10 Times Vince McMahon Backed The Wrong Guy

From the Lex Express to several evil foreigners, Vince McMahon hasn't got it right all the time.

Vince McMahon has been the driving creative force for WWE programming for over 30 years. In addition to being the Chairman of the company, he's also the head booker. He has always been the man in charge and even though he's 69 years old, he's still in that spot. Others like Triple H or his daughter Stephanie McMahon may have a lot of power too, but everything that happens on WWE TV is based on what Vince wants. There have been a number of guys that Vince has pushed hard on television with the idea that they would become the biggest stars in the business. Some are heels while others are faces. Some are American babyfaces while others might be foreign heels because that's an easy angle to do. They come in all shapes and sizes too, but as we know from watching WWE over the years, Vince likes the bigger performers. That may never change no matter how great smaller wrestlers like Daniel Bryan or CM Punk are. It's time to reflect back on some of the guys that Vince backed either on screen or behind the scenes in a major way. These are people that became WWE/World Champions at one point in their career or they were people that probably should have been there except they did something to screw it up. The wrestling business isn't easy to be successful in. Booking it may be even more difficult. While Vince gets a lot of criticism from WWE fans, he also deserves a lot of praise for all the great work he's done in his legendary career. Here's a closer look at ten times where Vince McMahon backed the wrong guy. Who are they and what went wrong with them? Let's find out.

10. Lord Tensai

Vince McMahon has always loved foreign heels. What's funny about it is that he doesn't even care if the guy is really a foreigner or even somebody that used to work for him under a different name. It just seems like Vince will always try to push a foreigner because it's such an easy thing to get a crowd chant "USA" against whoever that foreign heel is. Lord Tensai debuted on the first Raw after WrestleMania 28 in 2012 and was immediately thrust into the spotlight. Even though everybody knew he used to be in WWE as Alberto or A-Train, they didn't call him that. They just said that he went to Japan, changed several things about his life including his look (with tattoos on his head) and he was a new man known as Lord Tensai. He went on to beat main event babyfaces like John Cena and CM Punk. Those wins weren't that clean, but they were significant. He was rumored to become a WWE or World Champion soon after his debut, but it didn't materialize for him. They ended up dropping the "Lord" part of the name so he became Tensai and then he fell from there. He was just another guy. Eventually he became a tag wrestler with Brodus Clay. Earlier this year he retired. They brought him back two years ago to be a foreign heel main eventer. While the attempt was there, the execution was not.

9. The Miz

The main event of WrestleMania 27 saw John Cena challenging the WWE Champion while The Rock made his presence known as the host of the show. If you ask CM Punk, he probably should have been the WWE Champion because he felt like he was the best heel in the company, specifically the Raw brand, at the time. Instead, Vince McMahon chose to put the WWE Title on The Miz. There was nothing wrong with the rise of The Miz on the Raw brand in 2010 when he won the Money in the Bank briefcase as well as the WWE Title. He was a solid wrestler that was great upsetting the fans. However, CM Punk was clearly better. He was better from the moment they both entered WWE at around the same time. Punk had better matches, his 2009 year was arguably the best performance of anybody in WWE and his Straight Edge Society group in 2010 was very entertainer. The Miz was basically doing the same arrogant heel act we've seen in wrestling so many times in the past 30 years. Cena's match with The Miz was bad. It was one of the worst WrestleMania main events ever. There was a double countout, then a restart from The Rock and it didn't get better from there. Look at the matches that Punk had with Cena. They were some of the best matches of the last five years. Some might say that Cena vs. Punk was the best rivalry in that period too. It was special. When all is said and done, Punk will be seen as the bigger star than Miz. What's sad is that Punk never got to main event a WrestleMania even though he should have. Vince backed the wrong guy in this case.

8. Vladimir Kozlov

Vladimir Kozlov is a guy that really shouldn't have received a big push in his career, but it seemed like WWE was interested in doing it because they wanted to have a foreign heel. They love having foreign heels. Look at Rusev's push right now. Kozlov was signed in 2006 and by the 2008 edition of Survivor Series, he was getting a WWE Title shot. Did you know that Kozlov is on the short list of people that have actually beat The Undertaker clean? That just shows that he's a guy that they had really high hopes for. Some of the biggest names ever never beat Undertaker clean, yet Kozlov gave him a powerslam and pinned him on the February 27, 2009 edition of Smackdown. It was a shocker. What Vince McMahon saw in Kozlov was an athletic big, foreign wrestler that they tried to book into a main event role. It didn't last because of his limitations as a talker. Eventually he found his role as a comedy tag team partner of Santino, but that's not why he was brought in. Maybe if they gave Kozlov a manager he could have got over and been a top guy. It was another failed attempt by WWE in creating a new star.

7. Drew McIntyre

"I'd like to introduce you right now to the gentleman I personally signed here on Smackdown. He reminds me a lot of me, quite frankly. High intellect, extraordinarily aggressive and a handsome son of a gun as well. This man, ladies and gentlemen, is going to be future World Heavyweight Champion. Allow me to introduce you...from Scotland, here is Drew McIntyre." - Vince McMahon on Smackdown September 25, 2009. When you get an introduction to WWE fans like that then you are clearly somebody handpicked by Vince McMahon to be a huge star. At the time, McIntyre was only 24 years old and really lacked the experience to be a top guy, but if they developed him most people assumed he would get there. He had the right look that we know WWE likes and he was good enough as a talker too. It was just a matter of if he would get pushed to that level. http://youtu.be/YBLx0ItTeUA The "Chosen One" gimmick was pushed down our throats. There were times when it was clear that he was going to be a top guy. Then things kind of fizzled out for him. His WWE career ended earlier this year as part of the joke heel trio known as 3MB, which was never booked seriously. Since McIntyre is only 29 years old, he might be back in WWE one day. He has said he wants to come back and maybe he will return, but even if he does return he may never reach the lofty expectations that Vince McMahon had for him.

6. Bobby Lashley

Any time somebody gets booked in multiple matches with Vince McMahon they are clearly somebody that WWE wants to be a huge star. It's one of those things where Vince says in his head that there's nobody better on the roster to put this guy over than him. That's what happened with Bobby Lashley. Lashley's biggest push took place at WrestleMania 23 in 2007 when he represented Donald Trump in a match in a Hair vs. Hair Match against Vince McMahon. Lashley won the match for Trump, which led to McMahon shaving his head. The feud continued for several months after with Lashley wrestling McMahon in three straight PPV matches - twice in handicap match and once in a singles match. He was put over huge in the feud. Despite McMahon's best efforts to help Lashley become a top guy, he never reached the top. While he did get to headline a few PPVs, he never became a WWE or World Champion. The farthest he got was the ECW Title, which really wasn't as prestigious as the others. He was released in February 2008, less than a year after that big WrestleMania 23 match. Lashley has actually done really well in TNA this year. He looks like more of an all around and complete pro wrestler now. He's in his late 30s, so maybe he's somebody we could consider a late bloomer. When he was getting the big push in WWE he was still learning. It showed in his performances.

5. Ultimate Warrior

The Ultimate Warrior received one of the biggest pushes ever in the late 1980s and into the early 1990s. He got to do something that few wrestlers have ever done in wrestling history: he beat Hulk Hogan clean when Hogan was still in his prime. In the build up to Warrior's WrestleMania 6 match with Hulk Hogan in 1990, they really pushed the idea that Hogan was unbeatable. He almost never lost from 1984 to 1990, so people believed it. They also suggested that if anybody could beat him it was Warrior because he was a phenomenal superstar that got crowd reactions that were even louder than Hogan. He was a star on the rise. No doubt about it. After Warrior beat Hogan clean at WrestleMania 6, he was given the chance to be the man. However, Hogan was still there. He was lurking in the shadows. It wasn't easy for Warrior to really emerge from the Hogan shadow with him still around. Warrior was mostly a flop as WWE Champion, so instead of main eventing another WrestleMania, he dropped the WWE Title to Sgt Slaughter at the 1991 Royal Rumble. Once again it was Hogan in the main event, this time winning another WWE Title. It was another instance where McMahon tried to find his next Hogan. For a brief time, Warrior was that guy, but his WWE career really didn't last that long and he failed to live up to the enormous expectations that WWE management had for him.

4. Diesel

Any time somebody holds the WWE Title for 358 days (seven days short of one year) like Diesel did through most of 1995, it means that Vince McMahon has a lot of faith in that guy. The mid-90s was a period where Vince was looking for that huge star to replace Hulk Hogan as the biggest draw in the company. He thought it might be Kevin Nash, who was better known as Diesel, but he was very wrong about that. Diesel had a long WWE Title reign that didn't go well. Numbers were down across the board. The PPV buyrates were at all time low numbers (or close to it), ratings were poor with WCW Nitro also starting up in 1995 and house show attendance was also below what WWE would consider average. It also didn't help that unless Diesel was out there with Shawn Michaels or Bret Hart he usually had bad matches. The company was losing money. If it continued for another year or two that could have been it. Why did Diesel get the big push? He's a near 7 footer and 300 pounds. Vince loves the big guys. What's sad about it is that Vince invested all that time and money in this guy, yet a few months after he lost the WWE Title he ended up jumping to WCW for more money. The ironic thing about that is that while he was a poor draw in WWE, he was a difference maker in WCW largely because he was a WWE guy. If Vince didn't back Diesel the way he did, he really wouldn't have meant anything to WCW.

3. Mr. (Ken) Kennedy

Ken Kennedy was being groomed to be a top guy in WWE. It didn't happen right away, but thanks to his ability to cut interesting promos with his "Misterrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr Kennedyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy" routine he quickly gained a following. He was considered one of the fastest rising stars in WWE as a cool heel that had everything going for him. Another factor that helped him was that "Kennedy" is the middle name of Vince McMahon. Apparently he came up with the name along with Paul Heyman when they were in Ohio Valley Wrestling because they knew McMahon could use that in storylines down the road. Two things happened to him to derail his career: he got injured while he held the Money in the Bank briefcase (he ended up losing it to Edge) and he was suspended for using performance enhancing drugs. He was all set to be pushed as McMahon's son. Instead, they turned it into a joke by saying it was Hornswoggle and then later saying it was all fake. The whole thing was an entire mess. Kennedy ended up fired by WWE in 2009 after having too much heat with Randy Orton when he dropped him on his injured shoulder. He hasn't been back. He probably never will be.

2. Chris Benoit

"It all begins again." That was the slogan at WrestleMania 20 when Chris Benoit got to headline the show in Madison Square Garden against Triple H and Shawn Michaels. The idea behind putting Benoit in the match was to not only give a deserving wrestler the chance to headline WrestleMania, but also to show that they could create a new main event star. When Benoit made Triple H out to become the World Champion, it was supposed to solidify Benoit as a top guy. Over the next few months, Benoit really didn't prove to be any kind of draw. He ended up dropping the World Title to Randy Orton at SummerSlam 2004 and he was never able to get back to that main event champion level. The high expectations that WWE had for him were never really met. Part of it was because he wasn't really a big guy and his promo skills were average at best. The sad story about Benoit is that he committed a double murder suicide in 2007 when he killed his wife and young son along with himself. McMahon had no idea that was ever going to happen obviously. Benoit's a name that has been written out of WWE's history books with good reason. It's one of the saddest stories in wrestling history. No doubt about that.

1. Lex Luger

The Lex Express was supposed to carry WWE very far after Lex Luger slammed the mighty Yokozuna in July of 1993. He was supposed to be their next Hulk Hogan. This came right after Hogan left the company after dropping the WWE Title to Yokozuna and Luger was the heir apparent. Luger received a WWE Title push with a match against Yokozuna at SummerSlam 1993. Going into the match, most people thought Luger was going to win because the babyface usually goes over in a setting like that. While Luger won the match, he didn't win the WWE Title. Apparently somewhere along the way, WWE management lost their faith in him. At the 1994 Royal Rumble, he tied Bret Hart as the last man eliminated and Hart went on to become WWE Champ while Luger never held the coveted title. They did all they could to make Luger into the next huge superstar, but it just didn't happen. He didn't have the personality of Hogan or of other top guys that could really get a crowd excited. He was just a basic wrestler. By 1995, he jumped back to WCW and was never in WWE again. Lex Luger should have been a huge star in WWE. Instead, he was one of their biggest disappointments. Nobody was more disappointed than Vince himself.

Contributor
Contributor

John wrote at WhatCulture from December 2013 to December 2015. It was fun, but it's over for now. Follow him on Twitter @johnreport. You can also send an email to mrjohncanton@gmail.com with any questions or comments as well.