10 Things We Learned Attending WWE WrestleMania 40 Live

Stories finished and unfinished, Final Bosses, and more at WWE WrestleMania 40.

The Greatest Show on Earth
WWE

WWE had already dubbed WrestleMania 40 the biggest and best 'Show of Shows' in history before its first half had even wrapped - and at times, these lofty claims felt justified.

From Cody Rhodes finishing the story and The Rock's planet-sized return to the ring, to the emotional triumphs of Sami Zayn and Bayley and Rhea Ripley's legacy-cemented conquering of Becky Lynch, 'Mania was crammed with capital 'M' moments. This was a show so grandiose, over the top, and fun that the idea of anyone making their way through the turnstiles and not having a good time sounds insane.

The WhatCulture Wrestling team was fortunate enough to attend both nights of WrestleMania 40 amongst other events taking place across the weekend. As always, it proved a perspective-shifting experience, even for those of us whose wrestling preferences typically lie outwith the TKO juggernaut.

Within is a collection of what we thought and felt across a special weekend for the world's greatest form of entertainment, covering the live experience, pomp, circumstance, and everything in between...

NOTE: This article is a collaboration between Michael Sidgwick and Andy H. Murray. The specific author is denoted by initials at the foot of each entry.

10. The Two-Nighter Is King

WrestleMania 40 arena
WWE

WrestleMania 40 was the first 'Showcase of the Immortals' I had attended since 35 in East Rutherford, New Jersey, and, by default, the first since WWE flipped its annual supercard to its current two-night format the following year.

The difference was astronomical. Where previously WrestleMania was veering dangerously close to a monstrous eight-hour runtime, the new era's Saturday and Sunday shows each weigh in at roughly half that. A dreary slog of a live experience that rendered sustained energy levels nigh on impossible is no longer a factor.

WM35 was particularly egregious as it positioned an overlong Triple H vs. Batista No Holds Barred Match, a universally-loathed Baron Corbin defeat of Kurt Angle, and a Fabulous Truth dance break towards the end of a Premium Live Event that wore half its attendees out by Kofi Kingston's sensational victory over Daniel Bryan. And with the event reportedly running beyond its allotted runtime, fans were plunged into post-show travel chaos, scrambling for the last-departing trains and hideously overpriced Ubers.

No such problems with 40. With seven and six matches on Saturday and Sunday respectively, it was easy to stay focused, fresh, and energised. After five years of split-night 'Manias, WWE would be insane to go back to the old marathons.

- AM


9. Literally Blinded By The Light

WM Final Testament
WWE

I have attended three WrestleMania events in person; XXX, 35, and 40. Two of those events featured at least one match that was effectively ruined through a poor production choice - and what’s more annoying is that WWE has not learned a thing in the intervening five years. 

At ‘Mania 35, one entire corner of the stadium could not see AJ Styles Vs. Randy Orton. They only ended up missing a mediocre gentleman’s three, in the end, but it’s the principle of the thing. Those punters have paid an eye-watering sum of money, having saved up all year for the financial investment and spending just as long a time looking forward to what is a bucket list item. At a minimum, they should be able to watch the show. That is the bare minimum experience! 

It happened again at WrestleMania 40: Final Testament Vs. Bobby Lashley and Street Profits and LA Knight Vs. AJ Styles were all but impossible to watch live. A searingly bright spotlight above the screen that towers of the ring burned with the blinding intensity of the low winter sun. You should not have to pack sunglasses when you watch an outdoor event in April in the northeastern United States; given how cold it gets, between hoodies and coats, you’ve enough to carry. 

Compounding the sense of frustration is that WWE’s production values elsewhere are pure state of the art, and they aren’t shy about bragging over this fact. 

It’s half-entertaining to express your fury, and there may even be some sort of arcane production technique that necessitates this dilemma - but it’s pure amateur hour.

- MS


8. Becky Lynch's Mixed Reception

Rhea Ripley Becky Lynch
WWE.com

Though technically playing the babyface against Rhea Ripley, Becky Lynch's reception verged on frosty in some parts of the Lincoln Financial Field.

'The Man' fell to Ripley in Saturday's Women's World Title match. The Raw duo opened the show and though few would agree they met the bludgeonous heights of Rhea's brutal Charlotte Flair clash at WM39, their spirited, competitive bout delivered at a high level. Impressive, given Lynch had been fighting a flu and head cold in the days before 'Mania, carrying a 102-degree temperature into the event.

But Becky struggled to draw even majority support in Philadelphia. This likely speaks to Ripley's explosion in popularity more than anything else - and it'd be hasty to read too much more into it - but there were smatterings of jeers throughout the building as Lynch made her entrance. When working from beneath, Philly was far from universal in willing Becky towards her babyface comebacks.

Lynch's WWE contract was set to expire in under two months at the time of writing. Perhaps a break will remind WWE fans of her value, breathing new life into those reactions.

Or maybe it's a simple case of not working with Rhea Ripley next.

- AM


7. You Better Bundle Up

WWE WrestleMania XL Cody Rhodes Roman Reigns
WWE

If you ever wondered why WWE has promoted WrestleMania in Florida so often, you'll get your answer by attending WrestleMania in the northeastern United States. In Philadelphia, the temperature plummeted when the sun set. 

This was expected - attending an outdoor April show in New Jersey will steel you ahead of the occasion - but you can never actually prepare for it. I wore four layers of clothing on my upper half and my knees were still clacking together through the shivering cold. When WrestleMania is hot, you forget about the cold. When the show is at its most bombastic or visually striking, you can no-sell it. You take leave of your senses and experience very real WrestleMania magic. When you're watching a wrestler do little in the spaces between moves, it's difficult to roar your support. 

The atmosphere flattens as a result. WWE shouldn't alter the calendar nor deprive a state of the occasion, no matter how international the event has become, but be warned: the WrestleMania dream can feel like a first-world problem, a bit of a downer, even if you wrap up warm. 

Be wary of the sheer drop, too: don't be fooled by how warm it might feel during the day. Even if you're sweaty and uncomfortable before you leave your accommodation, you'll regret not covering up.

- MS


6. The Perfect Formula

WWE WrestleMania XL Seth Rollins Drew McIntyre
WWE

Becky Lynch vs. Rhea Ripley was a great wrestling match made more impressive with the knowledge that Lynch was struggling with strep throat and a high temperature in the Women's World Championship bout. It was an effective Saturday opener between two big stars - and certainly befitting of the spot.

But Sunday's opening sequence was perfect.

Post-Stephanie McMahon return, Drew McIntyre and Seth Rollins delivered a breathless, blistering World Heavyweight Championship bomb-fest. A flurry of finishes and kickouts and drama and chaos and adrenaline, it was a furious, frenzied head-rush of a match, layering pops on top of pops on top of pops - and this only continued with the post-match.

McIntyre's arrogant goading of CM Punk opened the door for Damian Priest's successful Money in the Bank cash-in. This chain of events wasn't just compelling from a narrative standpoint (Punk vs. McIntyre already feels massive, and Priest deserves his new strap), but also in terms of how it manipulated the WrestleMania 40 audience with its masterful sequencing.

This should be the new blueprint for WrestleMania opening acts. Colossal, planet-shifting developments, hot action, and bad blood.

- AM


5. The Difficulty Of A Certain Style

WWE WrestleMania XL Bayley
WWE

Because WrestleMania is held in a ridiculously cavernous stadium setting, there's a very good chance you won't have an ideal view of the ring. You'll probably find your line of vision drifting between the ring and the big screen. That's the trade-off for the extravagantly awesome aesthetic: you can't really see. 

And, because you can't see, the more subtle and intricate the in-ring action is, the harder it is to track. It's often said that a really good match is elevated by the WrestleMania Effect, but equally, a really good mat-based battle driven by limb work is very hard to get over in a stadium - hence why it took IYO Sky Vs. Bayley a decent amount of time to develop into something great. 

Conversely, Logan Paul's exaggerated smug facial expressions and glorified spot-fests absolutely rule in that setting. As clichéd and repetitive and cringeworthy as the finisher kick-out/shocked kick-out face is, you can see why the producers opt for it more often than not. It gets a reaction when getting a reaction is difficult. A show needs range, but the byproduct of the technical slow-burn is low volume. 

It is unavoidable.

- MS


4. The Rock Is, Quite Frankly, Godly

The Rock
WWE

As a 36-year-old child of the New Generation and Attitude Eras, I have a complicated history with Dwayne Johnson.

I was always more of a 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin guy. Though he and Johnson were both unfathomably huge as my hobby became a lifelong addiction at the turn of the century, Austin's harder edge spoke to me more than fellow franchise player's sharp tongue, slick outfits, and flashiness. I liked The Rock, but I loved Austin, and it wasn't until long after Johnson had transitioned from wrestler to actor that I fully appreciated Dwayne's mastery.

My appreciation of 'The People's Champ' only grew with time. And like Austin, I never got to see him live. Growing up in Aberdeen, Scotland made doing so nigh-on impossible in my early teens.

So for me, WrestleMania 40 was a long time coming. And Dwayne did not underwhelm.

The Rock is a giant. A titan of this industry. My colleagues and I were sat near the top of Lincoln Financial Field, but still felt his presence. He is "aura" personified. His sheer force of personality projected to every single seat in that gargantuan building during an all-timer of a ring entrance and an in-ring performance demonstrating that while Johnson, at 51, likely had a hard night physically, his performance instincts remain sublime.

The 'Final Boss' is one of the finest phases of Rock's career. Seeing him live is a transcendent, fandom-changing experience that I will carry with me forever. As soon as his next match is announced, I'll be pricing a trip.

- AM


3. WrestleMania 40 Holds The Solution To A Big Potential Issue

Logan Paul
WWE

Dominick Mysterio is the most hated figure in WWE. It's an exercise in conditioning in part, in that WWE pressed a button and asked the fans to echo the boos, but Dom is a good little bastard. 

That is until you attend WrestleMania live. 

He isn't the most loathed guy on the roster. He didn't generate that much of a reaction, strangely. As mentioned, anti-Becky Lynch sentiment existed in the stadium. To a considerably lesser extent, the same thing could be written about Cody Rhodes. More than a handful of people seemed exhausted by him, but again: vocal minority. Drew McIntyre is a cracking love-to-hate figure, so much so that people just enjoy and identify with his "hater" energy. In short: every wrestler irrespective of role had their detractors and their supporters. 

With one exception: Logan Paul. 

He is universally despised, which in wrestling is super rare. The baddies are the most fun. Look at heel Rock! You can't be too good at being a bad guy because the fans will grow to respect your mastery of the craft. Weirdly, Paul has mastered his craft, incredibly early, but it doesn't matter. People just hate the guy. 

If that anti-Cody sentiment mushrooms throughout 2024, WWE should know who to programme him against.

- MS


2. Vibes Over Everything In WWE

Jey Uso
WWE

That wrestling is best experienced live goes without saying, but when you attend events the size of WrestleMania, it almost becomes gospel.

There is nothing like the shared exchange of energy between the performers and 70,000+ fans. Middling matches become good, good matches become great, and great matches become all-timers. In-person connection cannot.

I am, at times, a jaded fan, as anyone who has been watching since 1992 has the right to be. I prefer a hard-hitting, grittier style of wrestling to that which WWE typically purveys. I like a tangible sense of animosity, and don't always care for bombastic ring entrances and video packages when sitting at home, watching on the couch, either turning my eyes to my phone or fast-forwarding through them 90% of the time.

But at WrestleMania, I had the greatest time yeeting with Jey Uso, screaming "YEAH-uh!" whenever LA Knight so much as moved a muscle, screaming myself hoarse for Cody Rhodes, and bouncing energy back and forth with my colleagues and our new friends sat around us in Lincoln Financial Field.

Vibes are everything at WrestleMania. Great technical matches mean little if the mood isn't right and the mana ain't flowing. This is a universal truth of live professional wrestling, of course, but it's extra critical at WrestleMania, where it'd be easy for those in the upper decks to feel disconnected from the action otherwise.

Fortunately, WrestleMania 40's vibes were just right.

- AM


1. You Should Definitely Go

WWE Wrestlemania 40 GUNTHER Sami Zayn
WWE.com

If you've ever wondered whether you should save up and make the bucket list item real - but are introverted or anxious or otherwise concerned about the mood - don't be. It can get a little bit intense, but a wonderful community atmosphere envelops the occasion. 

There's a performative element to it, in that people enjoy playing roles - literally, in the case of multiple cosplayers - but there's a genuine warmth, too. You're all there for the same thing. Catchphrases get volleyed across the car park, people will smile and compliment you on your merchandise, and everybody, in general, is friendly and set on having the time of your life. While you're in the stadium, anyway, the atmosphere could not be more welcoming. If the prospect of this much human interaction is too much, you can simply put your head down and avoid it altogether. Nobody will scream in your face. Nobody is aggressive (at least where I was). 

It's fun as much as you want it to be, but it's also genuinely quite heartwarming to watch people of different backgrounds come together for a silly but profound reason. 

It might seem ridiculous, but your faith in humanity might even get restored across the festivities.

- MS


Watch Next


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.