10 Tantalizing WWE Versus New Japan Dream Matches

What would happen if Japan's best tangled with the United States' finest?

"Fantasy Warfare" -- the debate over how hypothetical matches between wrestlers from opposing promotions would go down -- has been around for decades. While the big question on everybody's mind was once about Hogan versus Flair, as the years passed, it morphed into Bret Hart versus Sting, then Steve Austin versus Bill Goldberg. Even once WCW closed its doors and one major promotion dominated the U.S. scene, fans still wondered how indy darlings who never made the jump -- like A.J. Styles and Samoa Joe -- would do battling the sport's biggest superstars. Today, the two largest wrestling promotions on the planet are World Wrestling Entertainment and New Japan Pro Wrestling. While the companies are located in different countries -- and different hemispheres -- today's technology means that fans all across the globe can watch as much of either organization's product as they wish. With the advent of the New Japan World streaming video service, WWE and NJPW are just a browser click away from each other... and thus, the old questions start to rise up. What would happen in the ultimate contest of the best versus the best? What kind of action could the fans expect? How would it all go down? Here are 10 matches between the two wrestling companies that may never happen, but are guaranteed to get imaginations working overtime...


10. Cesaro Vs Katsuyori Shibata

Katsuyori Shibata graduated from the New Japan dojo in 1999, and before long, he, Hiroshi Tanahashi, and Shinsuke Nakamura were touted as "The New Three Musketeers," the next generation of New Japan trailblazers after Keiji Mutoh, Shinya Hashimoto, and Masahiro Chono. However, things didn't go as expected for Shibata -- despite a bright future, he left pro wrestling for MMA, not to return until 2012. Cesaro, meanwhile, is a wrestling journeyman who has competed in Europe, Mexico, Japan, and the U.S. He nearly signed with WWE in 2006, but ended up not joining the organization until 2011. Both men, therefore, have taken a long path to get where they are today. Both men are also hard-hitting grappling masters. Shibata prefers to kick and Cesaro favors a European uppercut, but they're both tough as nails and unlikely to show any weakness while trading blows with one another. With a solid technical background, Cesaro may try to take things to the mat, but he'd find that Shibata can go hold-for-hold there, as well. Cesaro would have to maintain his composure to hang with Shibata, who's typically unflappable, but in the end, if he was able to hang in there (and hit him hard enough), he may find himself victorious. Then again, he may not.

9. The Usos Vs The Young Bucks

Brother tag teams always seem to have a special rapport, and the two closest -- and most talented -- sets of brothers in the sport right now are The Usos and The Young Bucks. Both have found themselves at the center of a tag team division -- The Young Bucks are the stalwarts of New Japan's Junior Heavyweight tag scene while the Usos are singlehandedly (or doublehandedly) keeping WWE's tag ranks afloat. A fight between the honorable Jimmy and Jey Uso and the ultra-cocky Matt and Nick Jackson may be the most interesting bout on this entire list. The Usos' size and strength advantage would give them the upper hand in the early goings, but The Young Bucks, no strangers to cheating, would turn things around with some chicanery -- probably in the form of a double superkick. With an Uso isolated, The Young Bucks would press their advantage, but eventually, the WWE Tag Team Champion would reach his brother's hand, and the tide would turn. The Usos would retaliate with double-team moves -- including a double superkick of their own -- and both teams would pull out all the stops to win the bout, wowing the fans with their teamwork and acrobatics. With high-flying tandem maneuvers and broken covers all around, a miscommunication may be what ends the contest.

8. Dolph Ziggler Vs Tetsuya Naito

Both Dolph Ziggler and Tetsuya Naito are ultra-athletic wrestlers who, unfortunately, are as known for their inability to break through the glass ceiling as they are for their amazing skills. Naito won the prestigious G1 Climax tournament in 2013, but failed to capitalize on the title shot he earned at Wrestle Kingdom 8. As for Dolph Ziggler, from his Money in the Bank cash-in to his victory over The Authority at Survivor Series, he's had no shortage of what seemed to be career-making victories that, sadly, didn't really go anywhere. Both men have something to prove, and they'd hold nothing back -- not out of desperation, but because that's how they wrestle every match. After a short feeling-out process, both men to could be expected to pull everything out of their respective bags of tricks. Naito would likely nail Dolph with his slingshot dropkick and Stardust Press to send him reeling, but keeping the former World Heavyweight Champion down is no easy task -- and just when Naito thinks he has everything under control, a Zig Zag out of nowhere could change the course of the action. Only one thing's for sure -- whoever wins, the match would be a work of art.

7. Randy Orton Vs Kazuchika Okada

Where Kazuchika Okada stands today, Randy Orton stood a decade ago -- Okada's the young, charismatic, good-looking, talented star who stands primed to inherit an entire kingdom. One can argue that Orton never exactly made good on that prophecy (and that he's not a performer on the level of Okada), but the parallels between Okada's present and Orton's past are undeniable. The dynamic would create a scenario where both men have something to prove -- Orton would want to show that experience trumps youth (and that, by extension, he's better now than he was at Okada's age) and Okada would want to make it perfectly evident that he's a one of a kind talent, not to be compared to anybody. The buildup to the contest would show both men hungrier than they've ever been. Okada's agility for his size would likely surprise Orton, but then again, the reverse might be true -- after all, it's not very often that Okada faces someone taller than himself. Okada would probably outwrestle "The Viper" initially, but Orton would eventually slow the pace down and subdue the former IWGP Heavyweight Champion with stomps and chinlocks. In the end, both opportunists would be looking for a single opening, a second where they can hit their devastating finishers. Orton may have the edge in that department -- a ducked Rainmaker turns into an RKO quite easily -- but don't count Okada out. With so much glory on the line, the match isn't likely to end that easily.

6. Triple H Vs Yuji Nagata

There are few men on either company's roster with as much experience as Triple H and Yuji Nagata -- heck, both are WCW alumni. A showdown between "The Game" and "Mr. IWGP" would be a chess match between two grandmasters and a once-in-a-lifetime encounter. There are, of course, differences between their careers, and it would be wise to note them when promoting the fight. While injuries and age have slowed down HHH, seeing him work only a handful of matches a year, Nagata -- who is actually 15 months older than Triple H -- still works a full-time schedule against the best Japan has to offer and holds his own every single night. Still, on the rare occasions when "The Cerebral Assassin" competes, it's against WWE's top stars, and he looks more than comfortable in the ring. Expect a match that starts slow and builds to a fever pitch, with both men digging deep into their arsenals. Nagata's knowledge of submissions would allow him to reverse a Pedigree attempt into something potentially devastating -- like a Nagata Lock III -- compelling HHH to pull his Indian Deathlock out of mothballs. Finally, all of the strategy and knowledge would go out the window, with both men trying desperately for a Pedigree or a Backdrop Driver. This bout would be undoubtedly be clinic between two men with doctorates in professional wrestling.

5. Dean Ambrose Vs Tomohiro Ishii

The past couple of years have been very good to Dean Ambrose and Tomohiro Ishii, both of whom paid their fair share of dues before finding the spotlight (especially Ishii, who has been wrestling since the 90s). In the case of both men, what has made them stars is just how far they're willing to go to in any given fight -- they're totally comfortable taking punishment, and they love dishing it out. Dean Ambrose might be surprised when, in the early goings of the match, a hard lariat barely phases Ishii, but that wouldn't stop Ambrose from trying another... and another. Ishii would be pleased with the fighting spirit of "The Lunatic Fringe," and would encourage him to keep delivering hard blows (until he decided to retaliate with his own, of course). As each man got the measure of his opponent -- and realized just how much it would take to put him down for good -- the offense would get more reckless, with Ishii and Ambrose likely taking years off their own careers in the attempt to subdue one another. In the end, the man who couldn't take any more punishment would collapse, leaving the other the victor of a bout that may just last all night long.

4. Brock Lesnar Vs Minoru Suzuki

At first, a contest between Lesnar and Suzuki might seem like a mismatch -- after all, Lesnar is nine years younger and 60 pounds heavier than the former All Japan Triple Crown Champion. However, Suzuki is one of the pioneers of mixed martial arts in its current form, and he was beating people up for money when Brock was in middle school. Just like Lesnar's athletic credentials and pure badness can't be discounted, neither can Suzuki's. The match would probably start off like all of Lesnar's bouts do -- with an onslaught from "The Beast Incarnate." Punches, elbows, and of course, German suplexes would be the order of the day as Brock tried to take his foe apart, but if anyone can weather the storm -- and go on to find a weakness in Lesnar's game to exploit -- it's Minoru Suzuki. "The Man with the Worst Personality in the World" (yes, that's really one of his nicknames) can grab a body part, slap on a submission hold, and give Lesnar Frank Mir flashbacks in the blink of an eye. Would Lesnar, then, be able to handle Suzuki's onslaught? We'll probably never know.

3. Seth Rollins Vs Kota Ibushi

For a true high-flying spectacle, neither organization could send a better representative than Rollins or Ibushi. Rollins plied his trade on the independents and became famous for his high-risk offense. He toned it down when joining WWE with The Shield, but he still busts out the occasional corkscrew plancha (or, as seen at the Royal Rumble, Phoenix Splash) when needed, showing he hasn't missed a beat. Ibushi, meanwhile, has been voted Best Flying Wrestler of the Year by the Wrestling Observer Newsletter four of the last six years. He can brawl and wrestle as well as anyone, but he's mostly known for his springboard moonsault, standing shooting star press, and of course, Phoenix Splash. Rollins would probably start off the bout conservatively; he's gotten far more cautious as a wrestler. That wouldn't phase Ibushi, though, who can work any style with total acuity. Eventually, things would get more frantic, with both men attempting (and often missing) high-risk maneuvers. Rollins's willingness to bend the rules makes him a wild card, but in the end, Ibushi would bring out the best in him, and it would a Phoenix Splash -- from someone -- that ends the bout.

2. Daniel Bryan Vs Shinsuke Nakamura

Both Daniel Bryan and Shinsuke Nakamura are hailed as amongst the greatest pro wrestlers on the planet, and the styles they've used to gain that accolade are quite similar -- both use hard strikes (especially kicks) and submissions, an approach known in Japan as "strong style." As characters, however, the two couldn't be more opposite, and that would do just as much to make a match between them a classic as their amazing skill would. Bryan is a hard-fighting underdog babyface, clean cut (in attitude if not appearance), and always honorable. The equally-popular Nakamura, though, skirts the line between heel and babyface, mocking his opponents with eccentric, flamboyant displays, regardless of their alignment. Expect a mat-based classic that turns into an all-out brawl (with slaps, knees, and hard suplexes) before going back to the mat, with each man trying to catch his opponent in increasingly obscure submission holds. The only question is whether the match ends with a "Yes!" or a "YeaOh!"

1. John Cena Vs Hiroshi Tanahashi

One man is a record-setting world champion and a perennial main-eventer. He's anchored his company for years as the ultimate babyface, winning particular favor with young fans. He may be getting older, but he's still the ace of his entire promotion. The other man is John Cena. Cena and Tanahashi have more similarities than differences (and an argument against Cena's ring work shouldn't even be considered -- like Tanahashi, he's had more classic matches than anyone in his promotion over the past decade). Both are the supremely talented and charismatic flagships of their companies, larger-than-life heroes in an era with fewer and fewer of them. A match between the two legends is irresistible to imagine and would be amazing to witness. Both men are masters of the big-match scenario, and when Tanahashi caught Cena coming off the ropes for a Five Knuckle Shuffle with a Sling Blade, or Cena grabbed Tanahashi as he attempted a High Fly Flow and hoisted him into an AA, the response would be electrifying. No matter whose hand would be raised after the marathon encounter ended, it would be a clash for the ages.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott Fried is a Slammy Award-winning* writer living and working in New York City. He has been following/writing about professional wrestling for many years and is a graduate of Lance Storm's Storm Wrestling Academy. Follow him on Twitter at https://twitter.com/scottfried. *Best Crowd of the Year, 2013