10 Secrets To Vince McMahon's Success
It's all about the mon-ayyy.
WWE's Q3 financial results make for sobering reading.
Revenue hit a major high for what, traditionally, is a barren spell. While live attendances dropped, higher ticket prices and an inflated circuit compensated. Network subscriptions, albeit slowly, continue to justify the abandonment of the fading pay-per-view model. The mutual money generated by TV licensing, the company's most lucrative revenue stream, arms WWE with a strong negotiating hand.
It seems impossible to reconcile. While the buzz ahead of Sunday's Survivor Series is swarming (helped in no small part by a rare, hasty acknowledgement of failure), 2017 has not been WWE's best year, creatively. Far from it: Jinder Mahal reigned not supreme, but as a transparent rupee scheme, as WWE Heavyweight Champion. Bray Wyatt also won the WWE Heavyweight crown while still leading the charge for the 2017 Gooker Prize. Bayley was ruined. Shinsuke Nakamura was ruined. Bobby Roode was ruined. Brock Lesnar F5'd a shark in the 2003 SummerSlam promo; in 2017, he jumped it. 2017 is a year defined by self-indulgence and self-sabotage.
And yet, the prospect of Survivor Series is so exciting that it almost single-handedly reinforces Vince McMahon's genius - a genius shaped by factors beyond himself...
10. Old Money & Ruthless Aggression
The New York territory provided Vince McMahon with the perfect platform on which to launch his early 1980s nationalisation strategy.
The Madison Square Garden epicentre always represented a major payday for the travelling independent contractors of old, and acted as the primary lure for those turned by McMahon's monopoly attempt. With the moneyed northeast territory bequeathed to him by his father, Vince McMahon held the richest hand. In the plainest terms possible, McMahon simply threw that old money at the biggest draws of a splintered, superstar-powered landscape, which soon coalesced, ironically, under McMahon's divisive vision of "sports entertainment".
The National Wrestling Alliance model was oddly socialistic, given the country over which it ruled. McMahon's victory was secured through the very essence of capitalism. He likely wasn't the only man to recognise how antiquated the old model was - but, spurred by the game-changing advent of the cable television revolution, he was the only man with the transgressive balls to destroy its sacred, crumbling ground.
9. A Galaxy Of Stars
McMahon, well-renowned for a superiority complex over what he would later refer to as wrasslin', was nevertheless not above plagiarism.
WrestleMania wasn't quite his brainchild; Starrcade was its spiritual antecedent. McMahon didn't even name WrestleMania; Howard Finkel did, inspired by the Beatles. Still, McMahon's promotional drive was entirely his own; by devising the Rock N' Wrestling era, cross-promoting with the white-hot MTV, and borrowing stars from the "real" wing of celebrity (pity the fool who underestimates Mr. T's contribution to the WWF's expansion), McMahon framed the inaugural WrestleMania as pro wrestling's debutante ball. The public was mesmerised by the talismanic Hulk Hogan, the viciously charismatic Roddy Piper, the impossibly massive André The Giant, and the glamorous Wendi Richter.
In short order, the WWF, after the failed experiment that was WrestleMania 2, grew in popularity to such an extent they crammed a stupendous (though false) number into the Pontiac Silverdome for 'Mania III. The subsequent influx of memorable (and McMahon-modified) megastars - the minted mega-heel Ted DiBiase, the insanely intense Randy Savage, the simply insane Ultimate Warrior, scores of others - stacked the WWF so heavily that it evolved from fad to cultural cornerstone.
To McMahon's immense credit, this fit of creativity and commerciality remains unparalleled.
8. Pat Patterson
Pat Patterson was an invaluable henchman who contributed massively to the WWF's growth.
A veritable wrestling genius, Patterson's most famed creation was the Royal Rumble - the initial pitch for which McMahon rejected out of hand with the condemnation "stupid". A clearer head - and astute trust - prevailed; the Rumble did materialise, and became a hallmark of WWE. It's almost as enticing to lapsed fans as WrestleMania. The match layout is such genius - when else would fans actively, and loudly, count down every last appearance knowing it might be a Tom Brandi, a Mantaur, or a Michael Cole? - that people will still buzz in Philadelphia, despite the stain left on the January classic by Roman Reigns in recent years.
This expertise extended to the remaining 11 months; Patterson was and is a major component of so much storytelling brilliance. The WWF was never the most athletic wrestling company. It was never the most technically proficient, nor the most violent, nor the most realistic - but with Agent Patterson at the helm, it was almost the most dramatic, the most memorable.
7. Hulk Hogan
Vince McMahon, on the Road to WrestleMania XIX, described Hulk Hogan perfectly as a "slice of Americana".
Hogan embedded himself into the bedrock of American culture because he was the greatest worker in the history of the business. He benefitted from the WWF's production bells and whistles, for sure. His trademark red and yellow colour scheme was as iconic as it was marketable. His theme, Real American, was the aural translation of a fist pump - a triumphant anthem in which the hysterical backing vocals echoed the crazed reactions the magnetic Hogan was able to generate just by ripping his shirt off.
'Real American', to this day, erases the pitted dread generated by Hogan's dark later years, and makes the hairs on the back of your neck stand to undivided attention. It's fitting; Hogan was himself able to instantly transmit hope and euphoria with his G.O.A.T. crowd manipulation.
McMahon saw in Hogan what his old boss, the traditionalist Verne Gagne, could not bring himself to: Hogan, technically limited, was the new face of professional wrestling.
With expertly protective booking, Hogan genuinely felt Immortal in his '80s pomp.
6. Kevin Dunn
Kevin Dunn is persona non grata within the wrestling fandom, largely as a result of his documented hatred of - but massive influence over - professional wrestling. When he isn't making you sick with his various prejudices, he makes you motion sick with his multiple camera angles.
All that said: while Dunn has lost his touch in recent years (he seems to hate wrestling fans so much that he obscures them under garish lighting), his production nous propelled the WWF into elusive glitz territory.
Even Jim Crockett Promotions, the WWF's closest competitor, looked positively retrograde in comparison. Revisiting one of their major events, Starrcade '86: The Night of the Skywalkers, presents a stark comparison. The Greensboro Coliseum is cloaked in dingy darkness. Worked or otherwise, the publicised attendance of 30,000 just feels wrong; at times, the show looks deserted - and, consequently, small fry. Meanwhile, over in the WWF, the DayGlo bombast and the bright lights framed an inferior in-ring product as ultra-glamorous.
Credit, too, must go to David Sahadi - the man whose virtuoso vignettes ushered in an era of epic, borderline cinematic hype videos. And Jim Johnston, whose iconic, sting-laced entrance themes have firmly embedded themselves into the earlobes for decades.
5. Ted Turner
Vince McMahon first reacted to Ted Turner's arrival into his arena with the defensive lashing out of a child.
The infamous, reviled 'Billionaire Ted' skits of 1996 were damning stuff. The intention was to position the WWF as state-of-the-art; in reality, McMahon's failures manifested onscreen as pitiful desperation. McMahon, apoplectic, also wrote to Ted and dressed him down for allowing blading on WCW television in 1996. He wrote that this "encouraged practice of self mutilation is disgusting, violent, [and] potentially infectious."
McMahon didn't just have balls the size of grapefruits: he had a brass neck. One year removed from this petty business, he exposed himself as a hypocrite by lifting the blade ban (or turning a winked eye to it). Two years removed, and the WWF was awash with bloodshed. The lack of claret in WCW compelled him to fill in the blanks.
This was symptomatic of what Turner's two-year period of dominance did; Turner and Eric Bischoff awakened the bloodthirsty beast from his creative slumber, and moved him to translate the confidence generated by his offscreen court room success into his company's second boom period.
4. A New Galaxy Of Stars (And, Yes, Vince Russo)
As Turner and Bischoff dominated the North American scene, McMahon was gradually coerced into change.
Steve Austin petitioned to add a foul-mouthed cutting edge to his character. Shawn Michaels and Triple H sensed the attitudinal shift in wider society, and urged McMahon to grab the lowbrow zeitgeist. And, yes, Vince Russo seduced McMahon into both lowering the tone and accepting his fate as a heel - thus formally creating the Mr. McMahon character.
He also knew who not to listen to; Bret Hart was firmly against the WWF's crude new direction in 1997 - to such an extent that he wouldn't allow his children to watch - and Vince elected to ignore his antiquated vision for pro wrestling. Hart was a genius in the ring, but he wasn't prescient. Those who were enjoyed the next level of mainstream success as McMahon, eventually, rekindled his creative genius. McMahon's instincts didn't fail him, even if his narrow vision threatened to.
A quick side note on the much-missed, dearly-departed and little-known Chris Kreski - the man who steered the creative ship behind the magnificent year 2000. Even before his untimely 2005 death, the man was unassuming to a degree Russo wasn't, despite being as responsible for the WWF's second mainstream boom period.
3. John Cena
John Cena was the perfect choice to lead WWE into the lucrative PG Era.
Yes, he represented a reversion to type. In his garish colour scheme, comeback routine and triumvirate of moral mantras, Cena was very much the modern Hulk Hogan - but can you blame McMahon? Despite nightly showers of abuse from the older set wise to the trick, Cena was a super-charismatic and super-dedicated workhorse whose immense popularity secured a new generation of fans - and cosy arrangements with several sponsors, the likes of which would not have touched WWE, had Cena's beaming, child-friendly visage not acted as a lure. Cena was similarly PR-friendly; his work with the Make-A-Wish Foundation in particular was fundamental in scrubbing the company's public image, post-Chris Benoit.
That garish, ever-evolving colour scheme also helped WWE shift a ludicrous amount of merchandise - helpful in determining the scope of Cena's enduring appeal in an age in which traditional metrics started to fall by the wayside.
Cena is a hero to kids, and a big match worker even to those reluctant to outwardly praise him - and his house show pull hasn't yet been picked up.
2. Balls The Size Of Grapefruits
Grapefruit-sized balls, stubbornness, strength of conviction: call it what you will. McMahon's single-mindedness is what has elevated WWE into the single-most successful wrestling company to have ever existed.
McMahon formally terminated kayfabe, in 1989, in order to avoid steep regulation. People were p*ssed. He was not remotely bothered. You only need watch any footage of the WWF's Golden Age to determine that 99% of those physiques were artificially inflated - and McMahon still defeated the federal government in his steroid trial. He floated his company on the stock exchange - his pro wrestling company.
Even his failures were gloriously noble; the XFL was a financial catastrophe, but there's something hilarious and telling about the mentality behind it. McMahon thought himself capable of competing with the NFL. Of course he's going to get something unforeseen over. McMahon even flaunted one of many deaths under his watch in the face of his widow, 24 hours later, in a sociopathic drive to absolve his company of it.
He resisted the urge to turn John Cena heel when virtually every wrestling fan above a certain age begged him to do it. Paradoxically, he risked the safe option - but then, that's McMahon: a fascinating maze of contradictions.
1. Genuine Genius
Vince McMahon's historical genius is self-evident: bluntly, he did not come to oversee an empire, no matter how well-placed he was to build it, without possessing genuine brilliance.
As a storyline performer, McMahon was arguably wrestling's best ever - a hammy, hilarious, hysterical entertainment machine with a killer grasp of the catharsis at wrestling's core. As a promotor, McMahon was inarguably wrestling's greatest ever; even if he sometimes stumbled a*se-backwards into revelations - like the Undertaker's WrestleMania Streak - he held the nous to kick into a higher gear.
He sees things we'll never see; the ridiculous potential within Braun Strowman; the star power in Batista, who most pegged as a generic hoss; the subversive possibilities lurking within the anachronistic Kurt Angle persona, circa 1999...
His enduring genius still exists, despite the self-indulgence granted through the comfort of absolute market dominance. Sami Zayn, by his own account, thought he should act the tough guy following his recent heel turn. McMahon disagreed; "big smile out there," he instructed, per Zayn's appearance on the E&C Pod of Awesomeness. It worked: this new Zayn is brilliantly obnoxious.
McMahon is a wrestling genius; he's just been allowed to rest on his laurels for far too long.