10 Times Jim Cornette Got It Absolutely Right
Vince Russo sympathisers may wish to look away now...
For somebody as forthright and plainspoken as Jim Cornette is, a lot of people somehow manage to misunderstand him.
The perception of Cornette in some quarters of the wrestling fandom is of a bitter old-timer, whose anti-modernity diatribes stem not from sincerity but from bias. As some would have it, he criticises modern mainstream wrestling because he is not a part of it.
But Jim Cornette would not work for WWE if you paid him Brock Lesnar money. He hates their "sports entertainment" vision for pro wrestling, and did so before WWE even coined the term. He doesn't want a return to four hour George Hackenschmidt marathons - he just wants what he is passionate about to make sense.
Like the best brains in wrestling, he has ensured his longevity by carving out a hugely entertaining secondary career as a shoot video specialist - an inimitably grouchy, hilariously verbose vanguard against the dumb*ssery prevalent in wrestling.
Yes, he's a little on the unhinged side. Yes, his hatred of Vince Russo borders on the unhealthy. But he is a veritable treasure of the wrestling world, and he should be celebrated. And even when he's wrong, he's damn entertaining with it.
Here, though, we discuss just some of the many times he was absolutely spot on in his damning indictments of the wrestling landscape...
10. The Ryback Payment Plan
Ryback made waves across the wrestling world by suggesting that wrestlers should get paid - equally regardless of whether they win or lose.
You can almost see the logic - or at least, the thought process, myopic though it is. Ryback would have received less pay than CM Punk for wrestling him in the same match. Punk's supposed injuries notwithstanding, who watched the Ryback Vs. Punk matches for Ryback?
The former Ryan Reeves - Ryback, like the Ultimate Warrior before him, has changed his name - is right in one respect. But it's pretty much by accident.
There are pay disparities in WWE. If one is to believe AJ Lee, their female talents earn a "fraction" of what their male counterparts do. Her husband, CM Punk, is one of many to point out that the issue of Pay Per View appearances - which already had been calculated by an inscrutable algorithm - should be addressed, given that talents haven't yet been told how their salary will be augmented in the Network era.
That said, Cornette, with his winning use of analogy, summarised the idiocy behind Ryback's argument. "That means that the Shakespearean actor who gets a bit-part walk-on in a Schwarzenegger movie should get Arnold's money. He's a great actor, but he ain't the star of the movie. He's a f*ckin' bit-part player!"
9. The Brawl For All
The 1998 Brawl For All Tournament was a ridiculous concept, but the pitch wasn't without some merit - if one can squint. For the uninitiated, the tournament saw 16 men, largely also-rans, contest legitimate fights on obviously-worked WWF shows, with a fusion of boxing and amateur wrestling rules.
There were several guys flailing around the undercard, with little else to do, and the resurgent WWF was reaching stratospheric heights because it was flying outside of its comfort zone. What was the harm? Nothing was spoiling.
Except Steve "Dr. Death" Williams, an NWA and All Japan Pro Wrestling legend, who the WWF thought would be legitimised through his inevitable victory. He wasn't. He was knocked out by Bart Gunn and knocked out of main event contention forever.
Oh, and the less-heralded careers of Savio Vega and Brakkus, who sustained injuries that precipitated their withdrawal from the mainstream wrestling world.
Nobody is disputing that the Brawl For All was an unmitigated disaster - but Cornette provided the perfect insight on exactly why it was so bird-brained. The WWF, he argued, had finally, in late '97, all but announced (to their audience) that wrestling was predetermined - and had started writing around this (literal) attitudinal shift. Presenting a real tournament mere months after this admission completely undermined its potency, premise and legitimacy.
The WWF, in the ultimate jutting of their lips, refused to even push the winner, Bart Gunn, so upset were they that he had fairly won a shoot tournament they themselves had promoted.
8. The Admonishment Of Jonny Ace
Jim Cornette is not a fan of John Laurinaitis. Nobody else is, according to the former legendary manager. "His own mother slapped the stork that delivered him!"
If you've ever wondered why WWE was - bar the odd flash of inspiration and in-ring aberration - so comprehensively unbearable at the back end of the 2000s and the turn of the 2010s, John Laurinaitis is the foremost culprit.
Laurinaitis was the driving force behind the glamour model approach to WWE Diva recruitment, often compelled to hire women purely on the basis of their still image spread across swimsuit magazine centrefolds. According to some industry legends, he'd often peruse those pages while sat in Hooters' restaurants.
Cornette however principally loathes Laurinaitis for the torment the former Senior Vice President of Talent Relations subjected him to during his time at the helm of WWE's developmental system - which had implications on WWE's product prior to this vaunted NXT era.
Laurinaitis' oft-inexplicable meddling was, in Cornette's words, "constant" - ranging from ring rope disputes to wilful obstruction to tone-deaf attempts at calling up the talents Cornette had painstakingly readied for the main roster.
Laurinaitis, according to Cornette, would disregard everything good about an OVW-seasoned performer and repackage them for reasons his throbbing veins still cannot comprehend.
7. Some Perspective On The Invasion
Jim Cornette: The Calm Voice Of Reason is probably the "Chilly McFreeze" of desperate autobiography title pitches, but his response to the WWF's bungling of the ECWCW Invasion angle adds some measured shade to what is generally considered a stark, black and white picture.
Many cite it as the biggest missed opportunity in the history of wrestling - myself included - but what's often lost amongst the dissent is the sheer extent to which the WCW brand had been damaged before Vince McMahon purchased the rights to it.
To Cornette's mind, the WWF couldn't draw on WCW's genuine star power to drive it. The contracts of Goldberg et al. allowed them to sit on their a*ses for the same amount of - if not more - money. Spending creative resources on rehabilitating the WCW name, and jobbing star WWF names out to the midcard likes of Hugh Morrus, may have made the WWF's bread and butter mouldy.
The insight that WCW botched the Invasion before it began, if a little too forgiving to Vince McMahon, is a sound one. WWE have made their money back, and then some, on the videotape library. That much is indisputable. Sadly, we'll never know how much potential money was lost - but on reflection, Cornette's viewpoint is vindicated when one considers the failure of the nWo's 2002 return.
Even WCW's most famed and marketable brand was all but done for.
6. The Abomination Of Jim Herd's WCW
Cornette in his guest column for WhatCulture Wrestling Issue 2 laid the blame for the demise of pro wrestling squarely at the foot of one man's door...and it wasn't Vince Russo!
No, Cornette reserves a special hatred for Jim Herd - the former low-level Pizza Hut executive whose impossibly conceited mishandling of WCW did more damage to the diverse heart of wrestling than any other single individual.
Under Herd's stewardship, WCW would combine its breathless, critically-acclaimed in-ring action and superstar roster with a huge cash injection - and somehow contrive to turn into a sick joke. The suggestion that Ric Flair be repackaged as "Spartacus" is in itself an indictment of the man's disastrous reign.
The promotion would recover commercially and artistically in the mid nineties, but it never again felt like the old WCW - i.e. a genuine alternative to the WWF. Cornette's rage is sometimes hyperbolic - mostly for comic effect - but he was bang on with this insight.
In Eric Bischoff's attempts to resuscitate WCW, he turned it into WWF lite, handing the keys to the plane to the egotistical kamikaze pilot Hulk Hogan in the process. It was Hogan's penchant for self-preservation which ruined the best chance WCW had of emerging from the moribund nWo angle with its restored identity intact. But, at Starrcade 1997, Hogan's politicking curtailed Sting's would-be re-ascendence to the WCW mountaintop.
Cornette would, of course, rally against another man who stripped WCW of its identity...
5. The State Of (Some) Modern Wrestling!
Cornette's popularisation of the "flippy guy" meme to denounce the artificiality of modern wrestling has led many to believe that he loathes it. That it has passed him by.
That isn't true. He recently fawned over the NXT Tag Team Championship sequel between American Alpha and The Revival at TakeOver: The End, despite its thoroughly modern, content-stuffed approach - and not just for their athleticism, which is beyond reproach.
Cornette joined the wrestling community in bestowing lavish praise on the Revival, in particular, for their exemplary use of tag team psychology and manipulation of emotion. Cornette, despite having the best seat in the house to several tag team classics in the eighties, received its procession of inventions as a fan - even having to rewind some sequences to work out how they did them safely.
Cornette is, contrary to some criticisms, capable of recognising the merits of the modern style - just not when the Young Bucks are involved. His criticisms come not from a place of bitterness, but from a desire to see widespread improvements to the business he has passionately dedicated his life to.
This is a man who cherishes the development of talent for the advancement of the industry. In telling The Bucks that they're not strong enough to remove a greased-up string from a cat's *ss, he's actually imploring them to tone down their Superkick-heavy act so as to not dilute it.
4. Vince Russo Helped Kill TNA
TNA probably marked the last chance of a viable alternative to the WWE juggernaut. With serious money at its disposal, and capable of attracting many industry veterans, upstarts and darlings, it only needed a unique and patient creative approach to aim an attempted onslaught at its gigantic opponent.
Cornette, perhaps naturally, points the finger of blame for the company's abject failure to do so at Vince Russo - but not without some justification.
The root of Cornette's discord here isn't confined to Russo's second disembowelment of genuine competition, but one imagines he can't be happy with Russo's trademark procession of inanity, including but not limited to: the Last Rites match, the Reverse Battle Royal, the rushed and squandered Kurt Angle Vs. Samoa Joe series, the Claire Lynch angle...
No, Cornette took considerable umbrage with Russo's wallowing mid-2000s admission that he was "sick of writing fake wrestling scripts for wrestlers who didn't appreciate him."
He's not wrong. If Russo - or the "Sorry Sack Of Brooklyn Sh*t", as Cornette has it - could only see that wrestling fans are genuinely passionate about wrestling, and don't view it as a siphon through which to transfer tropes of his beloved late night cable dramas, he might have stood a chance of not becoming the object of their ire.
3. The Sting Debacle
When WWE, after years of courtship, eventually persuaded Sting to see out his career in Stamford, many were optimistic - despite his status as near-octogenarian.
Even when it became apparent that he was to tussle with Triple H - and not supposed WrestleMania dream opponent The Undertaker - fans were largely happy just to see him in a WWE ring. The storyline, too, seemed to promise an end to the interminable Authority angle. Besides, the prospect of a loss in his debut match was inconceivable, and Triple H had recovered from his years-long allergic reaction to jobbing.
Somewhere along the way, though, WWE decided to re-contextualise their dispute into some unfathomable WWE Vs. WCW retread. This should have set alarm bells ringing, in retrospect. The Authority didn't look like it was going anywhere soon.
That Sting was happy enough to do the job is irrelevant. WWE, as Cornette stated after the fact, shouldn't have paired him with Triple H in the first place. "The first impression shouldn't have been a loss. If you didn't want him to beat Triple H, don't book the f*ckin' match!"
Cornette, sagely sensing the wider picture, also criticised WWE for compromising the real reason they brought Sting in altogether. "Besides that, it devalues the property you own in terms of the video rights!"
2. The Ed Ferrara Rant
In Aladdin, everybody hates Jafar - but Iago, his back-up irritant, largely goes ignored.
Ed Ferrara is the obnoxious parrot atop the shoulder of Vince Russo's detestable Royal Vizier, but he isn't spared from Cornette's scorn. And with good reason; Ferrara was the "brainchild"/enabler behind Terri Runnels' infamous pregnancy angle, which in the hands of Russo and his spirit animal had just one logical conclusion: miscarriage!
Cornette summarised his grievance with the angle perfectly: "I always like to say that wrestling is bad taste in good taste, but this was bad taste done in bad taste." Cornette approached Ferrara after the angle's awful conclusion. Ferrara for his part claimed he proposed the angle because "they do it all the time on prime time TV!"
Ferrara would demonstrate a further propensity for disrespectful vulgarity by impersonating Jim Ross - purely to ridicule his struggles with Bell's Palsy. Ferrara as 'Oklahoma' (subtle) would cure the affliction by pouring barbecue sauce over his face, which Cornette in intervening years would spit on in retaliation. His reason?
"If you took Ed Ferrara's f*ckin' nuts, and you threw 'em into a god damn drinking straw, they'd look like a kernel of corn rolling into a storm drain."
1. Vince Russo Also Helped Kill WCW
While Bruiser Brody is credited with giving rise to the shoot video movement, Jim Cornette popularised it. And in initiating hostilities with Vince Russo, Cornette has crafted the most gripping rivalry outside of the ropes in modern wrestling.
Cornette, speaking before WCW closed its doors, was the first to posit the theory that Russo may not have been the messiah of wrestling's second mainstream boom period, attributing his WWF success to strict Vince McMahon regulation and the unprecedented two-headed Orthrus of The Rock and Stone Cold Steve Austin.
Presciently describing the WCW corporate arm as "marks" for hiring Russo, Cornette also criticised (that's understating matters) the Brooklynite for the manner of his WWF exit. As Cornette tells it, Russo didn't have the good grace to tell Vince McMahon in person of his intention to depart the doors of Titan Towers.
Cornette described Russo in his first, infamous rant as a "mark who no longer had to subsist on the internet fans" for adulation. He instead had WCW's dwindling audience for that. That dwindling audience would soon disappear altogether - with Russo largely to blame.
Jim Cornette is a man who does not mince his words - and we have the pleasure of hosting this irresistible wordplay at Refuse To Lose, our first ever iPPV!