10 Times WWE Dropped The Ball On Jack Swagger

The All-American American hasn't been relevant in years.

Although it has yet to be officially announced, Jack Swagger will likely be going up against Alberto Del Rio for the United States Championship at next Sunday at WWE's TLC pay-per-view. The feud has failed to excite fans in recent weeks, mainly because the it's been done before and Swagger hasn't been relevant in years. Swagger is far from a rookie on the rise; in fact, he's been with WWE for over nine years, having started out as a top prospect with a ton of potential, and impressing officials in developmental before punching his ticket to the main roster. He had a strong start on the now-defunct ECW brand, but it was all downhill for the All-American American from there. From forgettable title runs to missed managerial opportunities, the powers that be have mishandled Swagger on multiple occasions over the course of his career. As a result, fans can no longer take him seriously whenever the roster is low on star power and WWE attempts to make him meaningful again. In the near-decade he€™s been with WWE, officials have dropped the ball on him countless time, causing his momentum to fizzle out and become the midcard mainstay he is today.

10. Undefeated Streak

WWE's ECW experiment was basically a bust. It was far from what the promotion of the same name was in the mid- to late-'90s, but if nothing else, it served as a platform to introduce new stars (i.e. what NXT has turned into today). CM Punk and Sheamus were among the future world champions to debut in WWE in the Land of Extreme, and Jack Swagger joined that elite club as well in September 2008. After beating local athletes in his first few matches, Swagger set his sights on Tommy Dreamer, whom he beat in three consecutive matches. He then went on to defeat Matt Hardy for the ECW Championship in early January while still undefeated in singles competition in WWE. Swagger was living up to his nickname as the "Prodigy of WWE" before he ran into the roadblock that was Finlay. It was fine to do a feud between the two, but it was completely unnecessary to have the fighting Irishman hand Swagger his first loss in WWE that February. Granted, it was only after Hornswoggle made his presence felt at ringside, but there were more effective ways of getting to the title match at the No Way Out pay-per-view that didn't see Swagger suffer a defeat prematurely.

9. That Bald Eagle Mascot

After Jack Swagger dropped the World Heavyweight Championship to Rey Mysterio in June 2010, there was speculation among fans that he was going to be revealed as the one who attacked The Undertaker over Memorial Day weekend. Instead, he was removed from the main event scene all together. As fans, we should have seen that coming. Not only was Swagger no longer in contention for the prestigious prize, he wasn't even involved in anything of note for the remainder of the year. He didn't engage in any real rivalries: he just floated around the roster, but at least he made an attempt to reinvent himself by adding the bald eagle mascot to his act. Swagger has long been criticized for not being charismatic, so he looked to silence those naysayers by bringing in a bald eagle mascot to cheer him on from ringside. It was actually hilarious... at least until WWE randomly had Edge "flip the bird" and put him out of action indefinitely, never to make a return. And just like that, Swagger was irrelevant once again. A wasted opportunity.

8. Pairing With Vickie Guerrero

Whether it's been Vickie Guerrero, Zeb Colter or even the aforementioned bald eagle mascot, Swagger has always worked better with a mouthpiece. He joined forces with the former SmackDown general manager in the summer of 2011 as she was scouting clients for her newly formed faction, already having recruited Dolph Ziggler. Instantly, Ziggler and Swagger found chemistry together. The dynamic duo delivered in the ring while Guerrero helped them elicit heat, so it was the perfect pairing. Sadly, their win-loss record wouldn't reflect that as they proceeded to come up short against Air Boom every shot they had at the WWE Tag Team Championship. By mid-2012, the team was holding back Ziggler, who was on the brink of super stardom. But instead of having Guerrero turn on the bleached-blonde Superstar, she sided with him and left Swagger in the dust. Ziggler desperately needed to break out on his own and Swagger could have continued to use her as a manager, but WWE thought otherwise. https://youtu.be/eYIC1lS3Bbg

7. His Move To Raw

As noted, Swagger made a major impression on the WWE Universe with his arrival on ECW in late 2008. He quickly captured the ECW Championship and reigned as champion for three months before dropping the strap to Christian at Backlash. The remainder of his run in the Land of Extreme was nothing noteworthy, but it was evident he was ready for Raw. On the June 29, 2009 edition of Raw, it was announced that three top prospects from ECW would make the move to the flagship show and face then-WWE champion Randy Orton in a gauntlet match in the main event. After Orton knocked off Evan Bourne in an impressive outing, his next opponent was revealed to be the All-American American. Granted, he didn't actually go one-on-one with The Viper and instead opted to get himself counted-out as a show of respect, but the aftermath was anything but extraordinary. He engaged in a lackluster program with MVP before falling into obscurity. WWE failed to capitalize on the opportunity to push him from the get-go on the flagship show, making his Raw run fairly forgettable as a result. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMRdYf6_zfo

6. Pairing With Michael Cole

Following his Money in the Bank Ladder match victory at WrestleMania 26, Jack Swagger wasn't at all configured into the plans for WrestleMania 27. But to WWE's credit, they were wise to pair him with Michael Cole, one of the most hated heels on Raw in the early months of 2011, as his trainer. Similar to the bald eagle mascot, his alliance with Cole brought out the best in him. When he wrestled, it was in a winning effort, and afterward, he celebrated with Cole in hilarious fashion. Essentially, it was a match made in heaven that saw Swagger involved in the heated rivalry between Cole and Jerry Lawler, one of the more prominently featured feuds on the WrestleMania card. While he wasn't in action on the show, he did take a Stunner from Stone Cold Steve Austin, which is a 'Mania moment in of itself. Shortly after The Show of Shows, Cole broke off his partnership with the Oklahoma native when he wasn't bringing him the results he wanted. That would have been the time to turn Swagger, but he remained heel and was returned to "WWE Superstars" purgatory.

5. United States Championship Run

The All-American American as United States champion. Makes perfect sense, doesn't it? For whatever reason, that idea never occurred to WWE, otherwise they would have put the title on him much sooner than they did. And don't think for a second he couldn't have won it at any point in 2009 or 2010 when he was chasing the championship on Raw. It wasn't until January 2012 that he finally captured the star-spangled prize, and by virtue of being the one to take the title off The Long Island Iced Z prematurely, he was doomed to fail from the start. For one thing, it would have helped if WWE bothered to feature him on Raw or SmackDown. During his run as United States champion, he was rarely on either show and when he was, it was often in a losing effort. He was mainly relegated to working "WWE Superstars," further devaluing the title as a result. Before he could reach the two month mark as champion, he lost the championship to Santino Marella in early March. A fitting end to an awful title reign.

4. The Real Americans

Upon Jack Swagger's return from injury in mid-2013, he wasn't put back into the World Heavyweight Championship picture as expected but instead was paired with Cesaro. Led by Zeb Colter, The Real Americans immediately became a force to be reckoned with in the tag team division, spreading their message of patriotic unity and scoring victories over The Usos and the Rhodes brothers. Although they never once won the WWE Tag Team Championship and were wasted in a rivalry with Los Matadores, they still managed to endear to the audience with their amazing chemistry in the ring. Cesaro stole the spotlight more often not, but Swagger complimented him well as a partner. By WrestleMania season, they were as hot as they had ever been, which prompted WWE to split them up following The Show of Shows. They wanted to capitalize off the wave of momentum Cesaro was riding as soon as possible, but in doing so, they broke The Real Americans up before they could fulfill their full potential as a tandem.

3. World Heavyweight Championship Contention

Before Jack Swagger took a hiatus from WWE in September 2012, things couldn't have been going worse for him. Vickie Guerrero and Dolph Ziggler left him to fend for himself, he was rarely on Raw and he had embarked on a massive losing streak. That said, it was in his best interest to walk away for a while and return rejuvenated. The former ECW champion made an unannounced on the post-Royal Rumble episode of SmackDown, and from there, he underwent a complete character change. In the weeks that followed, he debuted a new manager (Zeb Colter), a new look, and even new entrance music. WWE was determined to move away from fans' perception of Swagger as an enhancement talent. He returned to the main event scene almost overnight when he won an Elimination Chamber match to become the new No. 1 contender to the World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania 29. But then he got himself arrested due to a DUI and cost himself any shot of winning the gold at WrestleMania. Technically, Swagger dropped the ball on his own push in this case, but nothing was stopping WWE from featuring him in the world title picture when he returned from injury in mid-2013. They just gave up on the guy.

2. His Face Turn

For the fist time in his six year career, Jack Swagger turned face in the summer of 2014 to feud with Rusev as the beloved patriot. It was evident from the get-go that he was only being built up to be ultimately fed to Rusev, but there was a hope among fans that he would be elevated by the overdue change in character. In his rivalry with Rusev, Swagger got over with the audience more than anyone expected him to. Yes, most of it had to do with his "We the People" catchphrase, but fans legitimately wanted to see Swagger be the one to hand Rusev his first loss in WWE. Had Rusev lost their Flag match at SummerSlam, he wouldn't have needed to get pinned and Swagger could have scored a meaningful victory, so it would have been a win-win. Not only did he come up short in that contest, he would lose to the Bulgarian Brute every time they faced off in the year that followed. The more things change, the more they stay the same, it seems.

1. World Heavyweight Championship Run

Nothing will come close to being as big of a blunder in Jack Swagger's WWE career than his short-lived World Heavyweight Championship reign in 2010. He had all the tools to be a main event caliber competitor early on in his main roster run, but WWE rushed him into the spotlight by having him win the Money in the Bank Ladder match at WrestleMania 26 (coming off an extensive losing streak, mind you) and cash in the contract successfully on SmackDown days later. Even then, they could have gotten away with making a star out of him on the blue brand, but the booking of his title reign was nothing short of atrocious. He lost just about every match he was involved in with his only clean victory coming against Randy Orton at the Extreme Rules pay-per-view. And as soon as he dropped the strap at the inaugural (and only) Fatal 4-Way event to Rey Mysterio, that was the end of his time on top. He had his championship rematch at Money in the Bank, but beyond that show, he was a virtually a non-factor on SmackDown. In fact, he wasn't present at SummerSlam in any capacity. So, I leave you with this: If no one remembers Jack Swagger was a world champion, did it really happen? Do you think WWE have mishandled Jack Swagger? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

Since 2008, Graham has been a diehard pro wrestling fan and, in 2010, he combined his passions for WWE and writing when he joined Bleacher Report. Equipped with a master's in journalism, Graham has contributed to WhatCulture, FanSided's Daily DDT, Sports Betting Dime, and GateHouse Media. Along the way, he has conducted interviews with wrestling superstars like Chris Jericho, Edge, Goldberg, Christian, Diamond Dallas Page, Jim Ross, Adam Cole, Tessa Blanchard, Ryback, and Nick Aldis among others.