10 Stages Of The WWE Championship’s Devolution: From Prize To Prop

The Bronze Age.

Hulk Hogan Jinder Mahal
WWE/WWE

How prestigious is a fabricated sporting achievement?

The only objective definition of the WWE Heavyweight title, reductively, is a platform for monetisation - but in order to be monetised, it needs to be marketed and believed in as prestigious. On the whole, WWE has managed a sterling job of marketing the gold - or perhaps "historically" is a better segue. Because there is no objective answer, the WWWF/WWF/WWE Heavyweight championship is as prestigious as you want it to be, or as Vince McMahon wants it to be - and increasingly, he is treating it as shorthand, which is backwards; its appeal lies within its longevity.

Interestingly, the physical redesigns of the strap have downgraded in parallel with its prestige. The classic golden eagle design was possibly the most perfect, beautiful belt design ever - both visually, in and of itself, and symbolically. Hulk Hogan was a decorated, soaring predator. Steve Austin's smoking skull was a neat marketing tactic, but John Cena's spinner was a damning indictment of the WWE landscape either side of this decade. Until part-time star The Rock was afforded the current design (another problem in itself), all of Cena's contemporaries were made to wear his prize - as if it always belonged to him. In effect, it did; it was always his to reclaim. It's now looks as basic as the man who holds it.

The answer, obviously, isn't reverting back to the golden eagle - but that's a far better shortcut than a manufactured "opportunity".

10. The Early Years

Bruno Sammartino
WWE.com

The WWWF Heavyweight title was born when the company first seceded from the NWA, and was "won" by Buddy Rogers in a fictional Rio De Janeiro tournament.

Though Vince McMahon Sr. rejoined the governing body, he retained his own version of a World Heavyweight crown, which came to be defined, initially, by Bruno Sammartino - a working class Italian-American hero to his working class Italian-American public. They adored Sammartino - likely because, before the always-thin kayfabe facade dissipated, their guy got to win each of his big fights. Wrestling used to be an emulation of sport, and the relatable Sammartino was a guaranteed dynasty who, with his power and innate charisma, elevated himself to stardom and the trophy he clutched - for years - to prominence. Pedro Morales was for Puerto Rican immigrants what Sammartino was for Italian-Americans: an aspirational figure there to enable their lofty wish fulfilment. Bob Backlund was less celebrated, but would not have held the title for a (partially fabricated) five year span, if he was a complete failure. It was a different paradigm then, pre-cable revolution - but the idea of these rugged, enduring, unbeatable champs underscores the legacy of the WWWF/WWF/WWE championship as something mythical, buoyed by the subsequent raft of relatively sudden changes.

So enshrined are those days in company lore that all WWE need do to remind modern audiences of the gold's history and prestige is roll sepia-tinged footage of Bruno and his public in the Garden.


9. Hulkamania Runs Wild

Gorgeous George
WWE

Hulk Hogan retained the essence of Bruno, but amplified it - here was a true mainstream superstar with the vibrant colour scheme, Hollywood physique, and preternatural crowd manipulation nous to emerge as the first major star of the super-popular national era, with a staunch (onscreen) moral code allowing previously hesitant families to accept pro wrestling as something more than a vicious bloodsport.

Hogan's first reign with the WWF Heavyweight championship was a gigantic, near-unprecedented success, insofar as scale. He remained champion for so long because he was an enduring draw. It's all monetary, ultimately - but his tanned box office muscle positively affected the aura of his crown, even if that was a secondary concern. That he held it for so long, in spite of the loaded talent roster in reality and the storyline monsters he swatted away, virtually elevated it into the realm of the holy grail. In the wake of WrestleMania III, at which he vanquished Andre The Giant, who had been expertly positioned as the immovable object, his legend grew. Hogan did move him, in the famous body slam heard 'round the world.

Like the man who held it, the WWF Heavyweight championship became immortal - though not entirely symbiotic, given that Randy Savage maintained the massive business Hogan generated, thus becoming perhaps the least appreciated pro wrestling draw ever.


8. A New Meritocracy

bret hart wwe champion
WWE.com

1992 marked a paradigm shift for the prize, for reasons both dubious and celebratory.

The marketing spin behind WrestleMania VIII promised a double main event - but conspicuously, the title (already tarnished by the UItimate Warrior's disappointing run) was relegated to the midcard slot, with the fans allowed a breather before they made noise for the real ticket-selling attraction: Hulk Hogan.

The WWF were left with little option but to enforce another relegation, at SummerSlam - but the in-ring wizard behind its famous Intercontinental Title main event, still to this day one of the greatest spectacles in the history of the company, was rewarded with a run at the top of it. Bret 'Hitman' Hart was the overwhelming fan choice, and he continued the nascent development, set by Ric Flair and Randy Savage, of genuine technical class within the title picture. It was no longer about the guy, but rather the match - a philosophy (literally, on occasion) Bret bled for. Hart was the perfect champion for those fans who remained committed to the Federation, once the fad had faded, because he was the best pure wrestler in the company. He was the art form distilled. While Hart was nowhere near the level of Hogan and Savage as draws, he gets nowhere near enough credit for retaining the core audience through his progressive body of in-ring work.

Retention, however, was not McMahon's concern in the wake of a turbulent start to the decade.


7. Early Red Flags

Yokozuna WWE Champion
WWE.com

In the wake of the early 1990s steroid scandal, Vince McMahon Jr. was forced to indulge his macrophilia more inventively.

The enormous Yokozuna was booked as a spiritual successor to Andre The Giant, in that he kayfabe dominated the landscape as this unbeatable, gigantic monster. This Yokozuna had no Hulk Hogan to eventually vanquish him - Vince McMahon, you suspect and has been widely reported, never saw Bret Hart as the guy - so McMahon had the actual Hulk Hogan dethrone him immediately after he captured the win. The new Hulk Hogan, Lex Luger, did not pan out, and his physique triggered...concerns, so McMahon had to relent. Bret Hart once again became WWF champion one year later at WrestleMania X - and thus began a game of literal push and pull, a never-ending battle with his audience.

Diesel, McMahon's Bret Hart replacement, was a tall, tall guy - a kayfabe 6'10" - and he rounded the rugged edges of his biker gang bada** persona by asking him to smile for the kiddies. Diesel was gathering steam, but there were no genuine, irresistible urge to see him to rule the promotion. He was Vince McMahon's idea of the WWF champion, an early example of the belt making the man - not his public's. The battle with them raged on.

Both WWF champions taught fans an invaluable lesson - one which remains unheeded to this day. Vince McMahon has a specific vision for what he markets as sports entertainment, and prestige is only factored in when a storyline, or a Hall of Fame ceremony, demands it. Aesthetics, always, trump talent. Which is perfectly logical - he's not in the business of amateur wrestling - but the prize has to mean something.

Around Diesel's waist, it was worn to literally prop him up. He didn't prop up business, which felt as small time as the title.


6. There Is No Guy

Shawn Michaels WWF Champion 1996
WWE.com

Diesel, infamously, was the worst-performing WWF champion in history. He tanked, and Bret Hart was installed as transitional champion once more.

Successor Shawn Michaels, who dethroned Hart at WrestleMania XII in 1996, wasn't 'the guy' - largely because his latent obnoxiousness melted the thin veneer of his goody-goody, dream-weaving babyface. Michaels was a phenomenal in-ring talent, one who maintained the prize as a benchmark of seminal in-ring performance. He wasn't a draw, nor particularly popular amongst the intended demographic; despite a raft of blinding defences, Michaels was booed out of the building at Survivor Series 1996, at which he lost the gold to white-hot heel Sid. The prestige of the belt took a battering when Michaels, who'd reclaimed the prize - by this point, the title was well worth the descriptor - infamously relinquished it under the pretence of a knee (and "mouth") injury.

Still, the events of the remainder of the year subverted the effects of that borderline sacrilegious locker room transgression. The Undertaker carried the gold as a legitimate storyline force, an oft-overlooked restoration, and the prize Michaels forfeited soon became the symbol for his intense personal rivalry with Hart. Their transposed onscreen feud dovetailed perfectly with the Undertaker's character arc in 1997. The gold became the one ring, and turned both men into Gollums - dark shadow selves ruined by its all-encompassing power.

Even if indirectly, the title became not merely a career accomplishment, but something worth destroying one over.


5. The New Guy(s)

Steve Austin Kurt Angle 2001 Raw
WWE.com

The events of the Montreal Screwjob - which saw Michaels win their personal war and Hart leave the promotion under a cloud, which set forth a deluge over his life and career - paved the way for the emerging Stone Cold Steve Austin to elevate the WWF back into the pop cultural stratosphere.

Around his waist, or rather dragged by his hands to the ring, the title was expertly presented as both the pinnacle of wider wrestling achievement - Austin's immense popularity hoisted the WWF above WCW, the greatest competition it had ever faced - and its rightful place as the lifeblood of the company. Presented as a company divided, in reality, management, talent and audience were in perfect harmony. The outed and turned company owner Vince "Mr." McMahon did so much to underscore the belt's importance by losing his mind at the prospect of this awesome renegade holding it. The contrivances he engineered to wrest it from him created both awesome, OTT storylines and the notion that it was everything. Austin, meanwhile, like Hart before him, evolved the in-ring mode by adopting a crazed ringside brawling style to protect his broken neck and bump clock.

Firing on all creative and commercial cylinders, the company through 1998-2001 created a collaborative environment in which so many men - Mankind, The Rock, Triple H, Kurt Angle - thrived in parallel with the title, now no longer a symbol of ascension but a fiercely-contested hot potato held only by the elite "sports entertainers" on the planet.

Regrettably, it was not immune to short-term damage.


4. Ratings Grab

Vince McMahon
WWE.com

Vince McMahon's decision to crown himself WWF champion was baffling both in itself and the context of company storylines - which, by the stupid standards of 1999, really is saying something.

To parse the (il)logic: McMahon, still (an awesome) heel, was driven out of the WWF by Austin per the stipulation of Fully Loaded 1999. Upon returning to the company as a face, he was goaded into a title match by Triple H - who would later recover, but by that point was a paper champion - and only went and won the bloody thing. Weird, is probably the word; by that point, the WWF was handily thrashing WCW in the battle for ratings supremacy, Mr. McMahon was never a critical smash in the babyface role, and the point was almost entirely missed: the McMahon family existed to elevate the stars, not act as the stars themselves - and they worked because they were the enemies of the common man, not their avatars.

The net result was a damaging blow to the prize. It was arbitrarily handed to and removed from McMahon for a ratings spike. Almost instantaneously, it devolved from prize to gimmick. While it was regrettable, retconned and ultimately restored, it remains both a blot on the lineage and a harbinger of the indiscriminate damage to come.


3. Restoration And Ruination

Sheamus WWE Champion
WWE.com

As the company itself entered into an identity crisis following the culturally entrenched but passé Attitude Era, so too did the flagship prize enter a state of flux.

Returning prodigal son Hulk Hogan provided a short-term blast of nostalgia in 2002 - but it was an artistic regression and a financial recession. Through a series of transitional champions, it found its way into Brock Lesnar's hands - designated onscreen and off as The Next Big Thing. His runs elevated the strap into the realm of the authentic, and his loss to Eddie Guerrero was a beautiful moment of both fan service and meritocracy - but, as he is wont to do, Vince McMahon reverted to type and suddenly installed John 'Bradshaw' Layfield into the role as his company unravelled both in terms of personnel and artistry.

It was one agitated scramble to find the guy - and find him, they did; John Cena was the NextGen Hulk Hogan - a colourful, kid-friendly comeback kid dynasty of a WWE champion. His massive appeal and success afforded WWE several luxuries, and one damning dilemma. He shifted tonnes of merch, marched his company seamlessly into the lucrative, corporate-friendly PG era, and on his best days fused the legacies of both the star (Hogan) and the match (Hart Vs. Virtually Anybody) - but Cena Mania consumed the company to such an extent that his peers floundered in comparison - even Randy Orton, Batista and CM Punk, at least two of which have publicly bemoaned the inordinate focus placed on his rippling shoulders. It also, eventually, subsumed the secondary World Heavyweight Championship - the mere existence of which diluted the power of its elder statesman equivalent. Almost imperceptibly, being over - once the minimum qualification - was no longer desired. Sheamus became WWE Heavyweight champion in late 2009, at which point WWE's western world monopoly had drained the talent pool and welcomed WWE out of their corner and into a roomy pad of inconsequential, careless luxury.

We were firmly in the-title-makes-the-man territory by now - backwards thinking that, consequently, reversed the legacy of the gold from organic achievement to cynical experiment.


2. Record Breakers

john cena wwe
WWE.com

CM Punk in 2012 embarked on the longest title reign since Hulk Hogan's inaugural reign - which reads as more impressive than it actually was. Around his waist, the prize wasn't at all a prop - but it certainly required the "consolation" prefix, something to satiate Punk as the real top star of the company. Cena continued to dominate storylines and headline PPVs at his expense. The title, by that year, was a notch below the top star, not something for the top star to wear.

Cena himself occupied a contrived role five years later; WWE, fixated on creating moments as opposed to letting them happen organically and desperately trying to glorify itself, booked Cena to end AJ Styles' run with the title - for the sole purpose of rivalling Ric Flair's phantom record of 16 World title wins. The tie was as fabricated as the record; it was pointless and avoidable, given that Cena was a transitional champion. It was inorganic desperation, which sullied Bray Wyatt's win before the referee struck the mat for a third time.

In the meantime, WWE, still unable or unwilling to escape the past, awarded WWE title wins to part-time nostalgia acts The Rock and Brock Lesnar - in thrall of their celebrity and the visual of the between-reigns gap, and at the expense of the untrustworthy full-time roster. The title served two functions: equaliser and shortcut to prominence. Neither strategy worked. The title used to exist to reward organic momentum; by 2017, it exists to transparently manufacture it.

The belt had creeped from achievement to tool. Now, it is held by one.


1. Jinder Hinders The Prestige

Jinder Mahal
WWE

Jinder Mahal became WWE Heavyweight champion at Backlash on May 21, 2017.

He was a categorical jobber before he captured it under the flimsy premise of SmackDown existing as the "Land of Opportunity"; in reality, WWE is now a risk-free enterprise which can allow itself the luxury of experimenting into emerging markets incompatible with the wants of established territories. There is no longer a Sammartino, a Hogan, an Austin. There's barely a Cena. WWE, a safeguarded publicly traded entity bereft of real competition, is the draw. One constant remains: McMahon's love of supernatural physiques and cheap heat, between which Mahal is the perfect marriage. This love has incited a maelstrom of hate within the audience - but McMahon's greatest trick is convincing his public that there is no other game in town. Look at the Dave Meltzer Tokyo Dome jokes for proof of that.

None of this is Mahal's fault. He was a gifted grafter in his role as comedy jobber in 3MB. And that, on the face of it, is it. His 2017 matches are tedious, his promos derivative and repetitive - and yet, his reign continues despite critical condemnation and empty arenas. The prestige of the WWE Heavyweight title has been tarnished because McMahon either cares nothing for it, or feels he can always restore it later. He's probably right. WWE is the only game in town.

We wanted to see if Hulk Hogan could surmount the Ultimate Challenge in 1990. We wanted to see 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin restore its identity as the barometer for legitimate superstardom in 1998. We wanted to see CM Punk escape with it and reshape it in his iconoclastic image in 2011. Nobody wants to see Jinder Mahal wear it in 2017 because the mentality behind it is years older than all of those classic moments.

It's the work of a disconnected autocrat indulging himself with retrograde thinking.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!