10 Things We Learned From Attending AEW: Double Or Nothing
What happens in Vegas... get's printed here.
They say that "what happens in Vegas, stays in Vegas", but, y'know, if I stuck to that I'd be a pretty s**t journalist.
That's right, the Great Men of WhatCulture.com were present this past weekend in the desert to see the first official show under the All Elite Wrestling Banner. Double or Nothing, live from the MGM Grand Garden Arena, 12,000 fans in attendance, and some huge, huge surprises on the cards.
Myself, Phil and Wilbourn have already done out high-banter podcast where we regale you all with the stories of Hornswoggle teaching us to play craps, Cris Cyborg crashing our videos, Tama Tonga ruining our podcast and me accidentally ending up at a Good Charlotte gig, so go give that a listen if you've not already. This, however, is the slightly more important stuff.
The eyes of the entire world were on Double or Nothing because it carries serious, serious implications for the future of professional wrestling. There is a chance this could provide genuine competition to WWE, and thus shake the foundations of the entire industry in a way that hasn't happened since WCW. But there's also just as much of a chance it falls flat, doesn't find an audience, and ultimately achieves nothing of note.
So what did we learn? Well, I'll tell you.
10. The Step Up From All-In Is Already Huge
A small one this but the gulf in class between AEW’s first show and the event that effectively spawned it was staggering. Production, organisation, logistics, scale, everything felt like it had come on leaps in bounds in just a few short months.
Now, yes, getting into bed with legitimate billionaire Tony Khan does afford you the luxury of such extravagances, but as anyone will tell you money guarantees nothing in this business. It’s clear that they’ve gone and put the right people in the right places backstage, and accepted that a lot of things are better handled by other people.
If nothing else, this bodes really, really well for their upcoming TV product. A lot of the roster have never worked a weekly TV show before, and the nuances of that compared to a string of indie dates are numerous and critical. Time will tell if Dynamite lives up to Double or Nothing, but they’re on the right track.
9. 4 Hour Shows In 12,000 Seat Arenas Are Perfect
Yeah I don’t want to bring up WWE too often here because, ultimately, AEW needs to live and die on its own terms but… but but but but but… having sat through 8 hours of WrestleMania in a crowd so big that 80% of them couldn’t even really see what was going on, this is better.
Wrestling is a small thing. It can spill out across the venue sure but, by and large, it’s usually just two people in a 20ft ring. It’s not a sprawling field with dozens of different people moving around it, and often the most important work is done subtly in expression and selling and, yeah, you sort of need to be able to see it.
The MGM Garden Arena isn’t exactly small, but even in its upper reaches you still felt close enough to the action to feel like you were a part of it. In the very nice media area we were kindly given seats in, it was brilliant.
As for the timing… we popped for something to eat in the afternoon, enjoyed 4 hours of great wrestling, and then ventured out to enjoy our evening. Nobody missed any trains and got stranded in a different city with a 3 hour wait for a $200 taxi.
8. MJF Is Going To Be A Star
The big names already signed to AEW have been grabbing all the headlines, but beneath them there’s now an entire roster with huge, huge opportunities to grasp. The eyes of the entire world were on Double or Nothing and, for many of them, this would have been the biggest show they’ve ever worked.
MJF is someone who’s star is on the rise, but it’s been largely in the UK and US Indies, as well as sporadic appearances on Being The Elite. As far as actual in-ring attention goes his biggest moment has probably been All In. Now though, positioned as he is as one of the company’s best heels, he could have a massive 2019.
His performance in the Casino Royale and the subsequent verbal dismantling of both Hangman Page and Bret Hart were two of the shows highlights. Any indy promotions still capable of booking would be wise to take advantage before he’s tied down permanently.
7. Wasting The Rhodes Brothers Feud Will Go Down As One Of WWE’s Biggest Mistakes
Admittedly, there are a lot of potential candidates for WWE’s Biggest Ever Creative Mistakes - hello there, Dean Ambrose’s heel turn - but watching Cody and Dustin reconcile in the ring after one of the most brutal singles matches in recent wrestling history really hammered home what this feud could always have been.
Let’s recap. Cody adopted the Stardust gimmick, went a bit strange, turned on his brother, got rolled up by him at Fastlane and… that was it. No return match at WrestleMania the next month, no real conclusion to the story, just… a roll-up… at Fastlane.
The sheer emotional weight of their Double or Nothing match, with the callbacks to their respective careers, their tag team run and their father made for one of the most compelling contests seen in an age. The sheer gut-wrenching volume of blood will divide opinion, but Cody’s voice breaking as he tells the world just how much he needs “his older brother” will be remembered for years.
WWE had this feud in the palm of their hands and gave it 9 minutes on a dreadful PPV.
6. Events Like Starrcast As So Important To Wrestling
Should go without saying this one, but the bizarre infrequency of events like Starrcast always suggests that the majority of wrestling promotions don’t really see the value in them. Cards fully on the table though, I’ve been a part of running similar things with WCPW/Defiant and, fair enough, they’re an absolute nightmare.
But nothing worth having comes easy, as the old saying goes. While getting dozens and dozens of wrestlers all in the same place at the same time is difficult, and organising hundreds/thousands of fans around them is even harder, it’s categorically worth it.
Without the connection between fans and the performers there is no pro-wrestling, and the partnership between AEW and Starrcast shows that the company absolutely get that. There were meet and greets, signings, podcasts, live talks, interviews, everything, and it will have made the weekends of so, so many fans.
5. The Elite Know What’s ‘Best For Business’
AEW finds itself in a rather unusual position for a wrestling promotion, in that its 4 biggest stars are also its Executive Vice-Presidents. This puts them in a bit of a weird position as they have to simultaneously book an exciting wrestling product as EVPs while, at the same time, trying protect their own careers are big stars. These are not mutually exclusive.
While 3 out of the 4 of them won, there’s no doubt whatsoever that all of their opponents on the night came out looking just as important to the company as they did.
The Lucha Brothers look every inch the tag team the Young Bucks do, Jericho got a huge win over Omega in the shock of the night and, as for Dustin Rhodes, well, he was last seen on TV getting dumped out of Greatest Royal Rumble. All 4 of them left that show the talk of the entire crowd.
4. Fans And Wrestlers Alike Are Desperate For This To Succeed
The hunger for a new, viable, wrestling product has never been stronger. Whether that’s down to changing tastes not being reflected by the mainstream product or, simply, WWE being in an utter creative cesspit at present, who knows. But it’s there.
However this isn’t merely about the fans getting excited about something new, everyone on the other side of the barrier sees the potential for AEW to change things and they want a piece of it as well. The game has been rigged for the only show in town for too long now, and the possibilities that open up if there’s successful competing can’t be overstated. Here, watch this…
3. Chris Jericho Is Still A Main-Event Attraction
Despite one of the most accomplished runs in the entire industry and some career-best work with the List of Jericho, Y2J’s final few matches for WWE were going 50/50 with Hideo Itami on a series of house shows. Entering his late 40s, it looked like his career was beginning to wind down.
Then of course, came Kenny.
His out-of-nowhere match with NJPW’s Kenny Omega for the IWGP United States Title became the special attraction match of a generation and revitalised his career as a global talking point. He went near 35 minutes with the best in the entire world, in the Tokyo Dome, for his first ever 5 Star match.
Despite this, almost nobody thought he’d then go on to be one half of the main-event in the most hyped wrestling show in decades, and arguably be the element of that match most people were excited about. But he did. And he was.
2. Moxley Is Going To Change The Game
A few months ago Dean Ambrose had the lamest gimmick in wrestling. He had the weirdest half-arsed heel turn that turned a super-hot potential feud with Seth Rollins into a weird, plodding, confusing back-and-forth that they forgot about within weeks. He also feuded with Nia Jax.
In the space of one weekend he’s become the biggest talking point in wrestling, gatecrashed the main-event of AEW’s first ever show, brawled with Kenny Omega and Chris Jericho, been unveiled for New Japan Pro Wrestling, and got himself at title match at Best of the Super Juniors. Again, he was feuding with Nia Jax.
Since WCW folded no big stars have left WWE and immediately looked to have taken a step up in their career. Everything was, in the short-term at least, something of a step-down or a period of recuperation for them to bounce back from. Ambrose, by contrast, has just launched himself into the stratosphere.
1. AEW Is The Real Deal
This is not the first wrestling show to have serious aspirations. This is not the first wrestling show that has rode into a big arena on a wave of hype and expectation. This is not the first wrestling show that has seen a recently departed WWE star make a shock debut.
But something was different here, and there a tangible sense of something genuinely special starting. Vegas, 12,000 people inside the MGM Grand, a card stacked with some of the greatest talent on the planet all hungry to prove a point. Slick production, a rabid crowd, F***ING PYRO, everything falling into place almost seamlessly.
And still, none of that guarantees you anything. A large crowd, an exciting card, JR on commentary, it all falls flat if the matches don’t deliver and the stories you tell don’t connect. However leaving that arena on Saturday night every single fan was buzzing with the memories they’d just collected and the excitement of what might be to come. They nailed it.
Was Rhodes vs Rhodes one of the greatest matches they’d seen in ages? Are The Lucha Bros Did Chris Jericho really just get himself into the first AEW world title match? Has Jon Moxley really just debuted. The conversation has moved from AEW the company to AEW the product, and that's the biggest tripumph of all.