10 Reasons WWE Is Losing Their Audience

How has RAW lost 7 million viewers since the Monday Night War?

Bayley Brooke
WWE.com

No matter how you look at it, seven million people is a lot of people.

That's how many viewers have stopped watching pro-wrestling on Monday nights since the demise of WCW in 2001. At the height of the 'Monday Night War', the pro-wrestling industry generated a combined total of 10 million viewers on a regular basis thanks to the weekly programs of WWE's Monday Night Raw and WCW's Monday Nitro.

After WCW ceased operations and Vince McMahon purchased its video library, Nitro was no more leaving Raw as the only show in town. If you want to watch wrestling on Monday nights, you didn't have to choose anymore as the choice was simple: Raw was all that was left.

One might think that without direct competition from WCW, it would've been smooth sailing for WWE from then on and in many ways, it was. Lately though, a different story has become apparent as Raw's television ratings continue to decline, recently reaching all-time lows. Raw now averages under three million viewers every week (down from 10 million pre-WCW). That's a worryingly huge loss.

So what happened? Where did all those wrestling fans go? Why have they tuned out?

We uncover all that and more as we look at 10 Ways WWE is losing their audience.

10. Few Events Are Truly Special

No Mercy 2016 poster
WWE.com

WWE is losing their audience for many reasons, but the first one is that they rarely provide truly "special events" anymore.

In 2016, pay-per-views have ballooned to 20 (including NXT) and will probably far exceed that number come 2017. Of all main roster shows, only the Royal Rumble, WrestleMania, and SummerSlam even have the potential to feel truly special. Unfortunately, more often than not these events fail to deliver any long-lasting developments or impact.

Take WWE's supposed biggest show of all-time, for example. What happened at WrestleMania 32 that mattered even one month, much less one year later? Shane lost to The Undertaker yet the match's stipulation was ignored. AJ Styles lost clean to Chris Jericho yet was announced the #1 contender the very next night on Raw. The League of Nations were supposedly given "the rub" from legends Steve Austin, Shawn Michaels, and Mick Foley yet were split days following the event with half the group leaving the company within a month.

Finally, the main event was as predictable as it gets when Roman Reigns defeated Triple H for the WWE Championship. Less than three months later, Roman was suspended and lost the title while Triple H has made only one appearance since.

In other words, these shows don't ultimately matter. It's all just filler.

In retrospect, outside of the large attendance and a few one-off appearances, WrestleMania wasn't special and that's been the case with nearly every show WWE presents.


9. WWE's Focus Is On The Past

goldberg raw
WWE.com

For being the biggest show of all-time, WrestleMania 32 really is a microcosm of all WWE's major problems, including its over-reliance on the past.

WrestleMania is always and will always be the biggest show that WWE will put on every year, but the card mainly consists of stars from a bygone era. The Rock, Triple H, Brock Lesnar, The Undertaker, Batista, and Shawn Michaels have all headlined WrestleManias in the past six years and the undercard has seen even more legends.

Shane McMahon, Sting, Ric Flair, Bret Hart, Vince McMahon, nWo, and D-Generation X have all been featured in prominent roles underneath while the regular, full-time superstars are relegated to the pre-show or opening match.

Whenever WWE needs to draw a number, they look to the legends. Whenever WWE wants to present something important, they look to the legends.

Another example is the recent return of Goldberg. Prior to Goldberg's return, Raw recently tied their all-time lowest rating ever set back in March of 1997. So what was WWE's solution to pop a rating? A star from a past era.

Until WWE realizes that they need to start putting the focus on their current full-time roster, the lifeblood of the company, this Catch-22 pattern is likely to continue.


8. Revisionist History

Vince McMahon The Cure For The Common Show Attitude Era
WWE.com

Way back when WCW was starting to make their presence known as a true competitor, WWF would often ignore the promotion. But when former WWF stars like Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage made the jump to WCW, the World Wrestling Federation started to ignore its own history by trying to erase their contributions to the promotion.

Instead of promoting and celebrating the rich history of the company, they began revising it.

It was a strategy that would last several years, and still does to this day for many topics. But when pro-wrestling had its all-time high record number of viewers on a weekly basis, the company actually embraced their history, regardless of their former stars' whereabouts.

When Vince McMahon delivered his famous "Introduction to Attitude" speech on Monday Night Raw in late '97, he promised the end of insulting the audience's intelligence. True to his word, the WWF shifted to a product that didn't ignore their past while also adding a plethora of adult-oriented content. They actually built on their past to develop their future.

Since then, WWE has gone back to revising history and crafting the past to fit the narrative they wish to tell. They say, "History is written by the victor," and that is absolutely true in the case of pro-wrestling.


7. Politics Matter Above All Else

triple h kevin owens
WWE.com

Politics have always been a huge part of pro-wrestling, but the difference between today's environment and yesterday's is that politics didn't always trump everything else. Today, they do.

The WWE environment used to be conducive to producing new stars, with talent being told to focus primarily on getting over. Regardless of whose idea the talents used or what agent or executive they were close friends with, if the talent could get over, they would be pushed, or featured. This led to the development of stars like Jake 'The Snake' Roberts, Mr. Perfect, Bret Hart, Diesel, Stone Cold Steve Austin, the New Age Outlaws, The Godfather, Val Venis, and nearly every popular act from the Attitude Era.

Today, getting over is not enough. Talents need to be aligned politically with certain powers-that-be in order to be heavily featured on TV. At various points in the recent past, talents like Zack Ryder, Dolph Ziggler, Ryback, Cody Rhodes, Wade Barrett, and Damien Sandow have all gotten over naturally with the crowd but weren't featured to the degree they probably should have been.

Of them, only two remain with the company today. What does that tell you?

It tells you that getting over and generating reactions are no longer the most important thing, and the audience can tell.


6. Too Much Content

wwe network
WWE.com

Another reason WWE is losing viewers is because they simply produce too much content.

To be fair, multiple weekly shows are nothing new to WWE. The difference is that in the past, these multiple weekly shows were much shorter in duration and not three hour marathons like Raw every Monday night.

With WWF Superstars, Wrestling Challenge, All-American Wrestling, and Prime Time Wrestling back in the '80s and early '90s, their television lineup combined for roughly five hours of programming a week. Today, with Raw, SmackDown Live!, Main Event, Superstars, Total Divas, Total Bellas, two monthly pay-per-views plus their extended pre and sometimes post-shows, there are weeks that see a total of 13-15 hours of content!

Even including the quarterly pay-per-views that WWF would present, that's still less than half the content of what the company produces today and that's without even mentioning the 24/7 WWE Network and its extensive catalog.

Content is king these days so it makes sense that WWE would want to produce more of it. But at the pace this company is churning it out, they are absolutely a victim of the law of diminishing returns, plus they're cannibalizing their own audience in many cases.


5. The Storylines Are Awful

dolph ziggler lana
WWE.com

As with any good television show, the goal is to leave the viewer wanting more. Fans of shows like Walking Dead, Game Of Thrones, and Breaking Bad can't get enough. They've even spawned multiple spin-offs and post-shows that are very successful in bringing in ratings for their respective networks.

While WWE has never been bashful about adding pre and post-shows, they are hardly doing the numbers that the competition is in the world of broad-based entertainment. The reason being that, quite frankly, WWE's shows and the quality of their storytelling aren't very good.

WWE's writing and storylines are so poor that they often get dropped without warning and without conclusion. It's a chore to sit through three hours of Raw every week, especially knowing angles might go nowhere.

Imagine if you were watching a series where episode 3 had nothing to do with episodes 1 or 2 nor 4 through 10. What if the roles of the protagonists and antagonists were constantly being flip-flopped, back-and-forth with no explanation or ramifications?

The show probably wouldn't have ever been given the green-light to be produced, but even if it did somehow, it would get cancelled very quickly. Unfortunately in pro-wrestling, the quality of the storylines are secondary and it's a major reason why modern day television viewers just won't tolerate WWE.


4. Constant Branding & Corporate Talk

WWE Corporate
Twitter, @StephMcMahon

You can't tune into a WWE broadcast for 15 minutes without hearing some type of corporate speech or company jargon in a desperate attempt at increasing brand awareness.

Instead of wrestlers talking about their upcoming match at Hell In A Cell, they're talking about their upcoming match at "WWE Hell In A Cell live this Sunday on the WWE Network." People don't really talk like that and this hokey trope of WWE promos immediately takes viewers out of the show, their suspension of disbelief now impossible.

It doesn't stop there, though.

Whether it's the endless promotion of WWE's charitable activities, Michael Cole's references to the "WWE Universe" instead of "fans", or the refusal to use words like "belt" or "wrestling", the escape that WWE used to provide its audience is ceasing to exist.

Let's be clear. The charity work that WWE does is wonderful, but WWE has been involved in helping the less fortunate for decades. Only since Stephanie McMahon took the newly-created title of Chief Branding Officer in 2013 has WWE's tacky attempts at branding their charity taken center stage. Stephanie McMahon shared her own feelings in a controversial tweet sent out in 2015.

Previously, WWE's charitable activities would be done in a quiet, more tasteful way and not plastered all over their television shows ad nauseam. The charity should be the important part, not the promotion of it.


3. Casual Viewers Have Little Reason To Watch

braun strowman sami zayn
WWE.com

On a weekly basis, the loyal viewers of Monday Night Raw are often forced to sit through an endless amount of replays from nearly every segment. Not only does this irritate the regular viewing audience that watches entire broadcast, but what reason does the casual viewer have to make sure they're tuned in from start to finish?

Another area in which WWE seems to have generally given up on the casual viewer is the way they introduce talents.

Nowadays, Raw viewers are expected to also be NXT viewers based on the lack of promotion or introductory vignettes given to new superstars. Sami Zayn, Kevin Owens, Bayley, and American Alpha are just a few examples of talents that just "showed up" on the main roster one day with little to no preparation time.

Whether it was the Million Dollar Man, Mr. Perfect, Razor Ramon, or Val Venis, many superstars from past generations were built up as big attractions ahead of time so that by the time they debuted in the ring, audiences were familiar with them as characters and would react.

Today, unless you watch NXT (and judging by the number of WWE Network subscribers (1.8 million vs. RAW's 3 million viewers), many don't), the casual fan would have no idea who these new wrestlers are.


2. The Show's Developments Have No Consequences

Bray wyatt triple h
WWE.com

For a long time now, what happens on Raw and SmackDown often does not matter from week-to-week.

Many fans have switched to watching strictly the pay-per-views on WWE Network, opting to skip the weekly dose of Raw and/or SmackDown, and they don't miss anything of importance. In other words, those weekly doses of Raw and SmackDown have meant absolutely nothing.

During the height of WWE's success, one episode of Raw lead to the next, which led to the next, and ultimately to the pay-per-view which would then bridge to the next night's Raw. It was a cycle that worked extremely well and resulted in a record number of people watching RAW every week. It's called episodic television and WWE has apparently forgotten how to write it.

Raw hasn't had that "can't miss" feeling in years. Sure, there are momentws that fans get excited for, like the night after WrestleMania or if WWE promotes an appearance by Goldberg, but even for those shows, the developments don't typically matter six weeks later, much less six months. If any other show on television operated with such a short-sighted view of things, where plots are ignored and don't have any impact from episode-to-episode, they wouldn't be on the air for very long.


1. They Ignore Their Audience

roman reigns wrestlemania 32.jpg
WWE.com

Finally, the number one reason why WWE is losing their audience is really very simple: they ignore them.

Numerous examples of how WWE does this include the well-documented Roman Reigns fiasco and Stephanie McMahon's endless television time emasculating all the talent. It can also be seen with the continuation of a three hour Raw despite declining ratings and overall negative feedback as well as WWE's insistence on featuring gimmick pay-per-views month-after-month no matter what the storylines may be.

Vince McMahon does what he wants to do, not what the fans what him to do. At times, they may coincide but lately, they haven't. It wasn't always like this though.

Whether it was switching to Bret Hart when fans rejected Lex Luger, turning the infamous MSG Curtain Call into the catalyst for the Attitude Era, or riding the momentum of Austin 3:16 despite only hiring Steve to be an in-ring mechanic, McMahon listened to his audience to determine the company's creative direction. It was a proven formula for success.

Nowadays, Vince is more focused on trying to change the audience to want what he, at 71 years-old, wants, and he's failed miserably (see: Roman Reigns).

As a fan, it is frustrating. As a consumer, if you tell a company what you want and they refuse to provide it, you're not going to buy their product. That is exactly what's happening with WWE.


Contributor
Contributor

A former stuntman for Paramount Pictures, Matt enjoys sports, water skiing, driving fast, the beach, professional wrestling, technology, and scotch. At the same time, whenever possible. Having attended many famous (and infamous) shows including WrestleMania XV, In Your House: Mind Games, and the 1995 King of the Ring, Matt has been a lifelong professional sports and wrestling fan. Matt's been mentioned in numerous wrestling podcasts including the Steve Austin Show: Unleashed, Talk Is Jericho, and Something To Wrestle With Bruce Prichard. As a former countywide performer, Matt has been referred to as Mr. 300 for his amazing accomplishments in the world of amateur bowling. He is also the only man on record to have pitched back-to-back no hitters in the Veterans Stadium Wiffle Ball League of 2003.