10 Talents TNA Totally Dropped The Ball With

Why wasn't Christopher Daniels a 21st century legend?

TNA gets a lot of flack for taking talent WWE has fired. But they definitely don€™t get the appreciation they deserve for building their own stars. Guys like Bobby Roode, AJ Styles, James Storm, Austin Aries, Samoa Joe, Magnus, and Eric Young have all been to the top of the mountain in TNA and have been great main eventers. Granted, some of the talent have made it big on the indies but TNA helped make them a household name and made them more familiar to the mainstream wrestling audience. TNA also has a knack for taking a talent WWE has, some would say, misused, and make them into something you want to see. Take EC3 for example. Relegated to being a low card guy in WWE, he comes to TNA and shows he is worthy of the main event slot and worthy of a World Championship. Taryn Terrell & Gail Kim are other good examples. WWE gave Gail the Women€™s Title but never really gave her a shot to prove just how good she is in the ring. Taryn barely even wrestled in WWE. But when those two fought each other in TNA, they tore the house down and put on one of the most entertaining matches of the year. Even a guy like Orlando Jordan made a more interesting move in TNA. He barely had a personality or a gimmick in WWE, but when he came to TNA he became the interesting character we all saw. The gimmick for sure made for some fascinating TV. So while TNA has had some success with using talent correctly, they also have definitely missed the mark on some of the wrestlers they have had. They had several pieces of coal that could have easily become diamonds, but TNA dropped the ball for one reason or another. Some of these people have even had title victories in TNA and even been World Champion, but still have been used poorly. These 10 stars are people TNA could have made big. And some, could have made the face of the company.

10. Mr. Anderson

Starting off with someone who has had a lot of success in TNA, just in a very bad way. Mr. Anderson has everything it takes to be the biggest star TNA has. He can put on a great match and his natural charisma is almost unmatched in the company. Mr. Anderson is actually a two time World Champion, yet both reigns left a lot more to be desired. Used very poorly as the World Champion, Mr. Anderson deserves a lot better. He has been in a storyline with Samual Shaw and now he is working with Chris Melendez, when he should be competing for the title. Anderson put on one of the best matches in TNA's recent history against Kurt Angle at Lockdown. He has shown time and time again he has what it takes to lead the company as champion. Yes, TNA has given Anderson a decent amount, but what they did with him after they give it to him is what hurts the most. Anderson has so much charisma and could easily be the face of TNA, yet they just won€™t pull that trigger.

9. Sonny Siaki

If you want to talk about an original TNA talent who could have been big, you have to mention Sonny Siaki. The guy had the look, simple as that. Siaki had the look and the ability to be a huge star for TNA. In the early days of TNA he was a member of Sports Entertainment Extreme and the group tried to take over TNA. He eventually found some success as a singles star when he beat Jerry Lynn to become X-Division Champion. Though the X-Title would be the only title he would win, he deserved a lot more. Siaki could have been with the likes of AJ Styles, Jeff Jarrett, Abyss, and Ron Killings as the main event talent TNA had to offer. Unfortunately Siaki was never able to match his success as X-Champion. He would leave TNA and sign with WWE. He was paired with Afa Jr. as the Samoan Fight Club. He would be forced to retire as he donated one of his kidneys to his dying brother, a move that ended his ten year career.

8. Hernandez

The Latin American Xchange, or LAX, would switch out members in the beginning of their run at TNA. First consisting of Konnan, Homicide, and Apollo, the group would replace Apollo with Machete. Machete would not last long as he was replaced by Hernandez and a tag legacy was born. As LAX, Homicide and Hernandez put on some of the greatest tag team matches in TNA history, and even were putting on match of the year candidates. LAX was alive and kicking in the best days of TNA€™s tag division. After the group split and they each went their own ways, Hernandez seemed like he was being groomed for greatness. Hernandez became €œSuperMex€ and had several singles feuds with several top talents. TNA seemed to be pushing Hernandez and it seemed to be working. He could put on a decent enough match and had a great look to him. And according to Hernandez himself, TNA did in fact have plans to push him big time. TNA however changed their mind and put Hernandez back into a tag team, never matching the popularity of LAX. Hernandez could have been a huge star for TNA, especially in the Mexican market. Hernandez had already been working in AAA in Mexico and him becoming TNA champion could have been huge and could have gained TNA some more fans from Mexico. Hernandez was definitely a star in the making and then TNA just dropped the ball.

7. Taeler Hendrix

The Knockouts division started real strong for TNA, with Dutch Mantel taking control over the division, their achieved a ton of success. The Knockouts would usually end up being the highest rated part of an Impact Wrestling episode. However, the division would have their fall from grace and would be in a rut. With seemingly five Knockouts in the division, they needed a new women€™s wrestler to come in and make things interesting again. And then along came Taeler Hendrix. Hendrix was working in OVW and got called up during the Gut Check segment of TNA. She fought Gail Kim in a valiant effort, but was never used properly. If there was one women€™s wrestler TNA dropped the ball on, it was Hendrix. She has the talent and definitely has the charisma. She could have been one of the best Knockouts champions if given the chance. In interviews she has stated how far she would be willing to go to push the envelope and how far she would take storylines, so she clearly would have been down to do any sort of storyline TNA wanted, controversial or not. TNA definitely missed out on having perhaps the next great female pro-wrestler. If TNA were smart, they would resign this girl instantly.

6. Lance Hoyt

Some call him TNA€™s version of Test. He had the look, was good on the mic, and was an entertaining wrestler, especially for a man his size. Hoyt could be quick and swift, and powerful and strong. Very few have had that €œmain event€ look more than Hoyt. He would accomplish some success in TNA as a two-time Tag Team Champion along with partner Kid Kash. He eventually broke out on his own and for some reason TNA never used him at the level he should have been used. He would get put into the Rock €˜n€™ Rave Infection with Christy Hemme and, another wasted talent, in Jimmy Rave. Playing Guitar Hero guitars and being 3MB before 3MB, Rock €˜n€™ Rave Infection was a team that never quite hit the right note. Hoyt would leave TNA and sign with WWE where he would again get misused. Cutting his hair and shaving his beard, he would be paired with Curt Hawkins. The duo seemed to wrestle exclusively on Superstars and never gained any traction. He now teams with Davey Boy Smith Jr. as the Killer Elite Squad and if you want to see the power this man has, go watch the chokeslam he does at Wrestle Kingdom 9. Hoyt easily could have been World Champion in TNA, very easily in fact. The guy had everything it took, but was just never given anything.

5. Alex Shelley

An amazing wrestler and absolute perfection on the mic, Alex Shelley was misused by TNA for so long. Starting out as €œBabybear€ Alex Shelley, he was misused as a lackey for Goldilocks. The Paparazzi Championship Series was the first time Alex Shelley got to truly shine. His interactions with Lethal, Dutt, Aries, and Nash were some of the funniest segments TNA has produced. It took, what some would call, far too long before Shelley was used greatly as one half of multi-time Tag Team Champions, The Motor City Machine Guns alongside Chris Sabin. Shelley may be small, but that has never stopped a wrestler before. Chris Sabin went on to become World Champion and Austin Aries was the prime example of what could have been Alex Shelley. TNA had a star in Shelley, an Austin Aries/CM Punk like personality with the in-ring talent to match. Shelley won the X-Division Title but never had that much more success as a singles star. This is one wrestler whose in-ring talent and personality was wasted for so many years in TNA. He deserved better.

4. Desmond Wolfe

Everyone was so excited when TNA signed Nigel McGuinness. A very talented, young man finally getting his break into the more mainstream wrestling scene. Nigel was previously signed by WWE but failed a pre-screening physical test and was let go by the company. So fans already went through a failed run in the big time so there was much worry over how TNA would €œruin€ him. However Nigel debuted as Desmond Wolfe and instantly was propelled into a feud with Kurt Angle. The feud with Angle was the best possible way to debut Desmond. Not to mention, the first few times they met, Desmond would beat Angle including one win via referee stoppage. Their matches at Turning Point and Final Resolution were considered classic too. Desmond feuded with D€™Angelo Dinero and Fortune before finally teaming with Magnus. Desmond and Magnus, otherwise known as London Brawling, were a great tag team. They both could put on a good match, their styles blended well together, and their charisma was off the charts. Unfortunately as the team was getting hot, Desmond tested positive for Hepatitis B and would be released from the company. It is such a shame to see that happen to such a talented man with tons of potential. Who knows where Desmond would be now in TNA had that not happened. While this one isn€™t technically on TNA, they still dropped the ball with him after his debut feud with Angle.

3. Christopher Daniels

Christopher Daniels has proven time and again why he is one of the very best performers TNA has ever had. Daniels has had a lot of success in TNA such as being multi-time Tag Champion and X Champion. Daniels has shown that he can be absolutely amazing as a singles star and a tag star. In XXX, Phenomenal Angels, and Bad Influence, Daniels would put on match of the year candidates almost every time he stepped out there. In Bad Influence we especially got to see just how funny and charismatic Daniels can be too. Daniels is the type of wrestler who makes whatever is given to him work. When he became darker and feuded with Sting, he made it work. The Curry Man gimmick got over big in the US too, even with being paired with Shark Boy and Super Eric. And of course, a Daniels promo would always be the highlight of the Clair Lynch angle. Daniels is a great wrestler, a great mic worker, and all around great athlete. He stuck with TNA no matter how many times they would fire him and then rehire him. And it is a darn shame that TNA never rewarded such a great talent with the World Title, something Daniels deserves more than most.

2. Jay Lethal

Macho Man Jay Lethal TNA was so close with this one. So, very close. Lethal debuted as the youngest member of the TNA roster and was a blue chipper for sure. Lethal clearly had a bright future ahead of him and it looked like he was actually going to be a World Title contender. Not long after he debuted with the company Jay Lethal was given the gimmick €œBlack Machismo€ because he could do a great Macho Man impression. He would dress like, act like, and talk like the Macho Man. Lethal made the gimmick work and held onto that gimmick longer than most probably assumed. He got over with it, though. Lethal starting becoming a big fan favorite between his dedication to the gimmick and his in-ring work. After a brief stint with Consequences Creed and a Tag Title win, Lethal would achieve his big push. Lethal got into a feud with Fortune. Lethal showed that he could also do an amazing Ric Flair impression and it led to one of the most memorable exchanges in TNA history between the two. Lethal would go on to defeat Desmond Wolfe, he would defeat AJ Styles, and he would even defeat Ric Flair with the figure-four leglock. Lethal was riding high and his status as a main eventer was pretty much solidified, until he won the X-Division title. TNA put the X title back on Lethal and had him feud with the debuting Robbie E. Lethal would lose the feud and leave the company afterwards. Lethal was on top of the world and just like that, TNA dropped the ball on one of their most talented, popular, young stars. Such a shame.

1. Monty Brown

€œThe Alpha Male€ Monty Brown was one of the biggest stars in the early days of TNA. Monty Brown had the look, was decent enough in the ring, and had charisma like you had never seen before. Brown would go on to have an unbeaten streak in TNA that lasted quite a while until he suffered his first lost to Jeff Hardy. Brown would win the first ever Monster€™s Ball match, he would compete against Sting in Sting€™s return to wrestling too. Brown was a top TNA star that suffered through the Jarrett era. Much like Roddy Piper during the Hogan era, Brown never stood a chance at winning the World Title as long as Jarrett was around. Monty Brown was a "face of the company" level talent that was always used as the lesser of the main eventers in a match. Brown could cut a promo so quick witted, so funny, and so charismatic it was unreal. Brown would never win a single title during his TNA run. What makes matters worse is that he left TNA for WWE where he also would go on yo never win a title. Brown could have been a true TNA original that could have been huge, but TNA dropped the ball big time. And unfortunately for us, it looks like Brown has left wrestling for good and isn€™t coming back to deliver The Pounce€€€..period. These are just a few stars that TNA has dropped the ball on, there have been plenty more and probably will be plenty more. However, even if people don't get what they probably should, an Austin Aries can come around at any moment and win the big one.

Contributor
Contributor

Katy Chef has been a lifelong wrestling fan. Chef has written for previous wrestling websites such as a TNA News website and Ringsidenews.com