10 Problems WWE Has With Modern WrestleManias

The blandest stage of them all...

the rock john cena wrestlemania 32.jpg
WWE.com

Although Vince McMahon might have gone cold on the nickname ‘The Granddaddy of them All’, it’s starting to seem more apropos as each WrestleMania rolls around.

Each year’s flagship event promises to be bigger than the last, and while WrestleMania 32 did break WWE’s attendance records, it was also widely derided as an overly long, out of touch mess of a show - one of the worst PPVs of the year.

So why is it that WWE seems to struggle to pull off a half-decent Mania in the 2010s? This is the very same event that birthed classics like Steamboat vs Savage, HBK vs The Undertaker, The Rock vs Stone Cold Steve Austin, and a plethora of other matches that epitomise exactly what great wrestling can and should be. The name alone lends the kind of star power a Payback or a Fastlane could only ever dream of, but even with all the pomp, circumstance and guest appearances, it usually winds up being a colossal disappointment, sprinkled with some vaguely memorable moments.

Some of the reasons behind the failings of modern WrestleManias are symptomatic of WWE’s culture – and the wider wrestling culture – as a whole, but others are specific to the event itself.

Perhaps WWE should heed one of their most commonly uttered in-match phrases: the bigger they are, the harder they fall.

10. A Split Audience

john cena aj styles
WWE.com

One of the most simultaneously interesting and frustrating aspects of modern WWE is how impossible it seems to be for fans to get on the same page.

While it’s always great to see two sides of a crowd going insane over their chosen combatant (AJ Styles vs John Cena being the prime example), there’s still nothing quite like 100,000 voices screaming in support of the ‘good guy’, or levelling deafening boos at the ‘bad guy’. But not since Daniel Bryan has WWE had a clear cut babyface with enough star power to headline WrestleMania.

As soon as an audience splits more than 50/50, it can have a negative impact on both the performers in the ring, and the minority side of the crowd. If somebody is booing you when you’re supposed to be cheered, it may well have an effect on your ability to perform, and if someone is ragging on the person you came to root for, it might be detrimental to your enjoyment of the match.

This is not to point blame on any one wrestler, booker or fan - but rather to point out that a major flaw in recent WrestleManias has been that they incite division and/or apathy.

A lot of people are excited about the prospect of Goldberg vs Lesnar, and aren’t the least bit interested in seeing what Samoa Joe and Sami Zayn are doing at WrestleMania. Conversely, a lot of people couldn’t care less about Goldberg vs Brock Lesnar, and would prefer to see two younger stars vying for the Universal Title.

In that situation, nobody really goes home happy. Everyone is going to be bored at some point during the evening.


9. People Don't Like The Babyfaces

roman reigns wwe title
WWE.com

Perhaps this aforementioned fan division comes down to one very simple truth: WWE’s babyfaces are almost universally terrible. The New Era is still struggling to escape the shadows of both the Attitude Era (when heroes were edgy and somewhat unpleasant) and the PG Era (when heroes were polite, proper and family friendly), and has landed somewhere in between the two.

Case in point: when Seth Rollins was a heel, he was an easily understandable and three dimensional character. Since turning face, he’s veered between contrasting motivations, only to become a wise-cracking, catchphrase spouting nerd, to borrow from a certain Doctor Gallows’ phrasebook. It didn't help that during his and Roman Reigns' feud with Kevin Owens and Chris Jericho, the latter pair were the more charming and entertaining duo. When your heels are more likeable than your babyfaces, you have a serious problem on your hands.

The very definition of a ‘WrestleMania Moment’, at least from the perspective of the fans, is seeing a beloved babyface overcoming the odds in service of championship glory. That can’t happen when very few people actually want to see them win.


8. They're Way Too Long

cm punk go to sleep.jpg
WWE.com

This is a problem WWE has with all of its PPV events, as well as Monday Night RAW. While Vince and co seem to think more content = better content, the majority of fans miss the days when WrestleMania would last four hours.

Last year’s event, Kick-Oportion included, was seven hours long. Seven hours. In that time, you could watch four average length movies, fly from London to Dubai, or get a good night’s sleep, as plenty of UK-based fans would probably rather do. Asking somebody to sit still for that amount of time is frankly preposterous, particularly if that time isn’t spent watching something of a consistently high quality.

With NXT TakeOver: Orlando, WrestleMania 33, RAW, Smackdown, 205 Live, Talking Smack and NXT, WWE will be broadcasting just under twenty hours of live wrestling over the space of five days. That's almost an entire day of content, a quarter of which is taken up by Mania alone.

WrestleMania 32’s insufferable length led to good matches being cut short, poor matches being stretched too long, and an overwhelming sense that the thing was never going to end. You might argue that the majority of people will probably skip the pre-show, but then that begs the question: what is the point in the pre-show? Surely a half-hour Talking Smack-esque segment in which Renee Young efficiently hypes the card would suffice.

It’d certainly be preferable to a two hour slog packed with filler matches like The Usos vs The Dudley Boyz or Team Total Divas vs Team B.A.D and Blonde.


7. Pointless, Meandering Skits

enzo amore big cass kfc
WWE Network

While longer runtimes have allowed WWE to fit more of its Superstars on more recent WrestleMania cards, it has also seen an increase in worthless, time-wasting skits and adverts.

It’s understandable that WWE wants to rake in advertising revenue, but when you’ve already had to sit through adverts on the WWE Network itself, several Flo Rida performances, and at least one awkward scene involving the Golden Truth, it becomes all the more unbearable to watch Dolph Ziggler and The Miz dressing up as Colonel Sanders and a chicken in order to sell KFC. While that particular display might have occurred at Summerslam last year, it's not unreasonable to think that WrestleMania will receive the same treatment this time around, particularly given Enzo and Cass's recent finger lickin' excursions.

Both fans in attendance and viewers at home tend to become more and more irritable the longer an event drones on, and this isn’t helped by the constant product placement, unnecessary tangents, and unwanted diversions. If WrestleMania absolutely has to be seven hours long, then wouldn’t it be better to fill that time with wrestling, the thing people have actually paid to watch in the first place?

The occasional bit of filler can work well to break things up, but only if it's entertaining and serves a purpose other than to satisfy sponsors and shareholders. The three way show of respect between Stone Cold, Hulk Hogan and The Rock was a great example of this, a nostalgic and heartfelt moment that didn't step on any other wrestlers - but still felt like it belonged on the show.


6. Too Many Main Events

Wrestlemania 33 Poster
WWE

The main event is supposed to be exactly that - the poster child for the larger show that makes everything else worth sitting through.

Not only is WWE now trying to push two World titles – one with over fifty years’ worth of history, the other with less than fifty weeks – but they’re also attempting to market secondary big name non-title matches as PPV headliners. That’s exactly what happened at SummerSlam last year, wherein the Universal Title match, the WWE title match, AJ Styles vs John Cena, and Brock Lesnar vs Randy Orton all fell in the running for main event status - with the latter inexplicably going on last instead of either title bout. Well, maybe not Dolph Ziggler.

It’s not hard to see WWE doing the same at this year’s WrestleMania, particularly with Roman Reigns vs The Undertaker now very much on the cards. But all this does is create an awkwardly paced, top-heavy show, and only raises expectations further for the real main event (i.e. the match the closes the evening). That’s exactly what happened when a slightly unpopular Triple H took on an even less popular Roman Reigns in the main main event of WrestleMania 32 - a match that was forced to follow higher quality encounters, and was thus booed into oblivion.


5. The WWE Network

WWE Network Flag
@VinceMcMahon Twitter

The longer show times, the increase in adverts, the shout outs to sponsors; it’s all linked to a desire to increase revenue for WWE. The WWE Network is to blame for this.

Thanks to the WWE Network offering every PPV for $9.99 a month, PPV buys have decreased drastically, but the admin cost of running the Network has simultaneously eaten into WWE’s profit margins. WrestleMania 32 was one of the biggest events in WWE history, but because it cost so much to produce, and the average viewer was paying less than they previously would have to watch it, WWE wound up making less money than they did with WrestleMania 31.

Now, the WWE Network has made wrestling more accessible than ever before, and for all its quirks and flaws, it is a net gain for WWE fans. For WWE itself, on the other hand, it’s a double-edged sword, and could be actively reducing the quality of each WrestleMania event. In order to try and increase PPV buys from casual fans (presuming more dedicated fans pay for the Network, while lapsed or drifting viewers don’t), WWE will advertise older stars and more established names in favour of up-and-comers, regardless of their popularity. If they didn’t, there’s always the chance that WWE could wind up making a loss with each WrestleMania.

Somewhere along the line, things have reached a stage of imbalance - something that ought to be addressed if WrestleMania is to return to its glory days as a high quality and financially lucrative show.


4. An Obsession With Breaking Records

the rock eric rowan.jpg
WWE.com

Wrestling PPVs are always great/terrible for devising drinking games around, because WWE's announce teams are known for endlessly repeating hackneyed catchphrases. At WrestleMania 32 (and in the weeks leading up to it), you probably could have inflicted permanent liver damage on yourself, if you’d drank every time somebody mentioned a ‘record’ being broken.

WWE loves its statistics and factoids, but last year’s show was plagued by feeble attempts to ‘make history’, like The Rock pinning Eric Rowan in six seconds, or the company allegedly breaking their own attendance record at AT&T Stadium. This kind of thing is fine, if it’s done in service of telling a story or making somebody seem like a big deal (say when somebody breaks an elimination or survival record in the Royal Rumble match), but more often than not it’s just there for the sake of it, or to fill time that could be used by another match.

Hardcore fans don’t care about these records, casual fans certainly aren’t interested in them, and the only people slightly concerned are potential shareholders and sponsors. It’s just another excuse for some ego stroking at the expense of everybody else’s time and money.


3. An Obsession With WrestleMania Moments

16 Zack Ryder Daddy WrestleMania 32
WWE.com

Without significant build or a well thought out storyline behind it, a WrestleMania Moment ™ is just another meaningless buzz phrase that gets thrown around in wrestling, like ‘vintage’ or ‘physical’ or ‘iconic’.

Technically, every single second of WrestleMania 33’s seven hour show will be a ‘WrestleMania Moment’, but for the sake of branding, it’s a term that defines a Superstar achieving personal glory at The Grandest Stage of them All.

But all too often, these Moments are shoehorned into the show in order to bring more meaning to the phrase, and to the WrestleMania brand. It doesn’t matter that Zack Ryder lost his Intercontinental Championship a day after winning it, he got his WrestleMania moment. It doesn’t matter that three injured and retired Hall of Famers buried The League of Nations after their win, because it was a WrestleMania moment.

It’s a catch-all excuse for a lot of the vapid nonsense that goes down at Mania each year, things that can often undermine larger story arcs taking place around the event.


2. Too Many Superstars

Wrestlers fight in the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal during Wrestlemania XXX at the Mercedes-Benz Super Dome in New Orleans on Sunday, April 6, 2014. (Jonathan Bachman/AP Images for WWE)
Jonathan Bachman/AP

Like many of the points on this list, this one goes hand in hand with the insurmountable length of recent WrestleManias. One of the biggest arguments for a seven hour Mania is that it gives more Superstars an opportunity to appear on the card. In years prior, feuds may have been left of the show and settled at a secondary PPV or on RAW or Smackdown instead.

But that’s not necessarily a bad thing. If a feud isn’t WrestleMania-worthy, then it shouldn’t be on the show - nor should it be combined with another three feuds just to facilitate a multi-man ladder match or tag team scramble. Saving otherwise solid matches and rivalries for weekly TV would improve the quality of WWE’s A and B shows, and would allow for a shorter, less bloated 'Mania card.

There simply will never be enough room at WrestleMania to give everyone a fair shake, and while there might currently be too many Superstars for that specific event, rosters are only going to grow larger as WWE tries to fill large talent gaps on both RAW and Smackdown. The problem isn't going to go away.

Adding on extra baggage to the show won't make it any better.


1. An Over-reliance On Part-Timers

Bill Goldberg
WWE.com

One of the most ubiquitous complaints about modern day WWE is that the company spends far too much time fawning over its old, greying has-beens, and less time cultivating new stars.

While there are definitely opportunities to tell great redemption stories wherein an old favourite can return to triumph over a cocky young upstart, all too often this leads to fresher talent looking weak or unimportant in comparison. They might be older, but a lot of WWE’s returning Attitude Era stars can’t possibly claim to be ‘old school’, as they’ve proven time and time again that they’re more interested in putting themselves over than the people who show up to wrestle day in, day out.

There is none more heinous an offender than The Rock, who only seems to return so that he can belittle current WWE Superstars in favour of promoting his Hollywood career. On RAW, he’ll trash talk the likes of Lana and Rusev without recompense, or make snide jabs at Roman Reigns and John Cena. It gets even worse when the Brahma Bull ‘finally’ returns to WrestleMania.

At last year’s event, he beat the imposing Eric Rowan in six seconds with a single Rock Bottom, all so he could break a record. It made the Wyatts look stupid, it made The Rock look a little stupid, and like his victories over CM Punk and John Cena a few years previous, it made everyone else on the roster look stupid.

Looking ahead to WrestleMania 33, an event co-headlined by Goldberg vs Brock Lesnar, it’s highly likely we’ll see the same kind of shenanigans pulled again. Just look at the poster, in which Goldberg, Brock Lesnar, The Undertaker and John Cena take centre stage, and the WWE Champion is almost invisible. You could argue that they’re box office draws, but sooner or later, they’ll retire from WWE for good, and there won’t be any more household names to replace them.


Contributor
Contributor

Liam is a writer and cranberry juice drinker from Lincolnshire. When he's not wearing his eyes away in front of a computer, he plays the melodica for a semi wrestling-themed folk-punk band called School Trips.