10 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE NXT TakeOver

The black-and-gold brand's undisputed golden era, from rise to rust.

Sami Zayn
WWE

WWE's business is booming in just about every aspect in 2023, but there was a period in the not-too-distant past where the WrestleMania brand was doing an incredible job of disguising a wider public malaise.

Vince McMahon's insistence that, after WrestleMania 22, the company were never to downscale the 'Show Of Shows' was such a smart one. The undisputed market leader was that in name alone at various points throughout the 2000s - a lack of real competition had blunted the company's creative blade, and a serious lack of clear post-Attitude Era identity was turning viewers away from wrestling as a whole rather than creating an audience for TNA, Ring Of Honor and other smaller operations.

The state of the future was as bleak as the present too. Developmental became a farcical prospect for anybody with anything unique to offer, and the main roster product became a landing point for those mostly too scared to colour outside of the lines or do anything that wasn't reduced to "pleasing Vince McMahon" on any given day. When that changed with the weather, so too did the trajectory of another generic and jacked greenhorn.

NXT's 2012 relaunch - and especially the quarterly "TakeOver" brand launched in 2014 - was the change Triple H spied from the inside, and delivered from his fairly protected catbird seat. The calls were coming from inside the house but Triple H's best trick was temporarily fooling people that wasn't the case.

For around 7 years, he did rather well...

10. Lost Classics

tyler breeze-sami-zayn-nxt-takeover
WWE.com

Genuinely lost, genuinely classics.

They're hard to come by in this era of content super-service and everything being available everywhere, but the Full Sail era of TakeOvers in particular left behind a legacy of contests that added WWE to conversations the Vince McMahon-led version of the brand had never been in.

Adrian Neville Vs Finn Bálor from TakeOver: Rival. Charlotte Vs Sasha Banks from TakeOver: R: Evolution. The Ascension Vs Kalisto & El Local from the original TakeOver. The Baron Corbin squashes as counted along by the Full Sail crowd in one of the closest ever comparisons to the magic Paul Heyman summoned with 911 during mid-1990s ECW's creative peak.

These are - unlike all the images and clips constantly re-shared on Twitter - matches and moments nobody talks about.

"The WWE roster in 2008 was STACKED", but so too was the first ever "NXT TakeOver" event, held in May 2014. "Randy Orton was a MENACE in 2009", but Tyler Breeze was a bigger one as the black-and-gold brand grew, working awesome and dramatic bouts with Sami Zayn and Hideo Itami either side of an electrifying TakeOver: Fatal 4-Way main event that also featured Zayn, Neville and Tyson Kidd. "SmackDown Live In 2016 Was FIRE" but NXT one year earlier was a raging inferno by comparison.


9. GOAT Follows GOAT Follows GOAT Follows GOAT Follows GOAT Follows GOAT Follows GOAT Follows GOAT

Charlotte Natalya Takeover
WWE.com

Did Triple H actually believe the rhetoric he used to spout about a revolution in women's wrestling happening under his purview? Regardless of the corporate speak chucked around on the main roster, he had about six years of showing rather than telling on the TakeOver stage.

There are fairly clear eras and dividing lines over the years, but the one constant is a sense of legitimately impressive change and growth with every step forward.

When Charlotte Flair and Natalya fought over the vacant Women's Championship at the first ever NXT TakeOver and it was the best WWE-branded women's match ever. Flair's defences against Bayley and Sasha Banks at TakeOver: Fatal 4-Way and TakeOver: R Evolution respectively and the Horsewomen at Four-Way at TakeOver: Rival continued the trend. Banks and Becky Lynch made each other at TakeOver: Unstoppable, and the Bayley/Banks matches to follow get their own entries elsewhere in this list.

Asuka picked up the mantle and dominated following her win over 'The Hugger' at TakeOver: Dallas in 2016, and when she departed for the main roster in 2017, the company had successfully prepped Shayna Baszler to re-do the entire thing but as a heel. The Women's Championship match routinely became a TakeOver highlight and/or show-stealer, with title changes typically being some of the hottest moments in the brand's history.

Emma and Saraya returning to mainstream roles in WWE and AEW respectively around the same time in late-2022 brought about conversations about them kicking all of this off with their awesome NXT Arrival showdown early-2014. Considering the snowball effect of that specific encounter...where's the lie?


8. NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn Was The Most Important Event In NXT History

Triple H
WWE.com

During the latter days of his in-ring career, NXT felt as much a proving ground for Triple H as anything else.

After a slow and steady 2012-13 reboot to wash away the stain of the gameshow era for the brand, it quietly morphed into the one thing wary and weathered WWE fans could still rely on. A weekly product offering logical progression and great matches that all fed into increasingly electrifying TakeOvers with their amazing payoffs and incredible matches. On its best day - and there were suddenly lots of those - NXT was quite simply an exceptional wrestling product and something Raws and SmackDowns from the era could only really harness in microcosmic moments.

Funded and augmented by WWE money and production respectively, it grew hand-in-hand with 'The Game's obscenely expensive Performance Center that, for better and worse, has determined a far more securer future than the wretched one promised by a mid-2000s developmental malaise overseen by John Laurinaitis.

TakeOver: Brooklyn was a celebration of all of this.

Back in the big building (and trumping fan interest in SummerSlam in that building the very next night), the show was a celebration of all 'The Game' had built (with WWE backing), presenting a near-perfect mix of indie darlings and homegrown talents colliding in a rare case of wrestling serving every master.

Hunter also achieved something as a booker that he never did as a wrestler too - he crafted something earnestly and truthfully transcendent. Sasha Banks and Bayley might have had a little something to do with it too...


7. Sasha Banks Vs Bayley Was The Best And Most Important WWE Match Of The 2010s

Sasha Banks Bayley NXT Takeover Brooklyn
WWE.com

The 2010s was the decade in which WWE addressed a years-long identity crisis on-screen and secured deals that protected its finances for life off, but neither of those stories combated the reality that the market leader was the biggest heel in the market.

Vince McMahon luxuriated in being disliked at times, but that negativity and needless needle flowed underneath his entire company like the toxic mood slime in Ghostbusters 2. Never was this more apparent than in the women's division, which, by 2015 was both a half-baked Divas division holder and an under-serviced in-ring presentation. A tag match pitting The Bellas against Paige and Emma was allotted just over 30 seconds of a three-hour Raw in February, and the surge of momentum behind a #GiveDivasAChance trend forced Vince McMahon to reply on Twitter. NXT between 2014 and 2016 made enormous, industry-changing strides to change that perception, and Sasha Banks Vs Bayley at TakeOver: Brooklyn was as integral a part of that change as Stone Cold Steve Austin and Bret Hart were to ushering in the Attitude Era and rise of 'The Rattlesnake' at WrestleMania 13.

Like all historic moments, it rules and it rules hard. It had to - as usual, the bar was way higher for women, and in stealing a show designed to highlight just how awesome NXT had become, the Women's Championship became one of the most prestigious in all of wrestling.

It's perhaps a leap to suggest a Women's Revolution on the main roster wouldn't have happened without this contest, but's absolutely fair to consider this proof of concept when none should have even been required.


6. The Four Horsewomen Were For Real

Four horsewomen
WWE.com

After Bayley and Sasha Banks' epic NXT Women's Title match at TakeOver: Brooklyn, Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch joined the pair in-ring to say a shared goodbye to the brand as all bar the new Champion headed for pastures new and unknown.

It involved the four breaking character seconds after the match to effectively pay tribute to themselves for every enormous and once-thought-unfathomable leap forward made in an organisation that had systemically discouraged it for decades up to that point.

The reason The Clique's 1996 "curtain call" was so destructive to locker room morale back then wasn't because wrestlers hated the idea that other wrestlers could be friends and wish them well as they parted ways. In an era where certain aspects of the industry required more protection, the acknowledgement of the real-life union felt like an intentional undermining a kayfabe wall everybody worked hard to preserve.

In front of a sold-out house still selling the euphoria of a bona fide classic, fans and fellow wrestlers alike couldn't have been more supportive of the quartet sharing a spotlight they'd grafted relentlessly to gain.


5. The Revival Rule

american alpha the revival
WWE.com

It wasn't just women's wrestling being given a much-needed overhaul on NXT during the brand's golden era. Triple H tackled tag teams too.

Identifying that the neglect of tag team wrestling on the main roster was fundamentally flawed, 'The Game' used The Ascension on early TakeOvers to reestablish the importance of the belts, but it wasn't until they found their way to The Revival via Blake & Murphy and The Vaudevillains that good intentions turned to great outcomes.

As Dash Wilder and Scott Dawson refined their throwback act, Chad Gable and Jason Jordan polished up their American Alpha unit as the polar opposites. In the meantime, TakeOver: London presented perennial nearly-men Enzo & Cass as perfect pretenders to the throne thanks to the exhilarating Dash and Dawson formula working so perfectly. American Alpha and The Revival traded the belts between TakeOver: Dallas and TakeOver: The End, and when the Alphas jumped to the main roster, the heels were perfect to start the years long #DIY story.

For years the best team in the world not named The Young Bucks (and plenty thought they were better), their iconic black-and-gold legacy was assured by the dream match discussed across multiple platforms until AEW finally provided the stage.


4. The Rise Of #DIY Is As Good As Everybody Remembers...

Tommaso Ciampa Johnny Gargano Candice LeRae
WWE.com

When TakeOver pivoted from presenting the first best-in-class set of Performance Center standouts to Triple H and William Regal's grand collection of newly-signed indie darlings, guaranteed match quality all but replaced regular storyline development.

TakeOver was such a safe bet of a destination that less care was given to the journey, but the uneasy rise through the tag ranks by #DIY, their engaging run as reigning-then-former Champions and the brutal blood feud that spanned nearly two years from heel turn to babyface redemption ensured that every supercard had something with emotional substance.

Fittingly, it all peaked on what must surely be the most creatively satisfying night of Triple H's booking career.

April 2019's TakeOver: New York was one of the company's best-ever shows, NXT's WrestleMania X-Seven and - in hindsight - the season finale proper for this magic era of NXT TakeOver. Gargano and Adam Cole found the peak of the well-trodden black-and-gold in-ring epic over 38 impossibly electrifying minutes, and 'Johnny Wrestling's embraced by an injured Ciampa as he's crowned Champion of the place he loves.

It was the perfect conclusion to their saga, but as NXT content was suddenly of greater value to Vince McMahon with the advent of All Elite Wrestling, there was no chance the story could ever be allowed to truly end...


3. But The Fall Is Even Worse...

NXT One Final Beat Johnny Gargano Tommaso Ciampa Candice LeRae
WWE.com

In February 2020, less than a year after an injury to Tommaso Ciampa put an enforced but welcome end to the #DIY feud, Johnny Gargano turned heel to reboot hostilities between them. They were to fight at TakeOver: Stand & Deliver over WrestleMania 36 weekend, in a retooling that drew quiet resentment from NXT lifers pining for something new.

Truthfully, their genuinely remarkable TakeOver: New Orleans war in the Spring of 2018 war had already felt further in the rearview mirror by the time they were fighting and reuniting later that year. Ciampa becoming NXT Champion thanks to accidental interference from Gargano was a great subversion of everybody's expectations, and it was sort of impossible to criticise the technical brilliance work, but almost every other match they had after the original was a little on the indulgent and overly-theatrical side.

It would be good when they were finally allowed to part ways, said nobody internally.

The aforementioned Gargano swerve turn brought about a rancid "One Final Beat" during the second week of 2020's TakeOver: Stand & Deliver payoff that came with a baked-in promise that they'd never wrestle again. They were back at it in the summer. Both encounters took place in empty buildings, and the actTING and am-dram facial expressions generated memes rather than Moments (TM).

Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa were too great individually and together to have their rivalry and its staples become such a tired collection of clichés. But the (black-and-)golden boys suddenly felt anything but valuable to the brand, and unfortunately they weren't the only ones...


2. How Gradually It Ate Itself Alive

Adam Cole Johnny Gargano
WWE

There was a point halfway through the stodgy main event of TakeOver: Toronto in August 2019 where Adam Cole and Johnny Gargano no longer knew what to do to one another, and on commentary Mauro Ranallo put this over as being the result of their many titanic struggles.

It was more a case of fact bleeding over into fiction.

The need for critically acclaimed classics grew more pronounced as Triple H tried to hide that he was running out of ideas. TakeOver: WarGames in 2019 offered scintillating titular battles, but they came at the expense of the performers' well-being. Adam Cole worked so much around this time that he looked like he'd been repackaged as an Egyptian mummy for 2.0 thanks to all the bandages.

There was no escaping the problem at the last TakeOver before the pandemic, and last of its kind before much of NXT's hardcore ticket-buying base migrated to AEW. It was fabulous by formula, with all the right moments making all the right noises but there was a frustrating sense of familiarity and excess in just about every match. Chesney Hawkes played "One & Only" twice in a 7-song set when he played the Unis after his brief peak. That looked disciplined compared to what became of the Factory Settings TakeOver show. Portland concluding with the setup to another Gargano/Ciampa showdown put too fine a point on that.

Obviously, none of that could go to plan, but March 2020's global shutdown at least squeezed some impressive ingenuity out of All Elite Wrestling. How would things go on the other side of the Wednesday Night War?


1. The Pandemic Expedites The End

Capitol Wrestling Center
WWE

NXT was heading for a number of different icebergs in 2020, but like The Titanic itself, wealth and extravagance would have continued to obscure that until the brand fully capsized under the weight of its own arrogance in the end.

The NXT Capitol Wrestling Center was a marginally better solution to the empty arena feeling that WWE's original Performance Center tapings, but even when people came back, the grimy aesthetic was simultaneously too sludgy and too polished to register in the way Triple H intended.

Every aspect of the presentation was - the loud roaring music was fine when accompanied by loud roars supporting a popular and theoretically counter-culture brand, but those days had long, long passed. The last NXT logo under Triple H's original tenure was an abomination true to the mutated vanity spectacle the black-and-gold brand had become. A big chrome "X" atop the existing NXT logo with its own big X (as if 'The Game' wanted one each for him and Shawn Michaels) adorned with skulls couldn't have related less to the wrestlers coming through the curtain, further decreasing a decaying connection with a diminished and/or deadened crowd.

TakeOvers weren't without minor moments of magic. Mining 1995 for nostalgia was a choice, but June 2020's In Your House was a cute play on words and an aesthetic dream factory. TakeOver: XXX offered up Adam Cole and Pat McAfee's awesome payoff even if the atmosphere was too haunted for such charismatic figures. And Walter provided the brand's last classics against Tommaso Ciampa and Ilja Dragunov at TakeOver: Stand & Deliver 2021 and TakeOver:36 respectively.

But, like all too many classic NXT programmes, the ending was protracted and drawn out. The 2021 2.0 reboot wasn't for everybody, but it was more of a necessity than many were willing to admit.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.