10 Recent WWE Rivalries That Underwhelmed In The Ring

AJ Styles vs. Shinsuke Nakamura is far from the feud that didn't meet fans' lofty expectations.

Dean Ambrose Chris Jericho
WWE.com

On paper, AJ Styles vs. Shinsuke Nakamura is a high-profile program that ideally should have kicked off this apparent new era on SmackDown Live with a bang. Fans had been clamoring for them to do battle inside a WWE ring since their exceptional encounter at Wrestle Kingdom 10 two years ago, and finally, that dream match became a reality at WrestleMania 34.

Unfortunately, fans were left unimpressed by what they witnessed from Styles and Nakamura that night, to say the least. While it was unquestionably an entertaining outing, it was by no means the instant classic fans had high hopes for. Worse yet, their last two rematches weren't quite up to snuff, either.

In their defense, Styles and Nakamura aren't the only athletes to fall short of fans' expectations in the ring. In some cases, certain superstars don't have the chemistry fans imagined they would, or the creative could be lacking. Time constraints can play a factor as well.

There are several other storylines that should have been much bigger (and better) than they were, but for whatever reason, the matches underwhelmed and are remembered for the wrong reasons - if they're remembered at all.

10. CM Punk Vs. The Shield

CM Punk The Shield Old School Raw
WWE.com

It was pretty apparent dating all the way back to SummerSlam 2013 that CM Punk was destined to fight Triple H at WrestleMania XXX. In the meantime, he would attempt to fend off all of The Authority's cronies, including The Shield at the tail-end of 2013.

Consisting of Dean Ambrose, Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns, The Shield was quite the cohesive stable and each of its members were outstanding athletes. Therefore, them having great matches with Punk should have been academic, but sadly, the focus of that feud was on anything but the quality of their matches.

In retrospect, it's clear Punk was at the end of his rope at that point and didn't care about having the best match of the night anymore. He phoned it in almost every time against The Shield, whereas the cracks were starting to show within the ranks of the rebellious faction as well. They spent far too much time teasing tension than proving themselves against the former two-time WWE champion, which is why their matches aren't remembered too fondly by fans.


9. Charlotte Flair Vs. Natalya

charlotte natalya
WWE.com

There can be no denying that Charlotte Flair and Natalya were a major reason why women's wrestling was taken to the next level starting in 2014. Their clash for the NXT Women's Championship at NXT TakeOver that May was a work of art and proved not only Natalya still had "it" but also that Charlotte was a star in the making.

Thus, there was excitement surrounding the renewal of their rivalry in 2016, and rightfully so. Charlotte was at the top of her game at that point as a heel, whereas it was refreshing to see Natalya getting a crack at the championship at long last. Once they faced off at Payback 2016, however, it became evident that the magic they shared from two years earlier was no longer there.

What started out as a solid match quickly went off the rails when the referee randomly called for the bell while Natalya was in the Figure Eight, which was designed to mirror the Montreal Screwjob. The "I Quit" rematch later that month at Extreme Rules was also painfully boring and ended in uneventful fashion when Dana Brooke interfered to cost Natalya the win.


8. John Cena Vs. Alberto Del Rio

John Cena Alberto Del Rio
WWE.com

Alberto Del Rio's meteoric rise to the top of WWE in 2011 saw him rub shoulders with the very best in the business at the time: Edge, Christian, CM Punk and John Cena. Most of the matches he had with those individuals were pretty good, but his biggest opportunity to shine came against Cena that fall when they feuded over the WWE Championship.

The Mexican Aristocrat had all the tools necessary to be a major star for years to come ... so long as he could have a great match with Cena. Ultimately, he failed, because their Night of Champions encounter was hardly anything special (not to mention he lost clean). That could have been chalked up to a number of things, but when they didn't deliver the goods at Hell in a Cell or Vengeance, only their stunning lack of in-ring chemistry could be blamed.

That continued to be the case any time they did battle in the years that followed (including in 2013, 2015 and 2016). Here's hoping we've seen the last of these two producing mediocre matches together.


7. The New Day Vs. The Dudley Boyz

The New Day Dudley Boyz
WWE.com

To be fair, no one expected The Dudley Boyz and The New Day to deliver five-star mat classics when their feud first started in the summer of 2015. However, considering how hot both acts were at the time, their program really should have been a turning point for WWE's depleted tag team division and not another run-of-the-mill rivalry.

First and foremost, WWE did them no favors by rushing into their first-ever outing on the 31 August edition of Raw. It was an enjoyable one, but not exactly what fans were hoping for from the two tandems. That said, it was believed they were holding out for their WWE Tag Team Championship clash at Night of Champions the following month.

Well, that was a fairly basic bout as well, except with a marred finish due to Xavier Woods intentionally getting New Day disqualified. Their rematch at the Madison Square Garden live special shortly thereafter was no different, and then their final encounter (which was average at best) at Hell in a Cell essentially solidified The Dudley Boyz as glorified enhancement talent.


6. Dean Ambrose Vs. Chris Jericho

dean ambrose chris jericho
WWE.com

Dean Ambrose and Chris Jericho were originally set to feud going into WrestleMania 32, but their program was pushed back so Ambrose could work with Lesnar. Perhaps that was for the best based off how the Ambrose vs. Jericho feud ended up shaking out.

Granted, Ambrose beat Jericho on back-to-back pay-per-views and those victories were what eventually launched him into WWE Championship contention, but the matches themselves left a lot to be desired. For a feud that should have been a lot less tame than it was, they simply didn't have a ton of chemistry against each other, largely having good-but-not-great matches every time.

That was especially evident at Extreme Rules when they fought in the first-ever (and thankfully only) Ambrose Asylum match. Basically, it was a steel cage with weapons attached at the top, but none of the "foreign objects" were particularly lethal.

It didn't help that the match dragged on, and on, and on, boring everyone in attendance as a result. Following that catastrophe of a contest, most fans would be content if they never saw another Ambrose vs. Jericho match again.


5. AJ Styles Vs. Kevin Owens

AJ Styles Kevin Owens
WWE.com

The 2017 Superstar Shake-up was more of a hindrance to SmackDown Live than a help, but at least they were left with two top talents in AJ Styles and Kevin Owens. They were set to feud coming out of WrestleMania 33 over the United States Championship and be positioned as the primary program on Tuesday nights due to Randy Orton vs. Jinder Mahal not being terribly exciting.

Unfortunately, Styles vs. Owens wasn't much of an improvement. Sure, their bout at Backlash 2017 was well-wrestled, but every one of their encounters after that fell flat. Their rematch at Battleground (with the botched finish) was easily the worst of the bunch and their SummerSlam match was equally underwhelming.

The only time Owens and Styles came close to contesting a classic with the star-spangled prize on the line was when Chris Jericho returned and the three battled in a Triple Threat on SmackDown. On top of that, Creative wasn't kind to their feud in the slightest and nothing was done to help elevate the U.S. title or either guy.


4. Brock Lesnar Vs. Randy Orton

Brock Lesnar, Randy Orton
WWE.com

After having a hot 2015, Brock Lesnar's 2016 was the exact opposite. It started with a disappointing No Holds Barred match with Dean Ambrose at WrestleMania 32 and continued with what should have been a blockbuster bout against Randy Orton at SummerSlam.

The hype was real. After all, these two both had roots in Ohio Valley Wrestling yet never crossed path on WWE's main roster (aside from a one-off SmackDown squash in September 2002). This was their chance to go all out and fight for the right to call themselves the biggest breakout star of their generation.

After such a strong build, the match was a major letdown. It was bad enough that they traded finishers back and forth for 10 minutes, but Lesnar busting Orton open before the referee called for the bell was a lousy finish.

An argument can be made that it "legitimized" Lesnar (more than before), but having that be the way SummerSlam went off the air was inexcusable. On the bright side, this was a one-and-done deal and a rematch was never held. Lesnar later lost to Goldberg in under two minutes, rendering this victory completely irrelevant.


3. AJ Lee Vs. Paige

AJ Lee Paige
WWE.com

The Divas division was in a deplorable state for several years, and there was a point where it appeared to be on the verge of extinction. The women rarely got time for their matches or for their feuds, and although AJ Lee's record-setting reign as Divas champion breathed new life into the division, she still lacked real competition.

Enter Paige.

If anyone was capable of bringing change to women's wrestling in WWE, it was the inaugural NXT Women's champion, who contested a Match of the Year candidate with Emma at NXT Arrival in February 2014. Fans had similar expectations for her feud with AJ, which didn't officially get underway until AJ returned from her sabbatical that summer.

The roles being reversed with Paige as the heel and AJ as the babyface freshened things up a bit, but the fans waited, and waited, and waited for them to have a blow-away bout. Their string of matches on pay-per-view were far too short to be anything of note, and the Divas Championship bouncing back and forth between the two made fans care even less.


2. Dean Ambrose Vs. Bray Wyatt

Dean Ambrose Bray Wyatt 2016
WWE.com

Around the same time AJ Lee and Paige were putting on matches that under-delivered, Dean Ambrose and Bray Wyatt were embroiled in a ruthless rivalry as well, or at least it was supposed to be a ruthless rivalry. We never truly found out why Wyatt was targeting Ambrose in the fall of 2014, but what was clear was that their matches really weren't that great.

Their initial outing at Survivor Series ended on a disqualification, so it was understandable that the matchup wasn't too memorable. They then had the chance to steal the show in the main event of the next month's pay-per-view in a Tables, Ladders, and Chairs match, but there no sense of a story told and both men didn't come across as motivated whatsoever.

Ambrose and Wyatt followed up that disappointing performance with another underwhelming encounter on the premiere episode of Raw in 2015, this time in an Ambulance match. Ambrose losing every single time killed any momentum he might have had, but regardless of the outcomes, they just didn't gel as well as expected.


1. Daniel Bryan Vs. Randy Orton

daniel bryan randy orton
WWE.com

WWE caught lightning in a bottle with the conclusion to SummerSlam 2013 where Daniel Bryan won the WWE Championship from John Cena before Triple H and Randy Orton turned heel to take the title from him. That shocking series of events set the stage for what could have been an exciting fall season, but instead, The Authority ruled WWE programming and made Bryan look like a loser at every turn.

Fans were also hopeful that Bryan vs. Orton would be a fresh feud over the prestigious prize, and it was. However, their matches earlier in the year on Raw were much better than the string of pay-per-view matches they had toward the end of 2013. None of their championship clashes reached that next level, and Bryan even admitted his own disappointment with the matches in his autobiography years later.

In theory, Bryan being beat by Orton and The Authority on every show should have led to him getting his big moment, likely at Hell in a Cell. Not only did the final match in their rivalry fail to feel like a true blow-off, Bryan lost yet again. It wasn't until WrestleMania 30 that he'd finally get his due, but only after the fans demanded it.


Contributor
Contributor

Since 2008, Graham has been a diehard pro wrestling fan and, in 2010, he combined his passions for WWE and writing when he joined Bleacher Report. Equipped with a master's in journalism, Graham has contributed to WhatCulture, FanSided's Daily DDT, Sports Betting Dime, and GateHouse Media. Along the way, he has conducted interviews with wrestling superstars like Chris Jericho, Edge, Goldberg, Christian, Diamond Dallas Page, Jim Ross, Adam Cole, Tessa Blanchard, Ryback, and Nick Aldis among others.