10 Reasons The WWE Title Is Meaningless In 2017
'That stupid piece of tin you've got on your shoulder'
Shawn Michaels was prone to sacrilegious remarks like the one above during his most reckless moments under a fog of drug and alcohol dependency in the mid-1990s.
His outburst came at the expense of Bret Hart, who proudly held the WWE Title as the symbol of excellence in an industry he still truly believed he was at the top of during a tumultuous final reign as champion.
Hart was frequently accused of taking the wrestling business too seriously, and the barb was a shot across the bow by Michaels designed to diminish the prestige 'The Hitman' felt he held by the virtue of his position as champion.
Of course, deep down 'HBK' felt the exact same way. His paradoxical reduction of Hart was the latest strike in a war of words between the two, but the quest for supremacy within the company was a real competition, and in 1997, holding the gold placed you at the very top.
20 years on from that fractious period, and just about everything has changed about the company and the business in general. The 'piece of tin' Bret and Shawn viciously fought over has suffered more than most over those two decades, but has now landed at a previously unthinkable nadir.
As the wrestling world awaits a potential pay-per-view WWE Title meeting of Randy Orton and Jinder Mahal, here are 10 reasons the once beloved championship has become virtually meaningless in 2017.
10. Record Breaker
Much was made of John Cena's attempt at equalling the iffy-but-accepted record set by Ric Flair as he prepared to take on AJ Styles at January's Royal Rumble pay-per-view.
'The Champ' dethroned 'The Phenomenal One' to win his 16th WWE/World Title since scooping his first back in 2005, amassing the same number as Flair in just under half the time it took 'The Nature Boy' to set the target.
However, Cena would criminally find himself a transitional champion on the 'Road to WrestleMania', and subsequent mentions of the historic reign were muted as the company moved towards the Elimination Chamber pay-per-view with sights locked on getting the belt into the Randy Orton/Bray Wyatt programme.
Cena's fabulous dethroning of Styles deserved a far superior follow-up than it subsequently received, and the reign in general mirrored Flair's own final stints with the title in WCW's miserable final years.
Vince Russo stripped him of the prize after just a week holding the gold in his penultimate period as champion, but Flair was given the title back by Kevin Nash the following Monday on Nitro. He wouldn't even make it to the end of the episode with the strap, losing a match against Jeff Jarrett in the main event of that very broadcast.
WWE's treatment of the top title this year has been only slightly better.
9. Champion Of The Month
After a period of virtual dominance by AJ Styles to close out 2016 on SmackDown Live!, there has been a titleholder for every month of the year since January 1st.
Cena's victory over 'The Phenomenal One' at the Royal Rumble pay-per-view was an epic contest befitting the once-richest prize in the industry, but it marked the first of three reckless changes that have ultimately damaged all four individuals.
Whilst the belt initially elevated Styles, AJ quickly flipped the script and became the blue brand's undisputed top star who just happened to be holding gold. The loss to Cena didn't damage his position on Tuesday nights, but Cena's underwhelming defeat in the Elimination Chamber less than a month later made the decision to switch the title feel a little wasteful.
That reign looked dignified in comparison to Bray Wyatt's maiden dalliance with the title.
He reached the pinnacle of his career just weeks before the premature conclusion of his rivalry with Randy Orton, and barely got to drag the title to ringside on television before he was weeping at the sight of his burning house and losing it in pedestrian fashion at the biggest show of the year. The title had flirted with prominence but had quickly returned to stasis as a needless prop.
8. The House That AJ Styles Built
The saddest thing about the WWE Title's rapid decline in 2017 has been how aggressively it undermines the outstanding work as champion from AJ Styles in 2016.
Considered a failure at the highest level less than a year removed from his experimental reign as champion, Dean Ambrose's elevation was too late into his own character's deconstruction to gain a foothold as SmackDown Live! kingpin.
Snaring the gold in a triple threat with 'The Lunatic Fringe' and John Cena was a landmark moment from AJ Styles' remarkable maiden year with WWE. He'd had simply been too good not to use on top.
In the ring, he remained in a league of his own, as most had known for the majority of his career. But his work on the microphone improved exponentially, despite a separation from 'Club' buddies Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson in the 2016 Draft.
AJ was and still is the best performer in the company, and his devoted relationship with the WWE Title played to the real and storyline assertions of his skills.
The fact he never received a one-on-one rematch even triggered his WrestleMania match with Shane McMahon, and has been quietly dropped since his inevitable babyface turn. That Styles has already moved onto a pursuit for Kevin Owens' United States title says far more about the WWE Title than it does about the 'The Phenomenal One'.
7. Crickets
Only history will determine just how bad WrestleMania 33's WWE Title match really was, but it was unthinkable prior to the event that a match could somehow be worse than the WrestleMania 32 show-closing snoozer between Triple H and Roman Reigns.
Amazingly, the projection of maggots, earthworms and insects onto the canvas wasn't the 'Ultimate Thrill Ride' WWE promised. Reaction to the concept was caustic.
From several accounts, the visual aids failed to land with the live crowd as WWE would have liked, despite the slew of screens and walls the company could have effectively promoted the stunt on.
On television, the initial projection created an air of confused shock, but the repeated indifference shown by Randy Orton ensured a minimal level of threat despite Bray's repeated acts of wizardry.
Like so many of Wyatt's tricks, it was a complete failure in helping him actually win a match.
Polished off with the RKO in under ten minutes, 'The Eater Of Worlds' became the second consecutive transitional WWE Champion, with his February Elimination Chamber victory feeling like a lifetime ago as he lay looking at the Florida sky to the sound of audience apathy yet again.
6. Hidden In The Undercard
The WWE Title was destined to take a downward slide thanks it's position on company 'B show' SmackDown Live! following the 2016 Brand Extension, but the initial distaste to Raw's Universal Title ensured a stay of execution for the industry's top prize.
As mentioned elsewhere in this article, AJ Styles worked wonders with the title after a listless spell for the belt over the shoulder of Dean Ambrose, but the die was cast and a cascade into irrelevance was inevitable.
The issue has been highlighted via the dual-brand pay-per-views since the split, with the WWE Title match failing to headline a single major event since the cards separated.
Admittedly, the John Cena/AJ Styles match belonged in the show-closing spot of the Royal Rumble pay-per-view. But outside of that, matches featuring Dolph Ziggler, Dean Ambrose, Bray Wyatt and Randy Orton were buried exactly where they belonged in the middle of the respective SummerSlam and WrestleMania cards.
With the exception of Styles, recent addition Shinsuke Nakamura and Cena should he return later this year, there are no other justifiable stars on the brand to carry the title to the show-closing slot, especially if competing with Universal Champion Brock Lesnar or a similar attraction performer at one of the quarterly supershows.
5. Lucky 13
It's been easy to ignore Randy Orton's growing legacy with the WWE Title since his first (World Title) win in 2004. Mainly because it's been nearly as easy to ignore Randy Orton full stop.
Outside of momentary flashes of personality and the almost literal occasional metamorphosis into a snake to put across his 'Apex Predator' persona, 'The Viper' has sleepwalked his way through over a decade of matches and promos, amassing a whopping 13 World/WWE Title reigns in the process.
It spoke to the insignificance of the current incarnation of the title that the remarkable statistic is barely ever mentioned despite Orton falling only three short of tying Ric Flair's record alongside John Cena.
Despite the malaise that has hung over Orton's career in prior reigns, his current circumstances may be the least engaging yet. Tucked away early on SmackDown Live! with Wyatt family runoffs and now unlikely new contender Jinder Mahal (more on him later), Randy's segments on the show look like token gestures to an ageing legend. Only one that happens to be WWE Champion.
To make matters worse, his first major defence will take place in a contest WWE still hasn't figured out the mechanics of, with a result they've openly telegraphed on television.
4. Horror Show
Even for the disjointed Bray Wyatt character, WWE have taken a leap into the abyss with the 'House of Horrors' stipulation for their WrestleMania rematch.
What's likely to be Bray's final pop at the title before slinking onto Monday Night Raw's undercard will take place in a match so weird and mysterious that the company can't even make up their mind what's going to actually happen.
Leaking out through Twitter and all the other usual sources, it emerged that WWE had quizzed their 'Fan Council' (an online opt-in focus group made of the most devoted members of the WWE Universe, it would seem) about what they'd like the stipulation to represent, despite already announcing and promoting the match two weeks earlier.
If the lack of foresight wasn't odd enough, the options the company threw out ranged from dull to demented.
Amongst other possible permutations, WWE proffered 'Darkness', 'Pitch Forks', 'Fog', 'Mirrors', 'Chainsaws', 'Snakes' and 'Axes'. Of course, if you loved the WrestleMania 33 calamity, 'Projections' and 'Bugs' were also available for selection, as well as the glamorous 'Other' and 'Nothing Different'.
It's ludicrous that the company would be so short-sighted with a programme that started with such promise, but it's a crime they've dragged the WWE Title into it's toxic grasp.
3. Jinder Mahal
And it's come to this.
With the title's legacy in tatters and even SmackDown Live!'s commentators haphazardly predicting easy victory for Randy Orton in the 'House of Horrors' rematch, his opponent for the first post-WrestleMania blue brand pay-per-view will be Jinder Mahal.
Victory in a six pack challenge over Sami Zayn, Luke Harper, Mojo Rawley, Erick Rowan and Dolph Ziggler propelled Mahal beyond the chasing pack just a week removed from losing two televised squashes and concussing Finn Balor live on Monday Night Raw.
With the big victory already in his back pocket, WWE will undoubtedly work backwards on the character as they usually do, but Jinder's sudden elevation may not just end with an RKO in May.
The precedent was set in 2004 (and on SmackDown no less), when Bradshaw was plucked from his position as a chubby Billy Gunn doppelgänger in a dated Acolytes unit and positioned against Eddie Guerrero for 'Latino Heat's WWE Title.
The shot came out of the blue with the new heel looking way out of his depth, and victory over Guerrero was considered a virtual impossibility. The shock of his win caused many to boycott SmackDown in disgust, but the reign carried on until JBL actually grew into the role. As another push in reverse, it's not out of the question to see a Mahal title win return Tuesday nights to those dark days.
2. Face Of America
After joining SmackDown Live! in the 'Superstar Shake-up' with a tweaked image, Kevin Owens ramped up the patriotism in week two of his 'Face of America' campaign. Slapping his sneering mug across the entire staging area, he then took down local jobber Gary Gandy as part of his megalomaniacal new open challenge.
The pro-Canadian anti-American rhetoric is well-worn schtick, but the latest twist on the trope almost guarantees the United States title's presence in some of the best action each week.
Starting as they mean to go on, the blue brand promoted a main event match just to become the number one contender for the title on 'KO's first night on the show. Won by bonafide headliner AJ Styles, the potential Owens/Styles meeting already has most fans salivating and positions their scrap comfortably above the Randy Orton/Jinder Mahal encounter that will anchor the Backlash pay-per-view in May.
For now and the foreseeable future, the WWE Title has already been forced into an unwelcome slot as a secondary title at best thanks to the Monday night equivalent current stowed away somewhere in Brock Lesnar's farmhouse. It will only be diminished further should Owens continue with his refreshed approach.
1. Universal Praise
Despite a rocky start thanks to shortsighted fan complaints on the aesthetics and a injury-hit quick switch between inaugural champion Finn Balor and Kevin Owens, the Universal Title has become the WWE's top prize in less than a year.
It was an inevitability that Raw's championship would gradually usurp the WWE Title as per the longstanding loyalty Vince McMahon holds towards his flagship show, but the gulf between the two championships was at it's widest as Brock Lesnar unseated Bill Goldberg after a breathless four minutes at WrestleMania 33.
The abbreviated length of the match and limitations of the performers didn't concern the mammoth Orlando crowd. Lesnar and Goldberg were stars and they were competing for the biggest prize in the industry. Furthermore, on a show without an Undertaker retirement, it was also a cert they would go on last.
As champion, Brock isn't even on television regularly, which only enhances the the credibility of the title and the challenger that ultimately unseats him.
This has forced Raw to promote the importance of the Intercontinental Title, which mirrors SmackDown Live!'s treatment of the United States title despite the fact a WWE Title is still in situ every week over on the blue brand. The former 'top' strap can nary afford to take more damage.