10 Times Wrestling Legends Returned (And NOBODY Cared)

The Great Khali at least got a reaction. Brian Christopher, on the other hand...

Skinner WWE
WWE

The shock return is often deemed one of pro wrestling's most worshipped facets.

There's a certain level of indulgence that stems from it. The immense satisfaction from the first beat of that fabled entrance track followed by the jubilant visual of seeing a wounded grappler or a legend from yesteryear reemerging in front of a typically boisterous audience is a feeling like no other in pro wrestling or indeed any art-form. Your writer, an otherwise inattentive MCU viewer, felt the same joy during Spider-Man: No Way Home's Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire's fervent appearances that was felt by a diehard viewer three cinema rows ahead; surround yourself with the right crowd and anything can have a delectable aura attached to it.

In pro wrestling, the shock return can, quite easily, go appallingly wrong.

Paul 'Triple H' Levesque's myriad of 2022 re-signings for WWE was archetypal of how the comeback of a once-idolised grappler can go so erroneously astray. The Good Brothers were scarcely on television until only recently. Johnny Gargano and Candice LeRae are no longer the cherished NXT power couple they were just two years ago. Eric Young may as well have not answered Papa H's texts.

When you're a legend, however, the response is usually more welcoming and cordial. Usually...

10. D'Lo Brown (2008)

D'Lo Brown
WWE.com

D'Lo Brown was silver amongst a treasure trove of prototypically golden Attitude Era grapplers, peaking in an era when The Rock, 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin, Mick Foley, Triple H, and a horde of other auspicious performers did so, too. He was inherently born into the wrong era and although D'Lo stood out from his fellow career mid-carders, he does not stand out as an Attitude Era great.

Perhaps, then, this is why his 2008 comeback played out in front of a joyless audience.

Competing in a throng of untelevised bouts preceded D'Lo Brown's initially-thrilling re-signing with WWE, his televised return coming on the 21 July 2008 broadcast of Monday Night Raw. Battering Santino Marella, he showed flickers of optimism, utilising a harsh repertoire heavily influenced by his time spent in Japan. His seated Lariat was executed with the sort of violence and velocity you'd typically associate with Tomohiro Ishii. It was sickeningly sumptuous.

If you ask the Uncasville, Connecticut audience though, it may as well have been Rodney Mack who'd resurfaced. They weren't fazed by D'Lo's return, nor did they have any reason to be. WWE themselves marred the comeback by relegating Brown to goober status within weeks of his comeback before cutting him altogether the following January, citing "budget issues".

It's funny how things change over the years.

Or don't.


9. George Steele (1998)

George Steele
WWE.com

In his prime, the late George Steele was an intrinsic cog in the WWE machine. He never reached the heights of Hulk Hogan or Bruno Sammartino, but Steele embodied sports entertainment to a tee. Meticulously perfecting his 'Animal' persona, a figure whose characteristics and woolly image allowed him to stand out in a crowd of hulking, chiseled frames, George Steele was everything the Golden Era stood for.

He did not, however, exemplify what the Attitude Era stood for.

Characters had their place in the Attitude Era, but none of them got by on their character work alone; each was a solid hand between the ropes as well. George Steele, too, was a fine wrestler in his prime. By 1998, at which time he was 61-years-old, the green-tongued grappler struggled through his walk to the ring, let alone a match or, God forbid, his horridly sluggish comeback.

Returning on Sunday Night Heat, which says enough about WWE's diligence toward George Steele's return, he lethargically emerged from an oversized Christmas gift box to clock one of The Headbangers before watching as both Mosh and Thrasher briskly walked away. It was a lazy, halfhearted comeback from Steele who threw punches like he was a tipsy pensioner outside his local boozer and unfortunately, the crowd wasn't nearly as ecstatic to see him as Kevin Kelly was.


8. Tommy Dreamer (2015)

Tommy Dreamer
WWE.com

Extreme Championship Wrestling - the actual ECW, not WWE's dilapidated 2006 reboot - will never die.

Formally ceasing operations in 2001 upon being bought out by a tyrannical Vince McMahon, Paul Heyman's 'Land of the Extreme' has endured reunion after reunion, its own entity now becoming something of a running joke over two decades later as chants of 'E-C-dub' continue to ring out. The best reunions are orchestrated outside of WWE, however, the McMahon-fronted sports entertainment brand, too, has been prone to rolling out a mangled, blood-soaked grappler.

Such was the case in November 2015 when Tommy Dreamer, a bin of weapons draped across his shoulder because it's all any ECW wrestler knows, was sent out to aid The Dudley Boyz in their disjointed fight against The Wyatt Family.

What made Dreamer's reemergence so whimsical was that in the seconds before, there was a terse moment where it's evident the audience is expecting an ECW icon the ilk of, say, Rob Van Dam. Tommy Dreamer is an icon of the defunct organisation, but he wasn't what the Pittsburgians had wanted and they let him know that. They were deathly silent for Dreamer's plodding walk through the crowd.

As they were for the subsequent six-man tag team match.

As they were for Rhyno's comeback the following Monday.

As they were for this entire storyline.


7. Tatanka (2016)

WWE Tatanka
WWE.com

The 2016 Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal was a bit weird, wasn't it?

It was won by Baron Corbin, who, at the time, was no more than a comparatively decent Performance Center graduate who'd done a cool move or two in NXT, so that was weird enough.

Shaquille O'Neal ran out as a last-minute entrant in one of those glorified WrestleMania 'moments' that's somehow gone forgotten. Weird, right?

Then, there was Tatanka. Tatanka! At WrestleMania! In 2016!

Indeed, the Battle Royal field stood in the ring, awaiting the arrival of the bigger names. It was a sea of goobers as you'd expect with such filler, but standing next to Heath Slater, R-Truth, and Darren Young was the fabled 'Native American'. What's hilarious is that he was reportedly intended to be sent out individually to receive the same sort of nostalgia pop that Diamond Dallas Page and Shaquille O'Neal got but alas, off he went with The Social Outcasts and indeed the real social outcasts of the WrestleMania card without so much as an 'oh' or an 'ah'.

Tatanka's very existence went almost entirely unmentioned by commentary until they spotted him hammering Darren Young, which only made his one-off comeback more strange, almost as if he got lost on his way back from WrestleCon.


6. Skinner (2007)

WWE Skinner
WWE Network

For context, below is a full list of the Raw 15th Anniversary Battle Royal entrants from December 2007:-

- Al Snow

- Bart Gunn

- Bob Backlund

- Doink The Clown

- Flash Funk

- Gangrel

- Gillberg

- The Goon

- Irwin R. Schyster

- Jim Neidhart

- Pete Gas

- The Repo Man

- Scotty 2 Hotty

- Sgt. Slaughter

- Skinner

- Steve Blackman

- Ted DiBiase

It reads more as a bag of assorted action figures you'd find in your attic than a memorialisation of fifteen years for the red brand. Various rows, disputes, and decaying ring prowess presumptively left WWE without the capacity to promote a Razor Ramon or a 1-2-3 Kid, for instance, but surely - surely - Skinner wasn't the only option left? For accuracy, Skinner had wrestled just twice on Raw prior to this bizarre December 2007 resurgence; he was ousted from a fifteen-man Battle Royal that was one by Razor Ramon before, the subsequent week, he was duly pinned by The Undertaker. He was barely a nod to WWE's past, let alone Raw's past, when Justin Roberts introduced the Everglades resident to a throbbing chorus of nothingness.

It was embarrassing, if not pitiful.

Mind you, the Connecticut faithful barely voiced their opinion for the major stars of the match - DiBiase, Slaughter, Backlund, et al - instead creating a roaring response for its filler, such was the live audience's ineptitude for the time.


5. Jackie Gayda, Joy Giovanni, Sunny & Torrie Wilson (2009)

WrestleMania 25 Divas Santino Santina Marella
WWE.com

Famously, Trish Stratus turned down WWE's invitation to participate in the Miss WrestleMania Battle Royal:-

“Simply, there were no finishes, no, ‘What’s going to happen? Will I win?’ discussed. It was just, ‘Would you like to be in this 25-woman Battle Royal at WrestleMania?’, and I said, ‘Thank you but I’m going to decline'.”

Trish Stratus, in one nimble rejection, saved face on her career. The same cannot be said for the assemblage of Divas legends who did enter the bout, which brought with it its first elimination - Layla - before Justin Roberts had finished explaining the match's inordinately elementary rules which instantly set the tone for the woeful disaster that was to follow. Making up the numbers were Jackie Gayda, Joy Giovanni, Sunny, and Torrie Wilson, Giovanni's inclusion being of particular interest as it was her first match ever. Coincidentally, it was also her last match, but you wouldn't have known she was even there, given WWE's petulance for disregarding the bout's blasts from the past.

Given the nature in which WWE nudged the match's lineup onto the stage, where they were then begrudgingly made to dance around a jiving Kid Rock as he staggered his way through "So Hott" like some sort of seductive Grand Theft Auto V cutscene at Vanilla Unicorn. Indeed, none of the four legends, nor the preferable Divas of the time were given an individual entrance, as would become the case with modernised WrestleMania Battle Royals. They were very much the Tatankas of the match whereas Kid Rock was the Shaquille O'Neal.


4. Vader (2005)

Vader Batista
WWE.com

Vader is often heralded as one of pro wrestling's greatest big-men performers. His deft finesse immediately stripped him of the stereotypical proverbs associated with performers of his size; Vader was no cumbersome, heavy-footed bozo, but rather a seasoned and potent striker whose slap to the head was equally-as-calamitous as dropping his 450-pound frame on whichever goober was foolish enough to get on his bad side.

When Vader returned to WWE programming in 2005, these undertones he'd made a career out of eluding quickly became his own state of mind.

Resurfacing on a 2005 Halloween broadcast of Raw, he lumbered through a beatdown of then-World Heavyweight Champion Batista, aiding Goldust and Jonathan Coachman - the whole thing reads as some WWE Universe Mode simulation booking.

What was worse, aside from the complete 360 in Vader's previously ingenious presentation and the audience's lethargic reaction, was that Vader appeared to jump his cue. He bundled onto the stage while Goldust was in control. It wasn't as if Batista had gained the upper-hand by the time Vader made it to the ring either; he stood idly by Coachman, waiting for Batista to strike Goldust before he himself struck 'The Animal'. The whole thing was a big mess that, thankfully, was redeemed for 'The Mastadon' when he made another cameo 2012.


3. Eugene (2009)

Eugene Calgary Kid
WWE.com

WWE will milk the sh*t out of a shock return, however, they're not always flawless executions.

They've built the Royal Rumble match around such attractions but even in 2023, they struggled to perfect the blueprint. Cody Rhodes, for instance, should have been the biggest surprise of the men's affair, were it not for the fact he was sent out in the number thirty slot after already declaring his comeback. With or without his outright admission, Rhodes would have received a gargantuan pop, but there was something dispiriting about the once-hallowed position effectively being known the entire match.

Eugene's 2009 comeback, meanwhile, was an entirely different strand of WWE's take on the shock return.

Resurfacing on Raw's 10 August broadcast after two years away, Eugene was barely welcomed back before he left again. Unlike the majority of entries on this list, the real-life Nick Dinsmore received the 'currently in the ring...' treatment, randomly standing in-ring when Raw came back from commercial break without so much as a peep of excitement from the Calgarian crowd. They couldn't be a*sed if Eugene was back, nor could they be bothered to react to The Calgary Kid - Eugene's bleak WWE Contract on a Pole match adversary - unmasking as The Miz.

What was the point, you ask?

Since when did Vince McMahon need a point?


2. The Great Khali (2017)

Jinder Mahal Great Khali
WWE.com

The Great Khali did receive a reaction when he monotonously waddled to the ring like a moribund penguin to save Jinder Mahal's WWE title from landing in Randy Orton's hands.

This reaction wasn't of joy or of surprise or of gratification though; it was a reaction of the worst possible thing that could've happened in the worst possible match.

Mahal and Orton's mid-2017 feud was mid in every sense. WWE, leaning heavily on their stereotype-heavy essence, were obviously planning a Punjabi Prison match from the minute they decided on crowning their first Indian World Champion two months prior. The match is one of WWE's worst creations, a somehow worse take on the Kennel From Hell match, but dogs p*ssing and sh*tting all over the floor would have been welcomed on this occasion, taking some of the shine away from what was objectively an abhorrent creative decision.

The seven-footer hadn't been in WWE for three years at this point. He hadn't done anything remotely notable since the night of his debut in 2006; even then, the only aspect making it notable was the audience's plodding reaction that went a little like this:-

"He's a big lad, isn't he?"
"Yes, mum."

This, extraordinarily, wasn't Khali's last surprise return either! He rocked up in April 2018's Greatest Royal Rumble match to an ample reaction. Perhaps he was there because the Saudi government demanded Giant Gonzales.


1. Brian Christopher (2011)

Brian Christopher
WWE Network

It was depressing.

It was melancholic.

It was funereal.

Not one soul gave a toss about Brian Christopher's 14 March 2011 reappearance on Raw, which made his full-hearted entrance dismally underwhelming. Out he came, doing the full Too Cool bit to the original soundtrack. The audience was turned off during an era when WWE hadn't yet discovered the fake crowd noise filter on their vision mixer; even then, would it have saved this comeback's spirit when each shot of the crowd displayed a motionless and indeed emotionless St. Louisan audience? They were bored, bored of WWE, bored of the Jerry Lawler vs. Michael Cole saga, bored of what professional wrestling had been reduced to in the largest pro wrestling organisation in the world.

Admittedly, Christopher - the believed third-best member of the Too Cool trio - garnered two larger reactions when he returned twice in 2014, first during that year's Old School Raw and the second, bizarrely, at NXT ArRIVAL in a forgettable NXT Tag Team titles match during The Ascension's lengthy and exhausting 364-day reign. His lack of reaction three years prior was very much a gauge of the audience's interest in the aforementioned commentator conflict.

There hasn't been another reaction like it because there wasn't a reaction in the first place.


Contributor
Contributor

Can be found raving about the latest IMPACT Wrestling signing, the Saints Row franchise, and King Shark in The Suicide Squad.