10 Specific Ways WWE Could Debut NXT Stars On The Main Roster
How to make it Purple Rain.
The current model is not working out.
At all.
WWE debuts a raft of NXT graduates on the flagship brands immediately following WrestleMania. The casual audience is left to interpret that these men and women and tag teams are stars because the hardcore set invariably receives them as such. The strategy is profoundly careless, given that we are rarely given any further reason to invest - and it's also profoundly counterproductive. The arrival of a new star should be a massive deal. It used to be. But because we are asked to process so much new information, we cannot register it all, hence why an act like Ember Moon was so quickly absorbed into the RAW fabric, hardly helped by the 50/50 booking that plagues virtually every main roster performer from Vince McMahon pet projects all the way down to those he deems living sneezes.
Why was Ember Moon even called up, if only to wander aimlessly around the midcard, defeating Liv Morgan (RAW, July 9) only to lose to Sarah Logan (July 16) only to defeat Liv Morgan (July 23) again? It was just her time, and the deathly connotations of those five words mirror the diminished mystique of her character.
A new moon must rise, and for WWE to alter the star-free skyline, the actual characters of the NXT roster must be considered.
10. Velveteen Dream
The Dream is driven by infamy.
The Dream has no time to waste against local competitors, nor the tragically unglamorous likes of Tye Dillinger. The Dream doesn't wrestle mundane matches; he provides his flock of fawning followers with "experiences". He wants you, desperately, to say his name, and you are not going to say it on a random episode of RAW as he goes 50/50 with Bobby Roode following a token two-minute win over a jobber on the post-'Mania RAW.
To serve and put over the most alluring and unique WWE self-creation in aeons, the Dream must immediately challenge and share his cherished spotlight with one of the main roster's leading lights. In this fitful era, in which we aren't to know who exactly will glow from one week to the next, he must also challenge one of the main roster's most protected and most enduring acts. Given the sometimes sloppy and disjointed nature of Dream's longer matches, he must also challenge a seasoned veteran to guide his shining light.
Enter AJ Styles.
There is quite the contrast between The Phenomenal One and The Dream. The Dream, you can imagine, would not appreciate the drab furnishings of the house AJ built, and so long as AJ remembers his PG surroundings, this tale of glamour versus grit writes itself.
9. Aleister Black
Aleister Black is a stoic presence on NXT television.
He is unflappable - a deathly serious practitioner of the martial arts only moved into a personal response, a response manifested with his awesome striking game, when provoked by the despicable. The most despicable heel on the main roster must provoke Black into showcasing the explosiveness with which he has, perhaps a little too quietly, connected with the Full Sail faithful. The Miz is a contender for most despicable, but his promo work is a little too prodding for an act as delicately balanced as Black's. What is framed in NXT as earnest and dark, Miz would likely make light of, using dreaded winking pop culture references to steer the character into Cheer Up Goth territory.
Randy Orton seems a more suitable antagonist.
He isn't glib; he is vicious, and he boasts a storyline weapon as sudden in its deadliness as the Black Mass. A simple televised game of avoidance and oneupmanship, predicated not on lengthy promos but physical storytelling, would create a genuine sense of intrigue ahead of their inaugural, high-stakes pay-per-view meeting.
8. EC3
You could make the following argument about most members of the main roster, current or imminent, in an era in which several of those who perform on it come equipped with heightened auras.
We often admonish the creative regime for its reckless treatment of those they are paid to promote, but we live in a strange new paradigm, post-NXT. The in-ring standard of that roster is incredible (when not over-produced). Several become part of it having conditioned their fans to expect the incredible, and having shown their main event credentials either in NXT or on the Independent circuit. Really, it's a roster crammed with main event talents, and though the slowed progress of an Andrade "Cien" Almas is inexplicable in a vacuum, the levelled landscape is something of an inevitability about which little can be done. With so little separating so many in terms of quality, and WWE's recruitment process greedy in the extreme, is it any wonder that they become sadly indistinguishable?
But EC3's entire act is predicated on his superiority.
The 1%, if we are to take him at all seriously, must dominate the 99%. It's so simple as to be mathematical, and this is something that has already weakened his standing in the ordinarily expert NXT environment.
A petulant EC3 on RAW, apoplectic at the parade of enhancement talents thrown his way by an eternally distracted and put-upon Kurt Angle, would reinforce his entitlement and create an inroad into a career-making GM scalp-taking.
7. Kairi Sane
It’s impossible not to approach this entry with a degree of cynicism.
It’s borderline racist to compare Kairi Sane with Asuka, purely because they share the same nationality, but it’s also borderline stupid not to expect WWE to do exactly that. This is a company that has long since depicted countless characters with an unhealthy and regressive focus. How long did it take WWE to remind everybody that Asuka is, in fact, Japanese, and unable to confidently spar with Alexa Bliss on the microphone?
Worse still, Sane is the sort of genuinely likeable and engaging character that tends not to do well in a company unable to gauge what makes a performer likeable and engaging. What the audience sees as endearing, WWE sees as geeky. A debut programme with Asuka, whose only redemption at this point lies within a heel turn, promises electric in-ring action but is patently unrealistic given that neither woman is particularly fluent in English and thus unable to build a feud via the mandated, lengthy verbal segments.
Ultimately, within WWE’s sports entertainment approach, perhaps the best way of channelling Sane’s cute strand of sympathy is by booking the IIconics to bully her ahead of a mini-series that eventually showcases her incredible flying elbow finish universal in its jaw-dropping appeal.
6. Lars Sullivan
All that written in the EC3 slide aside, booking a destroyer is as simple as the answer to the question Is Roman Reigns going to get the f*ck booed out of him at the Barclays Center?
WWE needs to learn lessons, already, from the Authors of Pain. Those lessons are: throw hapless skinny wimps at the big powerful men, on a weekly basis so that we don't think of them as unimportant, and have those big powerful men beat the ever-loving sh*t out of the wimps to satisfy our craven, vicarious bloodlust.
To build Lars Sullivan as the monster he so obviously is - he looks like one, which should help but is no guarantee of it - simply throw skinny wimps at the big powerful man, on a weekly basis so that we don't think of him as unimportant, and have that big powerful man beat the ever-loving sh*t out of the wimps to satisfy our craven, vicarious bloodlust. Lars did this to great effect before the main event-level match duration exposed him at TakeOver: Chicago, and though a man of his proportions may fare better under the watchful, leering eye of the size-obsessed Vince McMahon, he must be maintained gradually as a monster.
He must be sharpened by the more strenuous main roster touring circuit before being tasked with another feature bout beyond his current level of experience.
5. Ricochet
Anywhere but 205 Live, essentially.
His debuting directly on RAW or SmackDown may represent something of a plot hole - he is the best high-flier in the company - but then, WWE is a fictional universe in which Carmella is better positioned than Asuka, and in which the lighter Finn Bálor is a main roster fixture. Logical barely applies.
Debuting Ricochet on that show does make some sense. If anybody is capable of raising the crowds from the dead, it is a borderline supernatural performer capable of raising the pulse rate like no other. But Ricochet, simply, is too much of a potential difference-maker for a show on which nothing makes a difference - not the offscreen stripped-back stewardship of Triple H, not the onscreen coherent management style of Drake Maverick, not consistently very good matches, not anything.
Instead, Ricochet should arrive on one of the flagship shows to turn (and rotate) heads in the babyface role through being targeted, immediately, by an objectively unpopular wrestler unpopular as a result of his ancient ring style: Jinder Mahal.
Unlike Roman Reigns, fans, at the sight of Ricochet trapped in a dreaded chinlock, would be mobilised into supporting him, knowing d*mn well the extent to which he is Jinder’s incredible polar opposite. WWE should only tease the tedium. Have Ricochet immediately flip out of Mahal’s mundane rest holds.
Make it clear to the audience that this is a completely new breed of pro wrestling athlete by preying on a longstanding in-ring gripe.
4. Shayna Baszler
Shayna Baszler is a savage submission machine. The natural - inevitable - major opponent is WWE’s other savage submission machine: Ronda Rousey. This is a money match that, more than any other, possesses the potential to truly legitimise women’s wrestling as a serious concern not beholden to the gender stereotypes that still undermine the division, even at this forefront of the Women’s (R)evolution.
Owing to their shared history and natural fan expectation, we should be introduced to Shayna as she reintroduces herself to Ronda in a backstage segment. Create a tense tone in which something feels off. Have Shayna’s sinister body language and piercing facial expressions betray her cordial words. Have her stare a hole through Ronda slightly too long. Have her grip Ronda’s hand for slightly too long, elongating the shake.
Create the expectation…and wait to deliver upon it.
Baszler’s character motivation is clear: where she mastered pro wrestling on a less prestigious stage for less money, Ronda was immediately positioned on the most prestigious stage, WrestleMania, for more money than any other female talent including, obviously, the Queen of Spades.
Only by mirroring this resentment, through a spree of cathartic midcard killings, can the audience begin to feel it.
3. Tommaso Ciampa
Much like EC3, a character of Ciampa’s incredible ambition can only prosper if that ambition is reciprocated; otherwise, like Bobby Roode, a so-so midcard run would only bring into focus an hysterical degree of delusion.
Ciampa presents himself as nothing less than the greatest sports entertainer of all time. Short of retiring the Undertaker, a very optimistic prospect too unrealistic to suggest here, it’s actually realistic to instead emphasise the other key aspect of his awesome act: the legitimately sadistic and legitimately despised best heel in wrestling.
Really, the best and perhaps only protagonist for this antagonist to immediately terrorise is Daniel Bryan.
Admittedly, this is a potential - and immediate - diminished return of the Johnny Gargano rivalry that, after so long, is now losing its dramatic heft. We have seen - and are some are slowly tiring of - Ciampa tormenting an underdog.
But, equally, we haven’t yet seen something to truly stir the excitement promised by Bryan’s improbable return. Ciampa, a fantastic modern heel worker, represents the ideal opponent for the Yes! man, with the sheer potential of the programme drowning out the echoes.
2. Johnny Gargano
Through WWE’s myopic lens, Johnny Wrestling may be recast into the role of Johnny Sports Entertainment: a plucky one-dimensional underdog whose key characteristic is honed in on to the point of excess. This is the fate that has befallen Daniel Bryan on SmackDown, while on RAW, the central premise of the Finn Bálor Vs. Constable Corbin is of a feud between a man is tall versus a man who isn’t.
The clue is in Johnny’s nickname: to mirror the connection Johnny shares with the NXT audience, or did before his not-that-great “tormented” acting chops blunted the high of his career rivalry, have Johnny Wrestling wrestle.
To put the premise over, Johnny should make the title synonymous with workrate, the Intercontinental Championship, his main main roster ambition. The title remains over, and is enjoying something of a renaissance in 2018 through the respect paid to it in promos and in the ring by The Miz and Seth Rollins. This is something an acknowledging Gargano should announce immediately, to sell to the casual audience precisely the sort of pure artist he is.
WWE has not yet managed to effectively structure the new marathon B-level PPV times. A string of successful, lengthy, excellent title defences amassed by Gargano would make for a euphoric legacy reign enriching the prestige of the title itself, a means of limiting potential crowd hijacks, and, one would hope, a not inconsiderable career.
1. The Undisputed Era
The inherent problem with debuting a faction on the main roster landscape is that there are so few existing factions for Adam Cole et al. to target.
There are just two:
1) The New Day - en enduring and entertaining act so popular that, in a rare case, it tends not to matter whether they win or lose; they can be parachuted into most slots on the card and elicit a major reaction.
2) SAnitY - an utterly hapless heel faction that barely lived before they were killed off in a near-Ascension-level record.
The New Day it is, then.
Fortunately, there is scope for an excellent debut series here, with a contrasting dynamic very easy to sell to the audience. The Undisputed Era are all business, intent on shaping the company in their own elite image. The New Day meanwhile are all smiles, only showcasing a serious side when it is beaten out of them. Doling out an impactful, brutal beatdown - not on the post-‘Mania SmackDown, to create that all-too-rare iconic and system-shocking moment - during an intentionally goofy segment would effectively draw the battle lines.
The prospective matches almost guarantee crowd-popping, all-action chaos crammed with saves, melees and key character moments designed to introduce each member: Cole sliming away from Big E throughout, Roderick Strong killing the big-bumping Kofi Kingston with backbreakers, Kyle O’Reilly torturing the sympathetic Xavier Woods with agonising submissions…