10 Stars WWE Doesn't Want You To Love

Perhaps we can interest you in some Roman Reigns instead?

WWE's business model is fairly simple in theory - first, the company creates characters with whom the audience is supposed to identify in some way, or at the very least, find compelling. Then, WWE books feuds between the characters, digging into their personalities to create an antagonism that makes for gripping television. Finally, these feuds end in big matches, with fans forced to pay money to see the blowoffs. At its core, that's what pro wrestling is. Anyone who's ever watched wrestling can attest to the fact that it's not that easy in real life. Fans' preferences are hard to anticipate, and in an era where access to WWE's backstage workings is more open than ever before, audiences can be resentful when they catch wind of plans and feel like they're being led in a certain direction. As a result, the superstars that the fans get behind are often different men and women than the ones WWE wants to push. Still, no problem - just run with what the fans want, right? After all, their money keeps the lights on. Again, not that easy. WWE has been notoriously stubborn when it comes to whom they choose to push. If a wrestler is flagged for success, the company will push him lost past the point where it makes sense, and if a wrestler isn't seen as a star by management, no amount of fan support will change their minds. Being a fan of WWE can be frustrating when it seems like the most talented or beloved wrestlers are being undermined by the company that employs them. Still, the world's largest wrestling organization shows no signs of changing the ways it tries to create main event players. With that in mind, here are 10 stars WWE simply doesn't want you to love...

10. Zack Ryder

For a brief period, Zack Ryder was one of the most popular wrestlers in WWE - and it was through his own doing. Ryder created a YouTube show that made him a cult favorite with fans, and eventually, the company was forced to push the ultra-popular star. His good fortunes didn't last long, though - Ryder's reign as U.S. Champion was brief, and he was repeatedly humiliated on TV by John Cena, Kane, and Eve Torres. At the time, it literally seemed as though WWE was trying to punish him and make fans feel stupid for having supported him. The frenzy around Ryder cooled off when it became clear that WWE didn't see him as a major part of their plans, but it never completely faded. Even now - almost four years after his flirtation with stardom - Ryder gets huge reactions from audiences, and his signature "Woo Woo Woo" catchphrase and "LI" hand gesture are still popular with the WWE Universe. The company's solution to their problems with Ryder seems to simply be to keep him off of television. He hasn't had a real feud in years and he appears on Raw very rarely - after all, it wouldn't do much for the company to routinely show a lowercard worker who gets better reactions than the main eventers.

9. The Ascension

WWE traditionally doesn't promote tag team wrestling very well, but the opposite is true for developmental territory NXT, which has plenty of established teams competing over a set of highly sought-after championships. In NXT's short history, though, the brand's most successful tag team has been The Ascension. Boasting an NXT Tag Team Championship reign of just under a year, Konnor and Viktor may have their weaknesses as workers, but the gimmick and push they received showed that good booking could overcome a lot. When the two men were called up to WWE's main roster, it was assumed that they'd fill a long-empty niche in the tag team scene - the face-painted powerhouse tandem. They scored a few dominant wins in late 2014 and early 2015, but for unknown reasons, the company quickly changed its tune on the team. They were attacked by The New Age Outlaws, The APA, and the nWo, and soon began losing the majority of their matches while being buried on commentary. While Konnor and Viktor wouldn't have been a New Day-level success, they could have been a presence in the tag team ranks, playing foils to babyface tandems and establishing themselves as a long-term presence in the division. Instead, they'll need serious rehab to ever been taken as a threat to the titles.

8. Naomi

WWE's Divas' Revolution has drawn a mixed reaction from fans, but the addition of Sasha Banks, Charlotte, and Becky Lynch to the main roster has put more emphasis on a division that has largely revolved around Nikki Bella, Paige, and AJ Lee for the last couple of years. While the fresh faces are welcome, there's already a diva the company has been underutilizing for years - Naomi. Naomi first debuted in WWE as part of the NXT roster (back when it was a reality show) and soon made it to television. She's wowed many with her skill and the matches she's had, but despite receiving several shots at the Divas' Championship, she has yet to win the belt - feuds with Eve Torres and Paige saw her come up on the losing end of title matches, and a heel turn earlier this year wasn't enough, in the minds of WWE's decision-makers, to warrant taking the title off of Nikki and putting it on her. With the Divas' Revolution in full swing, Naomi is the leader of Team BAD, but she's already being overshadowed by the more popular Sasha Banks - and with Charlotte as the reigning Divas' Champion, the Charlotte-Banks NXT feud is likely to be revived in WWE. Again, Naomi will be on the division's sidelines.

7. Solomon Crowe

Independent wrestler Sami Callihan started gaining a reputation as one of the most scene's hottest talents in the early part of the the decade, and it wasn't long before WWE took an interest in him. In 2013, the company signed Callihan, giving him a computer hacker gimmick and renaming him Solomon Crowe. Crowe debuted in NXT that summer, but a planned television debut in February of 2014 was put off. Still, he continued to compete in dark matches, and finally, he debuted on NXT TV on January 28, 2015. His unique gimmick allowed him to "interfere" with the show's broadcast, causing technical difficulties with a computer tablet. A bright future seemed to be in store for the young star. Instead, he's floundered. These days, he rarely appears on television. Why did WWE drag its feet with Crowe, then back off of his push so quickly? It may be a case of the company signing talent that they'd rather be pushing. In between Crowe's arrival and his television debut, WWE came to terms with independent and international stars Finn Balor, Apollo Crews, and Hideo Itami. With those men in the mix, it's possible WWE's priorities changed. Whatever the reason, the company is clearly no longer invested in Solomon Crowe.

6. Dolph Ziggler

To say that the past half-decade has been frustrating for Dolph Ziggler is an understatement. In all of WWE history, there are few stars who have been so close to cracking the company's glass ceiling so many times without cementing themselves as main eventers. Dolph is a world-class talent who always delivers excellent matches, but for reasons known only to WWE's brass, they prefer to use Ziggler in the midcard. The sad truth is that, to the WWE office, the largest problem with making Dolph a main event star is that he isn't one already. It's a logical fallacy, considering he's had the talent for years and it's only the creative team's incompetence that's held him back, but the company typically likes to make superstars out of talent right off the bat - when a guy is considered a midcarder, that's a mark against him to the company, and he typically stays a midcarder for life. Still, fans maintain hope - they cheer loudly for the talented former World Heavyweight Champion, hoping that it will make a difference. Maybe it will - supposed career midcarders like Jeff Hardy and Daniel Bryan became top guys because of fan reaction. Nevertheless, a greater role for Dolph isn't something we'll see if those in charge have their way.

5. Kevin Owens

Few WWE superstars have debuted as auspiciously as Kevin Owens. As the reigning NXT Champion, Owens showed up on Raw and laid out John Cena with a Pop-Up Powerbomb. The two met in Owens's WWE debut at Elimination Chamber 2015, and the NXT Champion hit the Pop-Up Powerbomb again - this time, using it to pin Cena cleanly in a classic match. The two had a rematch at Money in the Bank and Cena came out on top, but a rubber match would decide the winner of the war. With Owens having lost the NXT Title and left the developmental brand prior to the third bout with Cena, the path for him to become U.S. Champion seemed to be clear. The two clashed once more in another exciting contest, but many fans were surprised - and disappointed - when Cena picked up the submission victory with the STF. Owens would not be the United States Champion anytime soon. The next night on Raw, Owens was part of a contingent of WWE stars who helped separate a brawling Brock Lesnar and The Undertaker - traditionally, not a slot in which WWE places its top talent, thinking it makes them look less important. While Owens has since won the Intercontinental Championship, his placement on the card since the third Cena match suggests he has more fans in the crowd than on the creative team.

4. Damien Sandow

Unbelievably, Damien Sandow - who once professed to be intellectually superior to the WWE Universe and later began dressing up as celebrities and other superstars en route to amassing a pathetic win/loss record - was one of the most popular stars in WWE earlier this year. It all began in 2014, when The Miz recruited Sandow to be his stunt double. Renamed Damien Mizdow, the former Mr. Money in the Bank began to act out The Miz's moves as Miz performed them. Fans were amused by his new role, and the two soon became WWE Tag Team Champions - and all the while, The Miz became more and more jealous of the reaction Mizdow was getting. It was clear the bearded grappler was ready to break out as a babyface. At WrestleMania XXXI, Mizdow came into his own when eliminated The Miz from the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal. The two started feuding, then met in a Raw bout where the winner would get the rights to the Miz brand. Even though Miz was leaving to film a movie, he inexplicably won. Since the loss, Sandow has floundered. He briefly competed as Randy Savage impersonator Macho Mandow, but he's since reverted to his original name and he been featured on TV in a while. WWE decision-makers had a chance to make Sandow a hot babyface, even for a brief period, but they ultimately decided against it.

3. Cesaro

One of the most technically adroit competitors on the entire WWE roster, Cesaro has a mixture of skill and charisma that allows him to take leaps and bounds up the card with a single performance. As a heel, Cesaro was a long-reigning United States Champion, a competitor in 2014's WWE Championship Elimination Chamber match, and the winner of the inaugural Andre the Giant Battle Royal. Despite some false starts, he seemed to be headed to the main event when he was paired with Paul Heyman following his WrestleMania XXX win. The optimism didn't last long, though - he failed to follow up on his success, was soon split from Heyman, and found himself floundering. A team with Tyson Kidd resulted in a brief Tag Title run, but they lost the belts and Kidd suffered a severe injury. Cesaro burst back into the forefront of WWE when he answered John Cena's U.S. Championship Open Challenge and took the champ to the limit in two consecutive matches. Though he didn't win the title, Cesaro got nearly an hour of time on Monday Night Raw to remind the WWE Universe of his capabilities. Plus, he was a babyface now - surely a star was born. Cesaro began feuding with Kevin Owens, but after failing to defeat the former NXT Champion at SummerSlam, he was back on a downward spiral. He's since lost matches to The Big Show, Sheamus, and Bad News Barrett, and he looks to be headed for a feud with Stardust. WWE had a potential superstar on their hands, but they purposely let him burn out.

2. Dean Ambrose

When Roman Reigns suffered an injury last year and was forced to miss three months of action, his massive push toward the WWE Championship had to be put on hold. Dean Ambrose took his place in a feud with Shield turncoat Seth Rollins, and even though the two had battled over the summer, they met in a huge Hell in a Cell match in October that saw Ambrose appear to break through as a main event player. Rollins won the Cell match with help from Bray Wyatt, but Ambrose was still the most popular active babyface in the entire company. Though it was long suspected that Reigns would win the 2015 Royal Rumble and challenge Brock Lesnar for the WWE Title at WrestleMania XXXI, fans began to hope that the changes on WWE programming would be reflected in the booking and Ambrose would get the coveted slot. Instead, when Reigns returned, he picked up right where he left off - only this time, the crowd resented him and the demotion his comeback meant for Ambrose. Reign won the Rumble, main evented WrestleMania (though failed to win the WWE Title), and has since been prepared for an eventual run at the top. The last thing WWE wants is for Ambrose to start eclipsing him again.

1. Daniel Bryan

While WWE does their best to make sure that the "wrong" wrestlers don't get over, sometimes the fans are just too powerful to ignore. In 2013, Daniel Bryan was so popular that he was pushed into the main event of SummerSlam and given a WWE Championship win over John Cena. He was immediately defeated for the title by Randy Orton, and when Bryan came up short in their subsequent feud, that was intended to be the end of his days as a main eventer. Instead, fans refused to give up on Bryan. Batista returned in January of 2014 and won the Royal Rumble, but fan reaction forced the company to turn him heel and insert Bryan into the main event. At WrestleMania XXX, Bryan won the WWE World Heavyweight Championship and gave his fans the moment they demanded. Unfortunately, an injury soon forced Bryan to vacate the title, and he was out for the remainder of 2014. Still, he was never a long-term top guy in the company's eyes, so it was okay - plans to make Roman Reigns the next John Cena could proceed. Bryan was cleared to return in January of 2015, and inexplicably, the company put him in the Royal Rumble match even though he wasn't scheduled to win it. For the second straight year, the event ended with fans booing the babyface who had dominated the competition. WWE then panicked, quickly booking a Reigns-Bryan feud over the number one contendership slot. During the program, which Reigns won, the former WWE Champion was portrayed as not being on the Royal Rumble winner's level before ultimately endorsing him (and all but begging the fans to do the same). Bryan is injured again, and his future is uncertain again. As a popular star who sells a lot of merchandise, WWE should hope he returns - however, if he does, the company's brass will undoubtedly be keeping their fingers crossed that he doesn't get too popular... after all, it's screwed up a lot of plans in the past.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott Fried is a Slammy Award-winning* writer living and working in New York City. He has been following/writing about professional wrestling for many years and is a graduate of Lance Storm's Storm Wrestling Academy. Follow him on Twitter at https://twitter.com/scottfried. *Best Crowd of the Year, 2013