10 Talented Wrestlers Let Down By Lame Gimmicks

Hello, midcard!

Val Venis Towel
WWE.com

Pro wrestlers are at the mercy of those employing them, and that can have truly disastrous results if the creative team doesn't pick the right character to fit each performer.

Things work the other way too, naturally; for example, Triple H morphing from the bland Hunter Hearst Helmsley into a crucial part of D-Generation X in 1997 allowed the man to display his strengths rather than be pigeon-holed into a one-note gimmick.

Not everyone has been as fortunate as 'The Game' though, and there are examples of those gimmicks that actually stifled a talented wrestler's career entirely, sometimes even killing any chances they had of making it to the top.

Often, it seems like the creative minds in major companies like WWE and WCW have just thrown things at the nearest wall to see what might stick; that explains why this list includes (amongst other things) pirates, disco dancers, porn stars, professors, burglars and the mentally ill.

Even the most sensitive of subjects are rarely exempt when those writers need a new character...

10. Paul Burchill (Pirate)

Paul Burchill Pirate
WWE.com

If Paul Burchill was still wrestling regularly on the UK scene, then the talented big man would surely be one of the top names around; before signing with WWE in 2005, the Englishman was already a standout in the old FWA promotion, and he offered something different to the standard British independent wrestler.

Tall, muscular and handsome, Burchill should have been a revelation to the WWE picture, but he was undermined with a series of uninspiring gimmicks that did nothing to highlight the surprising agility he possessed for a big man.

Cast as a pirate in 2006, Burchill was later shoe-horned awkwardly into an incest angle with his on-screen sister, Katie-Lea Burchill. That is not a joke; the man's WWE career went from Captain Jack Sparrow knock-off to a man sexually attracted to his own flesh and blood.

How anyone expected this to get over boggles the mind, especially considering the praise Burchill received for his stirring performances in England and for Ohio Valley Wrestling (WWE's former developmental league).

Both characters Burchill was handed failed to capitalise on exactly why WWE had been interested in him in the first place.


9. Barry Darsow (The Repo Man)

The Repo Man
WWE.com

Demolition weren't solely a success because of their Mad Max-inspired outfits, striking face paint or kick-a** entrance music; the tag-team excelled because both Bill Eadie and Barry Darsow were gifted in-ring performers.

Fundamentally more sound that The Road Warriors (a team Ax and Smash were often compared to) once the bell rang, Demolition are rightly considered one of WWE's greatest ever duos.

Sadly, the fun stopped for Darsow once Eadie retired and his subsequent 'New' Demolition with Crush failed to elicit the same response as the original; up next for Darsow was a series of horrendous gimmicks in both the WWF and WCW that ended his career on a sour note.

Repackaged as the sneaky Repo Man in 1991, the remodelled Darsow was a sneaky thief who repossessed items from other wrestlers; similar to the IRS character introduced around the same time, the cartoon-like Repo Man just didn't click with fans.

Later, WCW's brain farts for Darsow included The Blacktop Bully (a more traditional heel) and 'Mr. Hole In One'. Unsurprisingly, a golfing gimmick failed to register when cooler villains like the nWo were all over television.


8. The Disco Inferno (Disco Dancer)

Disco Inferno promo
WWE

For some reason, the entire world became obsessed with 1970's culture during the late-1990's. Part of this was due to the wild success of That 70's Show on television, but those in charge of World Championship Wrestling can't point to that program as inspiration for The Disco Inferno.

Launched in 1995, a full 3 years before That 70's Show hit screens, the new character was reportedly thought up by Raven; Glenn Gilbertti, the man playing the Disco gimmick, has credited Raven for this in numerous interviews since the closure of WCW in 2001.

A throwback to dancing fools of the 70's, the well-tanned Inferno was clearly a homage to John Travolta's character in Saturday Night Fever.

As well-remembered as the Disco Inferno guise is though, it's often forgotten that Gilbertti was actually a talented wrestler between the ropes and that his obvious skills were undermined by the character he was asked to play; during Disco's early months, he was scripted to actually forget how to apply his Figure Four Leg Lock finisher.

This did little to accentuate the man's wrestling ability.


7. Dean Douglas (College Professor)

Shane Douglas had all the momentum in the world, then WWF turned him into Dean Douglas
WWE.com

Regular ECW enthusiasts tuning into WWF programming in 1995 expecting to see 'The Franchise' Shane Douglas ended up disappointed, because the character Douglas played in the WWF couldn't have been more different to the brash main event machine he played in Philadelphia.

Stripped of everything that had made him cool in Paul Heyman's promotion, the unfortunate Shane was reimagined as college professor 'Dean' Douglas; the God-awful powder blue leotard Douglas wore - coupled with a goofy haircut and lack of real conviction in his promos - combined to cripple Shane's assault on the WWF roster.

Debuting in July, Dean Douglas was gone before the end of the year.

Douglas himself has cited issues with Shawn Michaels and 'The Kliq' backstage as a reason for his failed run, but the truth is that his 'Dean' character never had a hope in hell of getting over with a WWF audience that was crying out for something fresher than stuffy, cartoonish heels.

If Douglas had been set free as the cocky 'Franchise', he'd have stood a chance in the company even amidst a political minefield.


6. Nick Dinsmore (Eugene)

Eugene WWE
WWE.com

Anyone who slavishly trawled wrestling forums online during the early years of the new millennium would have become accustomed with the name Nick Dinsmore; whether true or not, many users routinely name-checked Dinsmore as a wrestler destined to make a splash in WWE when he was inevitably called up from OVW.

These fans reasoned that Dinsmore was one of the best wrestlers in the promotion's developmental system, and there was much merriment when the former 8-time (at that point) OVW Heavyweight Champ was called up to the main roster in 2004.

That buzz stopped dead when it was revealed that Dinsmore would play the role of Eugene, the mentally handicapped nephew of Raw GM Eric Bischoff.

Displaying many stereotypical traits associated with the mentally challenged, Eugene was considered out there in some circles and downright offensive in others. This outcry missed one of the most pressing points, that being the fact that Dinsmore was now typecast and would be unable to shed such a gimmick during his WWE career.

Dinsmore may have played Eugene faultlessly, but it left some uncomfortable - and also ruined a promising career.


5. Chavo Guerrero (Kerwin White)

Kerwin White 1
WWE

Chavo Guerrero must have been in dream land throughout much of 2002 and 2003; aligned on screen with his uncle Eddie, the Los Guerreros combination became a star of the glowing SmackDown Tag Team Title scene and led to the most fruitful period of Chavo's WWE career.

The smiles Chavo displayed whilst having a blast alongside Eddie were removed entirely in 2005 when WWE's creative team envisioned the character of Kerwin White.

Dismissing his Hispanic heritage and armed with the eye-opening "If it's not White, it's not right" catchphrase, this new gimmick was supposed to launch Chavo's singles career on Raw. Instead, it was a miserable failure that fans rejected.

Chavo quickly shed the Kerwin name when Eddie passed away in late 2005 and simply returned to his more natural guise. Even though the creative team were responsible for the White nonsense, at least they had the sense to abandon it in the wake of Eddie's tragic demise.

Playing a rich, xenophobic American didn't focus on Chavo's in-ring strengths, and Kerwin White must be considered the lowest point of his entire wrestling career.


4. Val Venis (Porn Star)

Val Venis
WWE.com

It was perhaps only a matter of time before the WWF introduced an adult film star character during the 'Attitude Era'; not held back by the same corporate restrictions WCW were, the WWF machine was able to push the envelope much more than any rivals outside ECW during the late-90's.

Enter Val Venis, international porn sensation and the object of every woman's desire.

Debuting in 1998, the Venis gimmick relied on juvenile humour that appealed to the target demographic of teenage boys and young adult males. After all, who wouldn't get behind a studly porn star who was bringing X-rated action to the wrestling world?

Sadly for Venis, the porn star idea did more to harm his career than help it; another decidedly one-note gimmick, the adult entertainer character made it impossible to take Val seriously during feuds or major matches, and he was regarded as more comedic than as a credible wrestler.

Gifted physically, charismatic on the mic and more solid than many remember inside the ring, the Canadian could have been a top star in WWE, had he not been saddled with such a light-hearted, tawdry persona.


3. Wade Barrett (King)

King Barrett
WWE.com

Tiring of his place in the WWE system and likely perplexed by the sheer lack of forward-thinking regarding his on screen character, Wade Barrett decided that enough was enough in May 2016 and left the promotion.

Rewind just 6 years earlier, and it seemed logical that Barrett would become a mainstay at the top of WWE cards for years to come - but the former leader of the Nexus was never given permanent keys to the main event kingdom.

It's ironic, then, that the character which ushered him out the nearest door was based on royalty.

Winning the 2015 King Of The Ring tournament was oddly the worst thing that could have happened to Barrett; immediately handed the garish crown, robe and sceptre combo, the formerly serious mannerisms gave way to horribly ill-placed promo material that turned him into some sort of royal wrestling version of Scrooge McDuck.

Playing the cartoon gimmick didn't appeal to Barrett; that much is clear from watching the almost-embarrassed looks on his face whilst adorned in that silly attire. It's hardly surprising that he was fed up, because Wade's previous 'Bad News' guise was over with the fans.


2. Billy Gunn (Mr. A**)

Billy Gunn Mr Ass
WWE.com

Stretching right back to his days as one half of The Smoking Gunns, it was clear to see that Billy Gunn had all the potential in the world to strike out on his own; post-Gunns, though, Billy struggled as the lame 'Rockabilly' before landing on success as The New Age Outlaws.

Determined to once again try to push him as a singles star, the WWF's creative team leaned heavily on the 'Bad A**' moniker Billy had patterned for himself and morphed the man slowly into 'Mr. A**' just in time for a 1999 push.

Obsessed with all things butt, the 'A** Man' character was supposed to kick start Gunn's ascent into the WWF's upper echelons, but it just left people feeling weird about watching him perform; regularly shaking his behind and fixated on admiring his posterior, Billy was never going to succeed with this embarrassing gimmick.

Admittedly, the 'Mr. Ass' persona is remembered - but that's more due to how much it hampered Billy Gunn's rise up the card rather than any nostalgic fondness. With the more credible 'Bad Ass' name, Billy may have achieved greater things on his own.


1. Steve Austin (The Ringmaster)

Steve Austin Ringmaster
WWE.com

The fact that Steve Austin went on to become WWE's biggest ever star is remarkable when considering his humble beginnings in the promotion - not to mention the absolutely rubbish character management first had in mind for him.

One of the most charismatic, captivating and successful wrestlers of all time was landed with one of Vince McMahon's most boring ideas in 1995; introduced as 'The Ringmaster', announcers reasoned that Austin was one of the greatest wrestlers between the ropes.

That was it: the WWF literally told fans nothing else other than the fact that Austin could wrestle. Surely that was a prerequisite for even signing with the company to begin with?

Via his podcast, a contemplative Austin has since remarked that he was viewed as a solid in-ring mechanic who was only there to make others look good. That adds up when analysing The Ringmaster character, because it was uninspiring at best.

Back in 1995, even the great Steve Austin was viewed with the same distinction as the default Create-A-Wrestler model in WWE video games. That must have felt like a total let down.

What other talented wrestlers can you think of who were let down by lame gimmicks? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!


In this post: 
Val Venis
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.