10 More Superstars Who Had Better Careers Outside WWE

Talented wrestlers WWE totally missed the boat with.

Not everyone who gets hired by Vince McMahon becomes a big star. So many Superstars have been signed to the WWE over the decades, but only a handful of them have managed to get to the top. In the past, WWE signed wrestlers who made their name in other promotions in the hopes that those same stars would succeed under the WWE banner as well. Unfortunately, it doesn€™t always work out that way. In fact, it rarely does. In the past number of years, we€™ve seen a number of stars who worked in other companies, gaining invaluable experience, get signed by the WWE and have gone on to become big stars. These stars include CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, Seth Rollins, Dean Ambrose, among others. But few can really make it as far as these have; WWE likes to build their own stars more than they like to use stars from other promotions or other countries. Continuing off of a previous article of mine, this article will look at another 10 former WWE Superstars who had better careers before or after a stint in the WWE. The following Superstars were either victims of poor booking, bad timing, or simply bad luck; either way, they shall had better careers outside of the hallowed halls of the WWE.

10. Harley Race

Harley Race was one of the top wrestlers of the €˜Territories€™ Era, achieving fame mainly throughout the 1960s and 1970s. Once described Harley Race by Bret Hart as a man with nerves twice as strong as a normal man€™s, Race was a genuine tough man who became a major in several promotions. He won the World Championship in All Japan Pro Wrestling, The AWA World Tag Team Championship 3 times alongside Larry €˜the Axe€™ Hennig, won the NWA World Championship 8 times in various American promotions, and was the first ever NWA United States Heavyweight Championship. By the time the 1980s came around, Harley Race began working as a booker for the NWA. However, by the mid-1980s, Vince McMahon began expanding into other territories in order to expand his WWF and to acquire the top talents of other promotions. Unfortunately, Harley Race was one of the victims of McMahon€™s rapid expansionism. That said, Race still managed to get a job in the WWF as a performer, despite his advancing age. Since the WWF at the time didn€™t recognize other promotions, they decided to make use of his wrestling skill and pedigree by making him King of the Ring in 1986. However, despite that accomplishment, as well as a rivalry with Hulk Hogan, Race€™s WWF on-screen run was nowhere near as successful as in other companies. As the years went on, he would play an important backstage role in the WWE, and would also wrestle sporadically in smaller promotions. In the end, however, Race earned the respect of virtually everyone in the business, including Vince McMahon. So much so that Race was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame Class of 2004. Though that is an accomplishment in and of itself, his career outside of the WWF was clearly superior.

9. Simon Dean

Simon Dean was a fitness expert who came to the ring on a moped, did push-ups in the ring, and claimed that his patented €˜Simon System€™ would be a great way to help people lose weight. Despite his technical skill and wide variety of maneuvers under his belt, he really didn€™t accomplish much in WWE. He was, for all intents and purposes, lower card act while in WWE, which was an insult when you look at his accomplishments elsewhere. Michael Bucci competed in ECW under the name Nova/Hollywood Nova/Super Nova. What started off as a single skit in which he was parodying KISS became an overnight sensation, and he soon became a part of one of ECW€™s funniest stables, the Blue World Order (BWO), and obvious parody of the NWO in WCW. Bucci is known for having used a plethora of different wrestling maneuvers that would otherwise not be seen elsewhere. In WWE, his finishers were a modified Curb Stomp and the Simonizer, which is basically Paige€™s finisher, the Paige-Turner. However, in ECW, he would perform incredible moves, including his Third Degree finisher, which was, literally, two Piledrivers followed by a Sitout Powerbomb. However, it would be much easier to simply show what he could do instead of writing about it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DKsXsrbOEMk While his career wasn€™t as illustrious as other people on this list, he was clearly an underused talent. He had the potential to have great matches with other WWE Superstars, but instead was made to make fun of fat people and behave like Richard Simmons. Well, at least he could cross out being a part of the WWE roster off his bucket list.

8. Colt Cabana

The man who was once Scotty Goldman, Colt Cabana is one of CM Punk€™s closest friends, and a talented wrestler in his own right. Though he started off on the independent scene, he was signed to the WWE from 2007 to 2009, where was mainly a jobber, losing in short televised matches to the likes of the Great Khali and Umaga. He was basically a victim of no booking; they had nothing for him, so they made him a jobber until they let him go. Cabana€™s career on the independent circuit was much more successful for him when compared to his WWE run. His list of accomplishments and titles in pro wrestling is indeed impressive: from winning the World titles in small promotions like Juggalo Championship Wrestling and Chikara, to making it to bigger promotions like Pro Wrestling NOAH and Ring of Honor. Had he been elevated in WWE, Cabana would€™ve made the perfect comedy wrestler, in the same vein as Santino Marella. His ability to make the audience laugh can be demonstrated in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=STK-pNUN79g Cabana has a certain cleverness that allows him to make virtually any situation funny, which would be perfect in today€™s WWE. His style of humor would be simple, with things like basic slapstick comedy, getting into his opponent€™s head in a funny way etc. Had he been given the opportunity, he would have been the perfect man to work alongside Santino Marella as WWE€™s comedy act, instead of having the ridiculous and borderline-stupid Bunny character, El Torito twerking, and Hornswoggle as a mini-gator.

7. Christopher Daniels

Some of you might be surprised that Christopher Daniels worked for the WWE, but he actually did, under the mask as Conquistador Dos. This was during the WWF Tag Team Title feud between The Hardy Boyz and Edge & Christian. To keep it simple, Christopher Daniels and Aaron Aguilera wore the Los Conquistadores costumes while the Hardys and Edge & Christian kept accusing each other of being under the mask. The point is, Daniels was just another light heavyweight jobber used in the WWF, and soon went back to the independent scene. He started off in Ring of Honor, but soon travelled all across the United States and into Japan. He has won either a singles or tag team title in several independent wrestling promotions, before signing with TNA in 2002. While there, he found considerable success, wrestling either as himself, a comedic character known as €˜Curry Man€™, or as one of three people to portray the Suicide/Manik character. Christopher Daniels could have been a big star in WWE, if used well. He possessed the technique to perform amazing aerial moves, notably his Double Jump Moonsault (Best Moonsault ever), had a variety of submission holds in his arsenal, and also had several impressive grappling moves, notable his Angel€™s Wings Facebuster. If Daniels had been in WWE, he could have been in the same position as Cody Rhodes is in now: a solid mid-card wrestler with both singles and tag team title reigns under his belt. While Daniels never won a World Title in either ROH of TNA, he still has demonstrated that he can perform alongside the best in-ring performers. WWE really lost a very talented athlete when they let him go.

6. Stan Hansen

To old school WWF fans, Stan Hansen is known as the large Texan who nearly ended Bruno Sammartino€™s wrestling career. To other fans, he is a legendary performer in Japan. Either way, Stan Hansen was one extremely stiff wrestler. Due to what he claimed to be poor eyesight, Hansen often hit his opponents as hard as he could, and never pulled any punches. Hansen competed in the WWF in the mid-1970s, and was responsible for one of the most infamous botches of that time period. During a match against legendary Superstar Bruno Sammartino, Hansen botched a Powerslam, causing Sammartino to land on his head, breaking his neck. Sammartino would return from said injury and gain a measure of revenge against Hansen. After Sammartino€™s grudge match, Hansen left the WWF and went to work in Japan, where he became a legendary performer. The Japanese wrestling press capitalized on Sammartino€™s injury and claimed that it was Hansen€™s finisher, the Western Lariat, which had caused the Living Legend€™s injury. This helped establish Hansen as a dangerous and formidable opponent for Japanese wrestlers. It was in All Japan Pro Wrestling where Stan Hansen€™s career truly reached its zenith. He won the coveted Triple Crown Championship four times, the Champion€™s Carnival (a tournament similar to WWE€™s King of the Ring) twice in a row, All Japan€™s World Tag Team Championships 8 times, and numerous World Championships throughout the fledging NWA. In fact, it is often said that Stan Hansen is the single greatest gaijin (foreign) wrestler in Japanese wrestling history. He has gone on to wrestle against All Japan€™s greatest stars, including Mitsuharu Misawa, Bruiser Brody, Kenta Kobashi, and AJPW founder Giant Baba himself. Moreover, he would go on to have a classic rivalry with Vader, who would go on to adopt many of Hansen€™s signature wrestling traits, including his stiff style (more on him later). Ultimately, Hansen€™s career in the WWE was short-lived, but he made the best of things by going to Japan and becoming a legendary performer in the hearts of wrestling fans around the world.

5. Samoa Joe

For a few years during the peak of the Attitude Era, the man who would later become Samoa Joe worked in the WWF as a jobber. For some reason, the company higher-ups didn€™t see anything in him, so they made him lose to bigger stars of theirs. Some rumors suggest that the WWF wasn€™t interested in him was because of his physique: he€™s a big on the chubby side when compared to other stars, and doesn€™t fit WWE€™s chiseled, muscular mold. By 2002, Joe was wrestling on the independent scene and TNA, where he would go on to become one of the greatest wrestlers in modern times. Combining his sheer size with MMA-style moves, Joe was a true multi-talented athlete: he was strong enough to perform power moves such as his Island Driver and Muscle Buster finishing moves, possessed the technique to perform dangerous submission moves like his Coquina Clutch, and had the sense of timing and speed to perform enzuigiris and suicide dives. When Kurt Angle began wrestling in TNA, the first person he confronted was Samoa Joe. The two of them would go on to have an outstanding feud in TNA, especially considering that Kurt Angle ended Joe€™s 18-month undefeated streak. In TNA, Joe is one of their most accomplished stars, having won every single title in the promotion, including their World Championship. He also wrestled for Ring of Honor, winning both the ROG Pure and World Championships. He would have been a perfect fit for WWE, had they ignored his lack of a super-muscular physique. His use of MMA-style wrestling moves and psychology would€™ve meshed perfectly with WWE€™s top stars, especially if Joe could€™ve gone up against Brock Lesnar. On October 12th of this year, Joe€™s TNA contract expired. This creates some uncertainty regarding his future in professional wrestling. It is possible that Joe, at 35, could end up in WWE, but that it very unlikely. That said, WWE truly missed out on Samoa Joe in the earlier years of his career. He was arguably one of the founding and most important members of the TNA roster during its earlier years, alongside AJ Styles, Abyss, and Christopher Daniels.

4. "Diamond" Dallas Page

There are multiple alleged reasons for why €˜Diamond€™ Dallas Page€™s career in the WWE was so disappointing. According to Hardcore Holly, Page was known to write unnecessarily long and complicated scripts dictating what happens in his matches (down to facial expressions), and once made these suggestions to the Undertaker. Others suggest that he was so desperate to work in the WWF that he agreed to get his contract bought out for half his price, making him seem like a less valuable contributing star to the company. What is important is that he got manhandled in the WWE, including getting pinned by Sara, the Undertaker€™s wife. After that, he became adopted the gimmick of a motivational speaker (which is something he did in real life), successfully defended the WWE European Championship against Christian at WrestleMania X8, before departing the company. It€™s a shame he was used to poorly when compared to his run in WCW. Though some say that his top spot in WCW was due to his close relationship with Eric Bishoff, Page did enjoy a lot of success in WCW, having matches with the likes of Randy Savage and Bret Hart, among others. He managed to win every title in WCW, including three reigns as WCW World Champion. Though his reigns were short, he was still considered a top star in WCW, the polar opposite of how he was treated in the WWF. He was very popular with the fans, and despite his age, proved that he could go toe-to-toe with the greatest wrestlers WCW had at the time. Part of this came from his dedicated work ethic, which included him going to the WCW Power Plant training facility on his days off or when the bookers didn€™t have anything for him. Alas, not even such a dedicated work ethic could help his WWF career. Thankfully, his post-wrestling career as innovator of DDP Yoga has helped many wrestlers and ex-wrestlers get into better shape, including Jake Roberts and Kane, among others. Since he€™s helping people get into better shape and be healthier, he truly has something to be happy about.

3. Vader/Big Van Vader

Leon White, a.k.a. Vader, is one of the best big men in wrestling history. Standing at 6€™5 and weighing between 400 and 450 lbs., Vader was able to brawl with the best of them, while at the same time being able to perform impressive aerial moves, including his Vadersault diving Moonsault. Think about that: a 450lbs. mammoth of a human being capable of doing a diving backflip in midair and landing on top of his opponents. Vader was a big star in both Japan and in the United States. He held the WCW Championship on 3 separate occasions, New Japan Pro Wrestling€™s IWGP Championship 3 times, and All Japan Pro Wrestling€™s Triple Crown Championship twice. Each one of those is a considerable accomplishment. Given his star power, coupled with his sheer size and maneuverability, Vader should have been a top star in the WWF. He fit the bill almost perfectly; though not overly muscular, he was strong and a capable worker. So why was his career so lackluster? According to Jim Cornette, it was due to backstage politics. He was meant to have a world title run, but he ran afoul Shawn Michaels and his Clique, and his main event push was over. There was also the Kuwait incident, where Vader physically threatened a Kuwaiti TV show host, after calling wrestling fake in front of both Vader and the Undertaker. That particular fiasco would lead to Vader being arrested and fined. Finally, there was also the issue of his weight. 300 lbs. is already heavy, even by WWE standards; being over 400 lbs. is never a good thing. The WWE at the time reportedly tried to get him to lose weight (just like they tried with Yokozuna, who was tipping the scales at over 600 lbs.), but he refused to go along with it. This weight issue is also what led WWE to release other heavyset stars like Big Daddy V and Rikishi, whose respective weights were reaching unhealthy levels. Ultimately, Vader€™s WWF run was characterized by a feud with the Undertaker, a spot on the Canada vs. USA traditional Survivor Series team at Survivor Series 1997, a Mask vs. Mask match against Kane, and a Slammy Award for attacking Gorilla Monsoon. Considering how good he can be in the ring, that kind of a career does a great disservice to what he could have done inside a WWF ring. It is a real shame that Vader was not used properly in WWF. He had everything Vince needed in a big star. Then again, he was a very accomplished star in Japan as well, where the fans respect ability over character. Maybe Vader should€™ve stayed in Japan the whole time, instead of going to work for Vince McMahon.

2. Raven

Scott Levy€™s career in the WWE was noted for a record 27 reigns as Hardcore Champion, but that was when the title was defended under 24/7 rules, and was basically treated as a joke title. But before that, he competed in WWE as €˜Johnny Polo€™ all the way back in the early 1990s, which didn€™t give him much either. Though he did have a match against Big Show and Kane for the Hardcore title at WrestleMania X7, the WWE simply didn€™t capitalize on his popularity in other promotions like they should have. It was his stint in ECW and subsequent travels to WCW and then later TNA that defined his career. Upon arriving in ECW, he changed his appearance and gimmick entirely, going from spoiled rich kid Johnny Polo to grunge-inspired, nihilistic sociopath Raven, who spoke in allegory and in reference to Edgar Allan Poe€™s Raven. Under this character, he would become famous for taking part in some of ECW€™s most infamous rivalries. Two that stand out the most are his feud with Tommy Dreamer, in which he helped elevate Tommy Dreamer as a gutsy underdog; and his feud with The Sandman, which featured the latter getting infamously crucified. Raven would also wrestle in WCW, where the announcers did acknowledge his accomplishment in other promotions. However, he was unable to replicate his ECW success, winning both the WCW United States Championship and the WCW World Tag Team Championships, with the latter reign only lasting one day. After his WWE run from 2000 to 2003 ended, he went to TNA, while at the same time competing for Ring of Honor against CM Punk, whose Straight-edge lifestyle was a mirror image to Raven€™s, which was based off the drug and alcohol abuse that he experienced during the peak of his career. While in TNA, he would win their version of the NWA World Heavyweight Championship, the 2005 King of the Mountain Tournament, and enjoyed success with such stables as The Gathering and Serotonin. Ultimately, WWE misused Raven just like they did many former WCW or ECW wrestlers. It€™s unfortunate that his WWE career didn€™t have many other high points. He was perfect for the Hardcore division, but that soon became a joke, and so did the Hardcore Championship. It is clear that Raven was smart to leave WWE when he knew nothing good would come by staying there.

1. "Dr. Death" Steve Williams

Steve Williams was a well-respected wrestler in Japan. He was considered an incredibly tough man, a true badass. He wrestled against All Japan Pro Wrestling€™s top stars, including Kenta Kobashi, Mitsuharu Misawa, Toshiaki Kawada, and Akira Taue (collectively known as the Four Heavenly Kings), among others. So during the Attitude Era, fellow Oklahoman Jim Ross thought that Steve would be a great addition to the WWF roster, and even pushed for him to become a top contender for the WWF Champion, €˜Stone Cold€™ Steve Austin. However, €˜Dr. Death€™ became a victim of poor circumstance, because his push was over before it even started. Someone in WWF management made the questionable decision of creating the Brawl For All Tournament, a shoot fighting competition. You had trained wrestlers fighting for real in an environment with few rules, with some of the competitors being true no holds barred fighters. What ended up happening was that Williams got knocked out of the competition (literally) by Bart Gunn, and his push was gone. He was supposed to win the entire tournament and go up against Stone Cold, but never got the chance. There were allegedly two reasons why this happened. The first is that €˜Dr. Death€™ wasn€™t as strong as the WWF Superstars thought; in the first round of the Brawl For All Tournament, Williams was up against Pierre Ouellet, and Williams was getting winded from the whole thing, so the referees decided to declare Williams the winner by points, much to the confusion (and disdain) of both fans and the other Superstars. They didn€™t think that Steve was as tough as he claimed to be if he couldn€™t out-fight a jobber. The second reason wasn€™t even Williams€™ fault; it was Jim Ross. Ross, who was a heel at the time, was lobbying for his fellow Oklahoman to be pushed as far as possible, going so far as to praise Williams whenever and wherever possible. According to Hardcore Holly, this aggravated the other WWF Superstars a lot. So when it was revealed that €˜Dr. Death€™ was paid upfront for the tournament after being injured, the rest of the WWF locker room resented Steve more than ever before. Imagine if Dr. Death had been introduced in a more €˜respectable way€™, i.e. as a monster heel who simply dominated his opponents with suplexes and hard strikes. He could€™ve made it to the top of the WWE ladder, if only he didn€™t get involved in Brawl For all. Ultimately, all of this led to Steve leaving the WWF, feeling bitter towards his longtime friend Jim Ross. He worked briefly for WCW and dabbled in Mixed Martial Arts. Sadly, tragedy struck in 2009 as €˜Dr. Death€™ passed away from throat cancer on December 29th of that year, at age 49. Thanks for reading. Be sure to leave a comment and be sure to check out WhatCulture's WWE section for other fascinating wrestling-related articles.

Contributor

Alexander Podgorski is a writer for WhatCulture that has been a fan of professional wrestling since he was 8 years old. He loves all kinds of wrestling, from WWE and sports entertainment, to puroresu in Japan. He holds a Bachelor of Arts degree from Queen's University in Political Studies and French, and a Master's Degree in Public Administration. He speaks English, French, Polish, a bit of German, and knows some odd words and phrases in half a dozen other languages.