10 Times WWE Fans Forced A Face Turn

We're good at getting what we want.

The Rock Hulk Hogan WrestleMania X8
WWE.com

Face turns rarely have the same impact as heel turns. This is because it's a lot more surprising to see a good guy do something bad than it is a bad guy do something good.

Imagine, for example, Daniel Bryan drop-kicking a small puppy into a swimming pool. It's shocking, isn't it? Certainly more shocking than Braun Strowman helping an old woman across the street, at any rate.

But face turns still, occasionally, make for compelling viewing, particularly when they have been driven by the WWE audience themselves, instead of Vince McMahon's own personal, big muscly-man fantasies.

This generally happens when a wrestler simply entertains us too much to be jeered, and the fans - sensing they have a chance to change the course of wrestling history - then refuse to dance to beat of the WWE drum until they rip up their script.

When you put it like that, it sounds kind of childish: stamping your feet until you get what you want - but it's tended to work for many of wrestling's backstage divas, so you can't really blame us for trying.

10. Mickie James

Mickie James Women's Title
WWE.com

On paper, a psychotic fan with an unhealthy obsession with one of the WWE Divas sounds like the perfect heel.

The problem, of course, was that Mickie - instead of being a creepy, middle-aged bloke - was a good-looking young woman. Besides which, she was also a terrific wrestler, in an era when many women of the company's female cast simply weren't.

Though she emerged from her WrestleMania 22 match with Trish Stratus a heel, Mickie never quite managed to turn the crowd against her. Fans were yearning for a new figure to spearhead the Women's Title Division that had for so long (and with good reason) been dominated by Trish and Lita.

By the end of her first 12 months with the company, she was officially a face. A face who was still, from to time, given to the occasional psychotic episode, granted, but that didn't exactly stop Undertaker or Mick Foley from being cheered either.


9. Brock Lesnar

Brock Lesnar Big Show Survivor Series 2002
WWE

Putting Paul Heyman by his side must have seemed like a shrewd way of ensuring that Brock Lesnar wouldn't be cheered.

The only problem was that fans were beginning to cotton on to the fact that the ECW mastermind was a force for wrestling good. And, even if he wasn't, his continued insistence that Lesnar was a world-beating, record-setting Next Big Thing was kind of persuasive.

Cheered in his SummerSlam showdown with The Rock (which could, at the time, be put down to Rocky's coming career change), Lesnar would slowly prove in the months ahead that he wasn't just a flash in the pan. And, despite a complete lack of human characteristics, we grew to love him.

Unwilling to turn Heyman face too, WWE cooked up a storyline wherein the manager began to doubt his client's ability. He eventually ran off with Big Show instead, and left Lesnar a more sympathetic, emotionally vulnerable baby-face in the process.


8. The Shield

The Shield Belts
WWE.com

As the launchpad for three future Hall of Famers, The Shield were perhaps always destined to fight on the side of good. Fans, though, enjoyed them from the outset: they were fresh and exciting, representing something we hadn't seen since the days of the Attitude Era.

With a pair of much-loved indie darlings either side of the Big Dog, and some of the most badass ring attire we've ever seen (except when worn by Kurt Angle), The Shield were simply too cool to boo - Roman Reigns or not.

The crowd saw in them not only a trio of main event-tier singles stars, but also a group capable of kicking back against the rule of The Authority.

And, sure enough, that's exactly how they became good guys, turning on Director of Operations Kane after appearing to come to the ring to beat up Jerry Lawler. Finally, we could give them a rapturous pop without having to feel guilty about it - and it felt great.


7. Kurt Angle

Kurt Angle
WWE.com

Kurt Angle's eventual face turn was helped by the fact that he never really fully committed to being a heel in the first place. Instead of trying to maim his opponents or make the fans cry, he was simply an ambitious rookie prepared to do whatever it took to make real his wrestling dreams.

That, along with his penchant for sheer goofiness, endeared him to the audience, and even when he joined up with The Alliance in 2001 to try and bring down the entire World Wrestling Federation, you couldn't really dislike the guy.

Officially speaking, Angle became a proper face for the first time in 2003 - ironically, after acquiring a more intense, ruthless streak once he got his hair shaven off by Edge the previous year.

It had to happen, though, because the already-loved Olympic gold medalist was now a true wrestling hero, having put in one of the all time great WrestleMania performances next to Brock Lesnar, despite his banged-up neck.


6. CM Punk

Cm Punk Triple H
WWE.com

Technically, CM Punk turned bad after cashing in his Money in the Bank briefcase to break the hearts of Jeff Hardy fans in 2009 - and never, in the next five years, went good again.

But since when does technically really matter in wrestling? The fact is that WWE gave us the truth-speaking, pipebomb-dropping CM Punk we wanted to see in the summer of 2011. Clearly some people - and if you're reading this, chances are that includes you - were supposed to like him.

Was this forced by the fans or by CM Punk himself? You imagine that a man as strident as the Straight Edge Superstar would have been forceful in getting his ideas across during creative meetings - so perhaps he deserves a little credit.

But, by the same token, he would not have felt emboldened enough to pitch such a radical idea were he not being cheered by the fans. And, for what, we all deserve credit as well.

OK, squared circle jerk over.


5. John Cena

John Cena 2003
WWE

Revisionists have claimed that Cena was groomed from the outset to fill the role of Vince McMahon's franchise player, but many will remember it differently. He was a bad guy rapper in the early goings, his gimmick less a masterstroke than it was a Halloween costume gone well.

True: Cena was jeered in career-making 2003 feuds with Undertaker and Kurt Angle, but these were fans still mourning the death of the Attitude Era. They couldn't really hate the man who was helping to inject some edge back into the WWE product.

Like The Rock, Cena's ability on the mic was too good for him to remain a heel. We were desperate to see him come over to the good side, if only because there were a queue of fellow bad guys who needed a Doctor of Thuganomics dressing down.

Courted by opposing Survivor Series teams in the fall, Cena cemented his long-awaited face turn by snubbing Brock Lesnar. He took an ass-kicking for his troubles, but the fans loved him for it - for about 18 months, anyway.


4. Daniel Bryan

Cesaro Daniel Bryan 2013 Raw.jpg
WWE.com

In his early WWE run, Daniel Bryan was so good at playing heel that he managed to get himself released after strangling Justin Roberts with his neck-tie.

On his return, he was initially a face and then - once drunk with World Heavyweight Championship success - an arrogant heel, but with a twist.

Fans who followed his indie career couldn't quite bring themselves to hate him. Instead of booing Bryan, they jeered the egregious WWE booking that saw him lose to Sheamus inside 18 seconds at WrestleMania.

Bryan initially responded to the crowd's "Yes!" chants with a firm "No!" - but they they refused to go away. Before long, Vince McMahon was forced to embrace what everyone knew: that the former ROH star had the makings of a top, promotion-leading baby-face.

This was as reluctant a face turn as they come, led by a grassroots campaign that believed Bryan - a man once unironically tutored by The Miz - was a talent the company simply couldn't afford to waste.


3. Stone Cold

Stone Cold Steve Austin
WWE.com

WWE can decide who it wants to push, but - as the Roman Reigns has found out over recent years - only the fans get to decide who becomes emblematic of an entire wrestling generation.

Face of the Attitude Era Stone Cold Steve Austin received Vince McMahon's blessing in 1996 with success in King of the Ring and the now-iconic Austin 3:16 victory speech that followed.

Initially intent on portraying him as a no-good heel, the company was surprised over the ensuing months by the realisation that edgy late-90s fans were now prepared to cheer those who refused to abide by the rule-book.

For anyone who remained unconvinced, the sight of a bloodied Austin determined that he wouldn't tap out at WrestleMania 13 was enough to bring them on side. It was the moment that made official what most of us had known in our hearts for a while: this guy was one of us.


2. Hulk Hogan

hulk hogan the rock
WWE.com

For most of the examples on this list, WWE writers can perhaps claim to have plotted an ingenious, slow-brewing character transformation. When it comes to Hulk Hogan's 2002 face turn, however, they can't.

We know for a fact that Hogan and The Rock were forced into changing plans right in the middle of their WrestleMania X8 match after realising that the Toronto crowd weren't going to play ball.

Though he sported his nWo black tights and walked to the ring without the patriotic sound of "I Am A Real American", fans (mostly Canadian) couldn't help but remember his former life as a red and yellow defender of the realm.

Hogan even used the referee's timely nap to nail his opponent between the legs, but it was all in vain. The audience had made up their mind: they wanted to see their childhood hero roll back the years. And he duly obliged.


1. The Rock

the rock 1999 promo.jpg
WWE

Just as they forced WWE to turn him heel after catching wind of his plans for a career in Hollywood, fans insisted Rock become a good guy for the first time in 1999.

They were seduced, mainly, by the man's unrivaled ability on the microphone, which often saw him elicit loud cheers - even when he was dressing down good guys. He was just too charismatic, too charming, to truly hate.

We got our wish soon after WrestleMania XV, when Rock got into a bust-up with Shane McMahon, leading to an official face turn and then a re-run of his feud with Triple H. It was as though they had read our minds.

And, really, they had. Though fans rejected the bland Rocky Maivia who debuted in the mid-90s, Dwayne Johnson's God-given ability to connect with an audience always made him a natural candidate for a switch to the good side. It was just a question of when, the answer to which being: as soon as his feud with Austin was in the history books.


Watch Next


Contributor