10 Recent Star-Making Wrestling Performances Nobody Saw Coming
Show me somebody who saw Brodie Lee squashing Cody coming, and I'll show you a liar.
Though WWE have consistently tried to prove otherwise in recent times, no wrestling company can truly survive and inspire people all around the world to routinely tune in without one vital component: stars.
Had 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin not regularly gone to war with his boss, The Rock refused to layeth the SmackDown on his rivals or Hulk Hogan scoffed at the thought of eating his vitamins and saying his prayers, generations of wrestling fans would've likely opted to spend their time doing something else.
But, stars don't just fall into a promoter's lap. In order to create the next big thing (no, not another Brock Lesnar) a wrestler must be built properly and eventually given an effective platform to get over with the fans.
These strategies can sometimes be seen coming a mile away, though, and this can unfortunately lead to a backlash if those paying their hard earned cash feel like they're being forced to cheer for a "company pick".
However, star-making performances aren't always soul-crushingly predictable. Whether it was through an unexpected squash, outstanding debut or seizing one of those imaginary 'brass rings' on the mic, these ten wrestlers all saw an unlikely chance to become the name on everyone's lips and successfully took it.
10. Dominik Mysterio Shines On His Debut Vs. Seth Rollins
Towards the back-end of 2019 it appeared Rey Mysterio's son, Dominik, was being positioned as a potential star of the future. The young performer was heavily involved in his father's feud with Brock Lesnar and even helped nail the 'Beast Incarnate' with a double 619 at Survivor Series.
Dominik was then left out of the spotlight for a spell before unexpectedly returning when his pap's eye was viciously attacked by Seth Rollins in May of this year. In the end, after weeks and weeks of going to war with the 'Monday Night Messiah' and Murphy alongside his father, Dominik was finally given the chance to get his hands on Rollins in a Street Fight at SummerSlam - a match which would also be his WWE debut.
Producing a performance which many full-time WWE talents would struggle to match, Mysterio more than held his own against the former Universal Champion and announced himself as the company's hottest young prospect in the process.
If you needed any more evidence of just how well Dominik did on his first night as an active competitor, the youngster also received a great big hug from WWE Chairman Vince McMahon when he got backstage and was told:
"Very few people can get that kind of reaction whenever they're in the ring. No matter how long they've been in the business. So, you should be very, very proud of yourself."
Not bad for 23 years-old!
9. Shotzi Blackheart Proves She Can Hang With The Best Vs. Io Shirai
For the most part, whenever fans of NXT bring up the topic of Shotzi Blackheart, the conversation tends to centre around the star's tank-assisted entrance and urge to howl every five minutes.
However, underneath her miniature mode of transport and tendency to staple things to her chest, lies a performer who has been quietly improving every single time she steps into the ring. This was never more clear than in her recent showdown against NXT Women's Champion and division standard-bearer Io Shirai on an episode of the black and gold show.
Spending less time pretending to be a wolf and more time matching the champ shot for shot, Blackheart, for the first time, felt like a genuine threat to Shirai's title, even if this was just a non-title encounter.
On top of bringing the fight, Blackheart also sold like an absolute warrior too, making fans believe she genuinely was done for after one particularly gnarly looking German suplex on the side of the apron.
This match may not have catapulted her straight into the current title picture. But, even in defeat, the green-haired 'weirdo' (Wade Barrett's words, not mine) unexpectedly proved she now has the wrestling chops to hang with the very best and back up her truly distinct character.
8. Brodie Lee Makes You Sit Up And Pay Attention Vs. Cody Rhodes
Though Mr. Brodie Lee was definitely being presented in a much more flattering way in the world of All Elite Wrestling than he had been in Vince McMahon's company, he still hadn't properly marked himself out as one of the top guys on Wednesday Nights.
All that changed, however, once he got his terrifying hands on TNT Champion Cody Rhodes on a special recent Saturday Night edition of Dynamite.
Quickly extinguishing the plucky American Nightmare's fire, Lee proceeded to rag-doll the former WWE star around the arena for an uncomfortable amount of time. Successfully squashing one of the biggest names in the promotion and an AEW Executive Vice President wasn't enough, though. Lee went further and sent an uncomfortable message, bringing in the rest of his Dark Order to massacre the entire Nightmare Family.
In one night, Lee went from just another TNT Championship challenger for Cody to overcome to arguably the biggest heel in the company. Sure, he'd eventually lose the belt back to Rhodes down the road. But, make no mistake, this was Mr. Brodie Lee's coming out party and it could also be a sign of darker things to come.
7. Timothy Thatcher Loses Teeth But Gains Respect In The Fight Pit Vs. Matt Riddle
Thanks to the world abruptly going into lockdown and Pete Dunne being stranded in England, Timothy Thatcher was suddenly brought in to pair up with Riddle and the duo actually remarkably retained the NXT Tag Team Championships against Undisputed Era.
So far, so good.
Yet, this honeymoon period didn't last too long. Thatcher eventually walked out on his teammate during another defence which resulted in them losing the titles to Imperium and ultimately facing off against each other later in the night. Despite losing that singles match, Thatcher would continue to attack his former partner. So, a Fight Pit battle between the two was announced for the following week's show.
It was here where Thatcher undoubtedly announced himself as one of NXT's brightest stars. Beating the absolute crap out of the former MMA man, Thatcher's brutal catch wrestling style marked him out as a truly unique prospect and Triple H has regularly shone the spotlight on him ever since.
He may have lost a few teeth in the gritty war of attrition, but he rapidly gained a ridiculous amount of respect from fans all around the globe and his 'Thatch-as-Thatch-can' promo segments have quickly become one of the most unexpectedly interesting features on the black and yellow brand.
6. Dakota Kai Pushes The Champion To The Limit Vs. Io Shirai
Without a shadow of a doubt, NXT's Women's division is currently the most stacked in all of WWE and arguably the world right now.
That's why it shouldn't have come as much of a surprise when Dakota Kai absolutely solidified herself as a credible main eventer during her recent feud with NXT Women's Champion Io Shirai. But, to many, it did.
Shirai had been consistently putting on decent displays during her feud with old pal Tegan Nox and the heel even scored herself a typical towering sidekick in Raquel Gonzalez. But, some fans still doubted whether she could believably pose a threat to the impressive Shirai coming into TakeOver: XXX.
However, by putting on a career-best performance at the landmark event, Kai thoroughly ensured that Shirai well and truly met her match, surprisingly leaning more on her underrated prowess in the ring than the usual heelish bending of the rules.
Her excellent display, regardless of the fact she didn't lift the NXT Women's Championship on the night, eventually earned her a ton of praise from none other than Triple H himself, with the Executive Producer of NXT claiming:
"Hats off to Dakota Kai just earning it every step of the way, and win or lose man, she had a star-making night across the board. She is a player. Absolutely, and one of the best in-ring female performers in the world. Bar none."
Though very few saw the New Zealander as a serious top name in NXT's Women's division at the start of 2020, Kai has now forced herself into the conversation and will likely only improve further in the coming months.
5. Orange Cassidy Actually 'Tries' Vs. PAC
A year ago, back when AEW Dynamite was in its infancy, if someone told you arguably one of the most over performers in the company would be a dude who wrestles with his hands in his pockets, you probably would've chuckled right in their face.
But, a year is a long time and something rather insane happened mid-way through this particular 12 month spell.
After spending weeks and months acting like he'd rather be anywhere else but locking up with AEW's finest, Orange Cassidy was finally booked in his first ever singles match for the company at Revolution against 'The Bastard' PAC. Only this time, his Best Friend pals revealed that he was actually going to 'try'.
The crowd went wild at this announcement on the Dynamite prior to the PPV, but that was nothing compared to the sound which met Cassidy during the eventual showdown.
After producing a few flickers of offence throughout the match, Cassidy finally let rip and the roof of the Wintrust Arena very nearly took off. Proving once and for all that he possessed the ability to go toe to toe with one of the best on the planet, 'Freshly Squeezed' went from light-hearted comic relief to bonafide superstar in one jaw-dropping encounter.
Seriously, go back and watch some of the reactions which went down during this bout. It'll send shivers up your spine... and also make you deeply depressed remembering what live crowds used to sound like.
4. Keith Lee Outshines The Big Dog For NXT Vs. Raw Vs. SmackDown
When NXT suddenly crashed the main roster Survivor Series party in 2019, you had a feeling something special was on the horizon. However, few people foresaw the black and gold brand actually coming out on top by the end of the historic PPV. But win they did and a number of rising stars more than made a game-changing impact on the night.
Yet, one particular performer, who had been slowly gathering a bit of momentum on Wednesday nights, unexpectedly walked out of the show as the most in-demand man in the company.
We're talking of course about the unstoppable Keith Lee, a star who almost single handedly toppled two thirds of The Shield in the closing stretch of an anything but typical Survivor Series Elimination match.
Sure, he wasn't able to conquer The Big Dog and earn NXT yet another point on the board that night, but he did enough to get people talking and they would continue to do so right up until the moment he made his Monday Night Raw debut in August 2020.
Things may not have gone exactly to plan so far since officially joining the main roster, but the former NXT and North American Champion has proven before that he is absolutely capable of making himself the centre of attention when we all least expect it.
3. Kyle O'Reilly Breaks The Prince's Jaw Vs. Finn Bálor
At a time when many had started to question whether NXT's ability to create future stars was on the wane, one thrown together Gauntlet Elimination match suggested otherwise.
Outlasting other future stars such as Cameron Grimes, Bronson Reed, Kushida and Timothy Thatcher, none other than Undisputed Era's Kyle O'Reilly scored himself an NXT Championship date at TakeOver: 31 with Finn Bálor.
Even with just a solitary week's worth of build, this contest immediately felt special and, after a rather intense sit-down face-to-face, O'Reilly suddenly went from tag team specialist to a singles performer capable of toppling the newly crowned Prince in the eyes of the NXT faithful.
Delivering on this set-up and then some, O'Reilly successfully beat the living piss out of a star he'd been chasing for years. But he wouldn't escape unscathed, carrying a debilitating liver injury throughout much of a match he would ultimately lose.
It was this ability to fight through the pain, though coupled with a demonstration of his top of the card calibre in-ring skill-set, which helped mark O'Reilly out as a serious potential superstar at the most recent TakeOver event.
The question is: Was this simply a one-off dance in the spotlight? Or will O'Reilly continue his unanticipated quest to truly become Undisputed?
2. Sonya Deville Tears Into Her Former Best Friend Vs. Mandy Rose
This unexpected star-making moment may not have gone down during a match or in front of any sort of live crowd, but Sonya Deville undoubtedly announced herself in a big way regardless a few months back.
Just a couple of weeks removed from a potentially friendship ending revelation, involving Deville conspiring with Dolph Ziggler to keep Mandy Rose and Otis apart, the Fire & Desire duo met face-to-face in the middle of an empty Performance Center.
A career-best stretch on the mic soon exploded from the former MMA fighter's mouth.
Impressively switching gears from remorseful best pal to cold, calculated villain in the blink of an eye, Deville flexed promo muscles which many previously hadn't seen from her before. In this moment, Deville successfully forced fans all around the world to invest in her budding feud with Rose and kickstarted what would become arguably the most engaging programme in WWE throughout the crowd-less era.
Her journey may have come to an abrupt end at SummerSlam, due to the star losing a 'Loser Leaves WWE' match against her old partner, but this is merely the beginning of a bold new period in Deville's wrestling career. Expect her to take whatever brand she shows up on next by storm once she finally makes her return.
1. Jey Uso Refuses To Bow To The Tribal Chief Vs. Roman Reigns
You may have noticed a certain theme throughout this list: The majority of these recent star-making performances have come from wrestlers who didn't actually have their hand raised at the end of the contest.
Sure enough, Jey Uso also falls into that category, but once again the result simply did not matter come the conclusion of this year's Clash of Champions.
During the build-up to this cousin vs. cousin Universal Championship showdown, the newly badass Roman Reigns had regularly reminded his own blood that he simply wasn't on his level and this upcoming match was merely a surprising pay-day for the tag team star. But, it was clearly so much more to the twin who'd spent his life being asked, 'Which one are you?'
Producing the performance of his life in the biggest in-ring moment of his career, Jey attacked, bumped and sold like the main event-level babyface his cousin arrogantly claimed he could never be. All before being pummelled into oblivion by the increasingly unsettling 'Tribal Chief' and forcing his brother to stop the match.
But Jey never quit and in doing so he suddenly established himself as WWE's latest organic, plucky, underdog star.
When a talent is drafted before the Mysterios, one of the most promising names in the company (Big E) and Mr. Money in the Bank, that should tell all you need to know about what the future holds for this unanticipated SmackDown hit.