric Bischoff dressed as an effeminate vampire.
It’s the sort of thing that WWE’s excellent production team could flourish with. Picture the mise en scène for a moment, imagine how the WWE ring would look with black ropes and a black canvas, with smoke billowing out of the entrance way as spooky imagery adorns the impressive HD screens. Imagine the Undertaker’s finest WrestleMania entrances, only for a full show! It could be wonderful.
If WWE were really feeling nostalgic, they could even bring back the absurd Chamber of Horrors match from Halloween Havoc ‘91. A concept which called for two teams to battle until one man had been strapped into an electric chair and a lever had been pulled to electrocute them. On second thoughts…
1. War Games
Perhaps the most pined for of all the former WCW concepts is the brilliant War Games. The match saw two teams battle inside two adjoining rings surrounded by a super-sized cage, with one man from each team entering at set intervals. Well, that’s how it worked when it was good; let’s all forget about that fiasco in 1998 with three teams of three and Warrior magically appearing from the ethers.
The brainchild of Dusty Rhodes produced some incredible matches (the 1991 and 1992 events in particular are must-see classics), yet WWE has always resisted the urge to deliver a War Games match of their own, likely down to Vince McMahon’s arrogantly adamant belief that anything not created by WWE is not good. He’s wrong.
While not a pay-per-view in its own right – War Games occurred as the main event of Fall Brawl in its final six years – it could be retooled as one. The obvious storyline purpose now the brands are split is to pit a team of Raw wrestlers against one from SmackDown Live, with both shows battling for supremacy. It certainly makes more sense that WWE putting on random Elimination Chamber matches once a year without any rivalries warranting such a blowoff.