10 Reasons NXT TakeOver Events Always Overshadow WWE PPVs

Why does WWE's 'developmental' brand outperform the main roster so consistently?

Authors of Pain, Johnny Gargano, Tomasso Ciampa
WWE.com

Another PPV weekend, another example of NXT totally overshadowing its big brother. TakeOver: Chicago was just the latest excellent show in the 'developmental' brand's chronology, a wonderful blend of excellent matches, moments, and storytelling.

Even with the perceived decline of NXT's weekly show (after the departure of leading stars such as Bálor, Bayley, and Nakamura), it still knows how to deliver in a big way.

In contrast, Backlash was a divisive affair. Although certain booking decisions - especially Jinder Mahal's shock victory - dominated the headlines, there's little denying the fact that in terms of quality, TakeOver: Chicago was leagues ahead of its main roster counterpart. Dunne vs. Bate was particularly incredible.

But surely, with more time and money dedicated to it, WWE's main roster should deliver a consistently better product. The consistent brilliance of NXT TakeOver specials is a strange phenomenon, and one with no single answer.

A blend of factors have ensured that, although casual fans may pay attention to the main roster show only, WWE's two-show weekends are almost always dominated by NXT. Let's dissect these and find out why.

10. Better Storytelling

Ciampa, Gargano
WWE.com

Last weekend's TakeOver had two big talking points: the Match of the Year candidate put on by Pete Dunne and Tyler Bate, and the shocking betrayal of Johnny Gargano by Tomasso Ciampa.

Ciampa's heel turn was a masterful example of storytelling, one full of subtle, visual nuances that are far rarer in main roster rivalries. While feuds on Raw or SmackDown will ram key themes down our throats with soundbite after soundbite, the disintegration of DIY was foreshadowed far more naturally.

From their terse encounter in the Cruiserweight Classic to Ciampa's visible disappointment at TakeOver Brooklyn II (where Gargano tapped out to The Revival), to Saturday's heart-wrenching betrayal, the story has been a brilliant one.

It's far from the only example too. Other highlights from TakeOver history include Sami Zayn wrestling with his conscience (and NXT Champion Neville), Kevin Owens' heel turn, and the glorious rise of Bobby Roode.


9. Simpler Booking

Shinsuke Nakamura, Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Although NXT's storylines culminate in a generally more satisfying way, it doesn't necessarily mean they're more complex than their main roster equivalents. In fact, this could actually be part of the reason why they're often superior.

TakeOvers generally tend to feature fewer run-ins and screwy finishes than Raw or SmackDown PPVs - the booking is usually far simpler. Stipulations are also thrown around with less reckless abandon, and even when things do get a little outlandish (such as Paul Ellering in a shark cage), these features thankfully don't overshadow the importance or flow of the matches themselves.

On the other hand, recent main roster pay per views have seen Kevin Owens losing a main event to Goldberg in a matter of seconds (thanks to Jericho's distraction), Bray Wyatt's WrestleMania projector nonsense, and - worst of all - the House of Horrors match.

TakeOver specials rely far less on bells and whistles, and (despite Vince McMahon's probable wishes) are focused far more on wrestling than sports entertainment.


8. Hand-Picking The Best Wrestlers In The World

Alestair Black
WWE.com

Dave Meltzer raised an interesting point on his recent Observer recap of TakeOver Chicago. He pointed out that, apart from the Authors of Pain, no other wrestler on the card could be considered a product of the Performance Centre. NXT cherry pick much of their talent from the best indie scenes around the world.

This is one of the simpler points on the list, but it's an undeniable one. WWE's main roster is more geared at fulfilling Vince McMahon's (sometimes narrow) vision, while NXT is able to bring together the best independent wrestling talent on the face of the planet.

It's unclear how much this will change in the future, especially if the performance centre continues to become a crucial part of the WWE machine, but TakeOver cards have often been a who's-who of astonishing indie talent.


7. A More Diverse Roster

Ruby Riot, Asuka, Nikki Cross
WWE.com

Another advantage of NXT taking most of their talent straight from the independent scene (without spending too much time in the Performance Centre) is that shows are filled with a diverse array of styles. Last week, for example, we saw the strong style of Asuka, the ROH moveset-mastery of Roderick Strong, the UK indie workrate of Pete Dunne and Tyler Bate, and the main-event showmanship of Bobby Roode.

In contrast, main roster pay per views can often feel rather samey. Yes, some exceptional performers such as AJ Styles and Kevin Owens are able to cater to WWE's demands without overly-compromising their own styles, but this is a hard balance to achieve and many are toned down as a result. Just look at the majority of the cruiserweight division, for a particularly disappointing example (given the exciting action of last year's CWC).


6. Fresher Faces

Authors of Pain
WWE.com

NXT's weekly show has endured several slumps over the past couple of years, usually a result of big names moving up to the main roster and leaving a vacuum of star quality - which is usually slowly filled as new names are pushed to the top of the card.

This could be seen as something of a self-defeating phenomenon; can NXT ever truly maintain momentum when, by its very nature, it is destined to lose its top stars.

On the other hand, this perceived weakness could also be seen as a strength. Yes, NXT often loses big names to Raw and SmackDown, but this constantly allows for new faces to make an impact, thereby lending the product a fresher feel. WWE is often criticised for keeping the same guys on top for far too long - Cena, Orton, etc. have headlined countless PPVs - but TakeOver specials will never have this problem.


5. Wrestlers Are Allowed To Do More In The Ring

Tyler Bate, Pete Dunne
WWE.com

Tyler Bate and Pete Dunne brought the house down at TakeOver Chicago, wrestling a long, inventive, exciting match with plenty of room for risk and innovation.

Although this is the most recent shining example, TakeOver matches on the whole seem to be put together with far more creative freedom than many of those on main roster pay per views.

I'm not saying anybody should be throwing unprotected chairshots or incorporating consistently dangerous moves into their matches, but NXT has clearly benefitted from allowing for a little innovation - even if it doesn't necessarily correspond with WWE's relatively rigid style.


4. A More Passionate Fanbase

Triple H
WWE.com

Although WWE pay per views obviously have a far larger audience, TakeOver shows often come across as more raucous affairs. Fans give louder reactions on the whole, whether in Full Sail, New York, Dallas, Chicago, or London - thereby elevating matches by providing an enthusiastic backdrop.

The cult nature of NXT has successfully melded the passion of indie fans with the polish of a WWE production.

It's worth mentioning one example of a passionate NXT fan in particular: Triple H. The creative head of the brand has clearly put a lot into ensuring its success, from recruitment to production. If he is to inherit WWE from Vince McMahon, the promotion could well be in good hands.


3. A More Forgiving Fanbase

Samoa Joe
WWE.com

Not only are TakeOver crowds more passionate on the whole, they also seem to be more forgiving of weaker moments.

"Smark" fans are often characterised as overly-cynical and quick to judge, but NXT audiences seem to have proven that if a brand attempts to stay in tune with its fanbase, they'll repay it.

Take the main event of NXT TakeOver: Dallas, which saw its momentum stall after an early cut to Samoa Joe. Although slightly restless, the crowd almost palpably willed things to be okay; there was no hijacking of the match, which may well have happened on a main roster PPV.

Additionally, NXT crowds seem more willing to play their part in storylines. Although many were probably delighted at Ciampa's turn last week, the reaction was almost entirely heel heat - adding to the moment rather than placing the focus on 'smart' fans.


2. No Overexposure

Enzo, Big Cass, Carmella
WWE.com

Many NXT stars have been called up to the main roster, only to lose much of their lustre after a few months. Wrestlers such as Apollo Crews, Enzo and Cass, and arguably Bayley have found themselves normalised - especially compared to the reactions they'd garner at TakeOver events.

The reason for this? Overexposure.

WWE's main roster produce so much wrestling content these days, it's often overwhelming. Raw lasts three hours; SmackDown lasts two - not to mention multiple PPVs a month.

NXT TakeOver specials come around every few months, and this seems to be the perfect amount of time. Stars don't risk being overexposed, even if that fate may sadly befall a sizeable chunk when they move up.


1. Every TakeOver Feels Special

Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Speaking of the frequency of WWE pay per views, how many of these events feel throwaway? Sure, some - such as WrestleMania, the Royal Rumble, Money in the Bank, and so on - are intentionally stocked with big moments, but many 'B' PPVs contain relatively little to get excited about. There's nothing quite as deflating as a disappointingly booked WWE pay per view, especially one which looked good on paper.

In contrast, almost every single TakeOver special has felt important - and unpredictable. Big moments happen at almost every event, and I'm not just talking about match results or individual spots. Take Seth Rollins' recent appearance at TakeOver San Antonio, an entirely unannounced arrival which felt huge and enhanced the show (as well as his own feud with Triple H).

Sadly, it's impossible to expect WWE to constantly pull surprises out of their hat for main roster PPVs due to their frequency. When such shows are scheduled so close together, some will naturally fall by the wayside. Thankfully, in the case of NXT, that problem has been avoided so far.


Content Producer
Content Producer

Highly overrated 23 year old from the North East of England. Hanging off of your gangster car.